Skip to content
S7253Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA7769

Let Courts Sue Foreign Companies

Official title

“Provides that a foreign corporation's application for authority to do business in this state constitutes consent to jurisdiction of the courts of this state”

Sponsor Michael GianarisSD-12
Status
Senate Floor Calendar
Impact
5/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Vetoed via A7769

What's happening

This bill clarifies that foreign business entities consent to New York court jurisdiction when authorized to do business, but consent ends if authorization is withdrawn.

Why it matters

  1. Ensures clarity and predictability for businesses. By explicitly stating that registering to do business in New York constitutes consent to court jurisdiction—and that this consent ends when authorization is withdrawn—the bill provides clear rules for foreign entities, reducing legal uncertainty around when they can be sued in New York courts.

  2. Impacts litigation strategy for both plaintiffs and defendants. Plaintiffs can more confidently bring suits against foreign business entities in New York while those entities are authorized, but must act before the entity withdraws its registration to avoid losing jurisdiction.

  3. Affects business risk assessment and compliance. Foreign companies considering doing business in New York will need to weigh the risk of being subject to New York courts and may adjust their registration and withdrawal timing accordingly to manage potential legal exposure.

  4. Aligns different business forms under a single standard. The bill amends multiple statutes (corporation, LLC, partnership, etc.) to create a uniform rule across various types of foreign business organizations, simplifying compliance and enforcement for both businesses and courts.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Let Courts Sue Foreign Companies

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Michael Gianaris

Senator · Senate District 12

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Substituted by A7769
  2. Ordered to third reading cal.1768
  3. Referred to rules

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A7769Assembly

Foreign Businesses Accept NY Lawsuits

Vetoed · Sponsor Helene Weinstein

Impact 5 · ModerateVetoed

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7253

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

June 10, 2021

Introduced by Sen. GIANARIS -- (at request of the Office of Court Administration) -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules

AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, the business corporation law, the general associations law, the limited liability company law, the not-for-profit corporation law and the partnership law, in relation to consent to jurisdiction by foreign business organizations authorized to do business in New York

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new section 301-a to read as follows:

§ 301-a. Termination of consent to jurisdiction in certain cases. Where a business organization registered, authorized or designated to do business in this state surrenders, withdraws or otherwise revokes its registration, authorization or certificate of designation, its consent to jurisdiction terminates on the date of such surrender, withdrawal or revocation.

§ 2. Section 1301 of the business corporation law is amended by adding a new paragraph (e) to read as follows:

(e) A foreign corporation's application for authority to do business in this state, whenever filed, constitutes consent to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state for all actions against such corporation. A surrender of such application shall constitute a withdrawal of consent to jurisdiction.

§ 3. Section 18 of the general associations law is amended by adding a new subdivision 5 to read as follows:

5. An association's certificate of designation prescribed by this section, whenever filed, constitutes consent to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state for all actions against such association. A revoca-

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD10576-01-1

S. 7253 2

tion of such designation shall constitute a withdrawal of consent to jurisdiction.

§ 4. Section 802 of the limited liability company law is amended by adding a new subdivision (c) to read as follows:

(c) A foreign limited liability company's application for authority to do business in this state, whenever filed, constitutes consent to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state for all actions against such limited liability company. A surrender of such application shall constitute a withdrawal of consent to jurisdiction.

§ 5. Section 1301 of the not-for-profit corporation law is amended by adding a new paragraph (e) to read as follows:

(e) A foreign corporation's application for authority to conduct activities in this state, whenever filed, constitutes consent to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state for all actions against such corporation unless such corporation is exempt from any law requiring it to designate the secretary of state as agent of the corporation upon whom process against it may be served and it has made no such designation. A surrender of such application shall constitute a withdrawal of consent to jurisdiction.

§ 6. Section 121-902 of the partnership law is amended by adding a new subdivision (e) to read as follows:

(e) A foreign limited partnership's application for authority to do business in this state, whenever filed, constitutes consent to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state for all actions against such foreign limited partnership. A surrender of such application shall constitute a withdrawal of consent to jurisdiction.

