Skip to content
S7872Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA8894

Let Prisoners Seek Sentence Cuts

Official title

“Authorizes certain persons confined in institutions operated by the department of corrections and community supervision to apply for a sentence reduction”

Sponsor Julia SalazarSD-18+15 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Codes
Impact
9/10
Transformational
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Codes

What's happening

This bill allows certain incarcerated individuals in New York to apply for a sentence reduction after serving part of their sentence.

Why it matters

  1. Creates a new, standardized process for long-term incarcerated individuals to seek sentence reductions, regardless of existing minimum sentence requirements. potentially impacting a significant number of people serving lengthy or life sentences in New York.

  2. Establishes explicit eligibility and procedural protections. incarcerated people may not waive the right to apply, must be notified in advance when they’re eligible, and have the right to counsel for any application or hearing. Prosecutors can also initiate resentencing, and applications can be made every three years if previously denied.

  3. Requires courts to use a broad, individualized set of factors in considering reductions. , such as age at crime, history of trauma, rehabilitation, family impact, and cost of incarceration, with a rebuttable presumption of release for those who were young at the time of the offense or are now older.

  4. Mandates transparency and oversight. courts must issue detailed written decisions, applicants can appeal denials, data on application outcomes (including demographic info) is reported annually, and after three years the state must analyze and recommend how to reinvest savings from reduced incarceration.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Let Prisoners Seek Sentence Cuts

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8894Assembly

Let Prisoners Seek Shorter Sentences

In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Latrice Walker

Impact 9 · Transformational0% to pass

Full text

5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

7872

IN SENATE

January 18, 2022

Introduced by Sen. SALAZAR -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to authorizing certain persons confined in institutions operated by the department of corrections and community supervision to apply for a sentence reduction

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new section 440.45 to read as follows: § 440.45 Application for sentence reduction.

1. (a) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, including any minimum sentence requirement, any person confined in an institution operated by the department of corrections and community supervision who has served ten years of their sentence, or one-half of the minimum term of an indeterminate sentence where the minimum term equals or exceeds ten years, or one-half of a determinate sentence where the sentence equals or exceeds ten years, whichever is less, may apply for a reduction of their sentence pursuant to the provisions of this statute. For the purposes of this subdivision, the term "sentence" shall include any aggregate sentence where consecutive sentences are imposed.

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this subdivision, an otherwise ineligible person shall be deemed eligible to apply for a reduction in sentence upon consent of the prosecutor in the underlying criminal action in which the sentence was imposed.

(c) Notwithstanding paragraph (a) of this subdivision, the prosecutor in the underlying criminal action in which a sentence was imposed may initiate an application for resentencing on behalf of the incarcerated person and upon such application an attorney shall be assigned to represent the incarcerated person in proceedings pursuant to this section.

(d) No waiver of the right to make an application for a sentence reduction under this section shall be permitted or honored by the sentencing court. Any such waiver shall be deemed void and unenforceable.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD13368-04-1

(e) No less than thirty days before the date on which the person becomes eligible pursuant to paragraph (a) of this subdivision to apply for a sentence reduction, the department of corrections and community supervision shall provide written notice of this section and its provisions to:

(i) the defendant;

(ii) the attorney of record;

(iii) the administrator of the county panel established for purposes of the administration of article eighteen-B of the county law and all institutional offices that provide criminal defense services within the county in which the sentence was imposed;

(iv) Prisoners' Legal Services of New York;

(v) the sentencing court;

(vi) the prosecutor in the underlying criminal action in which the sentence was imposed; and

(vii) the district attorney in the county in which the sentence was imposed.

(f) A person who is eligible for a sentence reduction pursuant to this subdivision may request that the court assign him or her an attorney for the preparation of and proceedings on the application for resentencing pursuant to this section. The attorney shall be assigned in accordance with the provisions of subdivision one of section seven hundred seventeen and subdivision four of section seven hundred twenty-two of the county law and the related provisions of article eighteen-A of such law for the application and any proceedings under this section, including any appeal and successive application. The court shall notify the applicant about the appointment of counsel.

