What's happening
This bill allows certain environmental violators to undertake approved environmental benefit projects instead of paying full civil penalties, under strict conditions.
Why it matters
Restricts eligibility to less egregious violators. Only those without a history of significant or repeated violations, or intentional, knowing, or reckless misconduct, can use environmental benefit projects, ensuring that habitual or severe offenders cannot avoid full penalties.
Prioritizes real, local environmental gains. Projects must provide tangible, additional environmental benefits in the community where the violation occurred, rather than simply meeting existing obligations or benefiting the violator.
Requires financial deterrence and transparency. Violators must still pay penalties that recapture any economic advantage from breaking the law, and settlements must be publicly disclosed and approved by the Attorney General, ensuring accountability and preserving the deterrent effect.
Mandates enforceable and trackable projects. Projects must have clear, enforceable timelines, ongoing reporting, and oversight from the environmental department, ensuring that promised benefits are actually delivered and monitored.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Businesses facing environmental enforcement
The bill would restrict eligibility for projects in lieu of civil penalties and require eligible violators to pay penalties recovering their economic gain from noncompliance plus part of the penalty reflecting the violation’s seriousness.
Department of Environmental Conservation
The department would have to ensure projects deliver benefits beyond required compliance, meet enforceable schedules and reporting requirements, and justify department oversight.
Residents near environmental violations
Projects would, where practicable, be located in the county and within 25 miles of the violation, with settlement details published locally at least 45 days before execution.
New York State Attorney General
The attorney general would have to review and approve settlements or administrative orders involving environmental benefit projects.
Headline styles
Green Projects Replace Penalties
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to environmental conservation
- Referred to environmental conservation
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Let Offenders Fund Green Projects
In Assembly Committee · Environmental Conservation · Sponsor Steven Englebright
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
4794
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
February 12, 2021
Introduced by Sen. PARKER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Environmental Conservation
AN ACT to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to environmental benefit projects in lieu of civil penalties
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The environmental conservation law is amended by adding a new section 71-0520 to read as follows: § 71-0520. Environmental benefit projects in lieu of civil penalties.
1. For purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
a. "Economic benefit of noncompliance" shall mean that portion of the civil penalty which includes the economic gain to the respondent resulting from its failure to comply with the applicable standards, calculated from the first day of violation and includes the present value of avoided capital and operation costs and permanently avoided costs which would have been expended if compliance had occurred when required.
b. "Environmental benefit project" or "project" shall mean a project in lieu of full payment of civil penalties undertaken by a violator that is intended to compensate for a violation or contravention of applicable standards.
c. "Gravity component" shall mean that portion of the civil penalty which reflects the seriousness of a violation, calculated on the basis of the potential and actual harm caused by the violation, and the value of the natural resource damages, if the violator is not repairing the harm.
2. The commissioner shall not enter into any agreement or administrative order which provides for a partial settlement of conditions in the form of any environmental benefit project in lieu of the payment of civil penalties unless all of the following conditions are met:
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD08680-01-1
S. 4794 2
a. The respondent does not have a record of significant or repeated noncompliance or recalcitrance;
b. The violation was not committed intentionally, knowingly or recklessly, or with any of the culpable mental states defined in section 15.05 of the penal law;
c. The violation did not result in a threat to public health or cause grave or serious environmental harm;
d. The respondent shall, in good faith, undertake all necessary steps to promptly correct the violation;
e. Projects shall be initiated in addition to all regulatory compliance obligations and shall be designed to provide an environmental benefit beyond the benefits of full compliance;
f. Projects cannot be activities otherwise required by law or already obtainable under the department's authority;
g. All violations shall be corrected to ensure compliance with applicable environmental law and regulations, and respondents shall not be given additional time to correct violations in order to complete a project;
h. Projects shall not be measures which the respondent would have undertaken anyway within the next five years;
i. Projects shall be designed to provide a discernible benefit to the environment rather than to the respondent;
j. To ensure that the deterrent effect of a settlement is achieved, settlements involving a project shall include a payable penalty component;
k. The project is within the capability of the department to review and monitor, and shall yield benefits significant enough to justify department oversight; and
l. A project can neither be used to cover administrative costs of the department nor as a revenue generating mechanism for the department.
3. Environmental benefit projects shall meet the following criteria:
a. The project shall, to the extent practicable, be located within the county where the violation occurred, within twenty-five linear miles of site of the violation;
b. An environmental restoration project shall go beyond repairing the damage caused by the violation to enhance the condition of the ecosystem or geographic area adversely affected;
c. A pollution prevention project shall substantially reduce or prevent the generation or release of pollutants through source reduction;
d. A risk reduction project shall develop and implement risk management or accident prevention/emergency planning programs which provide protection in excess of industry standards and existing or future regulatory requirements; and
e. An environmental education project shall, to the extent practicable, be directed toward understanding the nature of the industry which has caused the violation, how the violation impacted the community and ways in which the community can become more vigilant in monitoring environmental insults and violations.
