What's happening
The Judith Kaye School Solutions Not Suspensions Act limits suspensions, requires restorative interventions, and expands due process and educational supports for disciplined students.
Why it matters
Major shift away from suspensions for minor misbehavior. The bill specifically prohibits suspensions for infractions like tardiness, dress code violations, absence, lack of ID, and even "willful disobedience." This means students can no longer be removed from school for nonviolent, non-threatening actions, which could reduce the number of students missing instructional time for relatively minor issues.
Push for restorative and supportive responses. Schools are now required to try less severe, supportive interventions (like restorative practices, peer mediation, and social-emotional supports) before considering suspension or removal. This fundamentally changes the approach to discipline, aiming to address root causes, keep students in class, and potentially improve school climate, rather than relying on exclusionary tactics that can push students out of the education system.
Expansion of student and family rights and due process. The bill strengthens due process for students facing discipline by requiring more detailed written notice, timely hearings, the right to legal representation, and access to evidence. It also mandates that parents be notified in their primary language and informed of the potential legal consequences of student statements. This increases transparency and can help families better advocate for their children.
Guaranteed educational continuity and re-entry supports. When students are removed or suspended, schools must quickly develop an education plan to ensure students can keep up academically and successfully re-enter school. This reduces the risk of academic setbacks and dropout that often follow disciplinary removals, and signals a shift toward supporting students’ long-term educational success even when discipline is necessary.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Students in pre-kindergarten through grade three
The bill would prohibit their suspension except when necessary to comply with federal law.
School districts, BOCES and charter schools
The bill would require revised conduct codes, use of the least severe necessary response before removal or suspension, and education plans for removed or suspended students.
Teachers and their unions
The bill would limit classroom removals to one-half school day on the same day, require discipline training and include collective bargaining units in developing conduct codes.
Parents and students facing suspension
The bill would expand written notice and evidence access and allow an attorney or advocate to represent them at suspension conferences and hearings.
Headline styles
Limit School Suspensions
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
24 Co-sponsors
- Jabari Brisport
- Jamaal Bailey
- Alessandra Biaggi
- Samra Brouk
- Cordell Cleare
- Leroy Comrie
- Jeremy Cooney
- Michael Gianaris
- Pete Harckham
- Brad Hoylman-Sigal
- Brian Kavanagh
- John Liu
- Rachel May
- Zellnor Myrie
- Kevin S. Parker
- Roxanne J. Persaud
- Jessica Ramos
- Elijah Reichlin-Melnick
- Gustavo Rivera
- Julia Salazar
- James Sanders Jr.
- Luis R. Sepúlveda
- José M. Serrano
- Kevin Thomas
History
- Referred to education
- Referred to rules
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Limit School Suspensions
In Assembly Committee · Education · Sponsor Catherine Nolan
Full text
21 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
7198
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
June 7, 2021
Introduced by Sens. JACKSON, BRISPORT, BAILEY, BENJAMIN, BIAGGI, COMRIE, GIANARIS, HARCKHAM, HOYLMAN, KAVANAGH, LIU, MAY, MYRIE, PARKER, PERSAUD, RAMOS, RIVERA, SALAZAR, SANDERS, SEPULVEDA, SERRANO -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules
AN ACT to amend the education law, in relation to school climate and codes of conduct on school property and disciplinary action following violation of such codes of conduct; and to amend the education law, in relation to making conforming amendments
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "Judith Kaye School Solutions not Suspensions Act."
