What's happening
This bill prohibits New York colleges from considering legacy status or using early decision admissions, aiming to promote fairer college access.
Why it matters
Removes admissions advantages for legacies and early decision applicants, directly targeting practices that reinforce generational privilege and historically limit access for first-generation, low-income, immigrant, and minority students.
Seeks to reduce socioeconomic and racial disparities at New York’s most selective colleges by making admission decisions less dependent on family background or the ability to commit early without comparing financial aid offers.
Imposes significant financial penalties on institutions that violate these rules, with fines calculated based on student enrollment and tuition—creating a strong deterrent and directing any collected penalties toward state tuition assistance for undergraduates.
Explicitly allows ‘early action’ (non-binding early applications) and permits institutions to ask about alumni relations only after admission and financial aid decisions are finalized, ensuring such information is used strictly for data purposes, not admissions advantage.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Ban Legacy and Early Decision
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
2 Co-sponsors
History
- Referred to higher education
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Ban Legacy and Early Decision
In Assembly Committee · Higher Education · Sponsor Latrice Walker
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
8498
IN SENATE
March 7, 2022
Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Higher Education
AN ACT to amend the education law, in relation to prohibiting legacy preference and early decision admission policies at higher education institutions in this state
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Short title. This act may be known and shall be cited as the "fair college admissions act".
§ 2. Legislative intent. a. The legislature hereby finds that there are significant income gains associated with postsecondary education degree attainment, with New York state residents with a bachelor's degree three times less likely to live in poverty than those with a high school diploma.
b. The legislature further finds that students who attend and graduate from a highly selective higher education institution in the state of New York are much more likely to earn salaries in the top income quintile than those who graduate from less selective institutions, furthering economic and social inequality.
c. The legislature further finds that within most highly selective higher education institutions in New York state, degree completion rates for students from low-income and working class family backgrounds are comparable to students from upper-income family backgrounds.
d. The legislature further finds that many four-year higher education institutions in New York state consider whether a prospective student is related to alumni as part of the admissions process.
e. The legislature further finds that providing preferential treatment to students related to alumni of a higher education institution is discriminatory in nature and disproportionately hurts students who come from working class and low-income families, have parents who did not earn a bachelor's degree, are undocumented, are immigrants, and are members of historically underrepresented minority groups formerly denied entry into specific higher education institutions either as a matter of
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD14861-03-2
institution policy or the effect of historic underlying law and government practices.
f. The legislature further finds that 30 percent of bachelor degree granting institutions in the state of New York currently employ an early decision admissions policy that allows students to apply in the fall of their senior year and receive an application decision by December in exchange for committing to attend that institution and foregoing an opportunity to compare financial aid packages offered by competing institutions of higher education.
g. The legislature further finds that at a number of higher education institutions, particularly highly selective institutions with low admit rates, between 40 and 50 percent of enrolled students are admitted early decision, and early decision applicants are more than twice as likely to be admitted.
h. The legislature further finds that early decision admission policies are discriminatory in nature, as they favor students with strong college advising and the ability to commit to a college or university without considering a financial aid package. They put first-generation students, students at under-resourced high schools, and students from working class and low-income backgrounds at a disadvantage because they lack awareness of the strategic benefit of applying early decision and do not have the luxury of committing to an institution without knowing the post-financial aid cost of attendance.
i. The legislature further finds that inequitable, unfair admissions policies and practices such as legacy preference and early decision are a significant factor behind disparities in college enrollment among students from historically underserved racial and economic subgroups compared to their more advantaged peers at selective higher education institutions.
j. The legislature hereby declares that a prohibition on legacy preference and early decision admissions policies at degree-granting colleges and universities in the state shall further the goals of educational, economic, and social equity, helping to diversify highly selective institutions while closing achievement gaps between historically advantaged and disadvantaged groups, and shall commit to achieving the same with the following provisions of this act.
§ 3. The education law is amended by adding a new section 239-d to read as follows:
§ 239-d. Prohibition on legacy preference and early decision admission policies. 1. Definitions. As used in this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
(a) "Consider alumni/ae relation as a factor in admissions" shall refer to when an admissions application asks applicants to indicate where their relatives attended college and that such information is included among the documents that the higher education institution uses to consider an applicant for admission.
(b) "Early action" shall mean an admissions plan that allows a student to apply at an earlier stage of the admissions process and receive an expedited admissions decision but does not require such student to commit to attend such institution upon receiving a decision of admittance.
(c) "Early decision" shall mean an admissions plan that allows a student to apply at an earlier stage of the admissions process and receive an expedited admissions decision that requires such student, absent unique circumstances stipulated in the early decision application or otherwise agreed to by the institution, to commit to attend a higher education institution should such student be admitted and to withdraw all other applications to other higher education institutions.
(d) "Higher education institution" shall mean the state university of New York, as defined in subdivision one of section three hundred fiftytwo of this chapter, the city university of New York, as established in section sixty-two hundred three of this chapter, or any institution given the power to confer degrees in this state by the board of regents as provided in section two hundred eighteen of this article.
(e) "Legacy preference" shall mean a preference in admissions given by a higher education institution to applicants related by consanguinity or affinity to alumni of such institution.
