Skip to content
S8809Senate2021-2022 Session

Open Cathead Mountain Access

Official title

“Implements a land exchange and easements in the vicinity of Cathead Mountain”

Sponsor John E. BrooksSD-8+1 co-sponsorAffects Environment & Energy
Status
In Senate Committee
Environmental Conservation
Impact
4/10
Low
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Environmental Conservation

What's happening

This bill authorizes land exchanges, easements, and the construction of emergency communications infrastructure on Cathead Mountain to improve public recreation and safety in the southern Adirondacks.

Why it matters

  1. The bill leverages a recent constitutional amendment. to allow land swaps and easements that would otherwise be prohibited, aiming to expand the forest preserve by at least 580 acres while protecting sensitive natural resources and limiting new development on private lands through conservation easements.

  2. It balances public recreation with private and public interests. by creating public trail access and restoring the historic Cathead Mountain fire tower for hikers, but also includes restrictions to protect hunting seasons, private landowner rights, and local habitat management.

  3. The legislation addresses critical emergency communications needs. for remote Adirondack communities by authorizing the construction and utility access for a modern emergency communication tower, with explicit requirements for environmental restoration after the transition from old to new infrastructure.

  4. It builds in future-proofing and oversight. Reserved rights and right-of-first-refusal clauses ensure the state can further acquire or protect these lands in the future, and a required police study ensures the new communications facilities are both effective and compatible with safe public access. The bill includes a sunset provision to ensure timely execution.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Open Cathead Mountain Access

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
John E. Brooks

Senator · Senate District 8

Chair, Veterans, Homeland Security And Military Affairs

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Referred to environmental conservation

Full text

5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

8809

IN SENATE

April 19, 2022

Introduced by Sen. BROOKS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Environmental Conservation

AN ACT to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to implementing a land exchange and easements in the vicinity of Cathead Mountain

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Article 9 of the environmental conservation law is amended by adding a new title 23 to read as follows:

TITLE 23

RECREATIONAL ACCESS TO AND EMERGENCY COMMUNICATIONS

EQUIPMENT ON CATHEAD MOUNTAIN Section 9-2301. Legislative purpose and intent.

9-2303. Conveyances to the state and Hamilton county.

9-2305. Declaration of restrictions.

9-2307. New York state affirmative rights.

9-2309. Legislative approval of conveyance.

9-2311. Attorney general to approve title.

9-2313. Land to be conveyed by the state.

9-2315. Right of first refusal.

9-2317. Special conditions.

9-2319. Sunset provision. § 9-2301. Legislative purpose and intent.

1. The legislature hereby finds that the voters have approved an amendment to section 1 of article 14 of the state constitution for the purposes of increasing the acreage of the forest preserve, reopening to the public an historically significant and popular recreational destination on the summit of Cathead Mountain in the town of Benson, county of Hamilton in the southern Adirondacks, acquiring conservation easements over certain private land on the slopes of Cathead Mountain, and providing for a tower for state and Hamilton county emergency communications equipment on such summit, including motorized access to and a reliable source of power for such equipment.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15225-01-2

2. The legislature further finds that the amendment will facilitate public access to and enjoyment of the forest preserve in the southern part of the Adirondack Park, an area that is currently underutilized for recreation by the public.

3. The legislature also finds that the mountainous nature of the southern Adirondacks and the remote nature of southern Adirondack Park communities poses significant challenges to ensuring reliable emergency communications systems for municipalities, the state police, and the department of environmental conservation and that Cathead Mountain, located in the town of Benson, Hamilton county, is uniquely situated to meet critical public health and safety communication needs in the southern area of the Adirondack Park.

4. The legislature therefore finds that a tower containing emergency communications equipment on Cathead Mountain is essential for the public health and safety needs in the southern area of the Adirondack Park.

5. The legislature further finds that legislation is necessary to successfully implement the constitutional amendment in a manner which provides significant additional acreage to the forest preserve, provides substantial public recreational benefits, meets emergency communications needs, protects natural resources and limits development on certain privately held lands.

6. For these reasons, it is the intent of the legislature to implement the constitutional amendment in a manner which adds five hundred eighty acres to the forest preserve, creates trail easements for public access to and recreational use of a fire tower on the summit of Cathead Mountain, establishes an easement for access to and the construction and maintenance of a new Hamilton county and state emergency communications tower on Lot 166, Benson Tract, and creates conservation easements restricting development, subdivision, and forest management over four hundred thirty-four acres of private land on Cathead Mountain.

§ 9-2303. Conveyances to the state and Hamilton county.

1. Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. may convey to the state fee title to Lots 122, 165, and 172, Benson Tract, town of Benson, county of Hamilton, containing approximately four hundred eighty acres of true forest land, for incorporation into the forest preserve.

2. Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. may convey to the state and a designated accredited land trust easements for hiking trails across Lot 166, Benson Tract for access to the fire tower located on the summit of Cathead Mountain, provided that such easement shall restrict public use during firearm hunting season for public safety reasons, and provided further that such easement shall include language pertaining to trespass or other damage to lands owned by such club.

3. Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. may convey to the state and a designated accredited land trust a conservation easement restricting development, subdivision and forest management over Lot 166, Benson Tract and a right of first refusal over such lot. Such easement may reserve to such club the following rights:

a. the right to sustainable timber and forest product harvest;

b. the right to repair, maintain, improve or relocate any and all existing roads, trails and paths and to construct any new roads and trails necessary to support habitat management activities;

c. the right to provide the New York state police and other state agencies with exclusive use of the existing communication tower site, including accessory structures and facilities, unless and until a replacement tower is constructed and available for use;

d. the right to construct, establish and lease for construction one additional communication tower on Lot 166 if the state or a local government determines it necessary for communication purposes to support public safety, including an access road necessary to complete tower construction and facilitate ongoing operation, provided such tower shall be as low profile as practicable. Once construction of a replacement tower is completed and becomes operational, all infrastructure supporting the existing fire tower for purposes of communications will be removed by the responsible state agency within one hundred eighty days, provided that the New York state police or other state agencies may continue to locate whip antennas on the fire tower to provide local coverage as necessary. The infrastructure to be removed shall include solar panels, a wind turbine and backup power generator, unless deemed appropriate to serve the replacement tower. Once a new communications tower is in operation, the fire tower shall be restored to its original form for public enjoyment of the Adirondack Park in the Cathead Mountain area pursuant to a restoration plan produced by the department that includes budgets and timelines. The department shall produce such plan within two hundred forty days of the completed construction of the new tower. The state shall have full and unrestricted administrative access to the fire tower for its restoration, maintenance and use and such restoration, maintenance and use shall be the sole responsibility of the state;

e. the right to transition to the next generation of public emergency communication technology with the assistance of private communication service companies in the event public safety use by the New York state police, other state agency, or a local government ceases;

f. the right to install, repair, maintain, improve or relocate utilities to service the above towers. Utilities located on Lot 166 must be located on the surface of or under the ground and shall not be located on above ground poles.

4. Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. may convey to the state and Hamilton county a right of way over Lot 166, Benson Tract for a utility line to bring power to such tower and equipment and a road to provide motorized access to such tower and equipment.

5. Thomas Gang, Inc. may convey to the state and a designated accredited land trust an easement for a hiking trail across Lot 113, Benson Tract to provide public access to the fire tower located on the summit of Cathead Mountain, provided that such easement shall restrict public use during firearm hunting season for public safety, and provided further that such easement shall include language pertaining to trespass or other damage to lands owned by such club.

6. Thomas Gang, Inc. may convey to the state and a designated accredited land trust a conservation easement restricting development, subdivision and forest management over Lot 167, Benson Tract and a right of first refusal over such tract, and a conservation easement restricting subdivision on fifty-eight acres of Lot 113 and requiring a one hundred-foot vegetative buffer around the trail easement described in subdivision five of this section. Such easements may reserve to such club the following rights:

a. the right to sustainable timber and forest product harvest;

b. the right to maintain any existing camp structures and buildings;

c. the right to establish no more than one new hunting camp on Lot 167, Benson Tract, in accordance with regulations promulgated by the Adirondack Park agency;

d. the right to occupy, use, maintain, repair, improve, demolish or replace existing camp structures and outbuildings;

e. the right to repair, maintain, improve or relocate any and all existing roads, trails and paths and to construct any new roads and trails necessary to support habitat management activities;

f. the right to install, repair, maintain, improve or relocate utilities to service the above camps, and/or towers;

g. the right to conduct habitat management activities, including but not limited to food plot planting.

7. Thomas Gang, Inc. may convey to the state and the county of Hamilton a right of way over Lots 113 and 167, Benson Tract, for a utility line to bring power to the tower and equipment described in subdivision four of this section and for a road for motor vehicle access to the tower and emergency communications equipment located on Lot 166 of such tract.

8. The county of Hamilton may convey to the state for incorporation into the forest preserve a total of not less than one hundred acres of land suitable for addition to the forest preserve, subject to legislative approval. § 9-2305. Declaration of restrictions.

Except to the extent expressly provided by the Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. reserved rights under subdivision three of section 9-2303 of this title, and expressly provided by the Thomas Gang, Inc. reserved rights under subdivision six of section 9-2303 of this title, the following activities will be prohibited on conservation easements conveyed by the clubs to the state and a designated accredited land trust:

1. No residential, commercial agricultural or industrial activities shall be allowed.

2. No timber harvesting equipment shall be used within fifty feet of Beaver Pond unless necessitated by a wind storm, insect or disease, epidemic, fire, ice storm or other act of God. Any selective timber harvest within this area must maintain at least seventy-five percent of the pre-harvest basal area.

