Skip to content
S3184Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA5180

Guarantee Kids Broadband Access

Official title

“Relates to ensuring all children have access to the delivery of technology through high-quality broadband internet connectivity”

Sponsor Shelley MayerSD-37+36 co-sponsorsAffects Education
Status
In Senate Committee
Education
Impact
9/10
Transformational
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Education

What's happening

The E-LEARN Act creates a fund and mandates high-quality broadband internet access for all New York students and schools, funded by telecommunications providers, to support remote learning and educational equity.

Why it matters

  1. Addresses the Digital Divide. By mandating minimum speed standards and universal access regardless of location or cost, the Act aims to close persistent gaps that leave low-income, rural, and homeless students without reliable internet, which is critical for both remote learning and modern classroom activities.

  2. Creates a Sustainable, Provider-Funded Model. The E-LEARN Fund is financed by assessments on telecommunications companies, not by additional fees to consumers. This represents a shift in responsibility to industry stakeholders, ensuring stable funding without increasing household costs for families or schools.

  3. Ensures Equity and Non-Discrimination. The law explicitly prohibits prioritizing easier-to-serve students or schools over those in hard-to-reach or expensive areas, and bars internet providers from passing costs to customers or discriminating based on payment history—reinforcing the principle that all students deserve equal access to educational resources.

  4. Supports Schools and Home Learners Alike. Coverage includes all public, charter, non-public, and special education schools, as well as homeschooled students, ensuring that every student aged 5–21 in New York benefits from high-quality connectivity, not just those enrolled in traditional public schools.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Guarantee Kids Broadband Access

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Referred to education
  2. Reported and committed to finance
  3. Referred to education

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A5180Assembly

Guarantee Broadband For All Kids

In Assembly Committee · Education · Sponsor Michael Benedetto

Impact 10 · Transformational0% to pass

Full text

12 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

3184

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 28, 2021

Introduced by Sens. MAYER, PARKER, LIU, COMRIE, BIAGGI, ADDABBO, BAILEY, BROOKS, COONEY, GIANARIS, GOUNARDES, HARCKHAM, HINCHEY, HOYLMAN, JACK- SON, KAMINSKY, KAPLAN, KAVANAGH, KENNEDY, KRUEGER, MAY, PERSAUD, REICHLIN-MELNICK, RIVERA, SALAZAR, SANDERS, SAVINO, SEPULVEDA, SKOUF- IS, STAVISKY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Education

AN ACT to amend the education law, the tax law, the state finance law and the public service law, in relation to ensuring all children have access to the delivery of technology through high-quality broadband internet connectivity in support of the constitutional education obligations of the state; and providing for the repeal of such provisions upon expiration thereof

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "E-Let's Expand Access to Remote Now (E-LEARN) Act".

§ 2. Legislative intent. The legislature hereby finds and declares that the COVID-19 pandemic has plagued the health, economy and education systems throughout New York and impacted the livelihood of every resident of the state with an extensive, protracted and disproportionate impact on students in every region.

The legislature further finds the unprecedented closure of school buildings for the last quarter of the 2019-20 school year coupled with increasing COVID-19 public health and safety concerns throughout the summer and into the beginning of the 2020-21 school year have continued to present logistical challenges for the delivery of education and support services especially for students who are living in poverty.

The legislature further finds Article XI of the New York state Constitution which stipulates 'The Legislature shall provide for the maintenance and support of a system of free common schools, wherein all the

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD02813-01-1

S. 3184 2

children of the state may be educated' must be continuously upheld even throughout the ensuing pandemic period.

The legislature further finds schools across the state had to quickly implement technological programs and devices to deliver remote learning options to students during the closed down period and many schools are required to, or are requested to, continue distance learning modality as an instructional delivery model.

The legislature further finds lack of high-quality internet access has had and continues to have a disequalizing impact on children who are poor, homeless and without the resources to support their educational needs.

The Legislature further finds it is a state imperative to ensure all children have access to the delivery of technology through high-quality broadband internet connectivity in order to meet the State's constitutional requirement and maintain a system of free common schools.

The legislature further finds that high-speed internet access, commonly referred to as broadband internet, can be achieved through utilization of a variety of technologies, including wired infrastructure via fiber optic cable, and through wireless technologies such as fixed wireless internet and satellite internet, and that taking advantage of all available and evolving technologies can enable communities currently without wired infrastructure to nonetheless improve access to high quality internet until such time as wired infrastructure is made universally available.

The legislature further finds that almost every sector of New York's economy, democracy, and society depends on widespread, high-quality internet access that supports vital functions regulated under the police power of the state.

