What's happening
This bill restricts the use of a defendant's creative or artistic expression as evidence in criminal proceedings, setting strict standards for its admissibility.
Why it matters
Raises the bar for prosecutors. The bill requires prosecutors to meet a high standard (“clear and convincing evidence”) before creative works like music, poetry, or art can be used as evidence, making it much harder to use an artist’s work against them in court.
Protects artistic freedom and context. It recognizes that creative expression is often metaphorical or fictional, and demands proof that the work is literal and directly related to the alleged crime, helping prevent misinterpretation or unfair prejudice against defendants based on their art.
Limits prejudice and safeguards fairness. If such evidence is allowed, judges must minimize potential bias by redacting irrelevant parts, giving clear instructions to the jury, and ensuring the material is presented in the least harmful way, thereby prioritizing a fair trial.
Broad definition covers many art forms. The bill’s definition of “creative expression” is expansive, including music, dance, visual art, literature, and more, ensuring comprehensive protection for a wide range of artists and creators.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Criminal defendants who create music, writing or other art
The bill would presume their creative expression inadmissible against them unless the party offering it meets a clear-and-convincing-evidence standard.
Prosecutors
To use a defendant’s creative expression, they would need to establish literal meaning, a strong connection to the alleged crime, relevance to a disputed fact and distinct value not supplied by other admissible evidence.
Criminal defense attorneys
The bill would give them explicit grounds to challenge artistic evidence, including whether fictional or figurative material is being treated as a literal statement.
Criminal court judges
They would have to put essential factual findings on the record and, when admitting creative expression, apply careful redactions, provide limiting instructions and consider the least prejudicial presentation.
Headline styles
Limit Art as Legal Evidence
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Ordered to third reading rules cal.551
- Substituted for A8681
- Referred to codes
- Delivered to assembly
- Passed senateVote 38–23
- Advanced to third reading
- 2nd report cal.
- 1st report cal.233
- Referred to codes
- Referred to rules
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Limit Art as Court Evidence
Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Catalina Cruz
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
7527
2021-2022 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
November 17, 2021
Introduced by Sens. HOYLMAN, BAILEY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Rules
AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to rules of evidence concerning the admissibility of evidence of a defendant's creative expression
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new section 60.77 to read as follows: § 60.77 Rules of evidence; admissibility of evidence of defendant's
creative expression.
1. Evidence of a defendant's creative or artistic expression, whether original or derivative, may not be received into evidence against such defendant in a criminal proceeding unless such evidence is determined by the court to be relevant and admissible, after an offer of proof by the proponent of such evidence outside the hearing of the jury, or such hearing as the court may require, and an on-the-record statement by the court of the findings of fact essential to its determination.
2. In order to overcome the presumption of inadmissibility of evidence of defendant's creative expression, the proffering party must affirmatively prove by clear and convincing evidence:
(a) literal, rather than figurative or fictional, meaning and, where the work is derivative, that the defendant intended to adopt the literal meaning of the work as the defendant's own thought or statement;
(b) a strong factual nexus indicating that the creative expression refers to the specific facts of the crime alleged;
(c) relevance to an issue of fact that is disputed; and
(d) distinct probative value not provided by other admissible evidence.
3. Where the court admits creative expression as criminal evidence, the court has a duty to apply careful redactions, provide limiting
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD13206-02-1
instructions, and consider the least prejudicial means of presenting the creative expression to the fact-finder.
§ 2. Section 1.20 of the criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new subdivision 46 to read as follows:
46. "Creative expression" means the expression or application of creativity or imagination in the production or arrangement of forms, sounds, words, movements or symbols, including but not limited to music, dance, performance art, visual art, poetry, literature, film and other such objects or media.
§ 3. This act shall take effect immediately.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to rules of evidence concerning the admissibility of evidence of a defendant's crea- tive expression
Purpose or general idea of bill
The purpose of this legislation is to protect freedom of speech and artistic expression in New York State. This bill effectuates the enhanced free speech protections provided by the New York State Consti- tution, ensuring that criminal defendants are tried based upon evidence of criminal conduct, not the provocative nature of their artistic works and tastes.
Summary of provisions
SECTION 1: Amends the criminal procedure law by adding a new section 60.77, Rules of evidence; admissibility of evidence of defendants' crea- tive expression.
Section 2
Amends the criminal procedure law by adding a new section 1.20(46), Definition of "creative expression"
Section 3
Establishes the effective date.
Justification
There is no New York without art, whether it is provoking or inspiring, beautiful or crude. As recognized by the New York State Court of Appeals many decades ago, New York is "a cultural center for the Nation" that has "long provided a hospitable climate for the free exchange of ideas." Immuno AG. v. Moor-Jankowski, 77 N.Y.2d 235, 249 (1991). This is not happenstance, but the direct result of the enhanced protections that this State's Constitution provides for speech and creative expression.
Recent scholarship has highlighted a disturbing trend poised to threaten the haven New York has always provided its artists. In courtrooms across the country, artists' musical works are being admitted against them as "evidence" in criminal proceedings. Just as concerning, the mere appre- ciation of others' music-whether through reposting lyrics, performing, or simply listening-is also being used as "evidence." Unchecked, these practices chill free expression, transform the figurative into fact, and warp criminal courts into instruments for suppressing provocative speech. Moreover, these practices ignore the foundational principle that a criminal case should be tried on the facts and not on a person's "propensity" to commit the crime.
Rap has come under scrutiny for decades, being blamed by the media for criminal activity, and admitted as evidence of criminal behavior by the artist. Social scientists have linked anti-rap attitudes and racially discriminatory behavior. But rap is just like any other creative expression. The New Jersey Supreme Court wrote that "one cannot presume that simply because an author has chosen to write about certain topics, he or she has acted in accordance with those views" (State v. Skinner, 218 N.J. 496, 517, 521 (2014)). The court noted that no one believes that Bob Marley actually "shot the sheriff," or that there's a man buried in Edgar Allan Poe's floorboards.
This legislation would guarantee freedom of creative expression in New York by prohibiting prosecutors from using creative expression as crimi- nal evidence against a person without clear and convincing proof that there is a literal, factual nexus between the creative expression and the facts of the case.
Prior legislative history
New Bill.
Fiscal implications for state and local governments
This legislation will have no fiscal implications for State or local government.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.