§ 7. Section 121-1502 of the partnership law is amended by adding a new subdivision (r) to read as follows:

(r) A foreign limited liability partnership's notice to carry on or conduct or transact business or activities as a New York registered foreign limited liability partnership in this state, whenever filed, constitutes consent to the jurisdiction of the courts of this state for all actions against such foreign limited liability partnership. A withdrawal of such notice shall constitute a withdrawal of consent to jurisdiction.

§ 8. This act shall take effect on the first of January next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, the business corpo- ration law, the general associations law, the limited liability company law, the not-for-profit corporation law and the partnership law, in relation to consent to jurisdiction by foreign business organizations authorized to do business in New York

This is one in a series of measures being introduced at the request of the Chief Administrative Judge upon the recommendation of his Advisory Committee on Civil Practice.

This measure would amend § 1301 of the Business Corporation Law (BCL) to reinforce the continuing viability of consent as a basis for general (all-purpose) personal jurisdiction over foreign corporations authorized to do business in New York. In so doing, the measure serves a substan- tial public interest. Being able to sue New York-licensed corporations in New York on claims that arose elsewhere will save New York residents and others the expense and inconvenience of traveling to distant forums to seek the enforcement of corporate obligations. The measure likewise amends the General Associations Law, the Limited Liability Company Law, the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law, and the Partnership Law to encompass other similarly situated foreign business organizations that must regis- ter to do business in New York.

Read the full memo (2,671 words)

Until recently, a foreign corporation doing business in New York could be sued here on claims arising anywhere in the world. The doing of busi- ness in New York, such as soliciting and facilitating orders for New York sales from an office in New York staffed by corporate employees, was treated as corporate "presence," which traditionally allowed for the assertion of general personal jurisdiction. When general jurisdiction exists, the claim being sued upon need not arise out of activity of the corporate defendant in New York. These principles were articulated in the 1917 case of Tauza v. Susquehanna Coal Co., 220 N.Y. 259, and carried forward by CPLR 301.

In the 2014 decision in Daimler AG v. Bauman, 134 S.Ct. 746 (2014), however, the U.S. Supreme Court held that due process requires more than the doing of business in a state before the courts of that state may assert general jurisdiction. By analogy to the assertion of general jurisdiction over individuals domiciled in the state, the corporation must be "at home" in the state. This means that the only type of local activity by a corporation that will ordinarily qualify for general jurisdiction is incorporation in the state or maintenance of its princi- pal place of business in the state. Id. at 760-62. Doing business in the state, by itself, will not suffice, even if such business is conducted on a regular and systematic basis from a local office or other facility. Tauza-type general jurisdiction, therefore, is no longer available in New York for those seeking to enforce corporate obligations incurred outside the state. On the other hand, Daimler's at-home requirement has no application to cases in which a corporation is subject to "specific" jurisdiction pursuant to a long-arm statute, such as CPLR 302, which confers jurisdiction for claims arising from a defendant's local acts.

Because Daimler's limitation on general jurisdiction was decided on the basis of constitutional due process, amending the CPLR to explicitly confer general jurisdiction over foreign corporations simply because they are doing business in the state would be futile. The Daimler Court, however, did not address consent-based general jurisdiction that occurs through corporate licensing and registration with the Secretary of State. (See 134 S.Ct. at 75556, citing the "textbook case" of Perkins v. Benguet Consolidated Mining Co., 342 U.S. 437 (1952), for guidance as to circumstances that permit exercise of general jurisdiction "over a foreign corporation that has not consented to suit in the forum.")

