What's happening
This bill creates criminal penalties for state officials who intentionally fail to comply with New York’s Freedom of Information Law.
Why it matters
Introduces personal criminal liability for high-level state officials. (including the Governor, senior staff, and agency heads) who intentionally fail to fulfill their specific duties under the Freedom of Information Law (FOIL), such as reviewing requests or certifying compliance, making it riskier for officials to ignore or delay FOIL requests.
Establishes rigorous documentation and public accountability requirements. by mandating written directives, certifications under penalty of perjury, and posting such certifications online, aiming to increase transparency and make it harder for agencies to quietly stonewall records requests.
Removes financial protections for violators. , explicitly barring the use of state funds, campaign funds, or PAC money to pay fines or legal fees for those convicted under this new offense, which could serve as a significant deterrent and emphasize personal responsibility for compliance.
Narrows excuses for non-compliance. by clarifying that agencies cannot deny requests due to workload or lack of staff if outside help can be engaged (at the requestor’s expense), reducing common justifications for slow or incomplete responses and potentially speeding up access to public records.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
FOIL requesters
Entities acknowledging requests would have to grant or deny them within 30 days of the request and provide approved records within 90 days.
State agency heads
They would face written oversight directives, public certifications under penalty of perjury and a class B misdemeanor for intentionally failing to perform specified FOIL duties.
Governor and senior appointed staff
Delayed agency determinations would trigger review and written directive duties, with criminal liability for intentionally failing to perform specified duties.
State officials facing FOIL charges
Those found guilty could not use state funds, political action committee money or campaign committee money to pay fines or legal fees.
Headline styles
Criminalize FOIL Noncompliance
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Referred to investigations and government operations
- Referred to investigations and government operations
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Criminalize FOIL Noncompliance
In Assembly Committee · Governmental Employees · Sponsor Michael Lawler
Full text
4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
5752
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
March 17, 2021
Introduced by Sens. TEDISCO, JORDAN, BORRELLO, HELMING, MARTUCCI, OBER- ACKER, ORTT, PALUMBO -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Investigations and Government Operations
AN ACT to amend the public officers law, in relation to the failure to produce records in response to a FOIL request; and to amend the penal law, in relation to criminalizing the failure to comply with the freedom of information law
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 86 of the public officers law is amended by adding two new subdivisions 10 and 11 to read as follows:
10. "State agency" means any state department, division, commission, public authority or public corporation.
11. "Head of agency" means the commissioner, acting commissioner, deputy commissioner, superintendent, director, deputy director, or chief executive officer of a state agency.
§ 2. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 of section 89 of the public officers law, as amended by chapter 223 of the laws of 2008, is amended to read as follows:
(a) (1) Each entity subject to the provisions of this article, within five business days of the receipt of a written request for a record reasonably described, shall:
(i) make such record available to the person requesting it[,];
(ii) deny such request in writing; or
(iii) furnish a written acknowledgement of the receipt of such request and a statement of the approximate date, which shall be reasonable under the circumstances of the request, when such request will be granted or denied, including, where appropriate, a statement that access to the record will be determined in accordance with subdivision five of this section.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD09735-02-1
S. 5752 2
(2) Any entity which furnishes such a written acknowledgement and statement shall have up to thirty days from the date of the request to grant or deny such request, and where such request is granted, such entity shall have up to a maximum of ninety days from the date of the request to make such record available to the person requesting it. When a state agency grants a request for records from a person and the records are not made available within thirty days of such request, the head of such agency shall have a duty to review such request and direct such agency, in writing, to make the records available to the person who made the request no later than ninety days from the date of such request, and to ensure such records are made available. When a state agency receives a request for records and provides a statement of the approximate date when such request will be granted or denied, the head of such agency shall have a duty to direct such agency, in writing, to make such determination no later than thirty days from the date of such request, and to ensure such determination is made by such agency within such time. When a state agency has not denied a request for records or made records available within thirty days of a request for records, the head of such agency shall sign a certification, under penalty of perjury, which shall be signed and posted on the agency's website within forty-five days of the date of the request, and which shall include:
(i) Whether the head of such agency reviewed the request for records;
(ii) Whether the head of such agency directed the agency, in writing, to make a determination to grant or deny such request within thirty days from the date of such request;