§ 2. Section 2801 of the education law, as added by chapter 181 of the laws of 2000, subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 402 of the laws of 2005, the opening paragraph, paragraph a and paragraph c of subdivision 2 and paragraph a of subdivision 5 as amended by chapter 380 of the laws of 2001, paragraphs l and m as amended and paragraph n of subdivision 2 as added by chapter 482 of the laws of 2010, and subdivision 3 as amended by chapter 123 of the laws of 2003, is amended to read as follows:
§ 2801. Codes of conduct on school property. 1. For purposes of this section, school property means in or within any building, structure, athletic playing field, playground, parking lot or land contained within the real property boundary line of a public elementary or secondary school, including a charter school; or in or on a school bus, as defined in section one hundred forty-two of the vehicle and traffic law; [and a] or a school's electronic files and databases. A school function shall mean a school-sponsored or school-authorized extra-curricular event or activity regardless of where such event or activity takes place, including any event or activity that may take place in another state.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD06645-01-1
S. 7198 2
2. The board of education or the trustees[, as defined in section two of this chapter,] of every school district [within the state, however created, and every] or the chancellor of the city school district in the case of the city school district of the city of New York, and every board of cooperative educational services and [county vocational extension board] charter school, shall adopt and amend, as appropriate, a code of conduct for the maintenance of order on school property, including a school function, which shall promote and sustain a safe, respectful, and supportive school environment and govern the conduct of students, teachers and other school personnel as well as visitors and shall provide for the enforcement thereof. Such policy may be adopted by the [school] board of education or trustees, or the chancellor of the city school district in the case of the city school district of the city of New York, or other governing body only after at least one public hearing that provides for the participation of school personnel, parents, students and any other interested parties before its adoption. The school district, board of cooperative educational services, or charter school shall notify the school community and general public about the hearing at least fifteen days prior to the date of the hearing. Such notice shall include the date, time, and place of the hearing, the agenda, a copy of the proposed code of conduct, and information about a public comment period as determined by the school district, board of cooperative educational services, or charter school. The school district, board of cooperative educational services, or charter school shall take necessary steps to notify families who do not speak English and whose children attend a school in the district, a board of cooperative educational services, or a charter school. Such code of conduct shall define violations of the code of conduct and set clear expectations for student conduct on school property, including at school functions, and shall include, at a minimum:
a. provisions regarding conduct, dress and language deemed appropriate and acceptable on school property, including a school function, and conduct, dress and language deemed unacceptable and inappropriate on school property, including a school function[, and];
b. provisions regarding acceptable civil and respectful treatment of teachers, school administrators, other school personnel, students and visitors on school property[, including a] and at school [function] functions, including [the appropriate] a range of age-appropriate graduated and proportionate disciplinary measures which [may be imposed for violation of such] must be considered in responding to a code violation, and the roles of teachers, administrators, other school personnel, the board of education or trustees, or the chancellor of the city school district in the case of the city school district of the city of New York, or other governing body, and parents.
b-1. provisions that require schools to use the least severe action necessary to respond to any violation of the code of conduct before imposing a removal or suspension. Such options may include restorative practices, social and emotional supports, and other interventions. Restorative practices may include class meetings, facilitated circles, conferences, peer mediation, and other interventions that can effectively address student misconduct, hold students accountable for their behavior, and foster healthy relationships within the school community. No student, however, shall be required to participate in a restorative practice without their consent. Reasonable attempts shall also be made to obtain the consent of their parents or persons in parental relations;
S. 7198 3
[b.] b-2. provisions that prohibit classroom removals and suspensions to respond to tardiness, unexcused absence from class or school, leaving school without permission, violation of school dress code, and lack of identification upon request of school personnel;
b-3. provisions that prohibit suspensions for initial or repeated acts of willful disobedience. "Willful disobedience" shall mean disruptive, insubordinate, or rowdy behavior, including behaviors such as the use of foul or inappropriate language, gestures, comments, or refusal to follow directions;
c. provisions that prohibit the suspension of students in pre-kindergarten through grade three, except if suspension is necessary to comply with applicable federal laws;
d. standards and procedures to assure security and safety of students and school personnel;
