Skip to content
A8282Assembly2021-2022 SessionSame asS5493

Protect Jury Employment Verdicts

Official title

“Relates to certain jury awards in employment discrimination actions”

Sponsor Rebecca SeawrightAD-76+9 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Assembly Committee
Judiciary
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill restricts courts from reducing or overturning jury awards in employment discrimination cases unless clear and convincing evidence justifies such action.

Why it matters

  1. Raises the standard for overturning or reducing jury awards. Courts can only change jury verdicts in employment discrimination cases if there is "clear and convincing evidence" of jury misconduct (such as partiality, prejudice, mistake, or corruption), making it much harder for employers to get large awards reduced on appeal.

  2. Strengthens the role of the jury. The bill explicitly requires courts to give "substantial deference" to jury decisions in these cases, reinforcing the idea that jurors—not judges—should determine appropriate compensation for victims of discrimination.

  3. Limits judicial discretion and precedent. Judges are barred from substituting their own judgment for that of the jury or using prior cases to set limits on awards, specifically rejecting the "material deviation" standard that previously allowed courts to adjust awards based on what seemed reasonable to them.

  4. Emphasizes the law’s remedial purpose. By instructing courts to give primary weight to the remedial goals of anti-discrimination laws, the bill prioritizes robust compensation for victims and aims to strengthen enforcement and deterrence against workplace discrimination.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Employees bringing discrimination claims

    The bill would give their jury awards a presumption of correctness and require clear and convincing evidence before courts could reduce or increase them.

  • Employers defending discrimination lawsuits

    The bill would make it harder to secure reductions of jury awards or new trials on the ground that awards are excessive.

  • Non-employees bringing employment discrimination claims

    The bill would expressly extend the heightened protections for jury awards to claims under Executive Law Section 296-d.

  • Trial and appellate courts

    The bill would require substantial deference to employment discrimination verdicts and bar judges from substituting their judgment for the jury’s when reviewing damages.

Headline styles

Protect Jury Employment Verdicts

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Referred to judiciary
  2. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

S5493Senate

Protect Jury Employment Awards

In Senate Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Andrew Gounardes

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8282

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN ASSEMBLY

September 17, 2021

Introduced by M. of A. SEAWRIGHT -- read once and referred to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules and the executive law, in relation to jury awards for unlawful discriminatory practices relating to employment

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision (a) of rule 4404 of the civil practice law and rules, such rule as renumbered by chapter 315 of the laws of 1962, is amended to read as follows:

(a) Motion after trial where jury required. After a trial of a cause of action or issue triable of right by a jury, upon the motion of any party or on its own initiative, the court may set aside a verdict or any judgment entered thereon and direct that judgment be entered in favor of a party entitled to judgment as a matter of law or it may order a new trial of a cause of action or separable issue where the verdict is contrary to the weight of the evidence, in the interest of justice or where the jury cannot agree after being kept together for as long as is deemed reasonable by the court. No court shall order a new trial on the ground that the jury award was excessive, or otherwise act to reduce the jury's award in a case involving an unlawful discriminatory practice under section two hundred ninety-six of the executive law relating to employment, including a claim by a non-employee under section two hundred ninety-six-d of the executive law, without fully satisfying the pertinent standards set forth in paragraph two of subdivision (c) of section fifty-five hundred one of this chapter and paragraph (b) of subdivision nine of section two hundred ninety-seven of the executive law.

§ 2. Subdivision (c) of section 5501 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 474 of the laws of 1997, is amended to read as follows:

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD10273-03-1

A. 8282 2

(c) Appellate division. 1. The appellate division shall review questions of law and questions of fact on an appeal from a judgment or order of a court of original instance and on an appeal from an order of the supreme court, a county court or an appellate term determining an appeal. The notice of appeal from an order directing summary judgment, or directing judgment on a motion addressed to the pleadings, shall be deemed to specify a judgment upon said order entered after service of the notice of appeal and before entry of the order of the appellate court upon such appeal, without however affecting the taxation of costs upon the appeal. In reviewing a money judgment in an action in which an itemized verdict is required by rule forty-one hundred eleven of this chapter in which it is contended that the award is excessive or inadequate and that a new trial should have been granted unless a stipulation is entered to a different award, the appellate division shall determine that an award is excessive or inadequate if it deviates materially from what would be reasonable compensation.