(iii) Whether the request was granted or denied by the agency, or whether the agency failed to make a determination to grant or deny such request; and
(iv) Whether the head of such agency directed, in writing, that the records be made available to the person who requested them no later than ninety days after the date of such request. When a state agency receives a request for records, and a determination whether to grant or deny such request has not been made within thirty days of such request, the head of such agency shall have a duty to notify the governor that the agency has failed to make such determination, as required by this article, and to provide a copy of such request. Upon receipt of such notice, the governor, and any senior staff member of the governor, shall have an affirmative duty to review such request and to direct such state agency, in writing, to make a determination within forty-five days of the request and to direct such state agency, in writing, to make the requested records available within ninety days of the request, if such agency grants such request. If such state agency fails to make a determination to grant or deny a request within forty-five days of the request, or fails to make the requested records available within ninety days of the request, the governor, and any senior appointed staff member of the governor, shall each sign a separate certification, under penalty of perjury, which shall be signed and posted on the governor's website within sixty days after the record request and shall state whether the governor, or any senior appointed staff member, directed such state agency, in writing, to make a determination within forty-five days of the request and whether the governor, or any senior appointed staff member, directed such state agency to make the requested records available within ninety days of the request, if such agency granted such request.
(3) An agency shall not deny a request on the basis that the request is voluminous or that locating or reviewing the requested records or
S. 5752 3
providing the requested copies is burdensome because the agency lacks sufficient staffing or on any other basis if the agency may engage an outside professional service to provide copying, programming or other services required to provide the copy, the costs of which the agency may recover pursuant to paragraph (c) of subdivision one of section eightyseven of this article. An agency may require a person requesting lists of names and addresses to provide a written certification that such person will not use such lists of names and addresses for solicitation or fund-raising purposes and will not sell, give or otherwise make available such lists of names and addresses to any other person for the purpose of allowing that person to use such lists of names and addresses for solicitation or fund-raising purposes. If an agency determines to grant a request in whole or in part, and if circumstances prevent disclosure to the person requesting the record or records within twenty business days from the date of the acknowledgement of the receipt of the request, the agency shall state, in writing, both the reason for the inability to grant the request within twenty business days and a date certain within a reasonable period, depending on the circumstances, when the request will be granted in whole or in part. Upon payment of, or offer to pay, the fee prescribed therefor, the entity shall provide a copy of such record and certify to the correctness of such copy if so requested, or as the case may be, shall certify that it does not have possession of such record or that such record cannot be found after diligent search. Nothing in this article shall be construed to require any entity to prepare any record not possessed or maintained by such entity except the records specified in subdivision three of section eighty-seven and subdivision three of section eighty-eight of this article. When an agency has the ability to retrieve or extract a record or data maintained in a computer storage system with reasonable effort, it shall be required to do so. When doing so requires less employee time than engaging in manual retrieval or redactions from non-electronic records, the agency shall be required to retrieve or extract such record or data electronically. Any programming necessary to retrieve a record maintained in a computer storage system and to transfer that record to the medium requested by a person or to allow the transferred record to be read or printed shall not be deemed to be the preparation or creation of a new record.
§ 3. Title P of the penal law is amended by adding a new article 285 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 285
OFFENSES AGAINST TRANSPARENCY IN GOVERNMENT Section 285.05 Criminal failure to comply with the freedom of informa-
tion law. § 285.05 Criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law.
A person is guilty of criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law when:
1. such person is the governor, any senior appointed staff member of the governor, or the head of a state agency;
2. pursuant to section eighty-nine of the public officers law, such person has:
a. a duty to review a request for records;
b. a duty to direct a state agency to make a determination, in writing;
c. a duty to direct a state agency, in writing, to make records available in response to a request for records, or
d. a duty to provide a signed certification; and
S. 5752 4
3. such person, with intent, fails to review a request for records, fails to direct a state agency to make a determination in writing, fails to direct a state agency to make records available in writing, or fails to provide a signed certification. Notwithstanding any law to contrary, the state or any state agency shall not indemnify or save harmless or pay any penalty or legal fees of any person who is guilty of criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law. All those found guilty of criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law shall not use public funds, or monies from political action committees or campaign committees for the payment of fines or legal fees.
Criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law is a class B misdemeanor.
§ 4. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the public officers law, in relation to the failure to produce records in response to a FOIL request; and to amend the penal law, in relation to criminalizing the failure to comply with the freedom of information law
Purpose
This Legislation relates to the failure to produce records in response to a FOIL request; and creates a misdemeanor for the failure to comply with the freedom of information law.
Summary of provisions
Section 1. Section 86 of the public officers law is amended by adding two new subdivisions 10 and 11 to read as follows:
Read the full memo (1,947 words)
10. "State agency" means any state department, division, commission, Public authority or public corporation.
11. "Head of agency" means the commissioner, acting commissioner, Deputy commissioner, superintendent, director, deputy director, or chief execu- tive officer of a state agency.
§ 2. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 3 of section 89 of the public officers law, as amended by chapter 223 of the laws of 2008, is amended to read as follows:
(a) (1) Each entity subject to the provisions of this article, within five business days of the receipt of a written request for a record reasonably described, shall:
(i) make such record available to the person requesting it ,;
(ii) deny such request in writing; or
(iii) furnish a written acknowledgement of the receipt of such request and a statement of the approximate date, which shall be reasonable under the circumstances of the request, when such request will be granted or denied, including, where appropriate, a statement that access to the record will be determined in accordance with subdivision five of this section.
(2) Any entity which furnishes such a written acknowledgement and state- ment shall have up to thirty days from the date of the request to grant or deny such request, and where such request is granted, such entity shall have up to a maximum of ninety days from the date of the request to make such record available to the person requesting it. When a state agency grants a request for records from a person and the records are not made available within thirty days of such request, the head of such agency shall have a duty to review such request and direct such agency, in writing, to make the records available to the person who made the request no later than ninety days from the date of such request, and to ensure such records are made available. When a state agency receives a request for records and provides a statement of the approximate date when such request will be granted or denied, the head of such agency shall have a duty to direct such agency, in writing, to make such deter- mination no later than thirty days from the date of such request, and to ensure such determination is made by such agency within such time. When a state agency has not denied a request for records or made records available within thirty days of a request for records, the head of such agency shall sign a certification, under penalty of perjury, which shall be signed and posted on the agency's website within forty-five days of the date of the request, and which shall include:
(i) Whether the head of such agency reviewed the request for records;
(ii) Whether the head of such agency directed the agency, in writing, to make a determination to grant or deny such request within thirty days from the date of such request;
(iii) Whether the request was granted or denied by the agency, or wheth- er the agency failed to make a determination to grant or deny such request; and
(iv) Whether the head of such agency directed, in writing, that the records be made available to the person who requested them no later than ninety days after the date of such request. When a state agency receives a request for records, and a determination whether to grant or deny such request has not been made within thirty days of such request, the head of such agency shall have a duty to notify the governor that the agency has failed to make such determination, as required by this article, and to provide a copy of such request. Upon receipt of such notice, the governor, and any senior staff member of the governor, shall have an affirmative duty to review such request and to direct such state agency, in writing, to make a determination within forty-five days of the request and to direct such state agency, in writing, to make the requested records available within ninety days of the request, if such agency grants such request. If such state agency fails to make a deter- mination to grant or deny a request within forty-five days of the request, or fails to make the requested records available within ninety days of the request, the governor, and any senior appointed staff member of the governor, shall each sign a separate certification, under penalty of_perjury, which shall be signed_and posted_on_the governor's website within sixty days after the record request and shall state whether the governor, or any senior appointed staff member, directed such state agency, in writing, to make a determination within forty-five days of the request and whether the governor, or any senior appointed staff member, directed such state agency to make the requested records avail- able within ninety days of the request, if such agency granted such request.
