Skip to content
S5160Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA229

Counties Can't Override State Districts

Official title

“Provides no county shall supersede any state law which relates to the division of any county into districts for the purpose of apportionment”

Sponsor James SkoufisSD-39+8 co-sponsorsAffects Local Government
Status
Senate Floor Calendar
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Outcome
Companion signed

Bill progress

Signed via A229

What's happening

This bill sets new standards counties must follow when drawing legislative districts, emphasizing population equality, minority rights, compactness, and fairness.

Why it matters

  1. Reduces risk of gerrymandering and political manipulation. by explicitly prohibiting districts from being drawn to favor or disfavor incumbents, candidates, or parties, making the process more impartial and competitive.

  2. Prioritizes minority representation and voting rights. , requiring that district lines cannot be drawn to dilute the voting power of racial or language minority groups, which could bolster fairer representation for these communities.

  3. Strengthens legal standards for population equality and compactness. , setting a clear five percent population deviation limit for single-member districts and demanding contiguous, compact districts—potentially leading to more logical, community-based district maps.

  4. Preserves local communities and administrative efficiency. , by discouraging unnecessary splitting of towns, villages, or cities and aiming for districts that facilitate easier election administration, which may help keep communities together and elections simpler to run.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • County legislatures and charter officials

    The bill would subject county charter redistricting plans, except in counties wholly within a city, to ranked state standards notwithstanding contrary local laws.

  • Racial and language minority voters

    Districts could not be drawn with the intent or result of denying equal political participation or diminishing their ability to elect representatives of their choice.

  • Local incumbents, challengers and political parties

    The bill would prohibit drawing districts to discourage competition or favor or disfavor particular incumbents, candidates or parties.

  • City, village and town governments

    Mapmakers would have to consider existing municipal boundaries and, to the extent practicable, avoid splitting municipalities except those above the bill’s population threshold.

Headline styles

Counties Can't Override State Districts

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
James Skoufis

Senator · Senate District 39

Chair, Investigations And Government Operations

History

  1. Substituted by A229C
  2. Ordered to third reading cal.1448
  3. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  4. Print number 5160b
  5. Amend and recommit to local government
  6. Print number 5160a
  7. Amend and recommit to local government
  8. Referred to local government

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A229Assembly

Counties Can't Override Redistricting

Signed by Governor · Sponsor Amy Paulin

Impact 4 · LowSigned into law

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

5160--B

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

February 25, 2021

Introduced by Sens. SKOUFIS, GAUGHRAN, BROOKS, KAMINSKY, KAPLAN, THOMAS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Local Government -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to amend the municipal home rule law, in relation to the division of a county into districts for the apportionment of members of its local legislative body

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 4 of section 34 of the municipal home rule law is renumbered subdivision 5 and a new subdivision 4 is added to read as follows:

4. Notwithstanding any local law to the contrary, any plan of districting or redistricting adopted pursuant to a county charter or charter law relating to the division of any county, except a county wholly contained within a city, into districts for the purpose of the apportionment or reapportionment of members of its local legislative body shall be subject to federal and state constitutional requirements and shall comply with the following standards, which shall have priority in the order herein set forth, to the extent applicable:

a. If such plan of districting or redistricting includes only singlemember districts, such districts shall be as nearly equal in population as is practicable; the difference in population between the most and least populous district shall not exceed five percent of the mean population of all districts. If such plan of districting or redistricting includes multi-member districts, the plan shall provide substantially equal weight for the population of that county in the allocation of representation in the legislative body of that county; and

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD01955-14-1

S. 5160--B 2

b. Districts shall not be drawn with the intent or result of denying or abridging the equal opportunity of racial or language minority groups to participate in the political process or to diminish their ability to elect representatives of their choice; and

c. Districts shall consist of contiguous territory; and

d. Districts shall be as compact in form as practicable; and

e. Districts shall not be drawn to discourage competition or for the purpose of favoring or disfavoring incumbents or other particular candidates or political parties. The maintenance of cores of existing districts, of pre-existing political subdivisions including cities, villages, and towns, and of communities of interest shall also be considered. To the extent practicable, no villages, cities or towns except those having more than forty percent of a full ratio for each district shall be divided; and

f. Districts shall be formed so as to promote the orderly and efficient administration of elections.

§ 2. The opening paragraph and clauses (a.) and (b.) of subparagraph 13 of paragraph a of subdivision 1 of section 10 of the municipal home rule law, the opening paragraph and subclause (i.) of clause (a.) as amended by section 3 of part XX of chapter 57 of the laws of 2010, clauses (a.) and (b.) as added by chapter 834 of the laws of 1969, are amended to read as follows:

The apportionment of its legislative body and, only in connection with such action taken pursuant to this subparagraph, the composition and membership of such body, the terms of office of members thereof, the units of local government or other areas from which representatives are to be chosen and the voting powers of individual members of such legislative body. Except for the equal apportionment requirements in subclause (i.) of clause (a.) and clause (c.) of this subparagraph, which shall apply generally to any local government, the power granted by this subparagraph shall be in addition to and not in substitution for any other power and the provisions of this subparagraph shall apply only to local governments which adopt a plan of [apportionment] districting or redistricting thereunder.

(a.) A plan of [apportionment] districting or redistricting adopted under this subparagraph shall comply with the following standards, which shall have priority in the order herein set forth, to the extent applicable:

(i.) [The plan shall provide substantially equal weight for the population of that local government in the allocation of representation in the local legislative body.

(ii.) In such plan adopted by a county, no town except a town having more than one hundred and ten per cent of a full ratio for each representative, shall be divided in the formation of representation areas. Adjacent representation areas in the same town or city shall not contain a greater excess in population than five per cent of a full ratio for each representative.

