Skip to content
S794Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA306

Ban Torture by Medical Staff

Official title

“Prohibits participation in torture and improper treatment of incarcerated persons by health care professionals”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-27+8 co-sponsorsAffects Health
Status
In Senate Committee
Health
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Health

What's happening

This bill prohibits New York health care professionals from participating in, facilitating, or failing to report torture or improper treatment of incarcerated persons, with penalties for violations and protections for whistleblowers.

Why it matters

  1. Establishes clear professional and legal boundaries. for health care professionals, making it explicit that participation in, facilitation of, or failure to report torture or improper treatment of incarcerated persons is both unethical and grounds for professional discipline—even if such acts occur outside New York or under non-governmental authority.

  2. Creates an affirmative duty to report violations. , requiring health care professionals with reasonable grounds to suspect torture or improper treatment to report these instances to relevant authorities or oversight bodies, reinforcing accountability within the health professions.

  3. Extends whistleblower protections. to those who report or threaten to report violations, ensuring that health care workers cannot be retaliated against by their employers for refusing to participate in or for exposing unethical or illegal conduct related to incarcerated individuals.

  4. Aligns state practices with international human rights standards. , referencing global treaties and widely recognized definitions of torture and improper treatment, thereby elevating New York’s legal and ethical obligations for health care professionals working with vulnerable populations.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Ban Torture by Medical Staff

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Print number 794a
  2. Amend (t) and recommit to health
  3. Referred to health
  4. Referred to health

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A306Assembly

Ban Health Worker Torture

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Richard Gottfried

Impact 6 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

7 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

794--A

2021-2022 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE (Prefiled)

January 6, 2021

Introduced by Sens. HOYLMAN, BIAGGI, KAVANAGH, KRUEGER, RIVERA, SALAZAR, SEPULVEDA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Health -- recommitted to the Committee on Health in accordance with Senate Rule 6, sec. 8 -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to amend the public health law, the education law and the labor law, in relation to prohibiting participation in torture and improper treatment of incarcerated persons by health care professionals

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Legislative policy and intent. This legislation is based on, and is intended to give effect to, international treaties and standards; federal, state and local law; and professional standards relating to torture, improper treatment of incarcerated persons, and related matters. It is guided by two basic principles: (1) health care professionals shall be dedicated to providing the highest standard of health care, with compassion and respect for human dignity and rights; and (2) torture and improper treatment of incarcerated persons are wrong and inconsistent with the practice of the health care professions. The legislature finds that the conduct prohibited by this act violates the ethical and legal obligations of licensed health care professionals. This legislation will further protect the professionalism of New York state licensed health care professionals by authorizing and obligating them to refuse to participate in torture and improper treatment of incarcerated persons, which in turn will protect the life and health of the people of the state and those with whom New York licensed health care professionals interact. A health care professional who comes to the aid of an incarcerated person should not be presumed to be in violation when she or he is fulfilling the ethical principle of benefi-

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD00111-05-2

cence. In contrast, a health care professional who, for example, attends to an incarcerated person in order to allow torture or improper treatment to commence or continue is not acting beneficently. Such practices are inconsistent with professional ethics and standards and are violations of this legislation. The legislature is mindful that ordinarily there are limits on New York state's jurisdiction relating to conduct outside the state or under federal authority. However, it is proper for the state to regulate health care professional licensure in relation to a professional's conduct, even where the conduct occurs outside the state; certain wrongful out-of-state conduct is already grounds for professional discipline. Therefore, it is the legislature's intent that this legislation be applied to the fullest extent possible.

§ 2. The public health law is amended by adding a new section 25 to read as follows:

§ 25. Participation in torture or improper treatment of incarcerated persons by health care professionals. 1. Definitions. As used in this section, the terms "torture" and "improper treatment" shall be interpreted in accordance with applicable law, including international treaties to which the United States is a party. However, for the purposes of this section, it shall not be an element of either "torture" or "improper treatment" that such acts be committed by a government or non-government actor, entity, or official; under color of law; or not under color of law. As used in this section, unless the context clearly requires otherwise, the following terms have the following meanings:

(a) "Health care professional" means any person licensed, registered, certified, or exempt to practice under (i) any of the following articles of the education law: one hundred thirty-one (medicine), one hundred thirty-one-B (physician assistants), one hundred thirty-one-C (specialist assistants), one hundred thirty-two (chiropractic), one hundred thirty-three (dentistry, dental hygiene, and registered dental assisting), one hundred thirty-six (physical therapy and physical therapist assistants), one hundred thirty-seven (pharmacy), one hundred thirtynine (nursing), one hundred forty (professional midwifery practice act), one hundred forty-one (podiatry), one hundred forty-three (optometry), one hundred forty-four (ophthalmic dispensing), one hundred fifty-three (psychology), one hundred fifty-four (social work), one hundred fiftyfive (massage therapy), one hundred fifty-six (occupational therapy), one hundred fifty-seven (dietetics and nutrition), one hundred fiftynine (speech-language pathologists and audiologists), one hundred sixty (acupuncture), one hundred sixty-three (mental health practitioners), one hundred sixty-four (respiratory therapists and respiratory therapy technicians), one hundred sixty-five (clinical laboratory technology practice act), or one hundred sixty-six (medical physics practice), or (ii) article thirty-five of this chapter (practice of radiologic technology).

