Skip to content
S7311Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA5398

Protect Kids in Custody Cases

Official title

“Establishes "Kyra's Law"”

Sponsor Kevin ThomasSD-6+1 co-sponsor
Status
Stricken
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Rules

What's happening

Kyra's Law strengthens protections for children in custody cases by prioritizing child safety, mandating abuse hearings, and requiring specialized training for court professionals.

Why it matters

  1. Mandates swift, evidence-based hearings on abuse allegations. The bill requires courts to prioritize and promptly conduct evidentiary hearings (within 60 days) on any allegations of child abuse or domestic violence before considering other custody factors, ensuring that abuse claims are seriously examined early and not sidelined in custody decisions.

  2. Shifts financial burdens to abusive parties. If abuse or domestic violence is proven, the parent found responsible must pay the legal and expert costs of the non-offending parent and the child (unless they cannot afford it), which may deter frivolous or retaliatory litigation and reduce financial harm to protective parents.

  3. Limits use of controversial theories like “parental alienation”. The law restricts the use of “parental alienation” and similar concepts unless scientifically validated, and prevents courts from separating children from their primary attachment figure based on such theories, addressing concerns that these arguments are often used to undermine abuse allegations or punish protective parents.

  4. Requires specialized training for judges and court professionals. The legislation establishes new minimum training standards (20 hours initially, 10 every two years) on domestic violence, child abuse, trauma, and the risks of relying on unscientific theories, aiming to improve the competence and sensitivity of those making critical custody decisions.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Protect Kids in Custody Cases

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Kevin Thomas

Senator · Senate District 6

Chair, Consumer Protection

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Recommit, enacting clause stricken
  2. Referred to rules

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A5398Assembly

Protect Kids in Custody Cases

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Andrew Hevesi

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

7 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7311

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

July 30, 2021

Introduced by Sen. THOMAS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules

AN ACT to amend the domestic relations law, in relation to establishing "Kyra's Law"

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known as and may be cited as "Kyra's Law".

§ 2. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 1 of section 240 of the domestic relations law, as amended by chapter 567 of the laws of 2015, is amended to read as follows:

(a) In any action or proceeding brought (1) to annul a marriage or to declare the nullity of a void marriage, or (2) for a separation, or (3) for a divorce, or (4) to obtain, by a writ of habeas corpus or by petition and order to show cause, the custody of or right to visitation with any child of a marriage, the court shall require verification of the status of any child of the marriage with respect to such child's custody and support[, including any prior orders, and shall enter orders for custody and support] as, in the court's discretion, justice requires, having regard to the circumstances of the case and of the respective parties and to the best interests of the child and subject to the provisions of subdivision one-c of this section. Where either party to an action concerning custody of or a right to visitation with a child alleges in a sworn petition or complaint or sworn answer, cross-petition, counterclaim or other sworn responsive pleading that the other party has committed an act of child abuse against such child, or committed an act of domestic violence against the party making the allegation or a family or household member of either party, as such family or household member is defined in article eight of the family court act, [and such allegations are proven by a preponderance of the evidence, the court must consider the effect of such domestic violence upon the best

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD09163-01-1

S. 7311 2

interests of the child, together with such other facts and circumstances as the court deems relevant in making a direction pursuant to this section and state on the record how such findings, facts and circumstances factored into the direction] the court must first, before considering any other best interest factors, hear and determine upon competent admissible evidence such allegations set forth, and enter any findings regarding any child abuse or domestic abuse. The evidentiary hearing for such determination shall be held within sixty days of the filing of a verified pleading. The court shall not be precluded from issuing any necessary emergency orders to protect the child. All costs, including attorney and expert fees incurred by the non-offending parent and the child, to prepare for and participate in such evidentiary hearing, shall be paid by the parent who is found to have committed child abuse or domestic violence, unless the offending parent has insufficient means to fund such activities. If a parent makes a good faith allegation based on a reasonable belief supported by facts that the child is the victim of child abuse, child neglect, or the effects of domestic violence, and if that parent acts lawfully and in good faith in response to that reasonable belief to protect the child or seek treatment for the child, then that parent shall not be deprived of custody, visitation or contact with the child, or restricted in custody, visitation or contact, based solely on that belief or the reasonable actions taken based on that belief. If [an allegation that a child is abused is supported by a preponderance of the evidence, then the court shall consider such evidence of abuse in determining the visitation arrangement that is in the best interest of the child, and the court shall not place a child in the custody of a parent who presents a substantial risk of harm to that child, and shall state on the record how such findings were factored into the determination. Where a proceeding filed pursuant to article ten or ten-A of the family court act is pending at the same time as a proceeding brought in the supreme court involving the custody of, or right to visitation with, any child of a marriage, the court presiding over the proceeding under article ten or ten-A of the family court act may jointly hear the disposition's hearing on the petition under article ten or the permanency hearing under article ten-A of the family court act and, upon referral from the supreme court, the hearing to resolve the matter of custody or visitation in the proceeding pending in the supreme court; provided however, the court must determine custody or visitation in accordance with the terms of this section] the court finds a pattern of domestic violence or child abuse by a parent, the court shall award sole custody of the child to the non-offending parent or party and shall suspend visitation or only award professionally supervised visitation to the parent engaged in a pattern of violence or abusive behavior. If the court does not make a finding that a party has engaged in a pattern of domestic violence or child abuse, the court may not refuse to consider additional evidence of domestic violence or child abuse presented later in the case.

