Skip to content
S9149Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA10349

Limit Workers' Comp Board Decisions

Official title

“Relates to limiting the effect of determinations by the board of workers' compensation”

Sponsor Andrew GounardesSD-22Affects Economy
Status
Signed by Governor
Impact
6/10
Moderate
Outcome
Signed into law

Bill progress

Signed into law

What's happening

This bill prevents workers' compensation board decisions from having collateral estoppel effect in other legal actions, except for determining employer-employee relationships.

Why it matters

  1. Protects injured workers’ rights to pursue other legal claims. By preventing workers’ compensation board decisions from having collateral estoppel effect (except for employer-employee relationship), the bill ensures that findings in workers’ comp cases cannot automatically be used to block or limit a worker’s claims in other lawsuits (such as personal injury or discrimination cases) arising from the same incident.

  2. Promotes fairness and due process. Injured workers and other parties get a full and independent hearing in subsequent legal actions, rather than being bound by the workers' compensation board’s findings, which may have been decided under different legal standards or with different evidentiary procedures.

  3. Clarifies legal boundaries for employers and insurers. The bill creates clearer distinctions between workers’ compensation proceedings and other legal actions, reducing the risk that employers or insurers can use prior board findings to avoid further liability or litigation outside the workers’ comp system.

  4. Preserves key exception for employer-employee status. The only issue that can carry over is the determination of whether an employer-employee relationship exists, which maintains consistency in this foundational question across legal forums without extending preclusive effects to broader factual or legal findings.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Injured workers

    The bill would prevent workers’ compensation findings from binding them in other proceedings arising from the same occurrence, except findings on whether an employer-employee relationship exists.

  • Employers and third-party defendants

    They could not use workers’ compensation determinations to conclusively settle issues in related litigation, except the existence of an employer-employee relationship.

  • Workers’ Compensation Board and workers’ compensation judges

    Their findings would retain effect within workers’ compensation cases but generally would not bind other proceedings arising from the same occurrence.

Headline styles

Limit Workers' Comp Board Decisions

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Andrew Gounardes

Senator · Senate District 22

Chair, Budget And Revenue

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Signed chap.835
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to senate
  4. Passed assembly
  5. Ordered to third reading rules cal.747
  6. Substituted for A10349
  7. Referred to labor
  8. Delivered to assembly
  9. Passed senateVote 58–5
  10. Ordered to third reading cal.1914
  11. Committee discharged and committed to rules
  12. Referred to labor

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10349Assembly

Limit Workers’ Comp Rulings

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Latoya Joyner

Impact 5 · Moderate0% to pass

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9149

IN SENATE

May 11, 2022

Introduced by Sen. GOUNARDES -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Labor

AN ACT to amend the workers' compensation law, in relation to enacting the justice for injured workers act

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. This act shall be known as the "justice for injured workers act".

§ 2. The workers' compensation law is amended by adding a new section 118-a to read as follows:

§ 118-a. Effect of findings and determinations in subsequent proceedings. With respect to an action for a workers' compensation claim permissible under this chapter, no finding or decision by the workers' compensation board, judge or other arbiter shall be given collateral estoppel effect in any other action or proceeding arising out of the same occurrence, other than the determination of the existence of an employer employee relationship.

§ 3. Section 11 of the workers' compensation law, as amended by chapter 635 of the laws of 1996, the opening paragraph as amended by section 8 of part SS of chapter 59 of the laws of 2017, the fifth undesignated paragraph as added by chapter 49 of the laws of 1999 and the closing paragraph as added by chapter 392 of the laws of 2008, is amended to read as follows:

§ 11. Alternative remedy. 1. The liability of an employer prescribed by the last preceding section shall be exclusive and in place of any other liability whatsoever, to such employee, his or her personal representatives, spouse, parents, dependents, distributees, or any person otherwise entitled to recover damages, contribution or indemnity, at common law or otherwise, on account of such injury or death or liability arising therefrom, except that if an employer fails to secure the payment of compensation for his or her injured employees and their dependents as provided in section fifty of this chapter, an injured employee, or his or her legal representative in case of death results from the injury, may, at his or her option, elect to claim compensation

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15789-01-2

under this chapter, or to maintain an action in the courts for damages on account of such injury; and in such an action it shall not be necessary to plead or prove freedom from contributory negligence nor may the defendant plead as a defense that the injury was caused by the negligence of a fellow servant nor that the employee assumed the risk of his or her employment, nor that the injury was due to the contributory negligence of the employee. The liability under this chapter of The New York Jockey Injury Compensation Fund, Inc. created under section two hundred twenty-one of the racing, pari-mutuel wagering and breeding law shall be limited to the provision of workers' compensation coverage to jockeys, apprentice jockeys, exercise persons, and at the election of the New York Jockey Injury Compensation Fund, Inc., with the approval of the New York state gaming commission, employees of licensed trainers or owners licensed under article two or four of the racing, pari-mutuel wagering and breeding law and any statutory penalties resulting from the failure to provide such coverage.

For purposes of this section the terms "indemnity" and "contribution" shall not include a claim or cause of action for contribution or indemnification based upon a provision in a written contract entered into prior to the accident or occurrence by which the employer had expressly agreed to contribution to or indemnification of the claimant or person asserting the cause of action for the type of loss suffered.

An employer shall not be liable for contribution or indemnity to any third person based upon liability for injuries sustained by an employee acting within the scope of his or her employment for such employer unless such third person proves through competent medical evidence that such employee has sustained a "grave injury" which shall mean only one or more of the following: death, permanent and total loss of use or amputation of an arm, leg, hand or foot, loss of multiple fingers, loss of multiple toes, paraplegia or quadriplegia, total and permanent blindness, total and permanent deafness, loss of nose, loss of ear, permanent and severe facial disfigurement, loss of an index finger or an acquired injury to the brain caused by an external physical force resulting in permanent total disability.

