Skip to content
S9073Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA1091

Let Patients Sue Fertility Fraud

Official title

“Establishes a cause of action for fertility fraud”

Sponsor Cordell CleareSD-30Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Codes
Impact
5/10
Moderate
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Codes

What's happening

This bill creates a private right to sue for damages in cases of fertility fraud involving assisted reproduction procedures.

Why it matters

  1. Empowers patients, spouses, and children to seek damages. if a healthcare provider uses reproductive material in an assisted reproduction procedure without proper informed consent, or uses material from an unapproved donor, providing tangible legal recourse for victims.

  2. Holds donors and fertility service providers accountable. for knowingly providing false or misleading medical or genetic information, or for using reproductive material in ways not consented to by the patient, which could help deter deceptive practices and improve transparency.

  3. Gives donors themselves legal protection and a right to sue. if their reproductive material is used without their consent or outside of their agreed terms, addressing potential abuses against donors as well as recipients.

  4. Allows for compensatory and punitive damages, as well as court-ordered remedies. (including consideration of emotional harm), which may serve as a strong deterrent against fertility fraud and recognize the profound personal impacts such violations can cause.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Let Patients Sue Fertility Fraud

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Cordell Cleare

Senator · Senate District 30

Chair, Women's Issues

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A1091Assembly

Allow Lawsuits for Fertility Fraud

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Amy Paulin

Impact 5 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9073

IN SENATE

May 6, 2022

Introduced by Sen. CLEARE -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the civil rights law and the education law, in relation to establishing a cause of action for fertility fraud

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The civil rights law is amended by adding a new section 52-d to read as follows:

§ 52-d. Private right of action for fertility fraud. 1. Any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure with a health care provider, the spouse of any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure with a health care provider, or a child or person born as a result of such assisted reproduction procedure shall have a private right of action for damages against such health care provider under any of the following conditions:

(a) such health care provider knowingly or intentionally performs an assisted reproduction procedure using the human reproductive material of the health care provider or any other donor without the patient's informed written consent to treatment using human reproductive material from the health care provider or from any donor other than a donor from whom the patient consented to in writing; or

(b) such health care provider intentionally performs an assisted reproduction procedure and such health care provider knows or reasonably should have known that the human reproductive material was used: (i) without the donor's consent; or (ii) in a manner or to an extent other than that to which the donor consented.

2. Any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure, the spouse of any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure, or a child or person born as a result of such assisted reproduction procedure shall have a private right of action for damages against a donor or assisted reproductive service provider under any of the following conditions:

(a) such donor or assisted reproductive service provider knowingly provides false or misleading information about the donor's medical

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD06232-12-2

history including but not limited to an illness at the time of donation, any past illness of the donor, or the genetic or family history of the donor for the past two generations which is known to the donor at the time of donation; or

(b) such assisted reproductive service provider knowingly uses or provides human reproductive material for an assisted reproduction procedure in a manner or to an extent other than that to which the patient consented.

3. A donor of human reproductive material shall have a cause of action against a health care provider or assisted reproductive service provider, if the donor's human reproductive material was used: (a) without the donor's consent; or (b) in a manner or to an extent other than that to which the donor consented.

4. Damages recovered by a plaintiff pursuant to this section shall include compensatory damages. In addition thereto, the trier of fact may award punitive damages and such other non-monetary relief as may be appropriate. In awarding damages, the court may consider the emotional impact of the defendant's conduct.

5. Nothing in this section shall be deemed to abrogate or otherwise limit any right or remedy otherwise conferred by federal or state law including but not limited to, any right or remedy related to child support, nor shall any award under this section be used to offset child support obligations that may arise in connection with this section.

6. A cause of action under this section shall be commenced no later than six years from the date a person discovers, or reasonably should have discovered, the fertility fraud.

7. For purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

(a) "donor" shall mean an individual who does not intend to be a parent, who produces human reproductive material and provides such human reproductive material to another person, other than the individual's spouse, for use in an assisted reproduction procedure;

(b) "human reproductive material" shall mean:

(i) a human spermatozoon or ovum; or

(ii) a human organism at any stage of development from fertilized ovum to embryo; and

(c) "patient" shall mean any individual injected or implanted with human reproductive material.