(3) An agency shall not deny a request on the basis that the request is voluminous or that locating or reviewing the requested records or providing the requested copies is burdensome because the agency lacks sufficient staffing or on any other basis if the agency may engage an outside professional service to provide copying, programming or other services required to provide the copy, the costs of which the agency may recover pursuant to paragraph (c) of subdivision one of section eighty- seven of this article. An agency may require a person requesting lists of names and addresses to provide a written certification that such person will not use such lists of names and addresses for solicitation or fund-raising purposes and will not sell, give or otherwise make available such lists of names and addresses to any other person for the purpose of allowing that person to use such lists of names and addresses for solicitation or fund-raising purposes. If an agency determines to grant a request in whole or in part, and if circumstances prevent disclosure to the person requesting the record or records within twenty business days from the date of the acknowledgement of the receipt of the request, the agency shall state, in writing, both the reason for the inability to grant the request within twenty business days and a date certain within a reasonable period, depending on the circumstances, when the request will be granted in whole or in part. Upon payment of, or offer to pay, the fee prescribed therefor, the entity shall provide a copy of such record and certify to the correctness of such copy if so requested, or as the case may be, shall certify that it does not have possession of such record or that such record cannot be found after diligent search. Nothing in this article shall be construed to require any entity to prepare any record not possessed or maintained by such entity except the records specified in subdivision three of section eighty-seven and subdivision three of section eighty-eight of this arti- cle. When an agency has the ability to retrieve or extract a record or data maintained in a computer storage system with reasonable effort, it shall be required to do so. When doing so requires less employee time than engaging in manual retrieval or redactions from non-electronic records, the agency shall be required to retrieve or extract such record or data electronically. Any programming necessary to retrieve a record maintained in a computer storage system and to transfer that record to the medium requested by a person or to allow the transferred record to be read or printed shall not be deemed to be the preparation or creation of a new record.
§ 3. Title P of the penal law is amended by adding a new article 285 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 285 OFFENSES AGAINST TRANSPARENCY IN GOVERNMENT
Section 285.05 Criminal failure to comply with the freedom of informa- tion law. § 285.05 Criminal failure to comply with the freedom of infor- mation law.
A person is guilty of criminal failure to comply with the freedom of Information law when:
1. such person is the governor, any senior appointed staff member of the governor, or the head of a state agency;
2. pursuant to section eighty-nine of the public officers law, such person has:
a. a duty to review a request for records;
b. a duty to direct a state agency to make a determination, in writing;
c. a duty to direct a state agency, in writing, to make records avail- able in response to a request for records, or
d. a duty to provide a signed certification; and
3. such person, with intent, fails to review a request for records, fails to direct a state agency to make a determination in writing, fails to direct a state agency to make records available in writing, or fails to provide a signed certification. Notwithstanding any law to contrary, the state or any state agency shall not indemnify or save harmless or pay any penalty or legal fees of any person who is guilty of criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law. All those found guilty of criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law shall not use public funds, or monies from political action committees or campaign committees for the payment of fines or legal fees.
Criminal failure to comply with the freedom of information law is a class B misdemeanor.
Justification
This bill will hold the Governor, Commissioners and senior-level appointed decision makers personally liable and subject to a Misdemeanor for violating the open government law and failing to honor valid FOIL requests in a timely manner.
This legislation would also eliminate indemnification for the Governor and senior state officials for violating the open government law, prohibiting the use of public money, or campaign finance dollars to pay court-ordered fines, or legal fees.
The most recent example of the need for this initiative was the months- on-end delay to provide the public accurate data regarding COVID-19 nursing home fatalities. In a recent decision, Acting Supreme Court Justice Kimberly O'Connor ordered the Cuomo administration to pay legal fees for The Empire Center, who filed a lawsuit demanding the release of the records last fall. This ultimately put taxpaying New Yorkers on the hook to pay for the Governor's misdeeds, rubbing salt in the wounds of all New Yorkers, especially those who lost loved ones.
She added that its continued failure to provide the petitioner a response, given the straightforward nature of the request, how the data is collected and maintained, and the fact that some of the requested data has already been made publicly available without personally identi- fying information, went against FOIL's broad standard of open and trans- parent government and was a violation of statute.
This measure will make such a violation a Class B Misdemeanor ($500 fine or up to 90 days in jail).
Legislative history
New Bill.
Fiscal implications
Savings to the state by mandating legal fees and fines not be paid with public funds.
Effective date
: This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.