(b) "Torture" means any intentional act or intentional omission by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is inflicted on a person for no lawful purpose or for such purposes as obtaining from the person or from a third person information or a confession, punishing or disciplining or retaliating against the person for an act the person or a third person has carried out (including the holding of a belief or membership in any group) or is suspected of having or perceived to have carried out, or intimidating or coercing the person or a third person, or for any reason based on discrimination of any kind.

(c) "Improper treatment" means (i) cruel, inhuman or degrading, treatment or punishment as defined by applicable international treaties including but not limited to the Convention Against Torture, and Other Cruel, Inhumane, or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for Treatment of Prisoners, the Body of Principles for the Protection of All Persons Under Any Form of Detention or Imprisonment, the Basic Principles for the Treatment of Prisoners and, the United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice and their corresponding interpreting bodies; and applicable New York state law governing the proper treatment of incarcerated persons including, but not limited to, subdivisions twenty-three, thirty-three and thirty-four of section two, sections forty-five and one hundred thirty-seven, subdivision seven of section one hundred thirty-eight, and sections four hundred one, four hundred one-a and five hundred-k of the correction law, or applicable state or local law; or cruel and unusual punishment as defined in the United States Constitution or the New York state constitution; or (ii) any violation of subdivision three or four of this section; or (iii) any form of physical brutality, improper use of force, or deprivation of food, water, basic hygiene materials and access, or other basic human needs or living conditions.

(d) "Incarcerated person" means any person who is subject to punishment, detention, incarceration, interrogation, intimidation or coercion, regardless of whether such action is performed or committed by a government or non-government actor, entity, or official; under color of law; or not under color of law.

(e) To "adversely affect" a person's physical or mental health or condition does not include causing adverse effects that may arise from treatment or care when that treatment or care is performed in accordance with generally applicable legal, health and professional standards and for the purposes of evaluating, treating, protecting or improving the person's health.

(f) "Interrogation" means the questioning related to law enforcement, the enforcement of rules or regulations of an institution in which people are detained through the criminal justice system or for military or national security reasons (such as a jail or other detention facility, police facility, prison, immigration facility, or military facility) or to military and national security intelligence gathering, whether by a government or non-government actor, entity or official. "Interrogation" shall also include questioning to aid or accomplish any illegal activity or purpose, whether by a government or non-government actor, entity or official. Interrogations are distinct from questioning used by health care professionals to assess the physical or mental condition of an individual.

2. Knowledge. It shall be an element of any violation of this section that the actor knew or reasonably should have known that his or her conduct is of the kind prohibited under this section. A health care professional who receives information that indicates that an incarcerated person as defined by this section is being, may in the future be, or has been subjected to torture or improper treatment, must use due diligence, in order to assess the nature of his or her conduct as covered by this section.

3. General obligations of health care professionals. (a) Every health care professional shall provide every incarcerated person under his or her professional care with care or treatment consistent with generally applicable legal, health and professional standards to the extent that he or she is reasonably able to do so under the circumstances, including protecting the confidentiality of patient information.

(b) In all clinical assessments relating to an incarcerated person, whether for therapeutic or evaluative purposes, health care professionals shall exercise their professional judgment independent of the interests of a government or other third party.

4. Certain conduct of health care professionals prohibited. (a) No health care professional shall apply his or her knowledge or skills in relation to, engage in any professional relationship with, or perform professional services in relation to any incarcerated person unless the purpose is solely to evaluate, treat, protect, or improve the physical or mental health or condition of the incarcerated person (except as permitted by paragraph (b) or (c) of subdivision five of this section).

(b) No health care professional shall engage, directly or indirectly, in any act which constitutes participation in, complicity in, incitement to, assistance in, planning or design of, cover up of, failure to document, or attempt or conspiracy to commit torture or improper treatment of an incarcerated person. Prohibited forms of engagement include but are not limited to:

(i) providing means, knowledge or skills, including clinical findings or treatment, with the intent to facilitate the practice of torture or improper treatment;

(ii) permitting his or her knowledge, skills or clinical findings or treatment to be used in the process of or to facilitate torture or improper treatment;

(iii) examining, evaluating, or treating an incarcerated person to certify whether torture or improper treatment can begin, be continued, or be resumed;

(iv) being present while torture or improper treatment is being administered;

(v) omitting or suppressing indications of torture or improper treatment from records or reports; and

(vi) altering health care records or reports to hide, misrepresent or destroy evidence of torture or improper treatment.