For purposes of this section "person" means any individual, firm, company, partnership, corporation, joint venture, joint-stock association, association, trust or legal entity.

The liability under this chapter of the New York black car operators' injury compensation fund, inc. shall be limited to: (i) securing the payment of workers' compensation in accordance with article six-F of the executive law to black car operators, as defined in such article, whose injury arose out of and in the course of providing services for a central dispatch facility, as defined in such article, that is a registered member of such fund, and (ii) any statutory penalty resulting from the failure to secure such payment. The liability under this chapter of a central dispatch facility, as defined in article six-F of the executive law, that is a registered member of the New York black car operators' injury compensation fund, inc. that shall be limited to remaining a registered member in good standing of such fund and any statutory penalty, including loss of immunity provided by this section, resulting from the failure to become or remain a registered member in good standing of such fund, except, however, that such central dispatch facility shall be subject to the provisions of section one hundred thirty-one of this chapter and shall be liable for any payments for which it may become responsible pursuant to such section or pursuant to section fourteen-a of this [chapter] article.

The liability under this chapter of the New York independent livery driver benefit fund, inc. shall be limited to: (i) securing the payment of workers' compensation coverage to cover those matters required by article six-G of the executive law for independent livery drivers, as defined in such article, whose injury arose out of and in the course of providing covered services for a livery base, as defined in such article, that is a registered member of such fund, and (ii) any statutory penalty resulting from the failure to secure such payment.

2. Determination by the board shall not be given collateral estoppel effect in any other action or proceeding arising out of the same occurrence, other than the determination of the existence of an employer employee relationship.

§ 4. This act shall take effect immediately.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the workers' compensation law, in relation to enacting the justice for injured workers act

Purpose or general idea of bill

To correct recent court decisions that granted preclusive effect to decisions of the Workers' Compensation Board (WCB), barring injured workers from seeking justice through the courts because of an adminis- trative decision of the WCB.

Summary of provisions

Section one of the bill provides the title of the Justice for Injured Workers Act.

Read the full memo (721 words)

Section two of the bill adds a new section 118-a to the Workers' Compen- sation Law that would bar a court or other forum from granting preclu- sive or collateral estoppel effect to decisions by the Workers' Compen- sation Board in any other action or proceeding.

Section three of the bill adds a new paragraph (b) to section 11 of the Workers' Compensation Law that would bar a court or other forum from granting preclusive or collateral estoppel effect to decisions by the Workers' Compensation Board in any other action or proceeding.

Section four of the bill sets the effective date.

Justification

The Justice for Injured Workers Act ("JIWA") will bar determinations made in Worker Compensation proceedings from having preclusive effect in trials by a worker whose injuries are caused by negligence or wrongful conduct of third parties (i.e. parties other than the worker's employ- er.)

Over 100 years ago, New York enacted a Worker's Compensation hearing System with a "grand bargain" to address the plague of on-the-job inju- ries suffered by workers. The bargain: workers surrendered their consti- tutional rights to sue their employer for causing workplace injuries and, in exchange, employers provided insurance that guaranteed medical care and cash benefits for such injuries, regardless of fault.

To ensure that this "no fault" system provided quick and consistent benefits, disputes between an employer and an employee to the existence or extent of an alleged workplace injury are resolved in lightning-fast administrative hearings before a Worker's Compensation Law Judge ("WCLJ"). These hearings sacrifice basic procedures and evidentiary rules of trials to swiftly decide the claims. The hearings do not address fault; do not allow the parties to take depositions; do not provide a way to compel witnesses to testify; do not allow for exchanges of documents before a hearing; do not afford workers the right to order medical tests or elicit testimony from physicians; and do not give credence to injured workers' descriptions of their alleged injuries. Hearsay is allowed as evidence, and witnesses have strict time limits in which to provide testimony. Worker's Compensation hearings often consist of a cursory examination of medical records, and they do not consist of a searching review for truth, which occurs in a jury trial.

This is why, for almost 80 years, when an injured worker filed a "third- party action" against someone other than the employer for wrongfully causing a workplace injury, courts rejected attempts by defendants to apply collateral estoppel. Courts refused to use, as purportedly conclu- sive "facts" for purposes of the third-party litigation, the "findings" from Worker's Compensation hearings. But in 1989, this all changed. The New York Appellate Division for the Second Department held that a Work- er's Compensation hearing determination collaterally estopped the worker from pursuing a subsequent action against a non-employer third-party and dismissed the action. In the wake of this decision, other New York courts began to apply the collateral estoppel doctrine to findings by WCLJs to dismiss third-party actions. Workers suffered.

In 2013, the New York Court of Appeals held that the collateral estoppel doctrine was being used to deny an injured worker his right to a fair trial. This ruling, in Auqui v Seven Thirty One Ltd. Partnership, 22 NY3d 246, 255-57 (2013), reinforced the concept that the party responsi- ble for causing an injured worker's injuries remains obligated to pay for lost wages and medical expenses.

Unfortunately, Auqui left open the possibility that courts could apply the collateral estoppel doctrine to a prior Worker's Compensation deci- sion and deny injured workers the right to have a jury rule on their claims.

This legislation is needed to ensure that findings from cursory Worker's Compensation Board hearings do not prevent workers from exercising their constitutional right to a jury trial.

Prior legislative history

None

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

Immediate

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.