The legislature further finds that while the internet is an interstate resource, the essential support it provides for innumerable municipal and state operations, vital business and community service, delivery of educational programs and services and daily interactions between the people of New York and their governments are of state concern.

The legislature further finds that while the operations of telecommunication service providers must be subject to state oversight, they also must be protected from undue restraint and regulation so as to assure optimum technology and maximum availability in this state as rapidly as economically and technically feasible.

The legislature further finds that telecommunication service providers, notwithstanding their unique attributes, are part of an increasingly integrated telecommunications industry, the soundness of which is essential, not only to education, but also to the state's economic growth and general welfare, and portions of whose business are wholly intrastate.

The legislature further finds that there is a need for one or more state agencies to determine state internet access policy as it relates to the education of the state's students during the COVID-19 pandemic, ensure that telecommunication service providers provide adequate, economical and efficient service to students and schools, and oversee, consonant with federal regulations and statutes, the availability of high-quality internet access during the COVID-19 pandemic in support of the constitutional education obligations of the state.

The legislature further finds that it is necessary to establish a competitively-neutral funding mechanism to provide the resources necessary to assure and maintain satisfaction of the constitutional education obligations of the state.

S. 3184 3

Therefore, be it resolved, that, the legislature hereby approves the use of the police power inherent in the state of New York to protect and promote the safety, life, public health, public convenience, general prosperity, and well-being of society, and the welfare of the state's population and economy, as necessary to satisfy the provisions of Article XI of the New York state Constitution to provide a free public education pursuant to the E-Let's Expand Access to Remote Now (E-LEARN) act, as defined in this act.

§ 3. The education law is amended by adding a new article 9-A to read as follows:

ARTICLE 9-A

E-LEARN PROGRAM Section 430. Definitions.

431. Application for allocation from the E-LEARN fund.

432. Allocation of E-LEARN funds.

433. Grant of permission for use of information.

434. Provision of high-quality internet access to eligible

students.

435. Provision of high-quality internet access to eligible

schools.

436. Payment of costs and expenses.

437. Collaboration.

438. Cooperation of third parties.

439. Requirements.

§ 430. Definitions. For the purposes of this article:

1. "Broadband internet access service" means a service provided by wire or radio in New York state that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service. Broadband internet access service also encompasses any service provided in New York that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the provisions set forth in this article.

2. "Chancellor" means the chancellor of the New York city department of education.

3. "Department" means the education department of the state of New York.

4. "Eligible school" means a public school including a school operated by a board of cooperative educational services, non-public school, charter school, special act school, approved private school serving students with disabilities subject to article eighty-one or eighty-nine of this chapter, state supported school subject to article eighty-five of this chapter, or state operated school subject to article eighty-seven or eighty-eight of this chapter, in each case serving students between five and twenty-one years of age.

5. "Eligible student" means a student who is a resident of the state between five and twenty-one years of age who is enrolled in an eligible school or who is provided home instruction in compliance with part one of article sixty-five of this chapter and applicable regulations.

6. "High-quality internet access" means, with respect to broadband internet access service provided to an eligible student, uninterrupted broadband internet access service which is not limited to one or more particular devices and which provides actual and stable download speeds of at least 25 megabits per second (Mbps) and upload speeds of at least 3 Mbps at all times throughout the applicable school year, and, with

S. 3184 4

respect to broadband internet access service provided to an eligible school, actual and stable download speeds of at least 1 Mbps per enrolled student and upload speeds of at least 1 Mbps per enrolled student at all times throughout the applicable school year.

7. "Telecommunication service provider" means a business that provides broadband internet access service in the state.

§ 431. Application for allocation from the E-LEARN fund. 1. Each public school district with respect to eligible schools under the jurisdiction of such public school district, board of cooperative educational services with respect to eligible schools under the jurisdiction of such board of cooperative educational services, non-public school, charter school, approved private school serving students with disabilities subject to article eighty-one or eighty-nine of this chapter, state supported school subject to article eighty-five of this chapter, or state operated school subject to article eighty-seven or eighty-eight of this chapter is hereby directed to submit documentation to the department of the requirements necessary to satisfy the provisions of sections four hundred thirty-four and four hundred thirty-five of this article. Each such public school district, board of cooperative educational services or school, as applicable, shall make application within fortyfive days of the effective date of this article to the department setting forth such requirements, and annually thereafter before August first.