A foreign corporation, as a condition of doing business in New York, must apply for authorization to do so from the New York Secretary of State. BCL § 1301(a). As a part of such licensing and registration, BCL § 304(b) specifies that the corporation must designate the Secretary of State as its agent upon whom process may be served in a New York action. See also BCL § 1304(a)(6). Furthermore, BCL § 304(c) provides that foreign corporations already authorized to do business in New York as of the 1963 effective date of the BCL were "deemed" to have made such designation. (During the statutory regime that preceded adoption of the BCL, foreign corporations seeking authorization to do business in New York could appoint either a private individual or a public officer as agent upon whom process could be served. See Karius v. All States Freight, Inc., 176 Misc. 155, 159 (Sup.Ct. Albany Co. 1941)).

From 1916 until the decision in Daimler, New York courts - State and Federal held that a foreign corporation's registration to do business in New York constitutes consent by the corporation to general personal jurisdiction in the New York courts. Judge Benjamin N. Cardozo wrote in Bagdon v. Philadelphia & Reading Coal & Iron Co., 217 N.Y. 432 (1916), that such consent flows from the foreign corporation's statutorily required designation of a New York agent for service of process:

"The person designated is a true agent. The consent that he shall represent the corporation is a real consent. He is made the person "upon whom process may be served." The actions in which he is to represent the corporation are not limited. The meaning must, therefore, be that the appointment is for any action which under the laws of this state may be brought against a foreign corporation. . . that whenever jurisdiction of the subject matter is present, service on the agent shall give jurisdiction of the person."

Id. at 436-37. Judge Cardozo rejected the notion that the consent at issue in Bagdon was limited to claims that arose from the foreign corpo- ration's New York activity. The consent extended to all claims, regard- less of where they arose. Id. at 438.

The applicable New York statutes, both in 1916 and now, do not explicit- ly state that registration to do business or designation of a local agent to accept service of process constitutes consent to general juris- diction. Until recently, this omission was not viewed as a constitu- tional impediment to litigation against a registered foreign corporation The United States Supreme Court twice recognized that a corporation's statutorily required designation of a local agent to accept process rationally may be interpreted as consent to general jurisdiction: " When a power is actually conferred by a document, the party executing it takes the risk of the interpretation that may be put upon it by the courts. The execution was the defendant's voluntary act." Pennsylvania Fire Ins. Co. of Philadelphia v. Gold Issue Mining & Milling Co., 243 U.S. 93, 96 (1917.) The critical facts that the corporation had agreed to subject itself to the regulation of the state of New York and thereby had consented to general personal jurisdiction. This is "part of the bargain by which THE FOREIGN CORPORATION enjoys the business freedom of the State of New York." Neirbo Co. v. Bethlehem Shipbuilding Corp., 308 U.S. 165, 174 (1939). For at least 98 years, foreign corporations have been on notice that becoming licensed to do business in New York is a consent to general personal jurisdiction.

In the years since the Daimler decision, a number of courts have consid- ered whether the absence of explicit statutory notice that registration constitutes consent to general jurisdiction eliminates consent to such jurisdiction by the mere act of registration. The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in dismissing an action brought in a Connecticut state court and removed to the Federal District Court, wrote that the Connecticut registration of foreign corporations statute "was neither explicit about the scope of jurisdiction conferred, nor had there issued an authoritative state judicial decision construing the statute." Brown v. Lockheed, 814 F3d 619, 637 (2nd Cir. 2016) That deci- sion was relied on by the Appellate Division in dismissing a case in New York relying on general jurisdiction solely by virtue of registration under the current BCL, Aybar v Aybar, 169 A.D.3d 137 (2nd Dept.2019), leave dismissed 33 NY3d 1004). Aybar has been followed by Appellate Division decisions in other departments, Best v.. Guthrie Med. Group, 175 A.D.3d 1048 (4th Dept 2019), and Fekah v. Baken Hughes Inc., 2019 N.Y.App.Div> LEXIS 7463 (1St Dept. 2019).