3. No pesticides, insecticides, rodenticides or herbicides shall be allowed except as provided for in the performance of approved forest management activities or by state governmental agencies.

4. No new buildings, residences or mobile homes shall be allowed.

5. No mining shall be conducted, and no minerals, gas or oil will be extracted except the onsite use of gravel and sand for road construction. § 9-2307. New York state affirmative rights.

The state of New York shall have the following affirmative rights:

1. The right on Lot 166 to construct, use, repair, maintain, replace and improve the existing fire tower, including construction of a new communication tower, ranger cabin, utilities and a new road to the emergency communications tower.

2. The right to construct, use, repair and maintain a public trail from Grant Lake through Lot 166, Benson Tract, to the fire tower and summit of Cathead Mountain.

3. The right to construct, use, repair and maintain a public trail through Lots 113 and 166, Benson Tract, to the fire tower and summit of Cathead Mountain.

4. A right of first refusal, co-held by the state of New York and a designated accredited land trust, should the Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. or Thomas Gang, Inc. decide to sell any or all of Lots 166 or 167, Benson Tract, or any of the forty-six acres in Lot 120 of such tract which the state may convey to the Thomas Gang, Inc. pursuant to section 9-2313 of this title. § 9-2309. Legislative approval of conveyance.

The legislature shall approve the conveyance by the county of Hamilton authorized in subdivision eight of section 9-2303 of this title to ensure such land constitutes a suitable addition to the forest preserve. § 9-2311. Attorney general to approve title.

Title to land and easements to be conveyed to the state pursuant to section 9-2303 of this title and the deeds to the state shall be approved by the attorney general, as to form and manner of execution and recordability, before the deeds shall be accepted on behalf of the state. § 9-2313. Land to be conveyed by the state.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to implementing a land exchange and easements in the vicinity of Cathead Mountain

Purpose

This bill amends the Environmental Conservation Law (ECL) to implement a constitutional amendment authorizing a land exchange and easements in the vicinity of Cathead Mountain to provide for recreational access to and emergency communications equipment on Cathead Mountain

Summary of provisions

Section 1 amends Article 9 of the Environmental Conservation Law by adding a new Title 23:

Read the full memo (1,573 words)

ECL § 9-2401 provides the legislative purpose and intent to authorize recreational access to and emergency communications equipment on Cathead Motntain.

ECL § 9-2402 authorizes conveyances of fee title and certain easements to the state and Hamilton County.

ECL § 9-2403 details the restrictions applicable to fee owners who convey conservation easements to the state.

ECL § 9-2404 details the rights which the state will obtain in the conservation easements it acquires.

ECL § 9-2405 requires the legislature to approve the conveyance from Hamilton County to the state.

ECL § 9-2406 requires the Attorney General to approve title of the land and easements acquired by the state.

ECL § 9-2407 describes certain lands to be conveyed to the state and certain rights which the state must retain.

ECL § 9-2408 provides the state with a right of first refusal on certain lands.

ECL § 9-2409 sets forth certain special conditions which must be met prior to any such conveyance of land or easements as specified in this article.

ECL § 9-2409 includes a sunset provision.

Section 2. is the enacting clause.

Justification

This bill implements the new constitutional amendment by detailing the substantive requirements of the land exchange. The benefits of the constitutional amendment and the implementing legislation can be broken into two categories: conservation, recreation and rural economies; and public health and safety.

The southern part of the Adirondack Park is underutilized by the recre- ating public, in part because few mountaintops in the area provide the public with the opportunity to enjoy scenic vistas. Although Cathead Mountain contains an old fire tower providing an outstanding panoramic vista of the southern Adirondacks which was once a popular hiking desti- nation, it is located on private land and has been closed to the public for nearly 25 years. This amendment would allow the public to once again enjoy the view from the fire tower by acquiring easements providing public trails to the tower from two directions: from Grant Lake, located on Forest Preserve land to the west of Cathead Mountain, into Lot 166, Benson's Tract owned by the Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club; and from North Road located to the south of Cathead Mountain through Lot 113, Benson's Tract, owned by the Thomas Gang, Inc. and into said Lot 166. Providing the public with access to Cathead Mountain fire tower views would provide hikers with an outstanding view of the southern Adirondacks which is otherwise unavailable, and could thereby help to channel hikers away from the overly utilized High Peaks region of the Park.