An order directing the payment of child support shall contain the social security numbers of the named parties. In all cases there shall be no prima facie right to the custody of the child in either parent. Such direction shall make provision for child support out of the property of either or both parents. The court shall make its award for child support pursuant to subdivision one-b of this section. Such direction may provide for reasonable visitation rights to the maternal and/or paternal grandparents of any child of the parties. Such direction as it applies to rights of visitation with a child remanded or placed in the

S. 7311 3

care of a person, official, agency or institution pursuant to article ten of the family court act, or pursuant to an instrument approved under section three hundred fifty-eight-a of the social services law, shall be enforceable pursuant to part eight of article ten of the family court act and sections three hundred fifty-eight-a and three hundred eightyfour-a of the social services law and other applicable provisions of law against any person having care and custody, or temporary care and custody, of the child. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any written application or motion to the court for the establishment, modification or enforcement of a child support obligation for persons not in receipt of public assistance and care must contain either a request for child support enforcement services which would authorize the collection of the support obligation by the immediate issuance of an income execution for support enforcement as provided for by this chapter, completed in the manner specified in section one hundred eleven-g of the social services law; or a statement that the applicant has applied for or is in receipt of such services; or a statement that the applicant knows of the availability of such services, has declined them at this time and where support enforcement services pursuant to section one hundred eleven-g of the social services law have been declined that the applicant understands that an income deduction order may be issued pursuant to subdivision (c) of section fifty-two hundred forty-two of the civil practice law and rules without other child support enforcement services and that payment of an administrative fee may be required. The court shall provide a copy of any such request for child support enforcement services to the support collection unit of the appropriate social services district any time it directs payments to be made to such support collection unit. Additionally, the copy of any such request shall be accompanied by the name, address and social security number of the parties; the date and place of the parties' marriage; the name and date of birth of the child or children; and the name and address of the employers and income payors of the party from whom child support is sought or from the party ordered to pay child support to the other party. Such direction may require the payment of a sum or sums of money either directly to the custodial parent or to third persons for goods or services furnished for such child, or for both payments to the custodial parent and to such third persons; provided, however, that unless the party seeking or receiving child support has applied for or is receiving such services, the court shall not direct such payments to be made to the support collection unit, as established in section one hundred eleven-h of the social services law. Every order directing the payment of support shall require that if either parent currently, or at any time in the future, has health insurance benefits available that may be extended or obtained to cover the child, such parent is required to exercise the option of additional coverage in favor of such child and execute and deliver to such person any forms, notices, documents or instruments necessary to assure timely payment of any health insurance claims for such child.

§ 3. The domestic relations law is amended by adding a new section 240-d to read as follows:

§ 240-d. Custody and visitation; health and safety of the child. 1. For the purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(a) "Adverse childhood experiences" means any stressful or traumatic experience of a child during such child's childhood which are strongly related to the development and prevalence of a wide range of health

S. 7311 4

problems throughout such child's lifetime, including, but not limited to, physical or sexual abuse, domestic violence, parental mental illness, substance abuse, and incarceration.

(b) "Parental alienation" means claims that a child has become estranged from a parent or legal guardian as the result of psychological manipulation by the other parent or legal guardian.

(c) "Victim of domestic violence" shall have the same meaning as defined in section four hundred fifty-nine-a of the social services law.

(d) "Friendly parent" means the propensity of a parent to actively support a child's contact and relationship with the other parent, or the ability of such parent to cooperate in, and resolve disputes, regarding matters affecting such child.

(e) "Primary attachment figure" means the parent who best provides emotional security and comfort to the child and takes into consideration which parent provided most of the child care during the first two years of the child's life.

2. Notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary, a court making a determination based on the best interests of a child pursuant to the provisions of this chapter shall prioritize and promote the health and safety of such child when making such determinations. Promoting the safety of a child shall include preventing direct physical and/or emotional harm to such child and creating situations that may decrease the likelihood such child will engage in harmful behaviors.

3. Prior to the issuance of any form of an order of custody or visitation, the court shall determine the safety of the child who is the subject of such order by considering all relevant factors and by giving weighted consideration to those factors which affect the health and safety of such child, which shall include, but not be limited to:

(a) whether either parent is more likely to ensure the health and safety of the child. There shall be a rebuttable presumption that custody or visitation shall not be awarded to a parent or party who jeopardizes the health and safety of the child;

(b) the negative consequences associated with separating the child from its primary attachment figure;

(c) whether either parent jeopardizes the health and safety of the child by unreasonably placing the child at substantial risk of severe emotional distress or bodily injury;

(d) any present or past abuse committed by a parent, or a member of a parent's household against the child, regardless of whether there is continued risk of harm to the child;

(e) whether either parent has committed an act of child abuse against the child, or committed an act of domestic violence against the party making the allegation, a family member, or a household member of either party;

(f) whether either parent is better able and more likely to attend to the daily physical, emotional, developmental, educational and special needs of the child;

(g) any history of violence or abuse committed by a parent or a member of a parent's household against:

(1) any other party;

(2) another child in the parent's household; or

(3) the child's other parent or any other individual who currently resides, or formerly resided, in the other parent's household;

(h) any fear held by the child of a parent based on such parent's specific conduct that is contrary to the child's best interest, and specifically to the child's health and safety; and

S. 7311 5

(i) the presence of adverse childhood experiences, and whether either parent's behaviors have contributed to the presence of adverse childhood experiences for such child.

4. (a) The court shall not presume that a child's deficient or negative relationship with a parent was caused by the other parent, nor shall a child be separated from a parent found to be the primary attachment figure for the purpose of improving a deficient relationship with the other parent.

(b) Concerns regarding unconscious or subliminal parental alienation shall not be admissible in any proceeding for custody or visitation and shall not be considered in assessing a child's best interests.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the domestic relations law, in relation to establishing "Kyra's Law"

Purpose or general idea of bill

To protect children by prioritizing the health and safety of children over other best interest factors in child custody and visitation proceedings.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 of the bill amends paragraph (a) of subdivision 1 of the domestic relations law to require that in child custody or visitation proceedings in which a party alleges child abuse or domestic violence, the court must first, before considering any other best interest factors, conduct an evidentiary hearing and make a finding regarding such allegations. Should the court find a pattern of domestic violence or child abuse, this section requires a court to award sole custody to the non-offending parent.

Read the full memo (2,433 words)

Section 2 of the bill amends the domestic relations law to create a new section 240-d to identify specific factors to be given weighted consid- eration when determining the health and safety of children in child custody or visitation, to restrict admissibility of non-scientifically valid or proven theories such as parental alienation, friendly parent or reunification treatment in such proceedings, and to require specific training for judges and court personnel handling child custody cases in which child abuse or domestic violence is alleged.

Section 3 of the bill amends subdivision (a) of section 70 of the domes- tic relations law to ensure that the same protections as noted above are in place regardless of whether the parents of the child have ever been married.

Section 4 is the effective date.

Justification

This bill, known as "Kyra's Law," seeks to address the systemic weak- nesses in the current law regarding child custody and visitation and the failures of the court system to keep New York's children safe from dangerous abusers.

Kyra Franchetti, a toddler, was ordered by the court to have unsuper- vised visits with her father, despite repeated reports and eyewitness accounts of his anger and rage issues, suicidal ideation, stalking and history of coercive tactics and abuse. During two years of child custody hearings in Nassau County Family Court, Kyra Franchetti's mother repeat- edly pleaded with the court to acknowledge the risk of harm to Kyra. The court dismissed these urgent pleas to protect Kyra and permitted unsu- pervised visitation to proceed. In July 2016, Kyra was on an unsuper- vised, court-sanctioned visit with her father in Virginia when he shot her to death while she slept. He then set his house on fire and killed himself. Kyra was only twenty-eight months old.(1) Tragically, countless children in New York have been injured or murdered at the hands of a parent who is seeking to cause pain and trauma to their intimate partner. Yet courts continue to discount or minimize the risks posed in cases where domestic violence is present, dismissing allegations of domestic violence or child abuse as an attempt by one parent to win custody from the other.

