Skip to content
S8424Senate2021-2022 Session

Merge and Streamline NY Courts

Official title

“Relates to consolidation of the unified court system; and repeals sections 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 34, 35, 36, 36-a, 36-c, and 37 and subdivision j of section 22 of article 6 of the constitution relating there”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-27+2 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Judiciary
Impact
9/10
Transformational
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill proposes a constitutional amendment to restructure and consolidate New York’s unified court system, abolishing certain courts and establishing municipal courts with uniform jurisdiction statewide.

Why it matters

  1. Abolishes multiple existing courts and centralizes their functions. The amendment would eliminate the Court of Claims, County Courts, Family Courts, Surrogate’s Courts, and certain local courts, shifting their jurisdiction into new divisions of the Supreme Court and newly established municipal courts. This would impact how and where many civil, criminal, family, and probate cases are handled, aiming for greater efficiency but potentially disrupting established practices and specializations.

  2. Creates a uniform municipal court system statewide. Municipal courts with the same jurisdictional scope would be established both in New York City and in cities and counties outside NYC, replacing the current patchwork of local courts. This promises more consistent access to justice and standardized procedures across the state, but could affect local control and responsiveness to community needs.

  3. Expands Supreme Court divisions and absorbs specialized functions. The Supreme Court would be restructured to explicitly include divisions for family, probate, criminal, state claims, commercial matters, and general jurisdiction. This would integrate the functions of former specialized courts, which may streamline case handling but risks diluting expertise for complex matters like family or probate law.

  4. Emphasizes judicial diversity and smooth transitions for current judges and staff. The amendment includes language requiring appointing authorities to consider diversity (race, ethnicity, gender, etc.) when filling judicial positions and making temporary assignments. It also provides that existing judges and nonjudicial staff will transition into the new system, aiming to minimize job loss and maintain institutional knowledge during the reorganization.

  5. Potential for significant changes in how appeals and case transfers are handled. The amendment alters appellate procedures, including the transfer and handling of pending cases during the transition, and potentially changes where appeals from lower courts are heard. This could affect litigants’ choices and outcomes, particularly during the multi-year phase-in period.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Merge and Streamline NY Courts

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 27

Chair, Judiciary

History

  1. Referred to judiciary

Full text

24 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8424

IN SENATE

February 28, 2022

Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

CONCURRENT RESOLUTION OF THE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY proposing amendments to article 6 of the constitution, in relation to consolidation of the unified court system, and the repeal of sections

9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, subdivision j of section 22 and sections

34, 35, 36, 36-a, 36-c and 37 of article 6 of the constitution relating thereto

Section 1. Resolved (if the Assembly concur), That section 1 of article 6 of the constitution be amended to read as follows:

Section 1. a. There shall be a unified court system for the state. The state-wide courts shall consist of the court of appeals[,] and the supreme court including the appellate divisions and the appellate terms thereof[, the court of claims, the county court, the surrogate's court and the family court,] as hereinafter provided. [The legislature shall establish in and for the city of New York, as part of the unified court system for the state, a single, city-wide court of civil jurisdiction and a single, city-wide court of criminal jurisdiction, as hereinafter provided, and may upon the request of the mayor and the local legislative body of the city of New York, merge the two courts into one citywide court of both civil and criminal jurisdiction.] The unified court system for the state shall also include the [district] municipal, town, [city] and village courts [outside the city of New York,] as hereinafter provided.

b. The court of appeals, the supreme court including the appellate divisions and the appellate terms thereof as hereinafter provided, the [court of claims, the county court, the surrogate's court, the family court, the courts or court of civil and criminal jurisdiction of the city of New York] municipal courts, and such other courts as the legislature may determine shall be courts of record.

c. All processes, warrants, and other mandates of the court of appeals[,] and the supreme court including the appellate divisions and the appellate terms thereof[, the court of claims, the county court, the surrogate's court and the family court] as hereinafter provided may be served and executed in any part of the state. All processes, warrants,

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD89181-02-2

and other mandates of the municipal courts [or court of civil and criminal jurisdiction of the city of New York] may, subject to such limitation as may be prescribed by the legislature provided it applies uniformly to all municipal courts, be served and executed in any part of the state. The legislature may provide that processes, warrants, and other mandates of [the district court may be served and executed in any part of the state and that processes, warrants and other mandates of] town[,] and village [and city] courts [outside the city of New York] may be served and executed in any part of the county in which such courts are located or in any part of any adjoining county.