However, other courts have held that under statutes similar to the current BCL registration statute, consent jurisdiction is preserved, see, e.g. In re Sealed Case, 932 F.3d 915 (Fed. Cir. 2019),(1) The ques- tion has attracted substantial academic analysis, compare, for example, Consent to Judicial Jurisdiction: the Foundatjon of "Registration" Stat- utes, 73 N.Y.U. Ann. Surv. Am. L. 159 (Professor Oscar Chase 2018), supporting such jurisdiction with Registration Statutes, General Juris- diction, and the Fallacy of Consent, 36 Cardozo L. Rev. 1343 (Professor Tanya Monestier 2015) rejecting such jurisdiction. For an exhaustive analysis of the issue from the pen of a Federal appellate judge, dealing with general jurisdiction over foreign corporations registering under the Delaware statute analogous to New York's BCL, see Acorda Therapeu- tics, Inc. v. Mycal Pharms., Inc, 817 F.3d 755 (Fed. Cir. 2016, O'Malley, C.J., concurring).

The addition of the proposed new subdivision (e) to BCL § 1301 would avoid the recent Appellate Division case law restricting general juris- diction, by providing an explicit and forceful legislative declaration as to the effect of a foreign corporation's registration to do business in New York. Consent to general jurisdiction is a fair requirement to impose on corporations that benefit from conducting business in New York. Such consent provides the certainty of a forum with open doors for the enforcement of obligations of New York-licensed corporations without the expense and burden of proving jurisdiction on a case-bycase basis. In Daimler, the Supreme Court recognized the value of having an "easily ascertainable" and "clear and certain forum in which a corporate defend- ant may be sued on any and all claims." 134 S.Ct. at 760.

There is substantial judicial support for the proposition that the proposed addition to BCL sec. 1301 would pass constitutional muster. The Pennsylvania registration statute has for years provided that "qual- ification" of a foreign corporation "shall constitute a sufficient basis of jurisdiction to enable the tribunals of this Commonwealth to exercise general personal jurisdiction", and that explicit notice has insulated general jurisdiction claimants from dismissal in a plethora of cases. See, e.g., Healthcase Servs. Grp. V. Moreta, 2019 U.S.Dist. LEXIS 198954 (E.D.Pa.), and Gronch Co., Inc. v Simon Prop. Group, Inc., 2019 N.Y.Misc. LEXIS 1821, *7 (Sup.Ct.N.Y.Co) rejecting general jurisdiction because section 1304, as currently written, "does not expressly require a corporation to consent to jurisdiction to do business within the state."

Enactment of the proposed addition to BCL sec. 1304 will not burden the New York courts with cases which ought not to be litigated here when corporate defendants are registered in New York, courts retain the discretionary power to decline the exercise of jurisdiction over them in the interests of justice and convenience pursuant to the doctrine of forum non conveniens. CPLR 327; see, e.g., Bewers v. American Home Products Corp., 99 A.D.2d 949 (1st Dep't), affd, 64 N.Y.2d 630 (1984).

BCL § 1312(a) will continue to provide an indirect enforcement mechanism to encourage foreign corporations doing business in New York to become authorized and thereby confer consent to general jurisdiction. BCL § 1312(a) states that a foreign corporation doing business in New York without authority may not maintain an action in the state's courts until it obtains the necessary authorization and pays relevant fees, taxes, penalties and interest charges. This statute "regulate S foreign corpo- rations which are conducting business in New York so that they will not be on a more advantageous footing than domestic corporations." Reese v. Harper Surface Finishing Systems, 129 A.D.2d 159, 162 (2d Dep't 1987).

BCL § 1312(a) applies to corporations engaged in "regular, systematic and continuous" business in New York. See, e.g., Highfill, Inc. v. Bruce and Iris, Inc., 50 A.D.3d 742, 743 (2d Dep't 2008). This standard encompasses corporations that maintain offices or other facilities in New York for the purpose of engaging in a mix of local and interstate business and provides sufficient flexibility for the inclusion of corpo- rations that do business in New York without a fixed location, as was the case in Highfill. It has been noted that the "regular, systematic and continuous business" standard helps to ensure compliance with constitutional limits on state regulation of purely interstate business. See Airtran New York, LLC v. Air Group, Inc., 46 A.D.3d 208, 214 (1st Dep't 2007).