Moreover, there is now a specialized body of scientific research about domestic violence and child abuse that was not available when custody courts developed their present practices. The courts have been slow to integrate this research. Children exposed to domestic violence and child abuse will live shorter lives and suffer a lifetime of health and social problems.(2) Most of the harm is not caused by the immediate physical injuries, but from living with the fear and stress abusers cause. Most judges, lawyers and evaluators do not have the specific training and background necessary to evaluate domestic violence and child abuse cases. This leads to decisions that harm children. This legislation encourages a multi-disciplinary approach that would include experts in domestic violence and child sexual abuse.

The bill requires the court to conduct an evidentiary hearing within 60 days of the filing of the verified pleading to determine upon competent admissible evidence and enter findings regarding child abuse, family violence or domestic abuse

Requiring the evidentiary hearing at the outset of child custody and visitation proceedings will ensure that future decision-making takes into account the risks posed to that child, that the courts quickly address these issues and minimize the timeframe for which a violent offender may have access to a child at risk.

This hearing will not preclude the court from issuing emergency orders necessary to protect the child. If the court concludes a parent is abusive, the court may require such abuser to pay the legal fees for both parties, if the abuser has the economic means to do so.

By evaluating domestic violence and child abuse allegations at the initiation of court proceedings, the court will be better able to under- stand why one -parent may not be fostering a relationship between an offending parent and the child.

Currently, although New York State statute specifically restricts the court from depriving a parent of custody, visitation or contacts with a child if such parent makes a good faith allegation of domestic violence, non-offending parents typically have their children removed from their care for making such allegations.

According to research by Professor Joan S. Meier, Esq., of George Wash- ington University Law School, in conjunction with the National Institute of Justice, an analysis of more than 2,000 court opinions across the country confirms "courts are skeptical of mothers' claims of abuse by fathers; this skepticism is greatest when mothers claim child abuse.(3)

This bill requires the Court, when making a determination based on the 'best interest of the child' shall prioritize and promote the health and safety of the child.

Promoting safety of a child includes preventing direct physical and/or emotional harm to the child and creating situations that may decrease the likelihood such child will engage in harmful behaviors. This bill requires, that prior to the issuance of any order of custody of visita- tion, the court shall determine the safety of the child by considering and giving weighted consideration to the following factors:

1.) Whether either parent is more likely to ensure the health and safety of the child.

2) The substantial risks associated with separating the child from his or her primary attachment figure.

3) Whether either parent jeopardizes the health and safety of the child by unreasonably placing the child at substantial risk of severe emotional distress or bodily injury.

4) Any present or past abuse committed by a parent or a member of a parent's household against the child, regardless of whether there is continued risk of harm to the child.

5) Whether either parent has committed an act of child abuse against the child or committed an act of family violence or domestic violence against the party making the allegation, a family member, or a household member of either party.

6) Whether either parent is better able and is more likely to provide adequate health and safety safeguards and supervision of the child.

7) Any history of violence or abuse committed by a parent or a member of a parents' household against any other party, another child in the parent's household, or the child's other parent or any individual that resides, or formerly resided, in the other parents household.

8) Any fear held by the child of a parent based on such parent's specif- ic conduct that is contrary to the child's best interest, specifically the child's health and safety.

9) The presence of Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) and whether either parent's behaviors have contributed to the presence of ACEs for the child.

Far too often, domestic violence abusers are granted child custody or unsupervised visitation because they are deemed to be better able to support their child economically. While a determination of which parent can better economically support a child is an important one, it is not more important than assessing whether either parent places the child at substantial risk of bodily injury or severe emotional distress. Such an approach also does not take into account the resulting trauma from removing a child from their primary attachment figure, provided such parent is non-abusive. This bill prevents courts from factoring into custody or visitation proceedings the following:

1.) The court shall not presume that a child's deficient or negative relationship with a parent was caused by the other parent. No child's contact with a parent found to be the primary attachment figure shall be restricted as a means of attempting to improve a deficient relationship with the other parent. 2) Concerns regarding unconscious or subliminal parental alienation shall be not admissible and shall not be considered in assessing a child's best interests.

3) No psychological or medical theories or labels related to a child's resistance to contact with one parent shall be admitted into evidence unless they are generally accepted by the scientific and professional community based on empirical proof or scientific reliability and validi- ty

4) No reunification treatment or similar program shall be ordered by the court without scientifically valid and generally accepted proof of the effectiveness and therapeutic value of such treatment or program. No treatment or program shall be ordered which is predicated on separating a child from such child's primary attachment figure.

