Skip to content
S7183Senate2021-2022 Session

Appoint Fair School Hearing Officers

Official title

“Requires the appointment of impartial hearing officers in New York City school districts”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-22Affects Education
Status
In Senate Committee
New York City Education
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · New York City Education

What's happening

This bill transfers the appointment and management of impartial hearing officers for special education cases in New York City to the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings, establishing a new division and related procedures.

Why it matters

  1. Centralizes special education hearing officer management in NYC. By shifting the appointment and oversight of impartial hearing officers from the Department of Education to the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH), the bill aims to increase independence and consistency in resolving special education disputes in the nation’s largest school district.

  2. Creates a dedicated Special Education Hearings Division at OATH. The establishment of this new division, with full-time legal staff and independent contractors, seeks to address longstanding complaints about delays and backlogs in special education hearings, potentially speeding up the resolution process for families and schools.

  3. Implements new standards, training, and oversight for hearing officers. The bill gives OATH the authority to set qualifications, training requirements, and disciplinary procedures for hearing officers, which could improve the quality and professionalism of hearings and help ensure compliance with both state and federal mandates.

  4. Ensures continuity and transition protections. The legislation outlines a transition process so that ongoing cases and rights are not disrupted, providing legal clarity for families and school districts during the shift in authority and ensuring uninterrupted access to due process for students with disabilities.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • New York City students with disabilities and their parents

    The bill would place special education hearings in a new OATH division, allowing sworn testimony in person, by telephone or by video conference with cross-examination and confidentiality protections.

  • NYC Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH)

    The bill would require a special education hearings division and give its chief administrative law judge authority over adjudicator hiring, training, certification, compensation and case assignments.

  • Special education impartial hearing officers

    After the transition period, new NYC cases would be assigned only through OATH, while officers already assigned cases would retain jurisdiction over them.

  • New York City school district

    The bill would require the district to coordinate a random case-referral system with OATH during the transition and help implement the new hearing structure.

Headline styles

Appoint Fair School Hearing Officers

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 22

Chair, Budget And Revenue

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to new york city education
  2. Referred to rules

Full text

5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7183

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

June 4, 2021

Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules

AN ACT to amend the education law, in relation to impartial hearings in school districts in cities with a population of one million or more

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Paragraph c of subdivision 1 of section 4404 of the education law, as amended by chapter 583 of the laws of 2007, is amended to read as follows:

c. Individuals so appointed by a state agency or a board of education [or a state agency] other than the board in a city school district of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants shall be selected from a list of available impartial hearing officers who have successfully completed an impartial hearing officer training program conducted by the department according to a rotation selection process prescribed in regulations of the commissioner[; except that a city school district of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants shall be exempt from such regulations to the extent it maintains its rotational selection process in effect prior to July first, nineteen hundred ninety-three]. In a city school district of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants, impartial hearing officers shall be appointed from among independent adjudicators employed by the office of administrative trials and hearings. An impartial hearing officer may receive evidence, including but not limited to documentary and testimonial evidence. Testimony may be given in person, by telephone or video conference, provided that such testimony shall be made under oath and shall be subject to cross examination, provided further that all personally identifiable data, information or records pertaining to students with disabilities examined during such testimony shall be subject to the confidentiality requirements established by regulations of the commissioner. A record of proceedings before the

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD11755-01-1

S. 7183 2

impartial hearing officer shall be maintained and made available to the parties, and the hearing shall be conducted in accordance with the regulations of the commissioner. The board of education or trustees of the school district or the state agency responsible for providing education to students with disabilities shall have the burden of proof, including the burden of persuasion and burden of production, in any such impartial hearing, except that a parent or person in parental relation seeking tuition reimbursement for a unilateral parental placement shall have the burden of persuasion and burden of production on the appropriateness of such placement. The decision of the impartial hearing officer shall be binding upon both parties unless appealed to the state review officer. The commissioner shall establish a department training program which shall be completed to the satisfaction of the commissioner as a condition of certification, provided that the office of administrative trials and hearings of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants shall be authorized to grant certification to persons who have completed training required by such office, and to require additional training for persons who have received certification from the state education department. Impartial hearing officers shall have the qualifications specified in subsection (f) of section fourteen hundred fifteen of title twenty of the United States code, the implementing federal regulations and the regulations of the commissioner. The commissioner shall promulgate regulations to ensure that no individual employed by a school district, school or program serving students with disabilities placed by a school district committee on special education acts as an impartial hearing officer and that no individual employed by such schools or programs serves as an impartial hearing officer for two years following the termination of such employment. The commissioner shall promulgate regulations establishing procedures for the suspension or revocation of impartial hearing officer certification for good cause. The commissioner shall establish maximum rates for the compensation of impartial hearing officers appointed by a state agency or a board of education other than the board in a city school district of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants, subject to the approval of the director of the division of the budget.

