Skip to content
S8334Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA9340

Preserve Affordable NYC Housing

Official title

“Relates to the conversion of condominium ownership for the preservation of expiring affordable housing in the city of New York”

Sponsor Cordell CleareSD-30Affects Housing
Status
In Senate Committee
Housing, Construction And Community Development
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Housing, Construction And Community Development

What's happening

This bill creates a process for converting certain expiring affordable rental buildings in New York City to condominiums, with protections to preserve affordable housing units and tenant rights.

Why it matters

  1. Protects existing affordable housing and tenants. The bill ensures that when expiring affordable rental buildings convert to condos, all income-restricted rental units must remain affordable and rent-stabilized, with their tenancies protected indefinitely—even after conversion. This helps prevent displacement and the loss of affordable housing stock.

  2. Prioritizes tenant rights and homeownership opportunities. Tenants in occupancy are given an exclusive window (90 days, plus an additional 6 months under certain conditions) to buy their units at the offered price before non-tenants can purchase, supporting pathways to homeownership for current residents rather than outside investors.

  3. Prevents bad-faith conversions and speculative practices. The bill sets strict conditions for which buildings can convert, bars conversion where there are excessive vacancies or where affordable units have been improperly vacated, and requires ongoing “commercially reasonable good faith efforts” to sell to real occupiers rather than shell companies or insiders.

  4. Requires strong regulatory oversight and financial safeguards. The conversion process is tightly regulated by the Attorney General, including detailed disclosure requirements, ongoing annual updates, and the establishment of a dedicated reserve fund for building repairs. Penalties for non-compliance and enforcement mechanisms are included to protect both tenants and future condo owners.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Preserve Affordable NYC Housing

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Cordell Cleare

Senator · Senate District 30

Chair, Women's Issues

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to housing, construction and community development

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A9340Assembly

Preserve Affordable NYC Housing

In Assembly Committee · Housing · Sponsor Harvey Epstein

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

18 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8334

IN SENATE

February 15, 2022

Introduced by Sen. CLEARE -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Housing, Construction and Community Development

AN ACT to amend the general business law, the real property law, and the state finance law, in relation to providing expanded homeownership opportunities from the conversion of certain residential rental buildings to condominium status by property owners that commit to preserve the inventory of expiring affordable housing in the city of New York

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The general business law is amended by adding a new section 352-eeeee to read as follows:

§ 352-eeeee. Conversions to condominium ownership for the preservation of expiring affordable housing in the city of New York. 1. As used in this section, the following words and terms shall have the following meanings:

(a) "Annual update amendment". An annual update amendment is an amendment to the preservation plan that shall be submitted to the attorney general every year that a dwelling unit is unsold, with the first such annual update amendment due within forty-five days of the anniversary of the acceptance of the post-closing amendment to the preservation plan. An annual update amendment shall supply the evidence, data and information required in this section, and such other information as the attorney general's regulations shall require, so that the attorney general is satisfied that the preservation plan as amended discloses the information necessary for a reasonable investor to make his or her purchase decision and that the preservation plan is otherwise complete, current and accurate.

(b) "Bona fide purchaser". A bona fide purchaser is either (i) a tenant in occupancy who enters into a purchase agreement for a dwelling unit pursuant to his, her, or its exercise of one of the rights accorded to tenants in occupancy in subdivision five of this section, or (ii) a bona fide nontenant purchaser.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD14678-01-2

(c) "Bona fide non-tenant purchaser". A bona fide non-tenant purchaser is a purchaser of a dwelling unit who has represented that he, she, or they or a member or members of his, her or their immediate family intend to occupy the dwelling unit when it becomes vacant.

(d) "Commercially reasonable good faith effort". A commercially reasonable good faith effort on the part of an offeror of a preservation plan shall, at minimum, include (i) the filing of an annual update amendment to the preservation plan; (ii) all of the condominium's dwelling units other than any income-restricted rental units as the units being offered for sale under the preservation plan, each at an offering price that is consistent with comparable dwelling units recently sold within the locality; and (iii) entering into a written agreement with a licensed real estate broker or selling agent in connection with the sale of dwelling units offered for sale under the preservation plan. For the avoidance of doubt, a commercially reasonable good faith effort shall not require an offeror to sell dwelling units at a price substantially below the market-rate for comparable units recently sold within the locality, nor shall it require an offeror to offer for sale dwelling units that are occupied by non-purchasing tenants.

