What's happening
This bill reforms New York's process for determining a defendant's trial fitness, emphasizing restoration services and updating procedures for retention and civil commitment.
Why it matters
Shifts focus to restoration over indefinite hospitalization. The bill redefines the process for handling defendants found unfit for trial, emphasizing "restoration services" (targeted interventions to restore trial fitness) instead of viewing hospital confinement as default mental health treatment, aiming for quicker, more targeted returns to competence.
Adds time limits and periodic court review. It tightens limits on how long someone can be confined for restoration (e.g., 90-day increments instead of up to a year), and mandates regular judicial reviews to determine if further restoration is likely or if civil commitment proceedings should begin. This reduces the risk of people being held for excessive periods without clear progress.
Clarifies pathways for unresolved incompetence. When it's unlikely a defendant will regain competency, the bill requires courts to refer cases for civil commitment under mental hygiene law, ensuring that long-term care is handled through appropriate civil (not criminal) processes with added legal protections.
Increases procedural safeguards and oversight. The bill standardizes reporting requirements, expands the definition of restoration services, and ensures defense participation and judicial discretion at more stages. This could improve fairness and consistency, and reduce unnecessary institutionalization for those with mental illness or developmental disabilities.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Update Trial Competency Rules
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Print number 7461a
- Amend and recommit to codes
- Referred to codes
- Referred to rules
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Clarify Defendant Trial Competency
In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Aileen Gunther
Full text
12 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
7461--A
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
October 22, 2021
Introduced by Sen. BROUK -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules -- recommitted to the Committee on Codes in accordance with Senate Rule 6, sec. 8 -committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee
AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law and the mental hygiene law, in relation to determining the capacity of a defendant to stand trial
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Subdivision 1 of section 730.10 of the criminal procedure law is amended to read as follows:
1. "Incapacitated person" means a defendant who as a result of mental disease or defect lacks capacity to understand the proceedings against [him] such defendant or to assist in his or her own defense.
§ 2. Subdivision 8 of section 730.10 of the criminal procedure law, as separately amended by chapters 615 and 629 of the laws of 1974, is amended to read as follows:
8. "Examination report" means a report made by a psychiatric examiner wherein he or she sets forth his or her opinion as to whether the defendant is or is not an incapacitated person, the nature and extent of his or her examination and, if he or she finds that the defendant is an incapacitated person, his or her diagnosis and prognosis and a detailed statement of the reasons for his or her opinion by making particular reference to those aspects of the proceedings wherein the defendant lacks capacity to understand or to assist in his or her own defense. The report must also state the examiner's professional opinion as to whether or not there is at least a reasonable expectation that restoration services could have a substantial probability of restoring the defendant to competence within a reasonable period of time. The state administrator and the commissioner must jointly adopt the form of the examination report; and the state administrator shall prescribe the
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD13336-03-2
number of copies thereof that must be submitted to the court by the director.
§ 3. Section 730.10 of the criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new subdivision 10 to read as follows:
10. "Restoration services" means those services including but not limited to medication support, classroom-based competency instruction, mock trials, symptom management, and rehabilitative services provided to an incapacitated person which are designed to improve his or her mental state or developmental status to the extent that they can understand the charges against them and participate in their own defense. Restoration services are not intended to be mental health treatment aimed at recovery from mental illness or services aimed at improving a developmentally disabled person's ability to function on a day-to-day basis.
§ 4. Section 730.20 of the criminal procedure law, subdivisions 1 and 5 as amended by chapter 693 of the laws of 1989, subdivision 7 as amended by chapter 692 of the laws of 1972, is amended to read as follows: § 730.20 Fitness to proceed; generally.
1. [The appropriate director to whom a criminal court issues an order of examination must be determined in accordance with rules jointly adopted by the judicial conference and the commissioner.] Upon receipt of an examination order, the director to whom the court has issued an order must designate two qualified psychiatric examiners, of whom he or she may be one, to examine the defendant to determine if [he] the defendant is an incapacitated person. In conducting their examination, the psychiatric examiners [may] shall employ [any] a method [which is accepted by the medical profession for the examination of persons alleged to be mentally ill or mentally defective] as set forth in standards set by the commissioner to determine if the defendant is an incapacitated person. The court may authorize a psychiatrist or psychologist retained by the defendant to be present at such examination.
2. When the defendant is not in custody at the time a court issues an order of examination, because [he] the defendant was theretofore released on bail or on [his] the defendant's own recognizance, the court [may] shall direct that the examination be conducted on an out-patient basis, and at such time and place as the director shall designate and the court shall order the defendant to appear for such examination. If, however, the director informs the court that hospital confinement of the defendant is necessary for an effective examination, or if the defendant refuses to appear as ordered for the examination, the court may direct that the defendant be confined in a hospital [designated by the director] operated or approved by the commissioner only until the examination is completed. In no event shall the need for such examination be a basis for incarcerating a defendant who has been released on bail or his or her own recognizance.