Consistent with the history, policy and caselaw relating to foreign business corporations, this measure also codifies the principle that other types of foreign business organizations consent to general juris- diction when they do business in New York and, pursuant to statute, expressly appoint the Secretary of State as their agent upon whom proc- ess may be served. This measure thus includes foreign joint stock asso- ciations and business trusts (see Gen. Assoc. Law §§ 18; 2(4) (these are the only "associations" that must designate the Secretary of State as agent)); foreign limited liability companies (see Ltd. Liability Co. Law §§ 301(a); 802(a)); foreign not-for-profit corporations (see Not-for- Profit Corp. Law §§ 304, 1301, 1304(a)(6)); foreign limited partnerships (see Partnership Law §§ 121-104; 121-902); and foreign limited liability partnerships (see Partnership Law § 121-1502).

Authorized foreign corporations not wishing to continue their consent to jurisdiction may, of course, surrender their authority to do business in New York at any time in accordance with BCL § 1310. Other types of busi- ness organizations may likewise withdraw their authorization or certif- icate of designation to do business in the State. Currently, however, there is no statutory language specifically delineating the date upon which the consent to jurisdiction is deemed withdrawn. Accordingly, this measure would also enact a new CPLR 301-a to provide that where a business organization which is registered, authorized or designated to do business in this state surrenders, withdraws or otherwise revokes its registration, authorization or certificate of designation, its consent to jurisdiction terminates on the date of such surrender, withdrawal or revocation.

With respect to not-for-profit corporations, the amendment of the Not- for-Profit Corporation Law (§ 1301(e)) recognizes that some not-for-pro- fits, such as religious corporations, are exempt from the requirement that they designate the Secretary of State as an agent upon whom process may be served. See Relig. Corp. Law § 2-b. See also Not-for-Profit Corp. Law § 113(b); Private Housing Finance Law § 13-a (limited-profit housing companies). In such cases, consent-based jurisdiction is lacking. Furthermore, foreign banks and foreign insurance companies are excluded from this measure. Although these foreign entities must register to do business in New York, their concomitant designation of the Secretary of Banking and the Secretary of Insurance, respectively, as an agent upon whom process may be served is explicitly limited by statute to a narrow range of claims. See Banking Law § 200(3); Ins. Law § 1212(a).

This measure, which would have no fiscal impact on the State, would take effect on the first of January next succeeding the date on which it shall have become law.

2019-2020 LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

A7595 (Weinstein) REF TO RULES-2019; REPORTED TO RULES 2020

S6352 (Kaplan) REF TO RULES-2019; RECOMMITTED TO RULES 2020

2017-2018 LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

S5889 (Bonacic) COMMITTED TO RULES-2017; REFERRED TO JUDICIARY-2018

A5918 (Weinstein) ADVANCED TO 3RD RDG-2017; ORDERED TO 3RD RDG CAL. 421-2018

2015-2016 LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

S4846 (Bonacic) COMMITTED TO RULES

A6714 (Weinstein) PASSED IN 2015; ORDERED TO 3RD RDG., CAL. 253-2016

2014 LEGISLATIVE HISTORY:

S7078 (Bonacic) SUBST. BY ASSEMBLY 9576

A9576 (Weinstein) PASSED; COMMITTED TO RULES

(1) The same position has been adopted in Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, Arkansas, and New Jersey. See Am. Dairy Queen Corp. v. W.B. Mason Co, 2019 U.S.Dist.LEXIS 3314, *9-12 (Jan 8, 2019 D.C.Minn.), collecting cases., and most recently in New Mexico Schmidt v. Navistar, Inc., 2019 U.S.Dist.LEXIS 35064 (March 4, 2019 D.C.N.M.),

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.