Skip to content
S8166Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA9398

Set Nail Salon Standards

Official title

“Establishes the nail salon minimum standards council act”

Sponsor Jessica RamosSD-13+14 co-sponsorsAffects Economy
Status
In Senate Committee
Labor
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Labor

What's happening

This bill creates a Nail Salon Minimum Standards Council to set and enforce minimum wages, working conditions, and pricing standards for New York nail salons.

Why it matters

  1. Creates a formal, ongoing body with real power. The Nail Salon Minimum Standards Council goes beyond advisory status, giving workers and employers a structured, recurring role in setting wages and working conditions—ensuring that standards are regularly reviewed, updated, and enforced based on industry realities.

  2. Links service pricing to wage protections. By establishing a Minimum Pricing Committee, the bill acknowledges that low service prices directly contribute to wage theft and poor conditions, and it gives the state the authority to set minimum service prices, potentially reducing a “race to the bottom” while aiming to keep salons viable.

  3. Provides strong anti-retaliation protections. The bill grants nail salon workers who participate in council activities or report abuses robust legal protections—including reinstatement and triple damages if fired or retaliated against—likely encouraging more workers to come forward about violations.

  4. Prioritizes representation and accessibility for marginalized workers. Council membership is designed to reflect the linguistic, cultural, and geographic diversity of New York’s nail salon workforce and employers, with supports like multilingual websites and interpretation services, making policy-setting more inclusive and responsive to the industry’s most affected groups.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Set Nail Salon Standards

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Referred to labor

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A9398Assembly

Set Nail Salon Standards

In Assembly Committee · Labor · Sponsor Harry B. Bronson

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

10 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8166

IN SENATE

January 27, 2022

Introduced by Sen. RAMOS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Labor

AN ACT to amend the labor law and the state administrative procedure act, in relation to enacting the nail salon minimum standards council act

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "nail salon minimum standards council act".

§ 2. The labor law is amended by adding a new article 19-E to read as follows:

ARTICLE 19-E

NAIL SALON MINIMUM STANDARDS COUNCIL ACT Section 697. Statement of public policy.

697-a. Definitions.

697-b. Nail salon minimum standards council.

697-c. Minimum pricing committee.

697-d. Powers and duties of the council.

697-e. Powers and duties of the commissioner with respect to the

council.

697-f. Labor protections.

697-g. Future meetings.

697-h. Severability.

697-i. Preemption.

§ 697. Statement of public policy. The legislature hereby finds and declares that there are persons employed in the nail salon industry in the state of New York at wages and standards insufficient to provide adequate maintenance and adequate health protections for themselves and their families. Such employment: impairs the health, efficiency, and well-being of such workers; constitutes unfair competition against other employers and their workers; threatens the stability of the industry; reduces the purchasing power of workers; and requires, in many instances, that wages be supplemented by the payment of public moneys for relief or other public and private assistance. Documented inappro-

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD11486-09-2

priate working conditions include the following: exposure to known carcinogens that have been found to cause cancer, asthma, and reproductive health issues for nail salon workers; long hours in poorly ventilated areas; unpredictable work schedules that adversely affect nail salon workers' ability to act as caregivers to their dependents; nonstandard procedures for obtaining certifications; inconsistent standards and criteria for work performed by trainees; and high rates of wage theft. The current system of relying exclusively on individual complaints to the department has not been effective at creating industry-wide compliance with regulations now in effect. Intense competition on price has driven down standards to the detriment of workers, consumers, and employers themselves. Data has shown that there is a strong correlation between prices and wage violations: the lower the prices, the higher the rates of wage violations that occur in nail salons. Due to slim profit margins and intense industry competition, even small businesses wishing to increase pay and improve working conditions are unable to do so. It is imperative that such market conditions be corrected and regulated by the state of New York.

The purpose of this article is to install a mechanism to raise industry standards for nail salon workers, owners, and customers through a participatory and accessible process and to set the foundation for a thriving, stable, and sustainable nail salon industry in New York.

Accordingly, it is the declared policy of the state of New York that inappropriate conditions be eliminated as rapidly as practicable without substantially curtailing opportunities for employment or earning power. To this end, the commissioner shall establish a nail salon minimum standards council pursuant to section six hundred ninety-seven-b of this article, to investigate and recommend minimum wages and standards in the nail salon industry, and the commissioner shall establish and implement and maintain such wages and standards. Furthermore, the commissioner shall convene an independent minimum pricing committee pursuant to section six hundred ninety-seven-c of this article to determine a fair minimum pricing model that will provide adequate maintenance for nail salon workers and protect consumer and worker health and safety standards while maintaining business enterprise autonomy and a competitive marketplace.