3. When the defendant is in custody at the time a court issues an order of examination, the examination must be conducted at the place where the defendant is being held in custody. If, however, the director determines that hospital confinement of the defendant is necessary for an effective examination, the sheriff must deliver the defendant to a hospital designated by the [director] commissioner and hold [him] the defendant in custody therein, under sufficient guard, until the examination is completed.
4. Hospital confinement under subdivisions two and three shall be for a period not exceeding [thirty] ten days, except that, upon application of the director, the court may authorize confinement for an additional period not exceeding [thirty] ten days if it is satisfied that a longer period is necessary to complete the examination. [During the period of hospital confinement, the physician in charge of the hospital may administer or cause to be administered to the defendant such emergency psychiatric, medical or other therapeutic treatment as in his judgment should be administered.]
5. Each psychiatric examiner, after [he has completed his] completing the examination of the defendant, must promptly prepare and submit to the director an examination report [and submit it to the director] setting forth the examiner's opinion as to whether or not there is at least a reasonable expectation that restoration services could have a substantial probability of restoring the defendant to competence within a reasonable period of time. If the psychiatric examiners are not unanimous in their opinion as to whether the defendant is or is not an incapacitated person, the director must designate another qualified psychiatric examiner to examine the defendant to determine if [he] the defendant is an incapacitated person and, if so, whether or not there is at least a reasonable expectation that restoration services could have a substantial probability of restoring the defendant to competence within a reasonable period of time. Upon receipt of the examination reports, the director must submit them to the court that issued the order of examination. The court must furnish a copy of the reports to counsel for the defendant and to the district attorney.
6. When a defendant is subjected to examination pursuant to an order issued by a criminal court in accordance with this article, any statement made by [him] such defendant for the purpose of the examination or treatment shall be inadmissible in evidence against [him] such defendant in any criminal action on any issue other than that of [his] such defendant's mental condition[, but such statement is admissible upon that issue whether or not it would otherwise be deemed a privileged communication].
7. A psychiatric examiner, who is not regularly employed by the county or the state of New York, is entitled to his or her reasonable traveling expenses[, a] and to a reasonable fee [of fifty dollars] to be negotiated with the examiner by the director or the county or, if no such fee is agreed upon, to be set by the court for each examination of a defendant and [a fee of fifty dollars] for each appearance at a court hearing or trial [but not exceeding two hundred dollars in fees for examination and testimony in any one case]; except that if such psychiatric examiner be an employee of the county or of the state of New York he or she shall be entitled only to reasonable traveling expenses, unless such psychiatric examiner makes the examination or appears at a court hearing or trial outside his or her hours of state or county employment in a county in which the director of community [mental health] services certifies to the fiscal officer thereof that there is a shortage of qualified [psychiatrists] examiners available to conduct examinations under [the criminal procedure law] this chapter in such county, in which event [he] such examiner shall be entitled to [the foregoing] such fees and reasonable traveling expenses as approved by the court. Such fees and traveling expenses and the costs of sending a defendant to another place of detention or to a hospital for examination[, of his maintenance therein] and the cost of returning [him] the defendant shall, when approved and so ordered by the court, be a charge of the county in which the defendant is being tried, and the cost of the maintenance of such defendant therein shall be a cost to the state.
§ 5. Section 730.30 of the criminal procedure law, subdivision 3 as amended by chapter 629 of the laws of 1974, is amended to read as follows: § 730.30 Fitness to proceed; order of examination.
1. At any time after a defendant is arraigned upon an accusatory instrument other than a felony complaint and before the imposition of sentence, or at any time after a defendant is arraigned upon a felony complaint and before he or she is held for the action of the grand jury, or upon arraignment on an indictment by a grand jury, the court wherein the criminal action is pending [must] may issue an order of examination when it [is of the opinion] has a reasonable basis to believe that the defendant may be an incapacitated person.
2. When the examination reports submitted to the court show that each psychiatric examiner is of the opinion that the defendant is not an incapacitated person, the court may, on its own motion, conduct a hearing to determine the issue of capacity, and it must conduct a hearing upon motion therefor by the defendant or by the district attorney. If the court does not decide to hold a hearing on its own motion and no motion for a hearing is made, or if, following a hearing the court is satisfied that the defendant is not an incapacitated person, the criminal action against the defendant must proceed. [If, following a hearing, the court is satisfied that the defendant is not an incapacitated person, the criminal action against him must proceed; if the court is not so satisfied, it must issue a further order of examination directing that the defendant be examined by different psychiatric examiners designated by the director.]
3. When the examination reports submitted to the court show that each psychiatric examiner is of the opinion that the defendant is an incapacitated person and that there is at least a reasonable expectation that restoration services could have a substantial probability of restoring the defendant to competence within a reasonable period of time, the court [may, on its own motion,] shall conduct a hearing to determine the issue of capacity [and it must conduct such hearing upon motion therefor by the defendant or by the district attorney].