[c.] e. provisions for the removal from the classroom and from school property, including a school function, of students and other persons who violate the code of conduct;
[d.] f. disciplinary measures to be taken in incidents involving the possession or use of illegal substances or weapons, the use of physical force, vandalism, violation of another student's civil rights and threats of violence;
[e.] g. provisions for detention, suspension and removal from the classroom of students, consistent with section thirty-two hundred fourteen of this chapter and other applicable federal, state and local laws [including];
h. provisions for the school authorities to establish policies and procedures to ensure the provision of continued educational programming and activities for students removed from the classroom, placed in detention, or suspended from school. When a student is suspended from school or removed from the classroom, the principal, or the principal's designee, in consultation with the student's teachers, shall, within twenty-four hours, create an education plan for the student for each class in which the student is enrolled, provided that if such twentyfour hour period does not end on a school day, it shall be extended to the corresponding time on the next school day. The education plan shall make provisions for a student's on-going academic instruction during the removal or suspension and shall include the steps the school will take to provide the student with a successful re-entry to school. The student shall have the opportunity to earn all academic credit he or she would have been eligible to earn had he or she been in class, including the opportunity to complete any missed assignments or take any missed examinations or assessments during the student's removal or suspension. If an examination or assessment cannot be rescheduled, the student shall be allowed on school property to take such assessment or examination on the day and time that the assessment or examination is given;
[f.] i. procedures by which violations of the code of conduct are reported to the appropriate school personnel, the facts are investigated and determined, and discipline measures [imposed and discipline measures carried out] are determined and implemented;
[g.] j. provisions ensuring such code and the enforcement thereof are in compliance with state and federal laws relating to students with disabilities;
[h. provisions setting forth the procedures by which local law enforcement agencies shall be notified of code violations which constitute a crime;
S. 7198 4
i.] k. provisions setting forth the circumstances under and procedures by which parents or persons in parental relation to the student accused of violating the code of conduct shall be notified of such code of conduct violations including notice that any statement by the student, written or oral, may be used against the student in a criminal, immigration, or juvenile delinquency investigation and/or proceeding and/or in a court of law;
[j.] l. provisions setting forth the circumstances under and procedures by which a [complaint in criminal court, a juvenile delinquency petition] student may be referred to law enforcement, consistent with the provisions of section twenty-eight hundred one-a of this article, or referred for a person in need of supervision petition as defined in articles three and seven of the family court act will be filed;
[k.] m. circumstances under and procedures by which [referral to] a student may be referred to academic services, school-based support services, or appropriate human service agencies [shall be made]; and
[l. a minimum suspension period, for students who repeatedly are substantially disruptive of the educational process or substantially interfere with the teacher's authority over the classroom, provided that the suspending authority may reduce such period on a case by case basis to be consistent with any other state and federal law. For purposes of this section, the definition of "repeatedly are substantially disruptive" shall be determined in accordance with the regulations of the commissioner;
m. a minimum suspension period for acts that would qualify the pupil to be defined as a violent pupil pursuant to paragraph a of subdivision two-a of section thirty-two hundred fourteen of this chapter, provided that the suspending authority may reduce such period on a case by case basis to be consistent with any other state and federal law; and]
n. provisions to comply with article two of this chapter.
3. The [district] code of conduct shall be developed in collaboration with [student, teacher, administrator, and parent organizations] representatives from interested stakeholders including, but not limited to, students, teachers, administrators, parents, school safety personnel, collective bargaining units, and other school personnel and shall be approved by the board of education or trustees, [or] other governing body, or by the chancellor of the city school district in the case of the city school district of the city of New York. In the city school district of the city of New York, each community district education council shall be authorized to adopt and implement additional policies, which are consistent with the city district's district-wide code of conduct, to reflect the individual needs of each community school district provided that such additional policies shall require the approval of the chancellor.
3-a. The board of education or trustees, chancellor of the city school district in the case of the city school district of the city of New York, or other governing body shall provide professional development in accordance with this section for school personnel, law enforcement and public or private security personnel employed, retained or contracted with a school district or charter school regarding the code of conduct, the use of interventions, and graduated and proportionate discipline.