§ 2. Resolved (if the Assembly concur), That subdivisions a, b, d and f of section 2 of article 6 of the constitution be amended to read as follows:

a. The court of appeals is continued. It shall consist of [the] a chief judge and [the] six [elected] associate judges [now in office, who shall hold their offices until the expiration of their respective terms, and their successors], and such justices of the supreme court as may be designated for service in said court as hereinafter provided. The [official] terms of the chief judge and the six associate judges shall be fourteen years.

Five members of the court shall constitute a quorum, and the concurrence of four shall be necessary to a decision; but no more than seven judges shall sit in any case. In case of the temporary absence or inability to act of any judge of the court of appeals, the court may designate any justice of the supreme court to serve as associate judge of the court during such absence or inability to act. The court shall have power to appoint and to remove its clerk. The powers and jurisdiction of the court shall not be suspended for want of appointment when the number of judges is sufficient to constitute a quorum.

b. Whenever and as often as the court of appeals shall certify to the governor that the court is unable, by reason of the accumulation of causes pending therein, to hear and dispose of the same with reasonable speed, the governor shall designate such number of justices of the supreme court as may be so certified to be necessary, but not more than four, to serve as associate judges of the court of appeals. The justices so designated shall be relieved, while so serving, from their duties as justices of the supreme court, and shall serve as associate judges of the court of appeals until the court shall certify that the need for the services of any such justices no longer exists, whereupon they shall return to the supreme court. The governor may fill vacancies among such designated judges. No such justices shall serve as associate judge of the court of appeals except while holding the office of justice of the supreme court. The designation of a justice of the supreme court as an associate judge of the court of appeals shall not be deemed to affect [his or her] such justice's existing office any longer than until the expiration of [his or her] such justice's designation as such associate judge, nor to create a vacancy.

d. (1) The commission on judicial nomination shall consist of twelve members of whom four shall be appointed by the governor, four by the chief judge of the court of appeals, and one each by the speaker of the assembly, the temporary president of the senate, the minority leader of the senate, and the minority leader of the assembly. Of the four members appointed by the governor, no more than two shall be enrolled in the same political party, two shall be members of the bar of the state, and two shall not be members of the bar of the state. Of the four members appointed by the chief judge of the court of appeals, no more than two shall be enrolled in the same political party, two shall be members of the bar of the state, and two shall not be members of the bar of the state. No member of the commission shall hold or have held any judicial office or hold any elected public office for which [he or she] such member receives compensation during [his or her] such member's period of service, except that the governor and the chief judge may each appoint no more than one former judge or justice of the unified court system to such commission. No member of the commission shall hold any office in any political party. No member of the judicial nominating commission shall be eligible for appointment to judicial office in any court of the state during the member's period of service or within one year thereafter.

(2) The members [first appointed by the governor shall have respectively one, two, three and four year terms as the governor shall designate. The members first appointed by the chief judge of the court of appeals shall have respectively one, two, three and four year terms as the chief judge shall designate. The member first appointed by the temporary president of the senate shall have a one-year term. The member first appointed by the minority leader of the senate shall have a twoyear term. The member first appointed by the speaker of the assembly shall have a four-year term. The member first appointed by the minority leader of the assembly shall have a three-year term. Each subsequent appointment shall be] of the commission shall each serve for a term of four years.

(3) The commission shall designate one of their number to serve as chairperson.

(4) The commission shall consider the qualifications of candidates for appointment to the offices of judge and chief judge of the court of appeals and, whenever a vacancy in those offices occurs, shall prepare a written report and recommend to the governor persons who are well qualified for those judicial offices. In preparing such report and recommendation, the commission shall consider recommendations that reflect the diversity of the citizenry of New York, including, but not limited to, diversity in race, ethnicity, gender, religion, sexual orientation, nature of legal practice or professional background and geography.

f. When a vacancy occurs in the office of chief judge or associate judge of the court of appeals and the senate is not in session to give its advice and consent to an appointment to fill the vacancy, the governor shall fill the vacancy by interim appointment upon the recommendation of a commission on judicial nomination as provided in this section. An interim appointment shall continue until the senate shall pass upon the governor's selection. If the senate confirms an appointment, the judge shall serve a term as provided in subdivision a of this section commencing from the date of [his or her] such judge's interim appointment. If the senate rejects an appointment, a vacancy in the office shall occur sixty days after such rejection. If an interim appointment to the court of appeals be made from among the justices of the supreme court or the appellate divisions thereof, that appointment shall not affect the justice's existing office, nor create a vacancy in the supreme court, or the appellate division thereof, unless such appointment is confirmed by the senate and the appointee shall assume such office. If an interim appointment of chief judge of the court of appeals be made from among the associate judges, an interim appointment of associate judge shall be made in like manner; in such case, the appointment as chief judge shall not affect the existing office of associate judge, unless such appointment as chief judge is confirmed by the senate and the appointee shall assume such office.

