What's happening
This bill increases transparency and shareholder protections in New York cooperative housing corporations by requiring open meetings, financial disclosures, member approval of major expenditures, and timely sharing of official documents.
Why it matters
Gives shareholders more direct power over management. The bill allows members holding a majority of shares to remove and bar management companies after the sponsor loses majority ownership, effectively increasing resident control over building operations.
Limits conflicts of interest in board governance. Employees or representatives of management companies who are not both residents and shareholders are now prohibited from serving on cooperative boards, reducing the risk of self-dealing or outside influence.
Strengthens oversight of major building expenditures. Any non-emergency capital project over $50,000 must follow a transparent bidding process, with all bids shared unredacted with directors and subject to board approval, helping ensure fair contracting and preventing misuse of funds.
Improves access to critical information for residents. Members and residents gain the right to timely inspect financial receipts, board minutes, budgets, and official notices or violations, supporting accountability and enabling residents to better monitor their cooperative’s financial health and regulatory compliance.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Open Up Co-op Boards
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
1 Co-sponsor
History
- Referred to corporations, authorities and commissions
- Referred to corporations, authorities and commissions
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
4595
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
February 5, 2021
Introduced by Sen. MAYER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Corporations, Authorities and Commissions
AN ACT to amend the cooperative corporations law, in relation to increasing transparency in cooperative housing corporations
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The cooperative corporations law is amended by adding a new article 9 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 9
COOPERATIVE HOUSING CORPORATIONS TITLE I. APPLICABILITY.
II. COOPERATIVE HOUSING CORPORATION STRUCTURE.
III. COOPERATIVE SHAREHOLDER PROTECTION ACT.
TITLE I
APPLICABILITY Section 139. Applicability.
§ 139. Applicability. Any city with a population of one million or more shall be permitted to opt out of the provisions of this article.
TITLE II
COOPERATIVE HOUSING CORPORATION STRUCTURE Section 140. Applicability of business corporation law.
141. Definitions.
142. Additional powers of members.
143. Meetings; budget.
144. Service of employees of management companies on the board
prohibited.
§ 140. Applicability of business corporation law. If any provision of the business corporation law conflicts with any provision of this article, the provision of this article shall prevail, and the conflicting provision of the business corporation law shall not apply in such case. If any provision of this article relates to a matter embraced in the
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD08599-03-1
S. 4595 2
business corporation law but is not in conflict therewith, both provisions shall apply.
§ 141. Definitions. For the purposes of this title, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
1. "Cooperative housing corporation" means a corporation formed pursuant to this chapter or article four of the business corporation law that owns or leases residential premises and operates the same on a cooperative basis.
2. "Management company" means a person, firm, corporation, partnership, association, limited liability company, or other entity retained by a cooperative housing corporation to conduct the business of such corporation, including but not limited to, operating the premises, keeping the books and records, managing dwelling unit transactions, and taking such other actions as may be necessary for compliance with applicable law.
3. "Resident" means an individual maintaining a place of residence in a dwelling unit on the premises of a cooperative housing corporation.
4. "Member" means a natural person holding a membership in a cooperative housing corporation, whether evidenced by a certificate of membership or by a certificate of stock or by other authorized means of identification.
§ 142. Additional powers of members. After the first date on which the sponsor of a cooperative housing corporation owns less than a majority of all dwelling units operated by such cooperative housing corporation, the holders of a majority of the shares held by all members may, by action duly taken pursuant to either section six hundred fourteen or six hundred fifteen of the business corporation law, remove any management company of such cooperative housing corporation from such service and may prohibit such management company from serving in such capacity thereafter.
§ 143. Meetings; budget. 1. Meetings of the board of a cooperative housing corporation shall be held at least four times each fiscal year with at least one meeting in each fiscal quarter. Members shall be permitted to be present at all such board meetings except when such board meets in executive session.
2. Complete minutes of all meetings of the board of a cooperative housing corporation and/or members thereof shall be made available to members no later than one month after such meeting.
3. The board of a cooperative housing corporation shall submit an annual detailed budget to the members one month prior to the end of such cooperative housing corporation's fiscal year. Such budget shall be in plain language and subject to approval by a majority of members.