4. [The] At the beginning of each school year, the board of education or trustees, chancellor of the city school district in the case of the city school district of the city of New York, or other governing body shall: translate the code of conduct into at least the three most commonly spoken languages of the children attending the school district,
S. 7198 5
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the education law, in relation to school climate and codes of conduct on school property and disciplinary action following violation of such codes of conduct; and to amend the education law, in relation to making conforming amendments
Purpose
The purpose of this bill is to reform school discipline policies to ensure the application of fair and equitable school discipline for all students.
Summary of provisions
Section 1 is the title of the legislation, the "Judith Kaye School Solutions not Suspensions Act."
Read the full memo (2,664 words)
Section 2 amends Section 2801 of the Education Law to require schools to develop a code of conduct to promote and sustain a safe, respectful and supportive school environment. The code of conduct shall require notice and a hearing of the adoption of a discipline code. The code of conduct shall include the following: (1) define violations and set expectations for student conduct; (2) include a range of age-appropriate graduated disciplinary measures including restorative practices; (3) require schools to use the least severe action necessary to respond to a code violation; (4) removals and suspensions shall not be used for tardiness, unexcused absence from class or school, leaving school without permis- sion, violation of dress code and lack of ID; (5) suspensions not permitted for willful disobedience; (6) students in pre-K through grade 3 may not be suspended except if suspension is necessary to comply with applicable federal law; and (7) alternate education must be provided during removal/suspension.
Section 3 amends subdivision 3 of Section 2801 of the Education Law to require that the code of conduct be developed in collaboration with representatives from interested stakeholders including, but not limited to, students, teachers, administrators, parents, school safety person- nel, collective bargaining units, and other school personnel and shall be approved by the board of education or trustees, other governing body, or by the chancellor of the New York City school district.
Section 4 amends Section 3214 of the Education Law to create alternate learning sites during removal or suspension. School officials shall weigh the likelihood that a lesser intervention or discipline would adequately address the student's misconduct, redress any harm or damage, and prevent future violations of the code of conduct. Suspensions shall only be used as a last resort. In considering appropriate discipline measures, school authorities shall consider the facts of each case, including but not limited to: (1) the nature and impact of the student's alleged misconduct, including but not limited to the harm to the student or other persons, damage to personal or school property or threat to the safety and welfare of the school community; (2) the student's age, abil- ity to speak or understand English, physical health, mental health, disabilities, and provisions of an individualized education program as it relates to his or her behavior; (3) the student's willingness to resolve the conflict and repair any harm or damage; (4) the student's prior conduct, the appropriateness of prior interventions, and the effectiveness of any prior interventions; (5) the relationship, if any, between the student's academic placement and program an d the alleged violation of the code of conduct; and (6) other factors determined to be relevant. If the student is going to be suspended, the student must receive written notice of the charged misconduct including a brief explanation of the basis for the suspension and a description of the alleged behavior that violated the code of conduct that includes the date, time, and place of the scheduled informal conference with the principal, the right to appeal a suspension, and the procedures for appeal. At the conference, the student has the right to be represented by an attorney or an advocate. The suspension shall not exceed 20 school days. The entity or individual that conducts the hearing shall make written findings of fact based on a preponderance of the evidence and shall make recommendations as to the appropriate measure of discipline if any. The written decision shall be sent to the school and parent or legal guardian within 3 days of the hearing. The written decision shall state the length of suspension, if any, findings of fact, reasons for determination, length of suspension, if any, procedures for appeal, and the date by which the appeal shall be filed.
When a student is suspended from school, the principal or their designee shall within 24 hours create an education plan for the student for each class in which the student is enrolled, provided that if such 24-hour period does not end on a school day, it shall be extended to the corre- sponding time on the next school day. The education plan shall make provisions for a student's on-going academic instruction during the suspension and shall include the steps the school will take to provide the student with a successful re-entry to school. The student shall have the opportunity to earn all academic credit he or she would have been eligible to earn had he or she been in class, including the opportunity to complete any missed assignments or take any missed examination or assessments during the student's suspension. If an examination or assessment cannot be rescheduled, the student shall be allowed on school property to take such assessment or examination on the day and time that the assessment or examination is given.
