What's happening
This bill revises the definition of "clinical peer reviewer" in New York’s public health and insurance laws, clarifying required credentials and specialties.
Why it matters
Clarifies required qualifications for peer reviewers. The bill spells out that clinical peer reviewers must have specific credentials—including a valid New York license and, if applicable, board certification or eligibility in the relevant specialty. This aims to ensure that reviewers making decisions about patient care are truly qualified and experienced in the relevant field.
Tailors expertise to specific treatment areas. For reviews involving mental health or substance use disorder treatments, the bill requires that reviewers have relevant behavioral health specialization and direct experience with those types of treatments. This reduces the risk of inappropriate denials or approvals from reviewers lacking specialty knowledge.
Strengthens protections for patients and providers. By requiring reviewers to have comparable expertise to the treating provider and to be knowledgeable about the service under review, the bill may help ensure that utilization review decisions (such as denials of care) are clinically appropriate and fair, potentially improving patient outcomes and transparency.
Limits loopholes and ensures oversight. By specifying licensure under New York’s education law and credentialing by national bodies only where appropriate, the bill helps prevent unqualified or loosely-credentialed individuals from serving as peer reviewers, thereby increasing accountability in insurance and health plan decisions.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Health insurers and utilization review organizations
The bill would apply a single set of clinical peer reviewer qualifications to reviews and appeals, including at least five years of practice in the relevant specialty.
Physicians serving as clinical peer reviewers
The bill would require New York medical licensure and, where applicable, board certification or eligibility in the same or a similar specialty for both reviews and appeals.
Nonphysician health care professionals
The bill would require clinical peer reviewers to hold a current, unrestricted license or certification under New York’s Education Law and meet specialty experience requirements.
Patients seeking mental health or substance use disorder treatment
The bill would require reviewers handling their treatment determinations and appeals to specialize in behavioral health and have experience delivering the relevant treatment.
Headline styles
Clarify Clinical Peer Reviewer Rules
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
1 Co-sponsor
History
- Referred to health
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Update Peer Reviewer Standards
Vetoed · Sponsor Richard Gottfried
Full text
5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
599
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE (Prefiled)
January 6, 2021
Introduced by Sen. BENJAMIN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Health
AN ACT to amend the public health law and the insurance law, in relation to the definition of clinical peer reviewer
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Subdivision 2 of section 4900 of the public health law, as amended by chapter 586 of the laws of 1998, item (B) of subparagraph (ii) of paragraph (a) as amended by chapter 41 of the laws of 2014 and subparagraph (iii) as amended and subparagraph (iv) of paragraph (a) as added by section 42 of subpart A of part BB of chapter 57 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:
2. "Clinical peer reviewer" means:
(a) [for purposes of title one of this article:
(i) a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine; or
(ii) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who:
(A) where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; and
(B) is in the same profession and same or similar specialty as the health care provider who typically manages the medical condition or disease or provides the health care service or treatment under review; or
(iii) for purposes of a determination involving substance use disorder treatment:
(A) a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD00261-01-1
S. 599 2
and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment; or
(B) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; or
(iv) for purposes of a determination involving treatment for a mental health condition:
(A) a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment; or
(B) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of a mental health courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate, or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; and
(b) for purposes of title two of this article:
(i)] a physician who:
[(A)] (i) possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine under article one hundred thirty-one of the education law;
[(B)] (ii) where applicable, is board certified or board eligible in the same or similar specialty as the health care provider who typically manages the medical condition or disease or provides the health care service or treatment under review or appeal;
[(C)] (iii) has been practicing in such area of specialty for a period of at least five years; [and]
(iv) for purposes of a determination involving substance use disorder treatment, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment;
(v) for purposes of a determination involving treatment for a mental health condition, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment; and
[(D)] (vi) is knowledgeable about the health care service or treatment under review or appeal; or
[(ii)] (b) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license or certification under title eight of the education law:
[(A)] (i) where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration;
[(B)] (ii) where applicable, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession in the same profession and same or similar specialty as the health care provider who typically manages the medical condition or disease or provides the health care service or treatment under review or appeal;
[(C)] (iii) has been practicing in such area of specialty for a period of at least five years;
S. 599 3
[(D)] (iv) is knowledgeable about the health care service or treatment under review or appeal; [and]
(v) for purposes of a determination involving substance use disorder, specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession;
(vi) for purposes of a determination involving treatment for a mental health condition, specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate, or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; and
[(E)] (vii) where applicable to such health care professional's scope of practice, is clinically supported by a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine.
[(c)] Nothing [herein] in this subdivision shall be construed to change any statutorily-defined scope of practice.
