What's happening
This bill establishes procedures for courts to order post-termination visitation or contact between children and their biological parents after parental rights are terminated.
Why it matters
Creates a formal process for biological parents to seek court-ordered visitation/contact with their children even after parental rights have been terminated, potentially preserving important familial relationships when in the child's best interest.
Establishes clear standards and procedures: Visitation can be ordered by agreement or, if contested, after a hearing where the court must find that opposition is unreasonable and that contact benefits the child, ensuring decisions are evidence-based and child-focused.
Sets limits and protections: Visitation is barred if the parent has severely or repeatedly abused the child (unless proven not to be the perpetrator) and requires the child’s consent if they are over 14, prioritizing safety and the child’s wishes.
Provides flexibility and enforcement options: Orders can be modified upon a substantial change in circumstances, but non-compliance does not undo adoption or guardianship; appeals do not delay adoption finalization, balancing ongoing contact with permanency for the child.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Let Terminated Parents Visit Kids
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
1 Co-sponsor
History
- Vetoed memo.84
- Delivered to governor
- Returned to senate
- Passed assembly
- Ordered to third reading rules cal.217
- Substituted for A6700
- Referred to codes
- Delivered to assembly
- Passed senateVote 57–6
- Ordered to third reading cal.1292
- Committee discharged and committed to rules
- Referred to children and families
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Allow Visits After Parental Rights
Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Latoya Joyner
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
6357
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
April 23, 2021
Introduced by Sen. SAVINO -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Children and Families
AN ACT to amend the family court act and the social services law, in relation to establishing procedures regarding orders of post-termination visitation and/or contact between a child and such child's parent
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 634 of the family court act, as amended by chapter 666 of the laws of 1976, is amended to read as follows:
§ 634. Commitment of guardianship and custody; further orders. The court may enter an order under section six hundred thirty-one of this part committing the guardianship and custody of the child to the petitioner on such conditions, if any, as it deems proper, including but not limited to, an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact pursuant to section three hundred eighty-four-b of the social services law.
§ 2. Section 384-b of the social services law is amended by adding five new subdivisions 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18 to read as follows:
14. (a) Upon application by any party to a proceeding under this section, (i) the court shall order post-termination visitation and/or contact between the child and such child's parent who is a party to such proceeding on such terms and conditions as may be agreed upon by the parent, the child, and the foster parent or authorized agency prior to the entry of an order committing the guardianship and custody of the child; or (ii) if any party does not consent, the court may order posttermination visitation and/or contact between the child and the child's parent after a hearing at which the court has determined that (A) the party's consent is being unreasonably withheld; and (B) post-termination visitation and/or contact would be in the best interest of the child.
(b) The hearing to determine whether the court should enter an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact shall be held either (i)
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD10073-02-1
S. 6357 2
concurrently with a dispositional hearing held in the proceedings to terminate the parent's rights pursuant to this section; or (ii) if no dispositional hearing is held, subsequent to the close of the fact-finding hearing on the underlying petition to terminate the parent's rights and prior to the court's entry of an order committing the guardianship and custody of the child. The court shall not hold such a hearing at any other time.
(c) Parents and children who are parties to a termination proceeding under article six of the family court act or this section, as well as such child's foster parents, or, in the case of a child who is not in the care of a foster parent, the authorized agency, shall have notice of and standing to participate in the best interest post-termination visitation and/or contact hearing.
(d) The applicant shall have the burden of proof that (i) the opposing party's consent has been unreasonably withheld; and (ii) post-termination visitation and/or contact is in the child's best interest.
(e) If the application for post-termination contact is denied after this hearing, the applicant shall not have standing to bring the same application in any other proceeding regarding the same child. However, if the court grants any visitation and/or contact, an application to modify the order, upon a showing of substantial change in circumstances, may still be brought, pursuant to subdivision fifteen of this section.
(f) The court shall have discretion, depending on the best interests of the child, to determine the nature of any post-termination visitation and/or contact.
(g) Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph (a) of this subdivision, in no event shall an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact be entered where a court has entered a finding pursuant to paragraph (a) or (b) of subdivision eight of this section that a parent severely or repeatedly abused the child, except where a court has determined that the parent seeking post-termination visitation and/or contact was not the perpetrator of such severe or repeated abuse of such child.