The commissioner and the nail salon minimum standards council established pursuant to section six hundred ninety-seven-b of this article shall have the power to investigate the wages and standards for workers in the nail salon industry to ascertain whether the minimum wages and standards established in accordance with the provisions of this article are sufficient to provide adequate maintenance and adequate health protections for nail salon workers, consumers, and the general public. The legislature understands that provisions of this article may have anti-competitive effects, and enacts this article with full knowledge of its possible anti-competitive effects and with the specific intention that all conduct authorized by this article receive immunity from federal antitrust laws to the fullest extent possible.

§ 697-a. Definitions. As used in this article: 1. "Council" means the nail salon minimum standards council established pursuant to section six hundred ninety-seven-b of this article.

2. "Member" means a member of the nail salon minimum standards council established pursuant to section six hundred ninety-seven-b of this article.

3. "Standards" means any requirements applicable to nail salon workplaces for which the council may provide recommendations as per section six hundred ninety-seven-d of this article.

4. "Nail salon" and "nail firm" mean an appearance enhancement business which practices nail specialty, as that term is defined in section four hundred of the general business law.

5. "Nail salon worker" means any person engaged in whole or in part in the practice of nail specialty as defined in section four hundred of the general business law.

6. "Nail salon employer" means an owner or operator of an appearance enhancement business that specializes in the practice of nail specialty as defined in section four hundred of the general business law.

7. "Trainee" means a person who works as a trainee as defined in section four hundred of the general business law.

8. "Delegate" means a non-voting member on the nail salon minimum standards council established pursuant to section six hundred ninetyseven-b of this article.

9. "Nominating representative" means a person or entity appointed by the commissioner to nominate members of the council.

§ 697-b. Nail salon minimum standards council. 1. (a) There is hereby established the nail salon minimum standards council, which shall consist of fifteen voting members plus six non-voting delegate members. The voting members shall consist of six nail salon workers, six nail salon employers, and three public representative members. Three of the non-voting delegate members shall be nail salon worker delegates and the other three non-voting delegate members shall be nail salon employer delegates. The commissioner shall appoint the public representatives. In addition, the commissioner shall appoint one nominating representative with a demonstrated history of representing the interests of workers in New York state who shall nominate at least six worker members and at least three non-voting delegate members to the council. The commissioner shall also appoint one nominating representative with a demonstrated history of representing the interests of nail salon employers who shall nominate at least six employer members and at least three non-voting delegate members to the council. The public representatives shall consist of the following: one member from the department; one member from the department of health, with expertise in occupational safety and health; and one member at the discretion of the commissioner. The public representative members shall have no financial ties to the nail salon industry, including campaign contributions within five years of such representatives' appointment to the council, and shall not have had complete or partial ownership of a nail salon at present or within five years of such representatives' appointment to the council. No public representative member shall have lobbied on behalf of nail salon workers or nail salon employers within five years of such representative's appointment to the council.

(b) The commissioner shall appoint the nominating representative for nail salon workers, the nominating representative for nail salon employers, and the three public representatives within sixty days of the effective date of this article.

(c) Within sixty days of being appointed, the nominating representative for nail salon workers shall submit to the commissioner the names of the nail salon workers and non-voting worker delegates to be considered for appointment to the council. Within fifteen days of receipt of these nominations, the commissioner shall consider the nominations and appoint six nail salon worker members and three nail salon worker delegates.

(d) Of the six nail salon worker members:

(i) Four nail salon worker members shall be employed at the time of appointment at nail salons located in the city of New York, one nail salon worker member shall be employed at the time of appointment at a nail salon located in Westchester county, Nassau county or Suffolk county, and one nail salon worker member shall be employed at the time of appointment at a nail salon in any county of the state except for the city of New York, Westchester county, Nassau county or Suffolk county.

(ii) The nominating representative for nail salon workers shall endeavor to nominate members who reflect the demographic and cultural background of the population of nail salon workers in the counties in which they work and have language facility in one or more of the languages specified in paragraph (b) of subdivision two of this section.

(iii) Preference shall be given to nail salon workers with significant experience in the nail salon industry, as measured by time spent in the industry.

(e) The three non-voting worker delegate members shall have demonstrated experience in working directly with nail salon workers in areas pertaining to or are organizations related to:

(i) labor relations;

(ii) occupational health and safety standards and compliance with those standards; or

(iii) a community center focused on the nail salon industry and has a membership that includes both workers and owners in New York.

(f) Within sixty days of being appointed, the nominating representative for nail salon employers shall submit to the commissioner the names of nail salon employers and non-voting employer delegates. Within fifteen days of receipt of these nominations, the commissioner shall consider the nominations and appoint six nail salon employer members and three nail salon employer delegates.