2. (a) An application for a sentence reduction under this section shall be filed in the county in which the sentence was imposed to reduce the sentence of the applicant pursuant to this section and may include affidavits, letters, declarations, records from the department of corrections and community supervision, video submissions, or any other written or electronic material.

(b) Upon the court's receipt of an application for a sentence reduction, the court shall promptly notify the appropriate prosecutor and provide such prosecutor with a copy of the application.

(c) An application filed pursuant to this section shall be randomly assigned by the administrative judge designated by the office of court administration with jurisdiction over the county where the application is filed to any superior court judge with criminal jurisdiction other than the judge who first sentenced the applicant unless the judge who first sentenced the applicant is the only judge in that county.

(d) An application filed under this section may be amended or supplemented as necessary.

(e) After the filing of an application to reduce a sentence under this section, the court may direct the parties to expand the record by submitting additional written materials relating to the application.

(f) (i) The court shall, upon request of the applicant or the prosecuting office, conduct a hearing on the application, at which the applicant and counsel for the applicant shall be given the opportunity to be heard. Such hearing shall be recorded or transcribed. The applicant has the right to be present at any such hearing unless the applicant waives the right to be present in writing.

(ii) In a hearing pursuant to subparagraph (i) of this paragraph, the court shall allow parties to present any evidence pertinent to the issue of a sentence reduction and the factors outlined in paragraph (b) of subdivision four of this section. Such evidence may include documents, live testimony, tangible objects, or any other class of evidence or information pertinent to sentencing. At such hearing, the applicant shall have the right to make a statement personally, on their own behalf, in the same manner as provided in subdivision one of section 380.50 of this part.

3. (a) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a court shall reduce a term of imprisonment imposed upon a defendant if:

(i) the applicant is eligible pursuant to subdivision one of this section; and

(ii) the court finds, after considering the factors set forth in subdivision four of this section, that the interests of justice warrant a sentence modification.

(b) (i) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, when reducing an applicant's sentence under this section, the court may issue a sentence less than the minimum term otherwise required by article seventy of the penal law. Otherwise, the applicable provisions in article seventy of the penal law in effect at the time of the sentence reduction shall apply.

(ii) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, when reducing an applicant's sentence under this section, the court may issue a sentence to be served concurrently to any other sentence of imprisonment, being served by the applicant.

(iii) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, when reducing an applicant's sentence under this section, the court may sentence the applicant to a less than minimum term of supervised release otherwise required by law.

(c) In ordering a sentence reduction, the court shall, unless countervailing considerations require, reduce the applicant's sentence so that the applicant will be eligible for immediate release from prison after the necessary calculations.

(d) The court may not increase any applicant's sentence, and if the original judgment was the result of a plea agreement, resentencing pursuant to this section shall not constitute grounds for a prosecutor or the court to withdraw their agreement to the original plea agreement.

4. (a) There shall be a rebuttable presumption that the applicant's sentence shall be reduced in the case of:

(i) an applicant who is fifty-five years of age or older on the date on which the applicant files an application for a sentence reduction pursuant to subdivision one of this section; or

(ii) an applicant who was twenty-five years old or younger on the date on which the applicant committed the offense or offenses for which the applicant is imprisoned.

(b) The court, in determining whether to reduce a term of imprisonment pursuant to subdivision three of this section, shall consider the following factors:

(i) the history and characteristics of the applicant at the time of the application for a reduction in sentence, including but not limited to:

(1) any history of abuse, trauma, or involvement in the child welfare system;

(2) the potential benefits to children and family members of reunification with the applicant;

(3) rehabilitation demonstrated by the applicant;

(4) the applicant's records while incarcerated; and

(5) the applicant's efforts to participate in educational, therapeutic, and vocational opportunities while incarcerated to the extent such programs were available; provided however that the fact that the applicant may have been unable to participate in treatment or other programming while incarcerated despite such applicant's willingness to do so shall not be considered a negative factor in determining an application pursuant to this section;

(ii) the circumstances of the offense, including the applicant's role in its commission, whether the applicant was under the influence of another, and whether there is any other factor that would tend to diminish the applicant's culpability;