2. Prohibition. No higher education institution in this state shall:
(a) consider alumni/ae relation as a factor in admissions; or
(b) execute an early decision policy for undergraduate admissions. Such prohibition shall not apply, however, to a higher education institution that asks applicants about relations to alumni of such institution after an offer of admission and financial aid has been accepted for the purposes of data collection and reporting. Furthermore, the prohibition herein described shall not be construed to apply to an early action policy as defined in paragraph (b) of subdivision one of this section.
3. Penalty. A violation of subdivision two of this section shall result in a civil penalty of a sum equivalent to ten percent of the number of full-time equivalent first year students enrolled at the higher educational institution the year previous to the violation multiplied by such institution's published tuition and fees.
4. Dedication of penalty funds. All penalties paid pursuant to subdivision three of this section shall be assessed by the commissioner and deposited into the general fund of the state. Such monies shall then be used for the disbursement of tuition assistance awards by the higher education services corporation to eligible undergraduate students pursuant to the provisions of sections six hundred sixty-six, six hundred sixty-seven, six hundred sixty-seven-a, and six hundred sixty seven-c of this chapter.
§ 4. This act shall take effect on the first of July next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law. Effective immediately the addition, amendment, and/or repeal of any rules or regulations necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made on or before such effective date.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the education law, in relation to prohibiting legacy preference and early decision admission policies at higher education institutions in this state
Purpose or general idea of bill
To prohibit legacy preference and early admissions policies at under- graduate institutions.
Summary of provisions
Section one of the bill provides that this act shall be known as the "Fair College Admissions Act."
Read the full memo (901 words)
Section two declares legislative intent.
Section three adds a new section 239-d to the Education Law to ban lega- cy preference and early admissions, set penalties, and earmark penalty funds.
Section four provides the effective date.
Justification
Much has been written about the financial barriers low-income students face when applying to college, particularly in regards to the most elite institutions our nation and state have to offer. Perhaps equally impor- tant, however, are the structural barriers they face in the form of regressive college admittance policies such as legacy preference and early decision. These policies, which played a role in approximately 50% of current elite college and university students' acceptance, have the effect of excluding access to these institutions for our state's lowest-income students who are disproportionately likely to be first- generation college students or unable to apply to early decision due to a need to compare financial aid packages.
Legacy preference, in which colleges consider familial relationship to existing alumni in their admittance decisions, has resulted in legacy students being three times more likely to be accepted into a prestigious institution than a non-legacy student with a similar academic back- ground, according to a 2010 study. Virtually all top 100 private colleges and universities nationwide have express alumni preference policies, with legacies typically composing between 10 and 15 percent of a freshman class, and there have been more white students admitted to top ten universities benefitting from legacy preference than students of color admitted under affirmative action. The data show virtually no elite college legacy students are low-income.
Early decision, meanwhile, has had an equally discriminatory impact. Colleges that employ early decision policies allow students to apply in November of their senior year in exchange for committing to attend that institution if they are accepted. This deprives the student of the opportunity to apply to other schools in search of a better financial aid package and is thus not a luxury any but the wealthiest of appli- cants can afford. Early decision enrollees are overwhelmingly white, with higher incomes and parents with greater levels of education. According to some studies, applying early decision is worth an extra 100 points on the SAT. Admissions officers routinely tell students that applying early improves their chances of acceptance, and at the most elite colleges, up to 50% of an incoming class is admitted early deci- sion. Recently, the US Justice Department has even begun investigating some colleges' early decision policies and their possible violation of antitrust laws, as it appears that institutions may have agreements with each other to share information about potential applicants.
This bill would improve access to our state's highest-performing colleges and universities by banning legacy preference and early deci- sion outright. It would explicitly allow for the continuance of early action, in which, distinct from early decision, students apply to a college between October and November of their senior year under a non- binding application, and are free to apply to other schools and compare financial aid offers in the spring. This bill would specifically bar colleges from asking about and considering where an applicant's parents attended school, meaning they would not be allowed to include such a question on their own application, or review the answers to such a ques- tion on the Common App. Institutions found by the NYS Education Depart- ment to be in violation of this prohibition face a penalty of 10% of the prior year's number of full-time equivalent first-year students times tuition and fees, and penalty money collected by NYSED would then be distributed as TAP awards, which help subsidize tuition for students earning $80,000 or less.
As the debate around college affordability and access continues to roil our nation and state, a commonsense repeal of these regressive policies will help level the playing field for all hoping to attend our state's most celebrated and prestigious institutions. The direct correlation between income mobility and a college degree is well-known, with New York State residents with a bachelor's degree three times less likely to live in poverty than those with a high school diploma. Additionally, students who attend and graduate from a highly selective college in New York are significantly more likely to earn salaries in the top income quintile. This coupled with the fact that degree completion rates for low-income students at these institutions is comparable to that of students from wealthier backgrounds makes the clear case for a more open and inclusive college admissions policies that favors academic perform- ance over family history or generational wealth. The legislature has a pivotal role to play in ensuring that the opportunities afforded by these institutions are open to all, regardless of race, income, or fami- ly legacy - and bills such as this are a critical first step in that direction.
Prior legislative history
None
Fiscal implications
None
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the first of July next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.