§ 2. Subdivision 1 of section 4404 of the education law, as amended by chapter 583 of the laws of 2007, is amended to read as follows:

1. If the recommendation of the committee on special education is not acceptable to the parent or person in parental relationship of a student, or if the committee or board of education or trustees fails to make or effectuate such a recommendation within such periods of time as may be required by regulations of the commissioner, such parents or persons in parental relationship shall notify the board of education of this situation and the board shall appoint an impartial hearing officer to hear the appeal and make a determination within such period of time as the commissioner by regulation shall determine, provided that the board of education or trustees shall offer the parent or person in parental relationship the option of mediation pursuant to section forty-four hundred four-a of this article as an alternative to an impartial hearing. Individuals so appointed by a board of education shall be selected from a list of available hearing officers who have successfully completed a hearing officer training program conducted by the department according to a rotation selection process prescribed in regulations of the commissioner; except that in a city school district of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants [shall be exempt from such regulations to the extent it maintains its rotational selection

S. 7183 3

process in effect prior to July first, nineteen hundred ninety-three] impartial hearing officers shall be appointed from among independent adjudicators employed by the office of administrative trials and hearings. The impartial hearing officer may receive evidence, including but not limited to documentary and testimonial evidence. Testimony may be given in person, by telephone or video conference, provided that such testimony shall be made under oath and shall be subject to cross examination, provided further that all personally identifiable data, information or records pertaining to students with disabilities examined during such testimony shall be subject to the confidentiality requirements established by regulations of the commissioner. A record of proceedings before the hearing officer shall be maintained and made available to the parties. The board of education or trustees of the school district or the state agency responsible for providing education to students with disabilities shall have the burden of proof, including the burden of persuasion and burden of production, in any such impartial hearing, except that a parent or person in parental relation seeking tuition reimbursement for a unilateral parental placement shall have the burden of persuasion and burden of production on the appropriateness of such placement. The decision of the hearing officer shall be binding upon both parties unless appealed to the state review officer. The commissioner shall establish a department training program which shall be completed to the satisfaction of the commissioner as a condition of certification, provided that the office of administrative trials and hearings of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants shall be authorized to grant certification to persons who have completed training required by such office, and to require additional training for persons who have received certification from the state education department. The commissioner shall develop and implement a plan to ensure that no individual employed by a school district, school or program serving students with disabilities placed by a school district committee on special education acts as an impartial hearing officer and that no individual employed by such schools or programs serves as an impartial hearing officer for two years following the termination of such employment. Such plan shall be fully implemented no later than July first, nineteen hundred ninety-six. The commissioner shall promulgate regulations establishing procedures for the suspension or revocation of impartial hearing officer certification for good cause. The commissioner shall establish maximum rates for the compensation of impartial hearing officers appointed by a state agency or a board of education other than the board in a city school district of a city having a population of more than one million inhabitants, subject to the approval of the director of the division of the budget. The commissioner shall promulgate regulations establishing procedures and timelines for expedited hearings in cases involving: (a) review of a decision that a student with a disability's behavior was not a manifestation of such student's disability, or (b) review of an interim alternative educational setting or other placement to the extent required under federal law, or (c) a request by the school district for a determination that maintaining the current educational placement of the student is substantially likely to result in injury to the student or to others.

§ 3. The New York city charter is amended by adding a new section 1049-c to read as follows:

§ 1049-c. Special education hearings division. a. There shall be in the office of administrative trials and hearings a special education hearings division that shall be responsible for functions conducted by

S. 7183 4

impartial hearing officers pursuant to sections forty-four hundred four and forty-four hundred ten of the education law for the city school district.

b. The chief administrative law judge shall have authority to:

1. direct the division with respect to its management and structure;

2. appoint a staff of full-time attorneys and maintain a supplemental roster of independent contractors to serve as independent adjudicators with the authority of impartial hearing officers acting under sections forty-four hundred four and forty-four hundred ten of the education law. Such independent adjudicators shall have the qualifications required by such sections and applicable regulations of the state education commissioner, provided that they shall have a minimum of five years experience in the practice of law, including at least one year of practice or experience in the areas of education, special education, disability rights, civil rights or administrative law;