(h) If the child is over fourteen years of age, the consent of such child to post-termination visitation and/or contact is required.
(i) The court in its order shall indicate such person or persons who were given notice of the proceeding and whether such person or persons appeared.
15. All parties to a post-termination visitation and/or contact order entered pursuant to subdivision fourteen of this section, as well as any person who subsequently becomes the child's legal guardian, custodian or adoptive parent, may move the court to enforce or modify such order. Upon motion for modification by any such party, (i) the court shall enter an order modifying such post-termination visitation and/or contact order on such terms and conditions as may be agreed upon by the parties, or, (ii) if any party does not consent, the court may enter an order modifying such post-termination visitation and/or contact order, after a hearing at which the court has determined that (A) the party's consent is being unreasonably withheld; and (B) the modification would be based on a showing of a substantial change in circumstances and the best interests of the child.
16. Nothing in subdivision fourteen or fifteen of this section shall be construed to limit the rights of half-siblings or siblings to seek contact pursuant to subdivision nine of this section or section seventy-one of the domestic relations law following a termination of parental rights or adoption.
S. 6357 3
17. The failure of an authorized agency or a child's foster parent or any other person who subsequently becomes the child's legal guardian, custodian or adoptive parent to comply with the terms of the order of post-termination visitation and/or contact shall not constitute a basis for invalidating either the order committing the guardianship and custody of the child to the petitioner or any subsequent order of adoption regarding such child.
18. Unless a stay of adoption proceedings is granted by a judge of the family court or appellate court, an appeal from any order regarding the application for post-termination visitation and/or contact shall not provide a basis for delaying the finalization of a child's adoption.
§ 3. This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the family court act and the social services law, in relation to establishing procedures regarding orders of post-termination visitation and/or contact between a child and such child's parent
Purpose
To allow post-termination visitation and/or contact between children and their birth parents in termination of parental rights proceedings provided it is deemed in the best interest of the child.
Summary of provisions
§ 1- Amends § 634 of the family court act permitting, if proper, an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact.
Read the full memo (2,353 words)
§ 2 - Amends § 384-b of the social service law to add five new subdivi- sions 14-18:
- Allows for granting of post-termination visitation/contact either on the consent of the parent, child, and foster parents or foster care agency or after a hearing at which the court finds both that visitation/contact is in the best interest of the child and that any party opposing an order of visitation/contact does not have a reasonable basis for their opposition.
- Specifies that the party moving for an order of post-termination visitation/contact has the burden of establishing that visitation/contact is in the best interest of the child and that any party opposing an order of visitation/contact does not have a reasonable basis for their opposition.
- Provides for notification of involved parties of standing to partic- ipate in the hearing to determine whether there should be post-termina- tion visitation/contact.
- Requires the consent of a child over 14 to any post-termination visitation/contact order.
- Grants the family court the discretion to determine the appropriate form of post-termination visitation and/or contact.
- Bars repeated applications for post-termination visitation/contact orders once original application has been denied.
- Bars the entry of post-termination visitation/ contact order in cases of severe or repeated abuse, unless the parent seeking such an order was not the perpetrator of such abuse.
- Grants all parties to a post-termination visitation/contact order the ability to move the court to enforce or modify the order where there is a substantial change in circumstances and in the best interest of the child. Clarifies that siblings' rights to seek contact under the domes- tic relation law are not limited by these subdivisions.
- Specifies that failure to comply with the terms of a post-termination visitation/contact order is not a ground for invalidating either the underlying termination of parental rights or the child's adoption.
§ 3 - Provides for an effective date of 30 days after signed into law.