(iii.) The plan shall provide substantially fair and effective representation for the people of the local government as organized in political parties.

(iv.) Representation areas shall be of convenient and contiguous territory in as compact form as practicable.] If such plan of districting or redistricting includes only single-member districts, such districts shall be as nearly equal in population as is practicable; the difference in population between the most and least populous district shall not exceed five percent of the mean population of all districts.

S. 5160--B 3

If such plan of districting or redistricting includes multi-member districts, the plan shall provide substantially equal weight for the population of that local government in the allocation of representation in the local legislative body; and

(ii.) Districts shall not be drawn with the intent or result of denying or abridging the equal opportunity of racial or language minority groups to participate in the political process or to diminish their ability to elect representatives of their choice; and

(iii.) Districts shall consist of contiguous territory; and

(iv.) Districts shall be as compact in form as practicable; and

(v.) Districts shall not be drawn to discourage competition or for the purpose of favoring or disfavoring incumbents or other particular candidates or political parties. The maintenance of cores of existing districts, of pre-existing political subdivisions including cities, villages, and towns, and of communities of interest shall also be considered. To the extent practicable, no villages or cities or towns except those having more than forty percent of a full ratio for each district shall be divided; and

(vi.) Districts shall be formed so as to promote the orderly and efficient administration of elections.

(b.) A plan of [apportionment] districting or redistricting adopted by a county under this subparagraph may provide that mayors of cities or villages, supervisors of towns or members of the legislative bodies of cities, towns, or villages, who reside in the county shall be eligible to be elected as members of the county legislative body.

§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Purpose or general idea of bill

To provide that no county shall supersede any state law which relates to the division of any county into districts for the purposes of apportion- ment

Summary of specific provisions

Section one amends section 34 of the municipal home rule law by adding a new subdivision 4 which provides that notwithstanding any local law to the contrary, any plan of districting or redistricting adopted pursuant to a county charter or charter law relating to the division of any coun- ty, except a county wholly contained within a city, into districts for the purpose of the apportionment or reapportionment of members of its local legislative body shall be subjected to federal and state constitu- tional requirements and shall comply with the following standards, which shall have priority in the order herein set forth, to the extent appli- cable:

a. If such plan of districting or redistricting includes only single- member districts, such districts shall be as nearly equal in population as is practicable; the difference in population between the most and least populous district shall not exceed five percent of the mean popu- lation of all districts. If such plan of districting or redistricting includes multi-member districts, the plan shall provide substantially equal weight for the population of that county in the allocation of representation in the legislative body of that county; and

Read the full memo (833 words)

b. Districts shall not be drawn with the intent or result of denying or abridging the equal opportunity of racial or language minority groups to participate in the political process or to diminish their ability to elect representatives of their choice; and

c. Districts shall consist of contiguous territory; and

d. Districts shall be as compact in form as practicable; and

e. Districts shall not be drawn to discourage competition or for the purpose of favoring or disfavoring incumbents or other particular candi- dates or political parties. The maintenance of cores of existing districts, of preexisting political subdivisions including cities, villages, and towns, and of communities of interest shall also be considered. To the extent practicable, no villages, cities or towns except those having more than forty percent of a full ratio for each district shall be divided; and

f. Districts shall be formed so as to promote the orderly and efficient administration of elections.

Section two amends subparagraph 13 of paragraph a of subdivision 1 of section 10 of the municipal home rule law to mirror new subdivision 4 of section 34 of the municipal home rule law as described above and to make other conforming changes.

Section three provides the effective date.

Justification

The Municipal Home Rule Law (MHRL) contains specific guidelines for county redistricting. The guidelines include a directive that counties should follow political subdivision lines to the extent applicable during redistricting.

In 1991, a county League of Women Voters challenged their county's legislative redistricting in State Supreme Court on the ground that it ignored the state guidelines. The Court ruled that the county was immune from the directives of MHRL, a finding that was upheld in the Appellate Division. It stated that the county "operates under a charter form of government and its reapportionment plans are adopted pursuant to its charter, not Municipal Home Rule Law Sec 10(1)(a)(13)(a)." Accordingly, charter counties are not legally required to follow the State redis- tricting standards set forth in MHRL. The State should extend the reach of the MHRL guidelines on redistricting to cover charter counties so that statutory provisions for electoral procedures would be uniformly applied in New York State.

In the years since this bill was originally introduced in 2002, the consensus on which standards should govern redistricting has evolved. This bill updates the provisions of MHRL Sec 10(1)(a)(13)(a) and applies those provisions to charter counties by adding identical provisions to Section 34 of MHRL, which covers charter counties. Several of the stan- dards included in this bill were part of the 2014 amendment to the New York State Constitution, which applied redistricting standards to the drawing of congressional and state legislative districts. By adding these standards to MHRL, they would also apply to the drawing of county legislative districts. The changes set forth in this bill will extend generally accepted standards for representation to all the people of New York.

Legislative history

A.426b reported to rules in 2019 and advanced to third reading cal.399 in 2020 / Same as S.4611a, advanced to third reading and committed to rules in 2019 and referred to local government in 2020.

A.446 of 2017 and 2018, referred to local governments.

A.1408 of 2015 and 2016,referred to local governments.

A.501 of 2013 and 2014,referred to local governments.

A.142 of 2011 and 2012,referred to local governments.

A.782 of 2009 and 2010,referred to local governments.

A.1017 of 2007 and 2008,referred to local governments.

A.1773 of 2005 and 2006,referred to local governments.

A.5008 of 2003 and 2004,recommitted to local governments.

A.10698 of 2002, referred to local governments.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

Immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.