§ 3. Resolved (if the Assembly concur), That subdivisions a, c, d, h and j of section 4 of article 6 of the constitution be amended to read as follows:

a. (1) The state shall be divided into four judicial departments. The first department shall consist of the counties within the first and twelfth judicial [district] districts of the state. The second department shall consist of the counties within the second, ninth, tenth [and], eleventh, and thirteenth judicial districts of the state. The third department shall consist of the counties within the third, fourth, and sixth judicial districts of the state. The fourth department shall consist of the counties within the fifth, seventh, and eighth judicial districts of the state. [Each department shall be bounded by the lines of judicial districts.]

(2) Once every ten years, the legislature may increase or decrease the number of judicial departments, or alter the boundaries of the judicial departments[, but without changing the number thereof]. Upon any adjustment hereunder, each department shall be bounded by the lines of judicial districts, and the justices of each appellate division affected by such adjustment may be re-apportioned, and appeals in their respective courts transferred, as provided by subdivision g of section twenty-seven of this article.

c. The governor shall designate the presiding justice of each appellate division, who shall act as such during [his or her] such justice's term of office and shall be a resident of the department. The other justices of the appellate divisions shall be designated by the governor, from all the justices [elected to] of the supreme court other than those appointed to fill a vacancy pursuant to subdivision a of section fifteen of this article, for terms of five years or the unexpired portions of their respective terms of office, if less than five years, provided the governor shall consider whether the designation of such justice results in an appellate division that reflects the diversity of the citizenry of the judicial department, including, but not limited to, diversity in race, ethnicity, gender, religion, sexual orientation, and nature of judicial experience or professional background.

d. The [justices heretofore designated shall continue to sit in the appellate divisions until the terms of their respective designations shall expire. From time to time as the terms of the designations expire, or vacancies occur, the governor shall make new designations. The] governor may also, on request of any appellate division, make temporary designations in case of the absence or inability to act of any justice in such appellate division, for service only during such absence or inability to act.

h. A justice of the appellate division of the supreme court in any department may be temporarily designated by the presiding justice of [his or her] such department to the appellate division in another judicial department upon agreement by the presiding justices of the appellate division of the departments concerned.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

CONCURRENT RESOLUTION OF THE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY proposing amendments to article 6 of the constitution, in relation to consolidation of the unified court system, and the repeal of sections 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, subdivision j of section 22 and sections 34, 35, 36, 36-a, 36-c and 37 of article 6 of the constitution relating thereto

Purpose

Consolidate New York's trial court system, allow for the creation of additional justices of the supreme court, require considerations of diversity in all judicial appointments and designations, allow for the creation of new judicial departments and appellate divisions, and repeal the mandatory retirement age for judges.

Summary of provisions

Sections 1 through 25 make various changes to Article VI of the New York State constitution, as follows:

Read the full memo (1,172 words)

-Effective October 1, 2025, the Court of Claims will be abolished and its judges will become Supreme Court Justices. Supreme Court will acquire the jurisdiction of the former Court of Claims. Also, all NYC Family, Civil, and Criminal Court Judges who have been serving as Acting Supreme Court Justices for at least the preceding six months will become Supreme Court Justices.

-Effective January 1, 2028, the County, Family, and Surrogate's Courts will be abolished and their judges will become Supreme Court Justices. Supreme Court will acquire their jurisdiction.