If a student is removed from a classroom, such removal shall not exceed one-half school day on the same school day. When a student is removed from the classroom, the student shall have the opportunity to earn all academic credit including the opportunity to complete any missed assign- ments or take any missed examinations or assessments during the student's removal. If an examination or assessment cannot be resched- uled, the student shall be allowed on school property to take such assessment or examination on the day and time that the assessment or examination is given.
Section 5 amends subparagraph 1 of paragraph c of subdivision 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law to allow schools to suspend a student but not more than 20 school days. No student may be suspended more than 5 school days unless the student and their parent or legal guardian receives written notice of an opportunity for a fair hearing that shall include a brief description of the facts upon which the alleged violations of the code of conduct are based, the section of the code of conduct that the student is alleged to have violated, and the date, time and place of the hearing. Prior to the hearing, copies of all evidence regarding the alleged incident shall be provided to the student and parent or person in parental relation to the student. The hearing shall be convened within 5 days of the written notice, unless the parent or person in parental relation to the student or student requests a later date. At the hearing, the student shall have the right to be represented by an attorney or advocate with the right to request the presence of and to question witnesses against the student, and have the right to present witnesses and evidence on their behalf. The written decision shall be sent to the school and parent or legal guardian within 3 days of the hearing. The written decision shall state the length of suspension, if any, findings of fact, reasons for determination, length of suspension, if any, procedures for appeal, and the date by which the appeal shall be filed.
Section 6 amends paragraphs d and f of subdivision 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law provides the procedures for when a student brings a firearm to a school and that such student shall be suspended for a peri- od not less than 1 calendar year. A superintendent shall have the authority to modify the suspension on a case-by-case basis; however, the superintendent's determination shall be subject to review by the board of education or trustees, other governing body, or the New York City chancellor. A superintendent shall refer the student under the age of 16 that brought a firearm to school to a presentment agency for a juvenile delinquency proceeding.
Section 7 amends paragraph g of subdivision 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law to provide the disciplinary process for students with disabilities.
Section 8 amends paragraphs a, b, and c of subdivision 3-a of Section 3214 of the Education Law to provide that the teacher shall inform the student and school principal of the reasons for the student's removal from class. If the teacher determines that the student's continued pres- ence in the classroom does not pose a continuing danger to other persons or property and does not present a threat of disruption for the class, the teacher, prior to removing the student, shall provide the student with an explanation for removal and allow the student to informally present the student's version of the relevant events. The principal shall inform the student's parent or legal guardian of the student's removal and the reasons for removal within 24 hours of the student's removal. If the student denies the charges, the principal shall provide an explanation of the basis for the removal and allow the student and/or the student's parent or legal guardian to present the student's version of the relevant events. This informal conference must be held within 48 hours of the student's removal. The principal shall not vacate the discipline the imposed by the teacher unless the principal finds that the charges against the student are not supported by substantial evidence, the student's removal is a violation of law, or that the student's conduct warrants suspension.
Section 9 is the effective date.