3. train and certify such attorneys and independent contractors as qualified to conduct hearings pursuant to sections forty-four hundred four and forty-four hundred ten of the education law, and require persons who have certification granted by the state education department to receive additional training to supplement the training provided pursuant to the education law and applicable regulations;

4. determine the compensation of such independent adjudicators;

5. assign independent adjudicators to cases on a rotational basis;

6. set deadlines and other requirements for the disposition of cases as needed to comply with applicable mandates;

7. evaluate, discipline and remove independent adjudicators in a manner consistent with sections thirteen-a, three hundred eighty-seven and eight hundred twelve of this charter. Independent adjudicators in the special education division shall not be subject to the provision of section one thousand forty-nine of this chapter that requires administrative law judges to be appointed for a term of five years, and shall not be required to reside within the city;

8. promulgate regulations concerning the conduct of impartial hearings that supplement regulations of the state education commissioner in order to promote the fair and efficient resolution of cases; and

9. take such other actions consistent with state regulations as the chief administrative law judge determines necessary to effectuate the prompt and efficient resolution of cases.

c. Independent adjudicators shall conduct hearings in a manner consistent with regulations issued by the state education commissioner pursuant to section forty-four hundred four and forty-four hundred ten of the education law, and any additional regulations issued by the chief administrative law judge. They may receive evidence, including but not limited to documentary and testimonial evidence. Testimony may be given in person, by telephone or video conference, provided that such testimony shall be made under oath and shall be subject to cross examination, provided further that all personally identifiable data, information or records pertaining to students with disabilities examined during such testimony shall be subject to the confidentiality requirements established by regulations of the state education commissioner and any additional confidentiality requirements established by the chief administrative law judge.

§ 4. No existing right or remedy of any character shall be lost, impaired or affected by reason of the adoption of this act.

§ 5. No action or proceeding, administrative, civil or criminal, pending at the time when this act shall take effect, brought by or against

S. 7183 5

the city school district of the city of New York or any agency or officer of such city school district, or any impartial hearing officer, shall be affected or abated by the adoption of this act or by anything contained herein.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the education law, in relation to impartial hearings in school districts in cities with a population of one million or more

Summary of provisions of bill

Bill sections 1 and 2 amend Education Law § 4404(1)(c) to authorize the New York City Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH) to appoint independent adjudicators (who would be primarily be employees of OATH, and may also include independent contractors) to conduct impartial hearings concerning placements of students with disabilities. OATH would train and certify the independent adjudicators. These sections also codify current State regulations that authorize impartial hearing offi- cers to conduct hearings remotely.

Bill section 3 adds a new section 1049-c to Chapter 45 of the New York City Charter, creating a new Special Education Hearings Division within OATH responsible for functions conducted by impartial hearing officers pursuant to Education Law SS 4404 and 4410. Under § 1049-c(b), OATH's chief administrative law judge would direct the division; and would appoint, train, certify, evaluate, discipline and remove independent adjudicators, and determine their compensation. The chief administra- tive law judge would assign cases to the independent adjudicators on a rotational basis; set deadlines and other requirements for the disposi- tion of cases as needed to comply with applicable mandates; and have authority to issue regulations to supplement regulations of the State Commissioner of Education. Section 1049-c(c) requires the independent adjudicators to conduct hearings in a manner consistent with regulations issued by the State Education Commissioner and any additional regu- lations issued by the chief administrative law judge, and authorizes hearings to be conducted remotely.

Read the full memo (1,580 words)

Bill section 4 provides that existing rights and remedies will not be affected by reason of the adoption of this act. Bill section 5 provides that actions and proceedings pending at the effective date of this act will not be affected or abated by its adoption. Bill section 6 author- izes the State Commissioner of Education, OATH's chief administrative judge, and the New York City School District's Chancellor to promulgate rules necessary to effectuate the act consistent with applicable federal law. Bill section 7 establishes an immediate effective date with a transition period that starts on the effective date and ends on the later of January 1, 2022 or 30 days after the date when OATH's chief administrative law judge certifies to the State Education Commissioner that OATH has taken,all steps necessary to assume the responsibilities conferred on it by this act. Impartial hearing officers already assigned to cases prior to the effective date would continue to handle those cases. During the transition period, the City School District may refer cases to impartial hearing officers in accordance with provisions of the Education Law in effect prior to the transition period, or to OATH, in accordance with a random assignment system agreed upon between the City School District and OATH. After the conclusion of the transition period, impartial hearing officers would not be assigned new cases arising from City School District except by OATH. Bill section 7(3) provides for the amendments to Education Law § 4404 to be subject to the sunset of provisions of that section pursuant to Chapter 352 of the Laws of 2005.