(e) "Condominium". A condominium shall also include a qualified leasehold condominium as defined in subdivision twelve of section three hundred thirty-nine-e of the real property law.

(f) "Consummation of the preservation plan". Consummation of the preservation plan shall refer to the filing of the declaration for the condominium and the first transfer of title to at least one purchaser under the preservation plan following a declaration of effectiveness by the department of law declaring the preservation plan effective.

(g) "Eligible disabled persons". Non-purchasing tenants who have an impairment which results from anatomical, physiological or psychological conditions, other than addiction to alcohol, gambling, or any controlled substance, which are demonstrable by medically acceptable clinical and laboratory diagnostic techniques, and which are expected to be permanent and which prevent the tenant from engaging in any substantial gainful employment on the date the preservation plan is submitted to the department of law or on the date the attorney general has accepted the preservation plan for filing, and the spouses of any such tenants on such date, and who have elected, within sixty days of the date the preservation plan is submitted to the department of law or on the date the attorney general has accepted the preservation plan for filing, on forms promulgated by the attorney general and presented to such tenants by the offeror, to become non-purchasing tenants under the provisions of this section; provided, however, that if the disability first occurs after acceptance of the preservation plan for filing, then such election may be made within sixty days following the onset of such disability unless during the period subsequent to sixty days following the acceptance of the preservation plan for filing but prior to such election, the offeror accepts a written agreement to purchase the apartment from a bona fide purchaser; and provided further that such election shall not preclude any such tenant from subsequently purchasing the dwelling unit if it is not an income-restricted rental unit on the terms then offered to tenants in occupancy.

(h) "Eligible senior citizens". Non-purchasing tenants who are sixtytwo years of age or older on the date the preservation plan is submitted to the department of law or on the date the attorney general has accepted the plan for filing, and the spouses of any such tenants on such date, and who have elected, within sixty days of the date the preservation plan is submitted to the department of law or on the date the attorney general has accepted the preservation plan for filing, on forms promulgated by the attorney general and presented to such tenants by the offeror, to become non-purchasing tenants under the provisions of this section; provided that such election shall not preclude any such tenant from subsequently purchasing the dwelling unit on the terms then offered to tenants in occupancy.

(i) "Extended affordability term". The extended affordability term for the income-restricted rental units shall be in perpetuity for so long as the building or group of buildings or development are in existence, and subject to any obligation to rebuild in the event of condemnation, damage or destruction required by the new regulatory agreement with the relevant housing finance agency.

(j) "Inclusionary housing unit". An inclusionary housing unit is an income-restricted rental unit that is located within an inclusionary housing designated area or a mandatory inclusionary housing area.

(k) "Inclusionary housing designated area". An inclusionary housing designated area is a specified area in which the inclusionary housing program (also known as the voluntary inclusionary housing program) is applicable, pursuant to the regulations set forth for such areas in section 23-90 of the zoning resolution. The locations of inclusionary housing designated areas are identified in either (i) appendix "F" of the zoning resolution or (ii) in a special purpose district as described in section 15-011 of the zoning resolution.

(l) "Income-restricted rental unit". An income-restricted rental unit shall refer to a dwelling unit located in a building or group of buildings or development that is the subject of a preservation plan submitted to the attorney general pursuant to this section, and such dwelling unit:

(i) meets the definition of a "low-income unit" as such term is defined in section forty-two of the internal revenue code and is subject to a regulatory agreement with a relevant housing finance agency; or

(ii) meets the definition of a "low-income unit" as such term is defined in subdivision (d) of section one hundred forty-two of the internal revenue code and is subject to a regulatory agreement with a relevant housing finance agency; or

(iii) previously met the definition of "low-income unit" pursuant to the preceding subparagraph (i) or (ii) of this paragraph, and notwithstanding the expiration of a regulatory agreement with a relevant housing finance agency, the owner of such dwelling unit affirms, under the penalty of perjury, that it has continuously operated and rented the dwelling unit (A) as if it remained an income-restricted rental unit and (B) as if all of the restrictions of the expired regulatory agreement had continuously been extended or otherwise remained in effect; or

(iv) is a dwelling unit located within a building or group of buildings or development that, in accordance with provisions of section four hundred twenty-one-a of the real property tax law, the local housing agency shall have required to be a unit affordable to families of low and moderate income; or

(v) is a dwelling unit that is rented to persons of low income or families of low income as defined in subdivision nineteen of section two of the private housing finance law or as otherwise required by a federal, state, or local law or mandate.