2. The chancellor is hereby directed to submit documentation to the department of the requirements necessary to satisfy the provisions of sections four hundred thirty-four and four hundred thirty-five of this article with respect to eligible schools under the jurisdiction of the New York city department of education and eligible students enrolled in such eligible schools. The chancellor shall make application to the department within ninety days of the effective date of this article setting forth such requirements of such eligible schools, and annually thereafter before August first.

3. The person in parental relation to each eligible student who is providing home instruction in compliance with part one of article sixty-five of this chapter and applicable regulations is hereby directed to submit documentation to the department of the requirements necessary to satisfy the provisions of sections four hundred thirty-four and four hundred thirty-five of this article with respect to such eligible students. Such person in parental relation shall make application to the department within forty-five days of the effective date of this article setting forth such requirements of such eligible school, and annually thereafter before August first.

§ 432. Allocation of E-LEARN funds. The commissioner shall determine criteria for allocation of moneys from the E-LEARN fund to public school districts, boards of cooperative educational services, the New York city department of education, non-public schools, charter schools, special act schools, approved private schools serving students with disabilities subject to article eighty-one or eighty-nine of this chapter, state supported school subject to article eighty-five of this chapter, state operated school subject to article eighty-seven or eighty-eight of this chapter, and persons in parental relation to eligible students who are providing home instruction in compliance with part one of article sixty-five of this chapter and applicable regulations for achieving equitable access to remote learning resources for eligible students and eligible schools pursuant to sections four hundred thirty-four and four hundred thirty-five of this article. Such criteria shall include but not

S. 3184 5

be limited to the number of eligible students at each eligible school, the degree to which multiple eligible students are members of the same household and reside at the same residence, the response rate of grants of permission pursuant to section four hundred thirty-three of this article, the degree of need of each eligible school and their respective classrooms, and, subject to section four hundred thirty-seven of this article, the different regional factors affecting the provision of highquality internet access.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the education law, the tax law, the state finance law and the public service law, in relation to ensuring all children have access to the delivery of technology through high-quality broadband internet connectivity in support of the constitutional education obli- gations of the state; and providing for the repeal of such provisions upon expiration thereof

Purpose or general idea of bill

To ensure high-quality Internet access for every student and school in New York State during the COVID-19 pandemic by establishing the E-LEARN fund through an assessment on intrastate operating revenues of telecom- munication companies.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 sets the short title.

Read the full memo (1,542 words)

Section 2 sets forth the legislative intent, which stipulates the need for broadband Internet connectivity to uphold the state's constitutional duty to provide for the maintenance and support of a system of free common schools, wherein all the children of the state may be educated, and approves the use of the state's police power to achieve such contin- ued constitutional duty.

Section 3 provides for:

1. School districts, BOCES, the New York City Department of Education, certain charter schools, non-public schools, approved private schools, state supported schools, and state operated schools, and parents of homeschooled children to submit documentation to the state education department regarding the need for high-quality Internet access for students and schools currently lacking such service;

2. Equitable allocation of the E-LEARN fund by the state education department based on such criteria as the number of students served by each school, the degree to which multiple eligible students are members of the same household and reside at the same residence, the response rate of grants of permission by families for schools to use their contact information to obtain high-quality internet, the degree of need of each eligible school and their respective classrooms, and the differ- ent regional factors affecting the provision of high-quality internet access;

3. A process for school districts, BOCES, the New York City Department of Education, and certain schools to obtain information from students and their families as to whether they have high-quality internet access and permission from families of students to use their contact informa- tion to obtain high-quality Internet access on their behalf, or, for those with access already, to provide their contact information to their internet service provider for purposes of reducing their internet service costs;

4. Authorization for school districts, BOCES, the New York City Depart- ment of Education, and certain schools to enter into agreements to provide for high-quality internet access on behalf of their students who do not have such access;

5. Direction to school districts, BOCES, the New York City Department of Education, and certain schools to contract for high-quality internet access for those schools who do not have such access;

6. Reimbursement of costs, and payment of invoices, related to obtaining high-quality internet access in accordance with the E-LEARN Act out of the E-LEARN fund;

7. A requirement that efforts to achieve the objectives of the E-LEARN Act be made in coordination with community-based organizations;

8. Cooperation of certain third parties in the efforts of educational entities and their students to achieve the objective of securing high- quality Internet access for all eligible students; and

9. A prohibition against qualifying the requirements of the E-LEARN Act by reason of the difficulty or cost of providing high-quality internet access to particular students or schools.

Section 4 amends the tax law to detail the duties of the department of taxation and finance with respect to assessing a quarterly charge on telecommunication service providers and transferring collected amounts to the comptroller to be deposited in the E-LEARN fund.