Justification

The City School District for the City of New York (the "City School District") annually provides public education to over 1.1 million students who reside in New York City, and fully supports this bill.

Under both the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, and Article 89 of the Education Law, the New York City Department of Education (DOE) is required to evaluate and offer each student who resides in the City School District and is a student with a disability (as defined under federal and state law) a free appropriate public education ("FAPE"). The offer of FAPE is set forth in a written document known as an individual- ized education program ("IEP"), which is updated annually. Under the IDEA and Article 89, a parent of a student with a disability may chal- lenge the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the student, or the provision of a FAPE to the student, by filing a due process complaint ("DPC"), which commences an impartial due process hearing. The City School District may also bring a challenge on some of these grounds. See 20 U.S.C. §§ 1415(b)(6), (c), (f)- (i).

The statutory schedule for the due process proceeding begins with a 30-day resolution period, during which the parties to the DPC are to try to amicably resolve their dispute. If resolution is unsuccessful (and/or the parties do not agree to mediation), there is a 45-day period (excluding lawfully granted extensions) for the trial of the due process complaint.

The New York City Impartial Hearing Office is currently charged with the administration of the impartial due process hearing system for the City District. However, the recruitment, training, certification, appointment and discipline of impartial hearing officers ("IHOs") is committed to the State Education Commissioner ("SED"). In addition, state regulations govern the practice before the IHOs.

Currently, there are thousands of due process complaints that have been filed with the New York City Impartial Hearing Office for which an IHO has not been assigned. This is the result of several factors. First, to maintain certification, an impartial hearing officer need only accept one case every two years. Second, between roughly July and October every school year, thousands of DPCs are filed with the New York City Impar- tial Hearing Office (from July - October 2020 there were around 6500). Thus, not only is the current number of DPC filings extremely large, but also each year's DPC filings adds to the backlog. Third, the current roster of IHOs assigned to the New York City Impartial Hearing Office is insufficient to handle the caseload. There is no requirement that an IHO carry a minimum case load; indeed more than half of IHOs carry twelve or fewer cases. Thus, the current system is not working, with the result that all parties are being deprived of timely due process.

The proposed legislation would replace the current system for the City School District with a full-time administrative adjudicatory system, with the goal of efficaciously eliminating the backlog and providing timely hearings going forward. The New York City Office of Administra- tive Trials and Hearings ("OATH"), a component of New York City govern- ment, not DOE, would be responsible for the new system. OATH would be responsible for the recruitment, training, certification and appointment of a cadre of full-time hearing officers to hear both pending and newly filed DPCs. The officers would be required to have practiced law for at least 5 years, as compared to the one year currently required under State regulations, but as in State regulations they would be required to have at least one year of practice or experience in fields of particular relevance to the DPCs. OATH would also be responsible for implementing procedural rules concerning extensions of time, conduct of hearings, etc. as well as the discipline of IHOs. Because OATH is not part of DOE, there is no appearance of impropriety. Moreover, because OATH plans to staff its impartial hearing division with full-time administrative hear- ing adjudicators, it will have the staff and administrative structure to make it possible to have impartial hearings fairly and timely adjudi- cated, including trials on consecutive days, and to generate well-rea- soned decisions based on the facts applicable to the student's current special education placement.

Legislative history

New bill.

Fiscal implications for state and local governments

None to the State of New York. Undetermined to the City of New York.

Effective date

Immediately, provided that: 1. Impartial hearing officers assigned prior to the conclusion of the transition period described in subdivision two of this section to review a due process complaint or preside over a due process hearing pursuant to sections 4404 and 4410 of the education law shall continue to have jurisdiction with respect to such cases. After the conclusion of the transition period, impartial hearing officers shall not be assigned new cases arising from the city school district of the city of New York except by the office of administrative trials and hearings of the city of New York. 2. A transition period shall commence upon the effective date of this act. During such transition period, the city school district of the city of New York may refer cases to impartial hearing officers in accordance with provisions of the education law in effect prior to the transition period, or to the office of administrative trials and hearings of the city of New York. Such referrals shall be made in accordance with a random assignment system agreed upon between the city school district and such office. Such transition period shall end on the later of Janu- ary 1, 2022 or 30 days after the date when the chief administrative law judge of the New York city office of administrative trials and hearings certifies to the state education commissioner that such office has taken all steps necessary to assume the responsibilities conferred on such office by this act. 3. The amendments to paragraph c of subdivision 1 of section 4404 of the education law made by section one of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such subdivision pursuant to section 22 of chapter 352 of the laws of 2005, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section two of this act shall take effect.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.