(g) Of the six nail salon employer members:

(i) Four nail salon employer members shall at the time of the appointment be nail salon employers at nail salons located in the city of New York, one nail salon employer member shall at the time of the appointment be a nail salon employer at a nail salon located in Westchester county, Nassau county or Suffolk county, and one nail salon employer member shall at the time of appointment be a nail salon employer at a nail salon in any county of the state except for the city of New York, Westchester county, Nassau county or Suffolk county.

(ii) The nominating representative for nail salon employers shall endeavor to nominate members who reflect the demographic and cultural background of the population of nail salon employers in the counties in which their nail salons operate and have language facility in one or more of the languages specified in paragraph (b) of subdivision two of this section.

(iii) Preference shall be given to nail salon employers that have a higher than average minimum wage for their nail salon workers and that do not have any judgments, injunctions, liens, or administrative orders against them; no nail salon employer shall be appointed a member or a delegate who has an unsatisfied judgment, lien, or administrative order pending against them or an injunction in effect against them that arises out of a violation of state labor laws or federal wage and hour laws.

(h) The non-voting employer delegate members shall have demonstrated experience in working directly with nail salon employers in areas pertaining to:

(i) labor and government relations;

(ii) compliance and advocacy related to occupational health and safety standards; or

(iii) general business practices and operations.

(i) Council members shall serve the full term for which they have been appointed. A member who does not serve the full term for which they were appointed shall be replaced by a new member by appointment of the commissioner following the commissioner's receipt of nominations from the nominating representative. Nominations shall be submitted to the commissioner within thirty days of such vacancy arising.

(j) The public representative members shall be the chairpersons of the council. The chairpersons shall conduct the meetings of the council, take attendance at council meetings and act as the primary point persons between the commissioner and the council.

(k) The council shall convene its first meeting within sixty days of the date of appointment of the fifteen members.

(l) Members may submit to the department expenses incurred for travel to and from council meetings and hearings for reimbursement. Members shall also receive a per diem of one hundred twenty dollars for each day of council meetings and hearings the member was in attendance.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the labor law and the state administrative procedure act, in relation to enacting the nail salon minimum standards council act

Purpose

Creates a Minimum Standards Council for the Nail Salon Industry in New York State.

Summary of provisions

Section 1: This act shall be known and may be cited as the "nail salon minimum standards council act".

Read the full memo (1,555 words)

Section 2: Amends labor law by adding a new article 19-E to read as follows:

Section 697. Statement of public policy. Declares that persons employed in the nail salon industry in New York are subjected to wages and inade- quate working conditions including health and safety protections. At the same time, unfair competition exists between employers who break the labor law by not following minimum wage standards and employers that follow the law. Low pricing and minimum wage violations threaten the stability of the industry, and often require that wages be supplemented by the payment of public moneys or relief or other public and private assistance.

Therefore, the commissioner shall establish a nail salon minimum stand- ards council to investigate, recommend, and implement minimum wages and standards in the nail salon industry and convene an independent minimum pricing committee to determine a fair minimum pricing model that will provide adequate maintenance and protection for nail salon workers and consumers.

Section 697-a. Definitions. Provides all definitions for article 19-E of labor law.

Section 697-b. Nail Salon Minimum Standard Council. a) Establishes a nail salon minimum standards council with 15 voting members and 6 non voting delegate members-6 employees, 6 employers, 3 public reps, and 3 reps each for employers and employees.

b) 60 days for the commissioner to appoint I nominating representative for employers and 1 nominating representative for employees to select employee and employer members.

c) 60 days for nominating representatives to nominate delegates and voting members and the commissioner has 15 days to consider the nomi- nations and appoint.

d) Describes geographic and demographic requirements for the composition of council's voting members.

e) Describes requirements of three non-voting worker delegate members. f) Describe the process of nail salon employer member and delegate selections.

g) Describes geographic and demographic requirements of the composition of the council's employer voting members.

i) Permits the commissioner to appoint new representatives if a member does not serve the full term for which they are appointed.

j) Public representatives shall be chairpersons of the council.

k) First meeting shall be within 60 days of the date of appointment of the 15 voting members.

1) Members may be reimbursed for travel expenses and receive per diem for days missed from work.

2. Creates a website explaining the council, the rights of council members and the list of dates and locations of meetings and hearings.

Section 697-c. Minimum Pricing Committee.

1. The Commissioner shall establish an independent pricing committee to establish a fair pricing model to maintain adequate consumer and worker health and safety standards while maintaining business enterprise auton- omy and a competitive marketplace.

2. Establishes composition of committee.

3. The committee has authority to collect information through research and economic development. Sets the standards by which recommendations to the commissioner on fair pricing model must meet.