§ 2. Subsection (b) of section 4900 of the insurance law, as amended by chapter 586 of the laws of 1998, item (ii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph 1 as amended by chapter 41 of the laws of 2014, subparagraph (C) as amended and subparagraph (D) of paragraph 1 as added by section 36 of subpart A of part BB of chapter 57 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:
(b) "Clinical peer reviewer" means:
(1) [for purposes of title one of this article:
(A) a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine; or
(B) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who:
(i) where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; and
(ii) is in the same profession and same or similar specialty as the health care provider who typically manages the medical condition or disease or provides the health care service or treatment under review; or
(C) for purposes of a determination involving substance use disorder treatment:
(i) a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment; or
(ii) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; or
(D) for purposes of a determination involving treatment for a mental health condition:
S. 599 4
(i) a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment; or
(ii) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate, or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession; and
(2) for purposes of title two of this article:
(A)] a physician who:
[(i)] (A) possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine under article one hundred thirty-one of the education law;
[(ii)] (B) where applicable, is board certified or board eligible in the same or similar specialty as the health care provider who typically manages the medical condition or disease or provides the health care service or treatment under review or appeal;
[(iii)] (C) has been practicing in such area of specialty for a period of at least five years; [and]
(D) for purposes of a determination involving substance use disorder treatment, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment;
(E) for purposes of a determination involving treatment for a mental health condition, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine and who specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment; and
[(iv)] (F) is knowledgeable about the health care service or treatment under review or appeal; or
[(B)] (2) a health care professional other than a licensed physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license or certification under title eight of the education law:
[(i)] (A) where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration;
[(ii)] (B) where applicable, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession in the same profession and same or similar specialty as the health care provider who typically manages the medical condition or disease or provides the health care service or treatment under review or appeal;
[(iii)] (C) has been practicing in such area of specialty for a period of at least five years;
[(iv)] (D) for purposes of a determination involving substance use disorder treatment, specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of substance use disorder courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession;
(E) for purposes of a determination involving treatment for a mental health condition, specializes in behavioral health and has experience in the delivery of mental health courses of treatment and, where applicable, possesses a current and valid non-restricted license, certificate, or registration or, where no provision for a license, certificate or
S. 599 5
registration exists, is credentialed by the national accrediting body appropriate to the profession;
(F) is knowledgeable about the health care service or treatment under review or appeal; and
[(v)] (G) where applicable to such health care professional's scope of practice, is clinically supported by a physician who possesses a current and valid non-restricted license to practice medicine.
[(3)] Nothing [herein] in this subdivision shall be construed to change any statutorily-defined scope of practice.
§ 3. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the public health law and the insurance law, in relation to the definition of clinical peer reviewer
Purpose or general idea of bill
To ensure that a health plan may only deny payment for an otherwise covered benefit upon the review of a physician or other health care professional licensed in NYS and, when appropriate, board certified in the same or similar specialty as the treatment under review.
Summary of specific provisions
Section 1 of the bill would amend section 4900 of the Public Health Law to re-define the qualifications of a "clinical peer reviewer" who a, health plan or insurer may use to deny payment for an otherwise covered benefit on the basis that the treatment is not medically necessary. Under current law, only when a claim dispute arises to the level of an external appeal, does any qualification for such a "clinical peer reviewer" apply. This legislation would:
* require that when the clinical peer reviewer is a physician, he or she would be board-certified or board eligible in the same or similar specialty as the physician who typically recommends the treatment or manages the condition under review;
* require all clinical peer reviewers, whether physicians or other health care professionals, be licensed or certified in New York State;
* apply the same qualifications for clinical peer reviewers to the initial internal health plan utilization review process.
Section 2 of the bill would amend section 4900 of the Insurance Law to make the identical changes described above.
Section 3. of the bill is the effective date.
Justification
Under current law, the only qualification required for a utilization review agent, a person who, on behalf of a health care plan or insurer, may deny payment for an otherwise covered benefit on the basis that it is not medically necessary, is that such reviewer be a physician or health care professional licensed somewhere and trained in utilization review practice. There is no requirement that the reviewing agent be trained in the same specialty as the health care professional who would typically recommend the treatment that is under review.
Therefore, a patient's treatment recommendation may be reviewed by a provider working for the health plan who is not qualified to review the treatment that has been recommended. This can result in medically neces- sary care being inappropriately denied or unnecessarily delayed. The similar specialty qualification had been required by the 1996 Managed Care Bill of Rights. However, in 1998, in enacting the External Appeals Law, the requirement was not continued for utilization review. This legislation would restore this requirement, and in addition, ensure that all reviewers at both levels of appeal be licensed or certified in New York State, and when appropriate, such reviewing physicians be either board certified or board eligible in that specialty.
Prior legislative history
2019-20: S.8844/A3076A 2017-18: A.2539 2015-16: S.4783-A /A.445-A 2013-14: A.2693 2011-12: A.662 2009-10: A.723 2007-08: S.3450 / A.4609 2005-06: A.2206-B 2003-04: A.3441 2001-02:A.11479
Fiscal implications
None
Effective date
Ninety days after enactment.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.