§ 2. Section 6530 of the education law is amended by adding a new subdivision 51 to read as follows:

51. Found liable for fertility fraud under section fifty-two-d of the civil rights law.

§ 3. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law, and shall apply to acts occurring on or after such date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the civil rights law and the education law, in relation to establishing a cause of action for fertility fraud

Purpose

To provide civil recourse to patients, spouses, and children when a physician service provider, or donor commits fertility fraud.

Summary of provisions

Section one adds a new section 52-d to the civil rights law, creating a private right of action for fertility fraud.

Read the full memo (933 words)

Subdivision one provides that any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure with a health care provider, their spouse, and a child or person born as a result of such assisted reproductive procedure shall have a private right of action for damages against such health care provider when: (a) such health care provider knowingly or inten- tionally performs an assisted reproduction procedure using the human reproductive material of the health care provider or any other donor without the patient's informed written consent, or from any donor other than a donor from whom the patient consented in writing; or (b) such health care provider intentionally performs an assisted reproduction procedure and such health care provider knows or reasonably should have known that the human reproductive material was used: (i) without the donor's consent; or (ii) in a manner or to an extent other than that to which the donor consented.

Subdivision two provides that any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure, the spouse of any patient who has undergone an assisted reproduction procedure, or a child or person born as a result of such assisted reproduction procedure shall have a private right of action for damages against a donor or assisted reproductive service provider where (a) such donor or assisted reproductive service provider knowingly provides false or misleading information about the donor's medical history including but not limited to an illness at the time of donation, any past illness, of the donor, or genetic or family history of the donor for the past two generations which is known to the donor at the time of donation; or such assisted reproductive service provider knowingly uses or provides human reproductive material for an assisted reproduction procedure in a manner or to an extent other than that to which the patient consented.

Subdivision three provides that a donor of human reproductive material shall have a cause of action against a health care provider or assisted reproductive service provider, if the donor's human reproductive materi- al was used: (i) without the donor's consent; or

(ii) in a manner or to an extent other than that to which the donor consented.

Subdivision four provides that damages recovered by a plaintiff pursuant to this section shall include compensatory damages. In addition, the trier of fact may award punitive damages and such other non-monetary relief as may be. appropriate. In awarding damages, the court may consider the emotional impact of the defendant's conduct.

Subdivision five provides that nothing in this section shall be deemed to abrogate or otherwise limit any right or remedy otherwise conferred by federal or state law including but not limited to, any right or reme- dy related to child support, nor shall any award under this section be used to offset child support obligations that may arise in connection with this section.

Subdivision six provides that a cause of action under this section shall be commenced no later than six years from the date a person discovers, or reasonably should have discovered, the fertility fraud.

Subdivision seven defines terms used in this section.

Section three amend section 6530 of the education law to provide that a physician is guilty of profession misconduct if found liable for fertil- ity fraud.

Section three provides the effective date.

Justification

Several recent high-profile cases of doctors using their own sperm to inseminate patients have brought attention to the issue of fertility fraud. One Indiana doctor used his sperm instead of the intended donor sperm and has been found to have fathered at least sixty children, born in the 1970s and 1980s. Vocal patients who were victims of a doctor's fraud in Texas exposed his actions and were successful in advocating for the passage of fertility fraud legislation in their state. Currently, Indiana, California, and Texas have enacted laws creating a civil right of action for fertility fraud. Civil bills have also been introduced and are pending in Colorado, Nebraska, Ohio, and Florida.

New York law must protect the dignity of women undergoing assisted reproduction procedures. If a doctor violates their professional oath and takes advantage of a patient's confidence by using reproductive material without prior consent, there must be judicial recourse avail- able to victims. Learning that one has received unintended reproductive material without consent is the ultimate betrayal of trust and would leave a patient feeling nothing less than deceit and violation.

This legislation creates a civil right of action against a health care provider when such provider knowingly or intentionally performs an assisted reproductive procedure using their own human reproductive mate- rial, or that of any other donor, without the patient's informed written consent. It will also afford a civil remedy against donors and fertility clinics.

Patients must feel confident that the reproductive material used to have their child is the material that they have consented to using. Estab- lishing a right to sue for the act of fertility fraud will validate a victim's experience and will make it easier to seek justice when they have been wronged.

Prior legislative history

A.11141, 2020, referred to judiciary

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

On the ninetieth day after it shall have become law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.