(m) "Mandatory inclusionary housing area". A mandatory inclusionary housing area is a specified area in which the inclusionary housing program is applicable, pursuant to the regulations set forth for such areas in section 23-90 of the zoning resolution. The locations of mandatory inclusionary housing areas are identified in either (i) appendix "F" of the zoning resolution or (ii) in a special purpose district as described in section 15-011 of the zoning resolution.

(n) "Non-purchasing tenant". A person who has not purchased under the preservation plan and who is a tenant entitled to possession at the time the preservation plan is declared effective or a person to whom a dwelling unit is rented subsequent to the effective date. A person who sublets a dwelling unit from a purchaser under the preservation plan shall not be deemed a non-purchasing tenant. A tenant entitled to possession of an income-restricted rental unit at the time the preservation plan is declared effective is a non-purchasing tenant, notwithstanding that the income-restricted rental units are not offered for sale pursuant to such preservation plan.

(o) "Post-closing amendment". A post-closing amendment is an amendment to a preservation plan filed with the attorney general confirming that the preservation plan has been consummated.

(p) "Preservation plan". An offering statement or prospectus submitted to the department of law pursuant to this section for the conversion of a building or group of buildings or development from rental status to condominium ownership, wherein the offeror documents that it has agreed to an extended affordability term for the income-restricted rental units with a relevant housing finance agency.

(q) "Purchaser under the preservation plan". A purchaser under the preservation plan is a person who purchases a dwelling unit from offeror pursuant to the terms of a preservation plan that has been accepted for filing by the attorney general. A person or entity that acquires dwelling units and assumes certain obligations of offeror shall not be considered a purchaser under the preservation plan.

(r) "Relevant housing finance agency". Relevant housing finance agency shall refer to a city or state agency with oversight over income-restricted rental units due to the receipt of substantial government assistance prior to the date of submission of a preservation plan. For purposes of this section, a relevant housing finance agency shall also refer to the city or state agency that will continue to have oversight of income-restricted rental units after consummation of the preservation plan.

(s) "Regulatory agreement". A regulatory agreement shall refer to the written agreement with a relevant housing finance agency that restricts the income and rents of income-restricted rental units that is either: (i) in effect prior to the date of submission of a preservation plan; or (ii) in effect after consummation of the preservation plan.

(t) "Substantial government assistance". Substantial government assistance shall refer to either (i) low income housing tax credits under section forty-two of the internal revenue code or (ii) bond financing under section one hundred forty-two of the internal revenue code.

(u) "Zoning resolution". Zoning resolution shall refer to the zoning resolution of the city of New York.

2. The attorney general shall refuse to accept for submission a preservation plan for the conversion of a building or group of buildings or development to condominium ownership under this section where the attorney general determines that any of the following is applicable:

(a) The preservation plan is for a building or group of buildings or development that receives a partial property tax exemption pursuant to section four hundred-twenty-one-a of the real property tax law, and the applicable governing provisions of section four hundred-twenty-one-a of the real property tax law prohibit the dwelling units being offered for sale from being owned pursuant to condominium ownership; or

(b) The preservation plan is for a building or group of buildings or development that the offeror or a predecessor-in-title to offeror voluntarily renounced the receipt of a full or partial tax exemption, tax abatement or benefit under the real property tax law or the private housing finance law, or satisfied the terms and conditions of a regulatory agreement involving substantial government assistance prior to its expiration date, for purposes of complying with this section; or

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the general business law, the real property law, and the state finance law, in relation to providing expanded homeownership opportunities from the conversion of certain residential rental build- ings to condominium status by property owners that commit to preserve the inventory of expiring affordable housing in the city of New York

Purpose

This legislation aims to provide expanded homeownership opportunities from the conversion of certain New York residential rental buildings to condominium status by property owners that commit to preserve the inven- tory of affordable housing beyond the approaching expiration of the requirement to rent them to low income households.

Residential rental buildings constructed in the 1990s with incentives such as low-income housing tax credits, bonds and tax abatements are set to expire. As these building owners will soon be in a position to lawfully command market rate rents on formerly affordable apartments, the low income families within those apartments face an uncertain future. This bill creates an incentive for such owners to preserve their expiring low-income units for low income households while simultaneously creating homeownership opportunities for existing market-rate tenants.