-Effective January 1, 2030, the New York City Civil and Criminal Courts, the District Courts on Long Island, and the 61 upstate City Court Courts will be abolished and their judges will become judges of a new statewide Municipal Court (note: while established statewide, the Municipal Court will sit as a separate court in each of the following: New York City, Nassau County, Suffolk County, and each upstate city). Also, Housing Judges of the New York City Civil Court (who now are statutory, quasi- judicial officers appointed by the Chief Administrator) will become judges of the Municipal Court in New York City

-Once merged with the Supreme Court or the Municipal Court, as appropri- ate, judges of the abolished courts will serve out the terms in which they were serving in the abolished courts and, thereafter, they and their successors in office will be selected to service on Supreme Court or Municipal Court, respectively, in the same manner and for the same terms as their predecessors (merger-in-place), except that wherever any judge or justice was appointed, the appointing authority must consider whether the appointment would result in a judiciary that reflects the diversity of the citizenry of the jurisdiction.

-The cap on legislative creation of new Supreme Court Justices (i.e., no additional Justices may be added in a Judicial District where the resulting number in that District will exceed a ratio of one Justice per

50,000 of the population) is eliminated. All newly-created Supreme Court Justices will be elected Judicial District-wide for 14-year terms.

-Except as the Chief Administrator otherwise provides, Supreme Court shall have the following divisions: family, probate, criminal, state claims, commercial, and general.

-The mandatory retirement age of 70 will be abolished for all courts, and there will no longer be a need for a certification process for service beyond 70.

-Effective upon abolition of the several superior courts being merged with Supreme Court, the Chief Administrator will be divested of his present authority to temporarily designate Acting Supreme Court Justices except that the Legislature may authorize the Chief Administrator to designate Municipal Court Judges as Acting Supreme Court Justices where it deems the circumstances to warrant exercise of that authority.

-A statewide Municipal Court will be established having the same crimi- nal jurisdiction as now is exercised by New York's local criminal courts, and the same civil jurisdiction as now is exercised by the New York City Civil Court (to be $50,000 effective January 1, 2022 by virtue of the voters' approval of ballot proposition number five at the Novem- ber 2021 election) except that the Municipal Court's ceiling on damage claims will be $50,000 unless the Legislature provides for a greater ceiling.

-The Municipal Court will sit in separate branches: one for New York City, one each for the areas in Nassau and Suffolk Counties now served by the District Courts, and one for each of the 61 cities outside New York City. Additional branches may be established in upstate counties in the same manner as the Legislature may now establish additional District Courts.

-The current Housing Part of the New York City Civil Court, and its jurisdiction, will be merged into the Municipal Court in New York City. The Municipal Court outside New York City may have housing divisions as the Legislature shall provide.

-There will be no change in the structure or jurisdiction of the Town and Village Justice Courts.

-The Legislature will be empowered to adjust the number of Judicial Departments (and, thus, the number of Appellate Divisions) once every ten years.

Justification

New York has the most convoluted trial court structure in the nation, with eleven trial courts of various jurisdictions. This proposal would simplify the trial court system into two courts: the Supreme Court (with jurisdiction over cases currently heard by the Court of Claims, County, Family, and Surrogate's Courts) and the Municipal Court (with jurisdic- tion over cases currently heard by the NYC Civil and Criminal Courts, other city courts, and District Courts). This proposal does not affect town & village courts.

The merger will promote a more efficient allocation of resources, simplify the practice of law, reduce the cost of litigation, and increase access to justice.

This proposal also makes several necessary constitutional changes to modernize the judicial system, including:

-Allowing for the creation of new judicial departments. Currently, the constitution only allows four judicial departments, and therefore four appellate divisions. This current division does not account for signif- icant increases in population and caseloads in some departments.

-Removing the limit on the number of Justices of the Supreme Court (JSCs) in any one judicial district. Currently, the number of JSCs are capped at one per fifty thousand residents of each judicial district.

-Repealing the mandatory retirement age. Currently, all judges and justices must retire at age 70, and only JSCs or judges of the Court of Appeals can be administratively certificated to continue service until age 76. This proposal would remove this ageist provision and allow New York to benefit from the continued service of our most experienced judg- es.

-Mandating the consideration of diversity in any judicial appointment or designation, including appointments or designations to the Appellate Division and as administrative judges.

-Respects the nonjudicial staff by ensuring nonjudicial staff are not diminished in salary, benefits, or responsibility due to the merger.

Legislative history

New Bill

Fiscal implications

To be determined

Effective date

Resolved (if the Assembly concur), That the foregoing amendments be referred to the first regular legislative session convening after the next succeeding general election of members of the Assembly, and, in conformity with section 1 of article 19 of the constitution; be published for three months previous to the time of such election.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.