4. An environmental benefit project shall not include the following:
a. A contribution to environmental research at a college or university;
b. A project, though beneficial to the impacted local government, unrelated to environmental protection;
c. Studies or assessments without a commitment to implement the results;
S. 4794 3
d. Performance of projects by a third party unless such party is required to implement the project specified in the settlement document; or
e. Public education projects.
5. Settlements which contain a project shall contain:
a. a payable penalty component which fully recovers the economic benefit of noncompliance to the respondent;
b. a payable portion of the gravity component of the penalty; and
c. a written statement signed by the respondent which confirms that the respondent will not deduct the cost of the project from its taxes. If the settlement does not include such a statement, the gravity component of the penalty must be adjusted to reflect the tax benefit.
6. All projects factored into penalty calculations shall be performed pursuant to legally enforceable compliance schedules which:
a. accurately and completely describe the project, detail the actions to be performed, and provide reliable and objective means to verify that the compliance scheduled has been adhered to;
b. have enforceable milestone implementation schedules; and
c. oblige the respondent to submit periodic reports to the department describing compliance with the terms of the project.
7. All projects shall be subject to the following notice and approval conditions:
a. notice of the proposed settlement or order, including a description of the project and the payable penalties, shall be published in the environmental notice bulletin and at least one newspaper in general circulation in the area where the violations occurred, at least fortyfive days before the settlement or order is executed;
b. the attorney general shall review and approve the settlement or administrative order; and
c. whenever the respondents publicize the project or project results, the respondent shall acknowledge that the project was performed as part of the resolution of an enforcement action brought by the department.
§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to envi- ronmental benefit projects in lieu of civil penalties
Purpose or general idea of the bill
The bill codifies requirements in the environmental conservation law in relation to requirements for partial settlements in the form of environ- mental benefit projects. Most of the requirements are currently contained in a draft Departmental guidance document. A number of provisions have been added and modified. Section 71-0520(1) defines terms used in the bill. Section 710520(2) establishes conditions which must be met in order for the Department to authorize environmental bene- fit projects. Section 71-0520 (3) establishes criteria which must be met by environmental projects. Section 71-0520 (4) specifies types of activ- ities which do not qualify as environmental benefit projects. Section 71-0520(5) requires a payable economic benefit portion of the civil penalty which must be paid in full and a gravity portion of the civil penalty which reflects the seriousness of the violation which may be compensated in part by an environmental benefit project. If a respondent intends to deduct the cost of the environmental benefit project from its. taxes, an adjustment to the gravity component which reflect the tax benefit must be calculated and included in the penalty. Section 71-0520(6) specifies project completion scheduling requirements. Sec t ion 71-0520(7) requires notice in the environmental notice bulletin and a newspaper in general circulation in the area where the violations occurred at least 45 days before the settlement or order is executed; requires the Attorney General to review and approve the settlement or order; and allows the violator to publicize the environmental benefit project, acknowledging that it was performed in response to an enforce- ment action brought by the Department.
Justification
There have been instances in the recent past where the Department has approved projects authorized in lieu of monetary penalties which were not appropriate and did not benefit the community where the environ- mental damage occurred. The Department has proposed guidance which establishes requirements for "environmental benefit projects". This bill establishes many of the guidance elements in law and creates addi- tional or modified requirements. Pollution prevention projects are limited to those which reduce or prevent the generation of pollutants, and do not include actions which improve compliance. This provision will ensure that the pollution prevention project is truly directed at source reduction.
Read the full memo (699 words)
Environmental education projects are directed toward assisting the public in understanding the nature of the industry which caused the violations, how the community was impacted and ways for the community to become more vigilant. This should avoid meaningless public education programs which do little to provide the public with useful information or understanding of the enforcement process.
The settlement must include a fully recoverable economic benefit mone- tary penalty and a payable portion of the gravity component of the penalty. This provision should assure that a company avoid monetary penalties by creating an environmental benefit project which it claims is equal to the amount of the penalties.
The project should be located in the county where the violation occurred, within twenty-five linear miles of the site of the violation. This should ensure that the communities which suffered the environmental insult will recover some value from the project.
A notice of the proposed settlement must be published in the Environ- mental Notice Bulletin and in a newspaper in general circulation where the violation occurred at least 45 days before the settlement/order is executed, thereby giving the public an opportunity to review the settle- ment prior to its adoption. If the violator publicizes the project or project results, the respondent must acknowledge that the project was performed as part of the resolution of an enforcement action brought by the Department.
Prior legislative history
2019-20: S.4508/A.2421 - Referred to Environmental Conservation
2017-18: S.3113/ A.1495- REFERRED TO ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION
2015-16: S.1541/A.5134 - Died in Environmental Conservation
2013-14: S.830 - Died in Environmental Conservation
2011-12: S.7558/A.4134 - Died in Environmental Conservation
2009-10: A.1696 - Referred to Codes
2007-08: A.877 - Referred to Ways and Means
2005-06: A.6258 - Reported Referred to Ways and Means
Fiscal implications
None.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.