(iii) any report from a physical, mental, or psychiatric examination of the applicant conducted by a licensed healthcare professional;

(iv) any statement offered in response to this application by any victim of an offense for which the applicant is imprisoned or by a family member of the victim if the victim is deceased;

(v) any evidence concerning whether the applicant's sentence was enhanced because the applicant exercised their constitutional right to a trial, including but not limited to, evidence concerning the plea offers made prior to the trial;

(vi) any presentation of argument and evidence by counsel for the applicant or by the applicant;

(vii) any presentation of argument and evidence by the prosecutor; and

(viii) the financial cost of continued incarceration to the state and/or localities.

5. A written order determining an application for reduction of sentence shall issue forthwith and in no event later than thirty days after any hearing or after all submissions have been filed if no hearing is held. Such an order shall include detailed written findings of fact and the reasons for granting or denying the application.

6. In calculating any new sentence to be served by the applicant, such applicant shall be credited for any jail time credited towards the subject convictions as well as any period of incarceration credited toward the sentence or sentences originally imposed.

7. An appeal may be taken as of right in accordance with applicable provisions of this chapter:

(a) from an order denying the application for a sentence reduction; or

(b) from a new sentence imposed under this section and may be based on the grounds that:

(i) the term of the new sentence is harsh or excessive; or

(ii) the term of the new sentence is unauthorized as a matter of law.

8. The applicant shall be permitted to file successive applications and such applications shall not be considered more than once every three years.

9. (a) This section shall not be construed to abridge or modify any existing remedy an incarcerated individual may have under habeas corpus, statutory or judicial postconviction relief, or any other legal framework.

(b) An application under this section shall not impact in any way or be impacted in any way by any pending habeas or other postconviction proceeding, nor shall the denial of an application under this section preclude such remedies from being granted.

10. In three years, the comptroller shall conduct an analysis of savings found from decarceration and shall make recommendations to the legislature regarding diverting such savings to fund prison-based and community-based programs designed to counter recidivism through education, therapeutic intervention, maintenance of familial and social networks, restorative justice practices for survivors of crimes, and successful post-custodial re-entry to society.

11. (a) The clerk of the court upon determination of an application filed pursuant to this section shall report the following information to the office of court administration:

(i) the name, department identification number, and race of each incarcerated person who has been denied or granted resentencing;

(ii) how many years of imprisonment each incarcerated person served at the time of the application;

(iii) any new sentence if applicable;

(iv) the county and the name of the judge deciding the application;

(v) whether the prosecutor consented, opposed or took no position on the application; and

(vi) if any prior applications had been submitted and the date such applications were decided.

(b) The office of court administration shall provide an annual collective report containing the information received from the clerks of the court pursuant to paragraph (a) of this subdivision to the governor and legislature.

§ 2. Any applicant who is immediately eligible to apply for a sentence reduction pursuant to section 440.45 of the criminal procedure law shall be provided the notice required pursuant to paragraph (d) of subdivision one of such section within sixty days of the effective date of this act.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to authorizing certain persons confined in institutions operated by the department of corrections and community supervision to apply for a sentence reduction

Purpose

This bill provides incarcerated individuals who have been sentenced to lengthy prison sentences of a decade or longer the chance for a second look at their sentence. These individuals will now be able to provide post-sentencing information and mitigation from years of incarceration to a judge and apply for a sentence reduction in the interests of justice. This bill seeks to address the harms caused by overly harsh sentences, including those required by mandatory minimums, by allowing judges to utilize their independent discretion in the interest of justice to reduce an individual's sentence notwithstanding any required minimum sentence.

Summary of provisions

Section 1. Amends the criminal procedure law by creating a new section 440.45 that allows certain individuals to apply for a sentence reduction.

Read the full memo (1,083 words)

Subdivision 1 of the new section 440.45 provides the eligibility and notice requirements for an application to reduce a sentence as well as a right to counsel for eligible incarcerated individuals. Individuals who have served either ten years or half of a sentence of at least ten years, whichever is less, are eligible to apply for a sentence reduction. The prosecutor has discretion to deem individuals eligible who are otherwise ineligible and to make applications on behalf of incarcerated individuals.