§ 144. Service of employees of management companies on the board prohibited. No cooperative housing corporation shall permit an employee, officer, director, representative or agent of any management company of such cooperative housing corporation that is not both a resident and a shareholder to serve on the board.
TITLE III
COOPERATIVE SHAREHOLDER PROTECTION ACT Section 150. Short title.
151. Definitions.
152. Restrictions on capital improvements, renovations and
repairs.
153. Disclosure of expenses.
154. Availability of official notices and reports.
S. 4595 3
§ 150. Short title. This title shall be known and may be cited as the "cooperative shareholder protection act".
§ 151. Definitions. For the purposes of this title, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
1. "Cooperative housing corporation" means a corporation formed pursuant to this chapter or article four of the business corporation law that owns or leases residential premises and operates the same on a cooperative basis.
2. "Management company" means a person, firm, corporation, partnership, association, limited liability company, or other entity retained by a cooperative housing corporation to conduct the business of such corporation, including but not limited to, operating the premises, keeping the books and records, managing dwelling unit transactions, and taking such other actions as may be necessary for compliance with applicable law.
3. "Resident" means an individual maintaining a place of residence in a dwelling unit on the premises of a cooperative housing corporation.
4. "Member" means a natural person holding a membership in a cooperative housing corporation, whether evidenced by a certificate of membership or by a certificate of stock or by other authorized means of identification.
§ 152. Restrictions on capital improvements, renovations and repairs. 1. All non-emergency capital improvements, renovations, and repairs to premises operated by a cooperative housing corporation for which the cost to such cooperative housing corporation is in excess of fifty thousand dollars shall require prior approval of such action by the board of directors in compliance with section seven hundred four of the business corporation law.
2. A cooperative housing corporation shall maintain and adhere to a procedure, as set forth in the bylaws, for soliciting bids for all nonemergency capital improvements, renovations and repairs for which the cost to the cooperative housing corporation is in excess of fifty thousand dollars. Such procedure shall require that all bids received shall be provided in an unredacted form to all directors prior to any action being taken or any approval to authorize any such capital improvement, renovation or repair in accordance with subdivision one of this section is made.
§ 153. Disclosure of expenses. Any financial report provided to the members shall be in plain language. Itemized receipts of all expenditures of a cooperative housing corporation shall be submitted to the treasurer and kept in the books and records of such cooperative housing corporation for a period of at least seven years. Such receipts shall be made available for inspection by a member or resident on the premises within three business days after a request to inspect such receipts is made by the member or resident.
§ 154. Availability of official notices and reports. Any inspection report or notice of violation of any law, code, ordinance, rule, regulation or order received by a cooperative housing corporation by any federal, state, county, municipal body or agency shall be made available to all members and residents within two weeks of receipt thereof. Any written appeal, response or reply made by the cooperative housing corporation to any such report or notice of violation shall be made available to all members and residents within one week of when such response is made.
§ 2. This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the cooperative corporations law, in relation to increasing transparency in cooperative housing corporations
Purpose or general idea of bill
Enacts reforms in corporate governance and transparency of cooperative housing corporations.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 adds a new ARTICLE 9 to the cooperative corporations law to make a number of changes to the way cooperative housing corporations are governed.
Read the full memo (1,135 words)
Title I of the new ARTICLE 9 (new section 139 of the cooperative corpo- rations law) permits cities with populations of one million or more to opt out of the provisions of this legislation. Title II of the new ARTICLE 9 creates new sections 140-145:
* Section 140 makes reference to the business corporation law to clarify that this new ARTICLE 9 supersedes any conflicting provisions of the business corporation law.
* Section 141 establishes certain definitions.
* Section 142 permits shareholders, after at least 501 of all units in a cooperative have been sold, to remove a cooperative's management company by majority vote.
* Section 143 requires the board of a cooperative to meet at least once each fiscal quarter, that all board and shareholder meeting minutes be made available to shareholders within one week of the respective meet- ing, and that the board submit an annual budget to shareholders for approval by majority vote prior to each new fiscal year.
* Section 144 prohibits affiliates of management companies from serving on the board.