4. The committee shall submit a report within one year of the first meeting of the committee with recommendations.

5. The commissioner shall review the report and approve, reject, or modify pricing model recommendations.

6. Any recommendation or modification shall be published as a proposed regulation.

7. A final regulation shall be effective 30 days after a final regu- lation is adopted.

Section 697-d. Powers and duties of the council.

1. Provides for the contours of what the council will be negotiating over, including but not limited to hourly wages, scheduling require- ments, gratuities, policies regarding sick days, holidays and other related leaves of absences; health and safety protections; etc.

2. The council has the power to hold hearings and subpoena witnesses.

3. Sets a quorum of at least three worker and three employer members.

4. The council shall complete making recommendations after 180 days after its first meeting. 5. Each recommendation shall be voted and accepted by a majority vote.

6. The council shall hold four hearings across the state.

7. Interpreters are allowed for members who require it.

Section 697-e. Powers and duties of the commissioner with respect to the council. The commissioner shall:

1. Promulgate rules and regulations governing the functioning of the council.

2. Furnish the council with adequate administrative resources, as neces- sary.

3. Make data available regarding the matters of the council.

4. Provide translation of all documents used or issued by the council and interpretation of all council meetings and hearings in the languages requested by worker and employer representatives.

5. Review the report and recommendations submitted by the council and approve or reject each recommendation.

6. Submit a written memorandum to the council and the legislature within thirty days of receipt of the council's report explaining the final action of each recommendation.

7. Publish recommendations for proposed regulations in the New York state register for 30 days for public comments. After 30 days, the commissioner's adoption of the final regulation will have the force and effect of law.

8. Promote compliance with the minimum standards adopted by:

a) issuing a quarterly report to the secretary of state regarding any nail salon business determined to be liable in any action involving noncompliance with the minimum standards, and

b) publishing the report to the council's website.

Section 697-f. Labor protections. 1.Establishes that no nail salon owner or manager shall discharge, discriminate, or retaliate against any nail salon worker in any way because of:

a) complaints of working conditions,

b) testimony given or submitted to a council-sponsored hearing,

c) affiliation as a worker representative on the council, or

d) the employer suspects complaints have been made by employees.

2. Any nail salon worker found to be discharged, discriminated, or retaliated against shall be entitled to reinstatement, triple any lost wages and work benefits caused by such violation, and any reasonably incurred attorneys' fees and costs in accordance with section 215 of this chapter. Section 697-g. Future meetings. The council will reconvene within two years of implementation of the council's last recommendations. Current members will attest to the commissioner any changes in their employment or ownership status at nail salons three months prior to the meeting. The commissioner will fill vacant council seats with representatives nominated by the nail salon workers or employers.

Section 697-h. Severability. Declares that the provisions of each section of this article are severable. If any section of this article is adjudged invalid in court, it will not invalidate any other section or application of the article.

Section 697-i. Preemption. Declares that the law shall not preempt any state or local enactment which provides greater benefits or protections to a covered worker.

Section 3: Amends state administrative procedure act by adding a new subparagraph xv to ensure any regulation promulgated by the commissioner of labor in accordance with this article goes into effect.

Section 4: Provides an immediate effective date.

Justification

The nail salon industry in New York State for too long has had standards set by low road employers. In New York State, employers who want to do the right thing by following the law-and treating their workers with dignity and respect- are put at a competitive disadvantage by employers breaking the law and providing low standards.

Take the minimum wage as an example. In 2020 the Department of Labor and Governor's office decided to end the tipped minimum wage for nail salon workers. However, the New York Nail Salon Workers Association in their "One Fair Wage Denied: Chasing Compliance in NY's Nail Salon Industry " reported that in April 2021 76% of workers surveyed were being paid less than the minimum wage throughout the state. Research shows that low prices and wage theft are correlated. It is no surprise that New York prices have remained stagnant for years- NYC and LI price being $13.71. While wages are an egregious example of low wage employers creating lower standards for workers, it is not the only example. Around health & safety, scheduling practices, and benefits for workers we see how the state allowing for low standards makes it impossible for employers who want to treat their employees with dignity to do so.

This groundbreaking bill proposes the creation of a minimum standards council for the Nail Salon Industry in pursuit of a more sustainable business model for employers and better standards for workers. The coun- cil is sat on by six voting employers, six voting employees, three non- voting representatives of both the employers and employees, and three public representatives. The council would negotiate minimum standards around health & safety, working conditions, scheduling, wages, etc. The council would make recommendations to be adopted by the labor commis- sioner within a two year period. At the same time, a minimum pricing committee would be established to help recommend pricing model standards to eliminate wage theft in the industry and make it harder for low road employers to break minimum wage laws and hurt employers who are follow- ing the law.

Legislative history

None. New bill.

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.