Subdivision 2 of the new section 440.45 establishes accountability and requirements for the content and review of any application. Instead of having the same judge who initially sentenced the applicant review the application, where possible, the administrative judge of the relevant county must assign the application to a different judge. If requested, a hearing must be held on the application at which the applicant and their counsel would have a right to be present and to submit relevant evidence.

Subdivision 3 provides that an eligible applicant's sentence must be reduced when, after consideration of the statutory factors listed in subdivision 4, the court determines the interests of justice warrant a reduction. When such a reduction is warranted, the reviewing judge may issue a sentence less than the statutory minimum sentence, and general- ly, the reduction should allow for an applicant's release. The court cannot increase an applicant's sentence.

Subdivision 4 creates rebuttable presumptions in favor of a sentence reduction if an eligible applicant is 55 years of age or older or if the eligible applicant was under 25 years of age at the time of the offense. This subdivision also provides factors that must be considered by the reviewing judge in making a decision on the application for a reduction. Subdivision 5 requires the reviewing judge to provide detailed findings of fact and reasons in writing for any decision to grant or deny an application for a sentence reduction.

Subdivision 6 provides that any jail time or period of incarceration already served must be credited towards any new sentence.

Subdivision 7 establishes the right to appeal.

Subdivision 8 permits the filing of successive applications.

Subdivision 9 prohibits the use of this section to impact any other proceedings.

Subdivision 10 requires the comptroller to conduct an analysis of the savings found from decarceration pursuant to this section and to make recommendations to the legislature in three years regarding the diver- sion of those savings to prison-based and community-based programs designed to counter recidivism.

Subdivision 11 provides for data collection about the application proc- ess to assist with transparency.

Section 2. Provides the effective date of the act.

Justification

New York continues to incarcerate thousands of people pursuant to sentences of a decade or more, and most of these people are Black and Latinx. Many were sentenced pursuant to mandatory minimums, including two- and three-strike laws, which prohibit judges from utilizing any discretion and considering the individual being sentenced. No mechanism currently exists for judges to reconsider these sentences. This Act will provide these individuals with an opportunity to demonstrate to a judge that they have changed and to ask for extreme and disparate sentences to be reconsidered to account for not only the individual but also new laws, scientific research, and norms. Providing a second look for these individuals not only allows New York to account for the indi- vidual serving the sentence but saves New York the financial costs of unnecessarily caging a person in the state prison system. These dollars can be reinvested in community-based and prison-based programs designed to effectively counter recidivism.

Social and racial justice impact

The population of individuals serving lengthy prison sentences in New York reflects stark racial disparities - with people of color represent- ing a disproportionately high percentage of those serving such sentences. Not only are racial disparities reflected in the absolute numbers of people serving such sentences, such racial disparities are also reflected in imposition of lengthy sentences.

Statistics compiled by the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services show that in 2019, while Black people made up 15% of the state's popu- lation, they accounted for 38% of arrests, 45% of felony arrests, and 48% of those sentenced to prison. Similarly, Latinx people made up 18% of the population, yet accounted for 24% of arrests, 24% of felony arrests, and 23% of those sentenced to prison. A 2021 report prepared by The Sentencing Project, "The Color of Justice, Racial and Ethnic Dispar- ity in State Prisons", found that New York had one of the highest rates of racial disparities in imprisonment in the country - Black people are sentenced to prison in New York at 7.9 times the rate of white people and Latinx people are sentenced to prison in New York at 3 times the rate of whites. The disproportionate imposition of harsh and lengthy prison sentences on people of color has caused harm to individuals, families, and communities. By creating opportunities for lengthy sentences to get a second look and to be reduced if certain criteria are met, this bill would represent an important step for New York in taking account of and addressing the history of racially disparate sentences.

Prior legislative history

New Bill.

Fiscal implications for state and local governments

To be determined, though it is likely that by reducing rates of incar- ceration and by increasing the availability of educational and job opportunities, this legislation will save the State money (the cost of incarceration) and will increase tax revenue.

Effective date

Immediately after becoming law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.