(c) No health care professional shall apply his or her knowledge or skills or perform any professional service in order to assist in the punishment, detention, incarceration, intimidation, or coercion of an incarcerated person when such assistance is provided in a manner that may adversely affect the physical or mental health or condition of the incarcerated person (except as permitted by paragraph (a) or (b) of subdivision five of this section).

(d) No health care professional shall participate in the interrogation of an incarcerated person, including being present in the interrogation room, asking or suggesting questions, advising on the use of specific interrogation techniques, monitoring the interrogation, or medically or psychologically evaluating a person for the purpose of identifying potential interrogation methods or strategies. However, this paragraph shall not bar a health care professional from engaging in conduct under paragraph (d) of subdivision five of this section.

5. Certain conduct of health care professionals permitted. A health care professional may engage in the following conduct so long as it does not violate subdivision three or four of this section, it does not adversely affect the physical or mental health or condition of an incarcerated person or potential subject, and is not otherwise unlawful:

(a) appropriately participating or aiding in the investigation, prosecution, or defense of a criminal, administrative or civil matter;

(b) participating in an act that restrains an incarcerated person or temporarily alters the physical or mental activity of an incarcerated person, where the act complies with generally applicable legal, health and professional standards, is necessary for the protection of the physical or mental health, condition or safety of the incarcerated person, other incarcerated persons, or persons caring for, guarding or confining the incarcerated person;

(c) conducting bona fide human subject research in accordance with generally accepted legal, health and professional standards where the research includes safeguards for human subjects equivalent to those required by federal law, including informed consent and institutional review board approval where applicable;

(d) training related to the following purposes, so long as it is not provided in support of specific ongoing or anticipated interrogations:

(i) recognizing and responding to persons with physical or mental illness or conditions,

(ii) the possible physical and mental effects of particular techniques and conditions of interrogation, or

(iii) the development of effective interrogation strategies not involving the practice of torture or improper treatment.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public health law, the education law and the labor law, in relation to prohibiting participation in torture and improper treatment of incarcerated persons by health care professionals

Purpose or general idea of bill

To bar health care professionals from participating in torture or improper treatment of incarcerated persons, and provide a means by which health care professionals responsible for the care of incarcerated persons or detainees can refuse an order to directly or indirectly participate in torture and to insist on providing professionally respon- sible care and treatment.

Summary of specific provisions

Bill section one is a statement of the legislature's intent to give effect to existing international treaties, and standards, federal, state and local laws, and professional standards.

Read the full memo (1,460 words)

Bill section 2 would create a new Public Health Law § 25. Subdivision 1 defines "health care professional" to include all health professions licensed by Title Eight of the Education Law. The definitions of "torture" and "improper treatment" of a incarcerated person are consist- ent with international treaties, federal and state law and professional stand- ards. "Incarcerated person" is defined "as any person who is subject to punishment, detention, incarceration, interrogation, intim- idation or coercion.

Subdivision 2 of the new § 25 provides that it shall be an element of any violation of this section that the health care professional knew or reasonably should have known the nature of his or her actions.

Subdivision 3 establishes general obligations of health care profes- sionals in relation to the treatment of incarcerated persons and detained persons, consistent with generally applicable legal, health and professional standards, including protection of confidential patient information.

Subdivision 4 prohibits direct and indirect actions which constitute participation, complicity, incitement, assistance, planning, design, attempt, or conspiracy to commit torture or improper treatment of an incarcerated person. Health care professionals may not use their know- ledge or skill to adversely affect an incarcerated person's health by punishment, detention, incarceration, interrogation, intimidation or coercion, or to evaluate or treat an incarcerated person so that such improper treatment may be used or continued.

Subdivision 5 permits the proper conduct of health care professionals towards incarcerated persons: to provide proper care and treatment as reasonably able under the circumstances. The purpose must be to evalu- ate, treat, protect, or improve the physical or mental health or condi- tion of an incarcerated person. They may restrain or sedate an incarcer- ated person, where such actions comply with appropriate standards, are necessary to protect health or safety, and do not harm the incarcerated person. Health care professionals may appropriately participate in the investigation, prosecution or defense in criminal, administrative, civil matters. Health care professionals may provide training only in relation to recognizing and responding to physical and mental illness, the effects of interrogation techniques, and the development of effective interrogation strategies, so long as such training is not in support of specific interrogations.

Subdivision 6 establishes a duty to report, consistent with protecting the safety of both the incarcerated person and the health care profes- sional.