To ensure that the scenic and ecological values of the mountaintop are protected in perpetuity, the State will also acquire for inclusion in the Forest Preserve a total of 480 acres of land in fee simple on the mountain (lots 122, 165 and 172, Benson Tract, all owned by the Hatch- brook Sportsmen Club), and acquire conservation easements restricting development on 420 acres of private land on the mountain (Lot 166, Benson Tract owned by the Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club; Lot 166, Benson Tract and 58 acres of Lot 113, Benson Tract, both owned by the Thomas Gang, Inc;, and the 42 acres in Lot 120, Benson Tract, to be conveyed by the state to the Thomas Gang, Inc. as part of this land exchange).

The mountainous nature of the Adirondack Park and the remoteness of local communities pose significant challenges to ensuring reliable emer- gency communications systems for municipalities, the State Police, and the Department of Environmental Conservation. However, Cathead Mountain is uniquely situated to meet critical public health and safety communi- cation needs in the southern area of the Park. Currently, communications equipment owned by the Department of Environmental Conservation and the State Police are co-located on an old existing Department fire tower on the summit of the mountain. Lease payments are made by the State to the Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club for this use. Hamilton County does not currently have any emergency communications equipment on the mountain, causing a "dead zone" for County emergency communications which creates a serious public health and safety concern.

Although motor vehicle access and a consistent and reliable source of power are essential to ensuring the reliability of emergency communi- cations equipment, neither are currently available for the equipment on Cathead Mountain due to both Adirondack Park State Land Master Plan classification guidelines and Article XIV, Section l's "forever wild" provisions of the State Constitution. Consequently, unreliable power to the tower is now provided by unsightly solar panels, a wind turbine and a generator which clutter up the area around the fire tower, detracting from its scenic beauty and ecological value. To more fully and reliably serve the emergency communication needs of the region and reduce the existing eyesore's footprint on the mountain, the amendment would enable Hamilton County to erect a new tower at a site on private land on the mountain just to the north of the current fire tower (lot 166, Benson Tract), co-locating all emergency communications systems now located on the fire tower to this new site. The amendment would also allow power to be provided to the site by an electrical cable that is located either underground or on the surface of the ground (and not on above-ground poles), thereby eliminating the need for current on-site unsightly power sources, and allow motor vehicle access to the site. Under the amend- ment, both the power line and motorized access to the tower could trav- erse only private land on easements acquired by the state and Hamilton County (Lots 113, 167 and 166, Benson Tract), which is not subject to either Adirondack Park State Land Master Plan guidelines or "forever wild" provisions in the Constitution. An easement for such purposes would also be reserved by the state and conveyed to Hamilton County through that portion of Lot 120 that is granted to the Thomas Gang, Inc. as part of this land exchange.

Passage of this legislation will enable the State to implement the constitutional amendment and resolve complex, intertwined issues by allowing the public to once again hike to the summit of the mountain and use the fire tower, protect the mountain's scenic and ecological quali- ties by state acquisition of 580 acres of land for inclusion in the forest preserve and the acquisition of conservation easements over 420 acres of private land, and allow Hamilton County to provide for public health and safety by constructing a tower on the summit for emergency communication purposes, servicing both the state and the county, and providing motorized access and a stable source of power to the tower in a manner that is consistent with the summit's scenic beauty.

The mountainous and remote nature of Adirondack Park communities poses significant challenges to ensuring reliable emergency communications systems for municipalities, the State Police, and the Department of Environmental Conservation.Cathead Mountain, located in the Town of Benson, Hamilton County, is uniquely situated to meet critical public health and safety communication needs in the southern area of the Adirondack Park.

The summit of Cathead Mountain, including Lots 122, 165, 166, 167 and 172, is privately owned by Hatchbrook Sportsmen Club, Inc. (HSC). HSC, which is the successor in title to the Thomas Gang, also owns Lots 113 and 114 to the south of the summit. HSC's land on the summit is an inholding surrounded by land owned by the People of the State of New York as Forest Preserve. Of particular importance to this issue are Forest Preserve lots 120 and 121, which are located between HSC's land on the summit and HSC's land to the south of the summit. Thus, in order to access Lots 122, 165, 166 and 172 from Lots 113 and 114, Forest Preserve Lots 120 or 121 must be crossed.

Presently, communications equipment owned by both the Department and the State Police are co-located on an old existing DEC fire tower on Lot 166 at the summit of the mountain. Lease payments are made by the State to HSC for this use. There is no motorized access to the tower, and power is supplied by an on-site wind turbine and generator and on-site solar panels. To more fully and reliably serve the emergency communication needs of the community, Hamilton County proposes to erect a new tower at a site just to the north of the current fire tower and co-locate all existing emergency communications systems on the summit to this new site. Thus, existing DEC and State Police equipment and the power sourc- es for the equipment would be relocated off the existing DEC fire tower.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the same date and in the same manner as a concurrent resolution of the senate and assembly proposing an amendment to section 1 of article 14 of the constitution, in relation to Cathead Mountain takes effect in accordance with section 1 of article 19 of the constitution.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.