Justification
Current law controlling school discipline has been shown to have a disproportionately negative effect on students of color, students with disabilities, and students who identify as LGBTQ+. During the 2016-2017 school year, Black students in New York public schools outside of New York City were suspended at four times the rate of their White peers. In New York City public schools, Black students were suspended at five times the rates of their White peers. Students with disabilities repre- sent 18.7% of all students, but account for 38.6% of all suspensions. Across the State, the racial disparities in school disciplinary actions are widespread and persistent. In Westchester County, Black students are 11% of all students, but 40% of all students are suspended at least once. In Suffolk County, Black students are 8% of all students enrolled, but 24% of all students suspended. In Erie County, Black students are 5% of all students but 21% of all suspensions. Black girls across New York State face the harshest racial disparities in school discipline. In public schools outside of New York City, Black girls in middle school and elementary schools are nearly eight times more likely to be suspended from school than their White peers. In New York City high schools, Black girls are six times more likely to be suspended from school. Research shows exclusionary discipline such as suspensions and expulsions are ineffective and have long lasting impacts on student's academic futures and lives. One suspension in high school has been linked to students being twice as likely to drop out of school; and exclusionary discipline has been linked to students more likely to be held back a grade, lose critical instruction time, drop out before grad- uation, and to come into contact with the juvenile justice system and the criminal justice system later in life. In 2014, the Department of Justice (DOJ) and Department of Education (DOE) released School Disci- pline Guidance recommending school districts to move away from harsh and ineffective school discipline policies causing disparate impacts in school discipline outcome and to adopt fair, age appropriate, graduated, and positive alternatives to classroom removals, suspensions and expul- sions.
In 2018, the New York State Board of Regents adopted these recommenda- tions. Across the State, the racial disparities in school disciplinary actions are widespread and persistent. In New York State, students lose 686,686 days of school a year due to suspensions. Black students in New York State, per every 100, are forced out of school for more days than Black students attending public schools in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, Alabama, Mississippi, California, and Texas. There is near- ly a 19-point percent-age gap in the graduation rate between Black students and their White peers in New York State. Students must be in class receiving instruction in order to close that gap. The joint Guid- ance in 2014, from the DOJ and DOE included the recommendation guidance that recommends school districts "explicitly reserve the use of out-of- school suspensions, expulsions, and alternative placements for the most egregious disciplinary. Infractions that threaten school safety and when mandated by federal or state law." This bill will create fair and equi- table school discipline policies and practices, and reduce the troubling racial disparities by eliminating suspensions for minor infractions (late to class, cursing, insubordination) in all grades, limiting long- term suspensions from 180 days to 20 days, and prohibiting suspensions for students in K-3rd grades.
Legislative history
2019-2020: S.767-B - Referred to Education/A.1981-B - Referred to Ways and Means
2017-2018: S3036-A - Referred to Education/A.3873-A - Advanced to 3rd Reading Cal. 864
State and local fiscal implications
To be determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect September 1, 2022; provided, however that: (a) the amendments to subdivision 3 of Section 2801 of the Education Law made by section 2 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such subdivision pursuant to Section 34 of Chapter 91 of the Laws of 2002, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 3 of this act shall take effect; (b) the amendments to subpara- graph 1 of paragraph c of subdivision 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law made by section 4 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such subparagraph pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 8 of Chapter 430 of the Laws of 2006, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 5 of this act shall take effect; (c) the amendments to paragraphs d and f of subdivi- sion 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law made by section 4 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such paragraphs pursuant to Section 4 of Chapter 425 of the Laws of 2002, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 6 of this act shall take effect; (d) the amendments to paragraph g of subdivision 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law made by section 4 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such paragraph pursuant to Section 22 of Chapter 352 of the Laws of 2005, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 7 of this act shall take effect; (d-1) the amend- ments to clause (v) of subparagraph 3 of paragraph g of subdivision 3 of Section 3214 of the Education Law made by section 4 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such clause pursuant to subdivision d of Section 27 of Chapter 378 of the Laws of 2007, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 7 of this act shall take effect; (e) the amendments to paragraphs a, b and c of subdi- vision 3-a of Section 3214 of the Education Law made by section 4 of this act shall be subject to the expiration and reversion of such para- graphs pursuant to Section 12 of Chapter 147 of the Laws of 2001, as amended, when upon such date the provisions of section 8 of this act shall take effect; and (f) the amendments to subdivision 7 of Section 3214 of the Education Law, made by section 4 of this act, shall not affect the repeal of such subdivision and shall be deemed repealed ther- ewith.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.