Section 5 amends the state finance law to establish the E-LEARN fund and details how it shall be administered.

Section 6 amends the heading of article 11 of the public service law to include telecommunication service providers.

Section 7 amends the public service law to require telecommunication service providers, based on information provided by the state education department to the department of public service which is then conveyed to the telecommunication service providers, to reduce their invoices for students and schools who already have the benefit of high-quality inter- net access in an amount equal to the average cost of providing high- quality internet access to those students and schools who receive such high-quality internet access as a result of the E-LEARN Act.

Section 9 provides for severability.

Section 10 provides for the term of effectiveness.

Justification

The COVID-19 pandemic has stymied traditional education in New York. Despite heroic efforts on the parts of teachers, students, families, school administrators, community organizations, state officials, and others, the forced transition to remote and hybrid learning has been too swift and too underfunded to permit learning that achieves the state's objectives and the mandate to serve every student. In particular, the lack of broadband connectivity, both for students and schools, has thwarted remote learning efforts and exacerbated the "digital divide." A groundswell of stories from students, families, teachers, and school officials offer a stark picture of how inadequate Internet access has affected students' learning and wellbeing (see, e.g., the New York Times article "These Families Feel Forgotten as N.Y.C. Pushes to Open Schools" by Eliza Shapiro, September 14, 2020 and the Daily News article "NYC students in homeless shelters still can't get on the Internet even after city switches cellular providers: advocates" by Noah Goldberg and Micha- el Elsen-Rooney and, in Politico, "Legal Aid threatens to sue city over lack of internet access for homeless students" by Janaki Chadha, October 9, 2020). In addition, a host of studies, including those by Common Sense and Boston Consulting Group ("Closing the K-12 Digital Divide in the Age of Distance Learning") and McKinsey ("COVID-19 and student learning in the United States: The hurt could last a lifetime") detail the significant challenges faced by those students without high-quality internet access, and the widespread and enduring nature of the ensuing consequences. Press investigations and public-interest group reports have detailed that these difficulties are felt most acutely by students of color, low-income families, students in homeless shelters, and those who reside in rural parts of the state (see, e.g., the Daily News arti- cle "Majority Black & Latino NYC schools saw lower remote learning attendance last spring: analysis" by Michael Elsen-Rooney, October 15, 2020).

The situation calls for extraordinary measures. This bill recognizes the immediate and long-term threats poed to our children by requiring tele- communication companies to step up and provide their services to those in need for free. This type of shared sacrifice is what is needed to get us through the crisis, and without it, the magnitude of the consequences will plague our state for years to come. The mechanism in the bill for achieving this end is narrowly tailored to address the argument that federal preemption overrides the state's ability to regulate many aspects of telecommunication companies' businesses. Using an assessment on telecommunication companies' intrastate revenue to create the E-LEARN fund ensures that the amounts utilized to ensure high-quality internet for unserved students and schools are specific to New York State and are not of interstate concern. Moreover, the threat of failing to fulfill the mandate set forth in Article XI of the state Constitution, that "The Legislature shall provide for the maintenance and support of a system of free common schools, wherein all the children of the state may be educated" obligates us to invoke the state's police power to sustain adequate learning during the COVID-19 pandemic. Such power shall be used to require telecommunications companies to reduce invoices on existing internet service to students and schools who already have broadband connectivity, thus treating equitably all students and schools.

Upon creation of the E-LEARN fund, school districts, BOCES, the NYC Department of Education, and eligible schools report internet connectiv- ity needs to the state education department, which shall then allocate amounts in the E-LEARN fund in an equitable fashion based on a variety of pertinent criteria. These educational entities, in collaboration with community organizations and other third parties as necessary, then enter into contracts with telecommunication companies for internet service and take such other steps as shall be necessary to provide high-quality internet access to those students and schools without it.

Out of the E-LEARN fund, and at the direction of the state education department, the comptroller will reimburse costs incurred and pay invoices for the services obtained. The E-LEARN program will continue throughout any school year in which the COVID-19 emergency declaration continues in effect. Recognizing that more challenges lie ahead and that this bill is not the solution to all education connectivity issues, this approach imposes time-limited obligations to stem the tide of educational losses caused by the sudden shift to remote learning. An effort at this scale will give students and their families hope that they can emerge from the pandemic having sustained the learning that is central to their lives.

Prior legislative history

2020: 59112 Referred to Rules

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately and shall terminate on the last day of the school year in which the state of emergency declared pursuant to executive order 202 of 2020 terminates.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.