4. When the examination reports submitted to the court show that the psychiatric examiners are not unanimous in their opinion as to whether the defendant is or is not an incapacitated person[, or when the examination reports submitted to the superior court show that the psychiatric examiners are not unanimous in their opinion as to whether the defendant is or is not a dangerous incapacitated person] and that there is at least a reasonable expectation that restoration services could have a substantial probability of restoring the defendant to competence within a reasonable period of time, the court must conduct a hearing to determine the issue of capacity [or dangerousness] and expectation of restoration within a reasonable time.
§ 6. Subdivision 1 of section 730.40 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by chapter 7 of the laws of 2013, is amended to read as follows:
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the criminal procedure law and the mental hygiene law, in relation to determining the capacity of a defendant to stand trial
Purpose or general idea of bill
To amend the criminal procedure law to limit the use of restoration services for defendants who are deemed to be unable to understand the charges against them or participate in their own defense to those defendants who are likely to benefit from those services and to amend the law to comply with the provisions of the US Supreme Court case of Jackson v. Indiana and the NY Supreme Court case of Ritter v. Surles
Summary of specific provisions
Section 1. Makes the definition gender neutral
Read the full memo (926 words)
Section 2. Requires that the reports of professionals examining the defendant to determine capacity also gives the examiner's opinion of the likelihood that the person can be restored.
Section 3. Creates a definition of restoration services to make it clear that restoration is not aimed at recovery but simply at making the defendant able to stand trial, plead guilty or have the charged dismissed.
Section 4. Amends section 730.20 of the CPL to require that the commis- sioners of OMB and OPWDD promulgate regulations setting the standards that examiners must use in making their determination. Many states require examiners to undergo specific training or pass an exam to deter- mine their ability to properly evaluate capacity. New York currently has no standards. This section also recognizes that many defendants will now be out on their own recognizance and that a court directive to attend the examination may be required but that the defendant should not be held in custody any longer than is need for the examination. It also revises the section dealing with fees due the examiners which are now set by law at $50 and would require that the fees be set by the court.
Section 5. Amends section 730.30 to clarify the procedure for court review of the defendant's capacity.
Section 6. Amends CPL 730.40 to delete the sections which the court has declared to be unconstitutional.
Section 7 Modifies the procedure to a superior court to oversee the process of restoration and provides that if the court determines that there is not a reasonable probability that restoration will be effective (e.g., a defendant has a very low IQ or traumatic brain injury)then the matter will be referred to a civil court with a hearing to determine if involuntary retention is appropriate.
Section 8. Deletes the portions of statute which have been deemed uncon- stitutional.
Section 9. Provides that if a superintendent of a facility from which a defendant is to be released believes that the person should be involun- tarily detained, the superintendent can have tow psychiatric examiners examine the defendant and if they believe there it is appropriate the matter can be referred to a civil court for a hearing with regard to further involuntary retention.
Sections 10 and 11. Amend the mental hygiene law to allow the referral of the matter from a criminal status of a civil status.
Section 12.amends the mental hygiene law to make it clear that the section refers to patients being held in custody the commissioner and that it does not apply to patients being treated pursuant to section 508 of the Correction law.
Section 13.provides that the savings which counties incur from bill will be reinvested in other community mental hygiene services.
Justification
Currently section 730 of the criminal procedure law provides that defendants charged with felonies who are mentally ill or developmentally disabled and are determined by a court to be unable to understand the charges against them or participate in their own defense are sent to state operated forensic hospitals or developmental institutions solely for the purpose of trying to restore them to competency so they can stand trial. The cost of these services is over $1000 per day charged to the county in which the court which sent them is located. In many cases, the judge issuing the order truly believes that he or she is helping the defendant to obtain treatment services for their mental disability. This is not the case because restoration services are geared to making the defendant legally able to stand trial and are not aimed at recovery from the underlying illness. Indeed, in many cases the defendant is sent for restoration at a cost of about $360,000 per year to the county and returns to have the charge reduced to a misdemeanor and ultimately dismissed.
The US Supreme Court in the case of Jackson v. Indiana (406 US 715) has held that holding a person in this manner for a period of time longer than necessary to determine whether there is a substantial probability that he or she will attain capacity to stand trial in the foreseeable future is unconstitutional. The case of Bitter v. Surles, (144 Misc. 2d 945) has also held that certain parts of CPL 730 are unconstitutional.
This bill seeks to make clear what restoration services are and to limit their use to those situations in which they are likely to be effective. It also amends those sections of law which have been held to be uncon- stitutional.
Prior legislative history
New bill
Fiscal implications
None to the State. There will be substantial savings to local government due to the decrease of the cost of the inappropriate use of restoration services.
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.