5) Any order attempting to remediate a child's resistance to contact or visitation with a parent shall address any parental behaviors or contributions the court determines to be the cause of, either wholly or in part, such resistance.

6) In cases where the court has found a parent to be a victim of domes- tic violence, and/or where child abuse has occurred or is occurring, a court shall not consider whether either parent is a friendly parent.

Research finds that courts often err in awarding child custody or visi- tation to abusers due to the debunked theory of parental alienation, the theory that when parents allege that a child is not safe with the offending parent, they are doing so illegitimately, to alienate the child from such parent. In fact, cross-claims of parental alienation "virtually double" courts' rejection of parents' abuse claims, causing non-offending parents to lose custody to the parent accused of abuse.(4) This bill restricts parents from using such theories or labels in court.

This bill requires in cases where the court has found a parent to be a victim of domestic violence and/or where child abuse has occurred or is occurring the following:

1) The court shall not base decisions on a legal presumption of shared parenting.

2) All costs, including attorney and expert fees, incurred by the non- offending parent and the child, shall be paid by the parent who is found to have committed child abuse or domestic violence, unless the offending parent has insufficient means to pay such costs.

Domestic violence can have very harmful effects on children. When there is domestic violence in the home, children are at greater risk of being abused or neglected. But even when they are not "directly" abused, chil- dren who witness violence and abuse by one parent against another can be affected in ways similar to children who are physically abused. Seeing or hearing violence at home can hurt children emotionally, psychologi- cally, and even physically due to the stress they suffer.

Some individuals who use coercive power and control tactics against their intimate partners go so far as to use their children as pawns, even harming or murdering them, to try to maintain control over or devastate their partners. This bill enhances current training requirements for judges and court personnel and requires such training be developed and offered by domes- tic violence and child abuse experts working in the field to support and advocate on behalf of New York's domestic violence survivors and chil- dren.

1) Any judges and other court professionals handling child custody proceedings in which one or more of the parties have alleged domestic violence or child sexual abuse shall complete training for the handling of such cases at least once annually. Such training shall be developed by the Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS)

2) This training shall include but not be limited to:

* the dynamics of domestic violence and child abuse: emotional, finan- cial, physical, technological, and sexual abuse.

* Tactics commonly used by one party to induce fear in another pasty or child. Including verbal, emotional, psychological, and/or economic abuse, isolating tactics, threats, controlling behaviors, monitoring, litigation abuse, and demands for custody or joint custody in order to pressure the partner to return or punish the partner for leaving.

* Knowledge of trauma, particularly as it relates to sexual abuse and the risks posed to children, and the long-term dangers posed by the presence of ACEs.

* The increased risk of escalating violence that occurs during child custody proceedings

* Education regarding the harms courts may cause children in child custody cases where domestic violence or child abuse is present by rely- ing on non-scientific theories such as parental alienation, parental alienation syndrome, the friendly parent concept, or any other theory or label that is not supported by scientific research that is generally accepted by the scientific community.

Less than 4% of child custody cases require trial; most are settled outside of court. Research shows that the majority of contested custody cases that do go to trial involve domestic violence and/or child abuse.

Therefore, it is critical for judges and court personnel who hear child custody and visitation cases involving domestic violence or child abuse receive consistent, comprehensive training in the dynamics of domestic violence, trauma, coercive control, the harm courts may cause children by relying on nonscientific theories such as parental alienation, the increased risk of escalating violence that occurs during child custody proceedings, the impacts of Adverse Childhood Experiences on children, and other issues.

Prior legislative history

New bill

Fiscal implications for state and local governments

Undetermined.

Effective date

The 90th day after it shall have become law; effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to made and completed on or before such effective date. (1) https://kyrafranchetti.org/kyras-story/ (2) Vincent J. Felitti, Robert F. Anda, D. Nordenberg, D. F. Williamson, AM Spitz, V. Edwards., MP Ross, at al. The Relationship of Adult Health Status to Childhood Abuse and Household Dysfunction." American Journal of Preventive Medicine. 1998; 14:245-258. Available at https://www. ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9635069. (3) Meier, Joan S. and Dickson, Sean and 08A39;Sullivan, Chris and Rosen, Leora and Hayes, Jeffrey, Child Custody Outcomes in Cases Involv- ing Parental Alienation and Abuse Allegations (2019). GWU Law School Public Law Research Paper No. 2019-56; GWU Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2019-56. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3448062 or http://dx.doLorg/10.2139/ssrn.3448062 (4) Ibid.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.