Read the full memo (1,216 words)

Summary of provisions

Section 1 of the bill would add a new section to the general business law, section 352-eeeee. This new section of the general business law permits a limited class of condominium conversions from residential rental buildings in the City of New York without all the residential units being offered for sale as was mandated by the changes imposed by the housing stability and tenant protection act of 2019. Only condomin- ium conversions that will result in the preservation of affordable hous- ing in New York City which is currently at risk of permanently being lost will qualify to convert under this legislation.

Moreover, this new section of the general business law also addresses some of the common criticisms of conversions, namely, that sponsors game the process of declaring an offering plan effective by using interested parties as purchasers and that sponsors do not create viable condomin- iums by selling all units to bona fide purchasers. Provisions in the new law make it explicit that a sponsor must exercise commercially reasonable good faith efforts to sell its entire inventory of residen- tial units. A sponsor must sell at least 51% of its inventory of resi- dential units within the condominium's first five years of exis- tence.This requirement also addresses the issue of condominium viability. A sponsor of a conversion under this section will not be able to frustrate the creation of a viable condominium by retaining ownership of a large number of units.

While the initial threshold for declaring an offering plan effective is lowered, this bill requires offerors to exercise commercially good faith efforts to sell at least 51% of the units within five years and continue to exercise commercially good faith efforts until all residential units in the condominium are sold. Finally, given the financial benefits an owner receives in exchange for being able to convert a property at a lower threshold, the trade-off of preserving affordable units that would otherwise be lost is sound public policy. This explicit requirement to sell, rather than retain ownership of units, would expand homeownership opportunities while creating more stable, economically viable condomin- iums.

In permitting a building owner to declare the offering plan effective with a lower threshold of purchasers, the legislation will stem the loss of affordable housing units to the open market and preserves them as affordable in perpetuity. Only if a building owner accepts this trade- off and commits to preserving its at-risk low-income rental units as affordable rental units (or with approval of the relevant housing finance agency, as low-income ownership units) can the owner convert to condominium so easily.

Section 1 also clarifies that the income-restricted rental units shall remain subject to the rent stabilization code for current and future tenants, even after the building's conversion to condominium ownership.

Section 2 amends section 339-e of the real property law to include new defined terms.

Section 3 of the bill would create a new section 339-mm of the real property law that requires the offeror of a preservation plans submitted under the new section 352-eeeee of the general business law to fund a reserve for the capital replacements that are necessary to provide for the health, welfare and safety of the condominium's residents. The offeror's obligation to fund a reserve closely parallels the existing reserve fund obligations as codified at section 26-203 the administra- tive code of the city of New York.

Section 4 of the bill would modify three subdivisions of section 352-e of the general business law.

First, in subdivision (2), the prohibition on the attorney general from accepting an offering plan that converts existing residential rental buildings for at least four months from its submission date, is elimi- nated for preservation plans submitted under the new section 352- eeeee. This is to facilitate the preservation of at-risk income-restricted rental units; the four-month prohibition on the attorney general's acceptance of all other offering plans converting residential rental property is maintained.

Second, the definition of "plan" is amended in subdivision (2-b) to permit the attorney general to review and accept a condominium offering plan that preserves affordable housing under the new section 352-eeeee.

The other revisions are found in subdivision (7), which address filing fees. These revisions: (i) create a new filing fee scheme for preserva- tion plans submitted to the attorney general under the new section 352- eeeee; (ii) eliminate the filing fees payable by a corporation incorpo- rated under article 11 of the private finance housing law to the department of law; and (iii) increase the filing fees payable to the real estate finance bureau fund. These revisions are intended to defray the costs the attorney general will incur to implement and give effect to the law's purpose while rebalancing the fee structure of the depart- ment of law to favor the development of affordable housing units. Section 5 of the bill would amend section 352-eeee of the general busi- ness law so that it conforms with the revised terms of section 352-e of the general business law.

Section 6 of the bill inserts into the state finance law a new section 80-a for the establishment and funding of a new housing protection unit within the department of law, funded from the fees generated by the new section 352-eeeee of the general business law. This section parallels the design of the existing section 80 of the state finance law, which finances the operations of the real estate finance bureau of the depart- ment of law.

Section 7 of the bill would set an effective date.

Justification

This bill promotes homeownership opportunities in New York City while securing the inventory of affordable housing units at risk of being lost to the open market. This legislation will extend the affordability term of these units so that generations of tenants today's tenants as well as future tenants of these units - may experience a measure of financial security from making their homes here.

Fiscal implications

There are no fiscal implications created by this bill.

Legislative history

New bill.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.