Subdivision 7 establishes mitigation for compliance with an investi- gation of, or reporting, alleged torture or mistreatment of incarcerated persons.

Subdivision 8 applies this section to conduct taking place within and beyond New York's borders.

Bill sections 3 and 4 add the violation of the new § 25 to the defi- nition of professional misconduct in Education Law §§ 6509 (health care professionals other than physicians or physician assistants) and 6530 (physicians and physician assistants).

Bill section 5,6,7 and 8 adds whistle blower protections for employees and contractors to labor law §§ 740 and 741.

Bill section 9 clarifies that the enactment of this law shall not be construed to mean that the actions it prohibits are not already or otherwise unlawful, nor that conduct not covered by the bill does not violate other law.

Section 10 is a severability clause stating that if any provision or application of this act is held to be invalid, that shall not affect the validity or effectiveness of any other provision or application of this act.

Section 11 is the effective date of the first of January next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law; provided, however, that if chapter 522 of the laws of 2021 shall not have taken effect on or before such date, then sections five and six of this act shall take effect on the same date and in the same manner as such chapter of the laws of 2021 takes effect.

Justification

There is very strong evidence that U.S. health professionals have been directly engaged in or complicit in torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment of incarcerated persons and detainees. {1} {2} The situation does not appear to be that of a few errant individuals, but a more systemic problem, facilitated by official policy. Most frequently, involvement is indirect, such as enabling mistreatment to continue by treating the consequences of the mistreatment. However, complicity has also become more direct: evaluating an incarcerated person prior to interrogation and setting the limits for torture, resuscitating or treating an incarcerated person during an interrogation session so that the interrogation may continue, making an incarcerated person's medical

records available to interrogators, advising on strategies for a torture session, and developing torture techniques.

Health care professionals have an ethical obligation to protect incar- cerated people against torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment. However, we now know that American governmental authorities have reinterpreted both the meaning of torture and health professionals' ethical obligations to encourage them to participate in these acts. It is reasonable to assume that state and local authorities, as well as foreign governments, are also engaging in such practices and involving American health care professionals.

Widely accepted principles of medical ethics clearly define the roles and responsibilities of health care professionals in regard to the ethical treatment of incarcerated persons and detainees. In 1975, the World Medical Association adopted the Declaration of Tokyo, which contained the "Guidelines for Medical Doctors concerning Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment in relation to Detention and Imprisonment." These guidelines were amended and strength- ened in 2006 to forbid the participation of physicians in any interro- gation of an individual detainee or incarcerated person. In 1982, the UN General Assembly adopted "Principles of medical ethics relevant to the role of health personnel, particularly physicians, in the protection of incarcerated persons against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrad- ing treatment or punishment," {3} drafted by the World Health Organiza- tion. The Ameri- can Medical Association, the American Psychiatric Asso- ciation, and other professional organizations have adopted these and similar principles.

For professionals licensed by New York State, it is appropriate for New York to adopt legislation that provides accountability and implements these widely held rules of professional conduct. Both the Declaration of Tokyo and the UN principles call for all governments and professional organizations to adopt standards implementing these principles.

A professional licensed by the State of New York who comes to the aid of an incarcerated person, detainee, victim of torture etc., under the general obligations of health professionals should not be presumed to be in violation when she or he is fulfilling the ethical principle of bene- ficence. In contrast, a professional who, for example, attends to an incarcerated person, detainee, victim of torture, etc. in order to allow torture or improper treatment to commence or continue is not acting beneficently. Such practices are inconsistent with ethics and standards in the health profession and are violations of this legislation.

Prior legislative history

2008: A.9891- reported to Rules committee

2009-2010: A.6665-C - advanced to third reading

2011-2012: A.5891-A - reported to Rules committee

2013-2014: A.4440 - reported to Rules committee

2015-2016: A.4489 - advanced to third reading

2017-2018: A.3079 - advanced to third reading 2019-2020: A.1192 ordered to third reading cal-59

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the first of January next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law; provided, however, that if chapter 522 of the laws of 2021 shall not have taken effect on or before such date, then sections five and six of this act shall take effect on the same date and in the same manner as such chapter of the laws of 2021 takes effect. {1} US Senate Intelligence Committee Study of the Central Intelligence Agency's Detention and Interrogation Program, December 13, 2012. {2} OMS Guidelines on Medical and Psychological Support to Detainee Rendition, Interrogation and Detention, 2004; Approved for release 2016/06/10 C06541536 (B)(3) National Security Act. {3} Resolution 37/194 (Principles of Medical Ethics) adopted by the United Nations General Assembly on 19 December 1982. http://wwvv.cioms.ch/1983textsofguidelines.htrn.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.