Justification
The Preserving Family Bonds Act reflects a growing national consensus that openness in adoption is beneficial for adoptees, birth parents, and adoptive parents(1) and brings New York law in line with the federal government's most recent guidance on achieving permanency for children in foster care, which encouraged states to make greater efforts to main- tain children's ties to their families and communities of origin even after adoption(2) This guidance made clear that in the vast majority of cases, "adoption should be viewed as an opportunity to expand a child's experience of family rather than replace their previous family," (3) and that children's relationships with their biological parents, siblings, and extended family members should continue even after termination of parental rights and adoption. "Children do not need to have previous attachments severed in order to form new ones. In fact, they will be better positioned to develop new relationships if we work to preserve their original connections, sparing them from additional grief and loss.(4)
Current law in New York provides for open adoption and post-termination visitation and/or contact when a parent voluntarily surrenders their parental rights but does not give courts any authority to allow for contact between children and biological parents after a parent's rights have been terminated.
For many years, New York State judges in the Second and Fourth Appellate Divisions were authorized to order post-termination contact pursuant to case law.(5) That practice changed after the Court of Appeals held in June 2012 in Matter of Hailey ZZ that judges did not have the explicit authority to grant post-termination contact. The Court reasoned that "the Legislature, the entity best suited to balance the critical social policy choices and the delicate issues of family relations involved in such matters, has not sanctioned judicial imposition of post-termination contact where parental rights are terminated after a contested proceed- ing.(6)
As a result of the Halley ZZ decision, parents who do not surrender their parental rights risk losing all contact with their children if they choose to defend their rights in a termination of parental rights proceeding and lose-and children's ability to remain connected to their parents hinges on the manner in which their parents' rights were severed. Yet the difference between a voluntary surrender of parental rights and an involuntary termination by the court is a procedural one; it has nothing to do with the strength of the bond between the parent and their child, or the child's need to maintain some form of contact with their family of origin following adoption.
This legislation seeks to recognize the value that post-termination contact between children and parents has for many children, especially those who have strong bonds with their biological family members. Specifically, it would provide the family court with the authority to order post-termination visitation and/or contact between a child and their biological parent after a termination of parental rights, subject to the best interests of the child. The bill gives the court the discretion to determine the appropriate type of contact for a given family, which may include, but is not limited to, supervised visitation by a family member or unsupervised visitation, telephone calls, emails, letters, exchange of pictures, social media, and skype or other forms of video chat.
If the parent, child, and the child's foster parents, do not all consent to the order of post-termination visitation and/or contact, the bill requires the court to hold a hearing to determine whether such an order is in the child's best interest. The bill ensures that parents and chil- dren who are parties to the termination proceeding, as well as the child's foster parents; have standing to participate in this hearing. It places the burden of establishing that contact would be in the child's best interest on the party seeking the order of post-termination contact and requires that party also to establish that any party opposed to the order lacks a reasonable basis for their opposition.
While the termination of a parent's right to a child may ultimately be best for that child, a growing body of research has shown that retaining some contact with a biological family or parent may also be in that child's best interest.(7) Even when a biological parent is unable to care for their child, post-termination contact allows the child to retain a relationship with their parent and may allow that parent to play a positive role in the child's life. Most children placed in the foster care system already have established significant ties to their biological parents and other family members.(8) Even children who enter foster care at birth and are ultimately adopted will likely have had regular contact and strong bonds with their biological families for a lengthy time period, even years, prior to the time the parent-child relationship is legally severed.(9)
Children who enter foster care and are eventually adopted can experience long-term emotional consequences stemming from the break-up of the biological family, the disruption in the children's most basic source of security, and the feelings of displacement that follow.(10) Children who have been adopted may experience insecurity and doubt in future relationships, based on the termination of the biological parent-child relationship.