Title III of the new ARTICLE 9 creates new sections 146-151:
* Section 150 establishes the title of Title III to be the "cooperative shareholder protection act."
* Section 151 establishes certain definitions.
* Section 152 requires that (1) any non-emergency capital expenditure in excess of $50,000 receive prior approval by the board of directors, and (2) that cooperatives adhere to a procedure set forth in the bylaws for soliciting and accepting bids for capital improvements, renovations, and repairs in excess of $50,000, including that bids be provided to the board in unredacted form prior to any action to approve a bid.
* Section 153 requires that (1) all financial reports provided to share- holders be in plain language, and (2) itemize receipts of all expendi- tures be submitted to the treasurer, retained for seven years, and made available to shareholders and residents upon three business days' notice.
* Section 154 requires that any official notices of violation by the cooperative of any law, code, ordinance, rule, regulation, or order be made available to all shareholders within one week of receipt, and that any responses thereto likewise be made available to all shareholders and residents within one week of when the response is made.
Section 2 sets the effective date.
Justification
In many New York State metropolitan areas, prices for homes are cost prohibitive and affordable rentals are scarce. Cooperative housing is a wonderful option for many residents looking to invest in a community. However, current laws governing cooperatives present challenges for shareholders and can undermine their confidence in the governance of their home and investment. Unless there is overt abuse of corporate power, financial malfeasance, or blatant legal problems with the cooper- ative board or management company, there are limited protections for both shareholders and residents. The cooperative shareholder is in the unique situation of being an owner of a property where they reside with- out adequate laws for ensuring they have information from, and control over, management of the living space which they own.
Many cooperative shareholders express frustration that their access to information is limited and that management companies, which are entities hired to help run cooperatives, have conflicts of interest or use their power to exclude shareholders from important decisions. For example, shareholders and residents are frequently kept in the dark about expen- sive capital improvements and excluded from decision-making and control. When shareholders suspect financial mismanagement, they often struggle to gain access to financial information, sometimes even in violation of law, with little recourse. To address these mostly unmitigated diffi- culties, this bill enacts broad-scale reforms to enhance protections for cooperative housing shareholders and residents by implementing substan- tial modifications to current laws relating to corporate governance and transparency. One of the primary thrusts of this legislation is to reign in management companies by reducing opportunities for abuse.
Specifically, allowing shareholders to fire a management company by majority vote, and by limiting affiliates of management companies from serving on the board of directors, this bill reduces their ability to obfuscate and/or control operations, expenses, and management to the detriment of the shareholders and residents. The bill also improves oversight of management company operations by requiring non-emergency capital projects over $50,000 to be approved in advance by the board, that all bids on projects over $50,000 be solicited and considered under a set procedure, and that the board receive full disclosure of bid details prior to any action to approve a project.
Shareholder access to information and oversight powers are other realms in which cooperative housing law requires increased protections. While shareholders nominally enjoy rights to certain information under the business corporation law, procedures for exercising those rights are difficult and time-consuming, requests for information are routinely and improperly denied, and enforcing such rights often entails protracted legal action and substantial expense. This bill addresses these inade- quacies by requiring that:
1. all financial reports be in plain language;
2. an annual budget be submitted at least one month before the beginning of the fiscal year for approval by the shareholders;
3. board and shareholder meeting minutes be made available to sharehold- ers;
4. itemized receipts be obtained for all expenses, retained for at least seven years, and made available to shareholders upon request; and
5. notices of any legal violation by the cooperative, and any response thereto, be made available to shareholders. Within some cooperatives, Boards of directors cause undue difficulties for shareholders and resi- dents attempting to become more involved with or informed about cooper- ative governance and finances. To combat a lack of oversight and other challenges shareholders face, this bill requires board meetings to be held at least once each fiscal quarter so that board members are more engaged in managing the cooperative. Boards can also make it difficult for shareholders to enforce their rights. As mentioned above, by requir- ing that minutes of board meetings (as well as shareholder meetings) be made available to shareholders, this bill gives shareholders increased access to information regarding cooperative management matters, which they can use to conduct better oversight of both board and management company activities, and thereby understand and, when necessary, shine light on mismanagement and improper actions.
Prior legislative history
None
Fiscal implications
None to the state
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.