2. Where an award is made by a jury for any damages in a case involving an unlawful discriminatory practice under section two hundred ninety-six of the executive law relating to employment, including a claim by a non-employee under section two hundred ninety-six-d of the executive law, the jury's verdict is presumed to be correct and entitled to substantial deference. Any such award shall not be disturbed unless the court finds that the proponent has proven by clear and convincing evidence that the verdict compels the conclusion that the jury was influenced by partiality, prejudice, mistake or corruption, and remittitur or additur is necessary to avoid a complete miscarriage of justice. In making such determination, the court shall not substitute its judgment for the jury's, shall give primary weight to the remedial purpose of the law, and shall not limit any award by inclusion in or exclusion from any category of case or by using any characterizations of other damage awards. In reviewing any such verdict in any case filed after the effective date of this paragraph, the court shall not be bound by any precedent which utilized the concept of material deviation from what would be reasonable compensation, or a judge's personal knowledge or experiences from prior cases. The evidence shall be reviewed in the light most favorable to sustaining the verdict. A court should exercise its authority to order a remittitur or additur only in the most exceptional of circumstances.

§ 3. Subdivision 9 of section 297 of the executive law, as separately amended by chapter 160 of the laws of 2019 and chapter 236 of the laws of 2020, is amended to read as follows:

9. (a) Any person claiming to be aggrieved by an unlawful discriminatory practice shall have a cause of action in any court of appropriate jurisdiction for damages, including, in cases of employment discrimination related to private employers and housing discrimination only, punitive damages, and such other remedies as may be appropriate, including any civil fines and penalties provided in subdivision four of this section, unless such person had filed a complaint hereunder or with any local commission on human rights, or with the superintendent pursuant to the provisions of section two hundred ninety-six-a of this [chapter] article, provided that, where the division has dismissed such complaint on the grounds of administrative convenience, on the grounds of untimeliness, or on the grounds that the election of remedies is annulled, such person shall maintain all rights to bring suit as if no complaint had been filed with the division. At any time prior to a hearing before a hearing examiner, a person who has a complaint pending at the division

A. 8282 3

may request that the division dismiss the complaint and annul his or her election of remedies so that the human rights law claim may be pursued in court, and the division may, upon such request, dismiss the complaint on the grounds that such person's election of an administrative remedy is annulled. Notwithstanding subdivision (a) of section two hundred four of the civil practice law and rules, if a complaint is so annulled by the division, upon the request of the party bringing such complaint before the division, such party's rights to bring such cause of action before a court of appropriate jurisdiction shall be limited by the statute of limitations in effect in such court at the time the complaint was initially filed with the division. Any party to a housing discrimination complaint shall have the right within twenty days following a determination of probable cause pursuant to subdivision two of this section to elect to have an action commenced in a civil court, and an attorney representing the division of human rights will be appointed to present the complaint in court, or, with the consent of the division, the case may be presented by complainant's attorney. A complaint filed by the equal employment opportunity commission to comply with the requirements of 42 USC 2000e-5(c) and 42 USC 12117(a) and 29 USC 633(b) shall not constitute the filing of a complaint within the meaning of this subdivision. No person who has initiated any action in a court of competent jurisdiction or who has an action pending before any administrative agency under any other law of the state based upon an act which would be an unlawful discriminatory practice under this article, may file a complaint with respect to the same grievance under this section or under section two hundred ninety-six-a of this article. In cases of housing discrimination only, a person whose complaint has been dismissed by the division after investigation for lack of jurisdiction or lack of probable cause may file the same cause of action in a court of appropriate jurisdiction pursuant to this section, unless judicial review of such dismissal has been sought pursuant to section two hundred ninety-eight of this article.

(b) A verdict involving an unlawful discriminatory practice under section two hundred ninety-six of this article relating to employment, including a claim by a non-employee under section two hundred ninetysix-d of this article, shall not be subject to remittitur or additur, or granting of a motion for new trial on the ground that the verdict was excessive or inadequate, or otherwise reduced or increased, unless the court finds that the party seeking remittitur or additur has made a clear and convincing showing that compels the conclusion that the jury was influenced by partiality, prejudice, mistake or corruption and that remittitur or additur is necessary to avoid a complete miscarriage of justice. In making such determination, a jury verdict shall be presumed to be correct and entitled to substantial deference. The court shall not substitute its judgment for the jury's, shall give primary weight to the remedial purpose of the law, and shall not limit any award by inclusion in or exclusion from any category of case or any characterizations of other damage awards. In reviewing any verdict in any case filed after the effective date of this paragraph, the court shall not be bound by any precedent which utilized the concept of material deviation from what would be reasonable compensation. A court should exercise its authority to order a remittitur or additur only in the most exceptional of circumstances. This provision is substantive in nature, as opposed to procedural, and shall be so applied in any employment discrimination action under this article, regardless of forum.

§ 4. This act shall take effect immediately.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.