Post-termination contact with a child's family of origin, where appro- priate, may offer several benefits to children who may remain in foster care or transition into an adoptive family. Continued contact after a parent's rights have been terminated, whether voluntarily or involuntar- ily, allows a child to maintain a relationship with his or her biolog- ical parent. It may also help a child develop a more secure sense of self by offering them the ability to better understand their parents, biological family and what led to the termination of the legal relation- ship. Post-termination contact may also help a child with the transition that comes after the termination of a parent's rights. This same child has likely already transitioned from their biological family to foster care and may now be dealing with the transition to their adoptive fami- ly. Contact may offer children the opportunity to heal and transition through communication, where appropriate and safe, with their biological parents and come to accept their life story. Especially as children age, they are better equipped to process the emotional burdens of what happened in their families that led to the termination. Biological parents can reinforce with their children, through post -termination contact, that the termination was not the fault of the child and that the parent still loves and cares for the child, even if he or she is unable to parent them.(11)
Many adopted children, no matter how their adoption was processed, find themselves curious about their biological parents and their biological ancestry.(12) Satisfying a child's curiosity about where they come from has been directly correlated to a child's well-being. Studies have shown that the more children know about their family histories, even negative family histories, "the lower their anxiety, the higher their self-esteem, the more internally controlled they were, the better their family functioning, the fewer their behavioral problems, and the more cohesive their families.(13) Post-termination contact, where appropri- ate, allows children access to their racial, ethnic, religious and cultural histories, critical in developing a sense of self. Contact may also become crucial to them later in life, including the exchange of family medical and health information.(14)
This bill will bring New York law in line with the complex realities of families involved in the child welfare system and will better allow family courts to tailor dispositional orders in termination of parental rights proceedings to meet the needs and best interests of children.
Legislative history
Similar to 4203A of 2019 Session that was vetoed by the Governor (VM 268 of 2019) This bill addresses the veto as follows:
While maintaining its core commitment to ensuring that children have the opportunity to maintain contact with their families of origin after adoption when such contact is in their best interest, the language of the proposed Preserving Family Bonds Act has been changed in significant ways in response to concerns raised by the Governor's office, child protective and foster care agencies, and others.
Most importantly, the bill now has a provision making it clear that an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact can and should be entered when the parties all consent; we hope and expect that many such orders will be issued on this basis. The bill also places an increased burden on the party seeking an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact over the opposition of one or more of the other parties. In addition to establishing that the order sought would be in the child's best interests, the applicant must now also establish that the party opposing the order does not have a reasonable basis for their failure to consent. This latter requirement is based on the caselaw interpreting the requirements of section 72 of the Domestic Relations Law, which allows a court to order visitation between a grandparent and their grandchild over the objection of the child's parent and which was held to be constitutional by the Court of Appeals in People ex rel. Sibley on Behalf of Sheppard v. Sheppard, 54 N.Y.2d 320 (1981).
In his 2019 veto memo, the Governor specifically expressed concerns about the fact (1) that the bill might permit post-termination visita- tion and/or contact to be ordered between a child and a parent who severely or repeatedly abused them; (2) that the bill might permit post- termination visitation and/or contact to be ordered over the objection of the child in question; and (3) that the modification provision in the bill might infringe on the rights of adoptive parents. The bill as now drafted addresses each of these concerns. The bill carves out exceptions for children fourteen years of age or older who do not consent to contact, and for cases of severe or repeated abuse, so that post-termination visitation and/or contact cannot be ordered in such cases, unless the party seeking such contact was not the perpetrator of the abuse. Additionally, the bill contains an updated modification provision that requires the party seeking to modify the post-termination visitation and/or contact order to establish (1) a substantial change in circumstances justifying such a modification; (2) that the modification is in the child's best interests; and (3) that any party opposing such a modification does not have a reasonable basis for their failure to consent. As discussed above, this latter requirement is based on the caselaw regarding D.R.L. § 72, which was held to be constitutional by the Court of Appeals.
The bill also addresses a number of other concerns that were raised during the 2019 Legislative session, including concerns about the timing of applications for post-termination visitation and/or contact and the possibility that litigation surrounding such applications might delay permanency for some children. Specifically, the bill clarifies that a hearing regarding a party's application for an order of post-termination visitation and/or contact must occur simultaneously with the disposi- tional hearing in the proceedings to terminate the parent's rights or, if there is no dispositional hearing, at the point in the proceedings when the dispositional hearing would have been held, i.e., subsequent to the close of fact-finding in the termination proceeding and prior to the entry of an order committing custody and guardianship of the child to the petitioning foster care agency for the purposes of adoption. The bill also specifies that an appeal from any order regarding the applica- tion for post-termination visitation and/or contact shall not provide a basis for delaying finalization of a child's adoption.
Fiscal implications
To be determined
Effective date
180 days after being signed into law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.