Skip to content
S9219Senate2021-2022 Session

Reform Medical Malpractice Damages

Official title

“Relates to economic loss”

Sponsor Jeremy CooneySD-56Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Judiciary
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill revises procedures and requirements for medical, dental, and podiatric malpractice lawsuits, including stricter affidavit of merit rules and limits on recoverable health care costs.

Why it matters

  1. Tightens requirements for filing malpractice lawsuits. by mandating that an affidavit of merit be signed by a qualified healthcare professional (not just the plaintiff's attorney), with specific, detailed statements about the standard of care, the breach, and causation for each named defendant—making it harder to initiate weak or speculative claims.

  2. Introduces automatic dismissal with prejudice. for lawsuits that fail to file these new, stricter affidavits of merit, increasing the risk for plaintiffs and potentially reducing the number of non-meritorious malpractice claims.

  3. Limits recoverable health care costs. in malpractice suits by tying them to Medicaid reimbursement rates or 100% of “usual and customary” private rates, which could substantially lower the amount plaintiffs can receive for future health care expenses—potentially affecting compensation for seriously injured patients.

  4. Expands and accelerates expert witness disclosure and depositions. by requiring earlier, more detailed identification of expert witnesses and mandating that all sides produce experts for depositions before trial, or risk losing the right to present expert testimony—making litigation more predictable for defendants but possibly more challenging and expensive for plaintiffs.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Personal injury plaintiffs and defendants

    The bill would extend the limit on qualifying defendants’ liability to economic losses, including care costs and lost earnings, when their assigned share of fault is 50 percent or less.

  • Medical, dental and podiatric malpractice plaintiffs

    The bill would require defendant-specific expert affidavits of merit, including for plaintiffs without lawyers, and require dismissal with prejudice on a defendant’s motion for failure to meet the affidavit requirement.

  • Malpractice attorneys and expert witnesses

    The bill would require disclosure of expert identities and allow parties to compel expert depositions, with the requesting party paying a reasonable fee.

  • Malpractice claimants, health care providers and the Department of Health

    The bill would calculate health care damages using usual and customary rates for private physician practices and Medicaid reimbursement rates for other services, with the health commissioner defining rates where specified.

Headline styles

Reform Medical Malpractice Damages

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Jeremy Cooney

Senator · Senate District 56

Chair, Cities 2

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to judiciary

Full text

5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9219

IN SENATE

May 12, 2022

Introduced by Sen. COONEY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to "economic loss" and damages for health care costs in actions for medical, dental or podiatric malpractice

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 1600 of the civil practice law and rules, as added by chapter 682 of the laws of 1986, is amended to read as follows:

§ 1600. Definitions. 1. As used in this article the term "non-economic loss" includes but is not limited to pain and suffering, mental anguish, loss of consortium or other damages for non-economic loss.

2. As used in this article, the term "economic loss" includes but is not limited to the cost of medical care, dental care, custodial care, rehabilitation services, loss of earnings, or other similar damages for economic loss.

§ 2. Subdivision 1 of section 1601 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 635 of the laws of 1996, is amended to read as follows:

1. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, when a verdict or decision in an action or claim for personal injury is determined in favor of a claimant in an action involving two or more tortfeasors jointly liable or in a claim against the state and the liability of a defendant is found to be fifty percent or less of the total liability assigned to all persons liable, the liability of such defendant to the claimant for non-economic loss and economic loss shall not exceed that defendant's equitable share determined in accordance with the relative culpability of each person causing or contributing to the total liability for non-economic loss and economic loss; provided, however that the culpable conduct of any person not a party to the action shall not be considered in determining any equitable share herein if the claimant proves that with due diligence he or she was unable to obtain jurisdiction over such person in said action (or in a claim against the state, in a court of this state); and further provided that the culpable conduct of any

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15807-02-2

person shall not be considered in determining any equitable share herein to the extent that action against such person is barred because the claimant has not sustained a "grave injury" as defined in section eleven of the workers' compensation law.

§ 3. Section 3012-a of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 507 of the laws of 1987, is amended to read as follows:

§ 3012-a. [Certificate] Affidavit of merit in medical, dental and podiatric malpractice actions. (a) In any action for medical, dental or podiatric malpractice, the complaint shall be accompanied by [a certificate, executed by the attorney for the plaintiff, declaring] an affidavit of merit executed by a healthcare professional who the plaintiff's attorney or, the plaintiff if not represented by an attorney, reasonably believes is knowledgeable in the relevant issues involved in the particular action to be an expert physician in a medical malpractice action, an expert dentist in a dental malpractice action or an expert podiatrist in a podiatric malpractice action, stating that[:

(1) the attorney has reviewed the facts of the case and has consulted with at least one physician in medical malpractice actions, at least one dentist in dental malpractice actions or at least one podiatrist in podiatric malpractice actions who is licensed to practice in this state or any other state and who the attorney reasonably believes is knowledgeable in the relevant issues involved in the particular action, and that the attorney has concluded on the basis of such review and consultation that there is a reasonable basis for the commencement of such action; or

(2) the attorney was unable to obtain the consultation required by paragraph one of this subdivision because a limitation of time, established by article two of this chapter, would bar the action and that the certificate required by paragraph one of this subdivision could not reasonably be obtained before such time expired. If a certificate is executed pursuant to this subdivision, the certificate required by this section shall be filed within ninety days after service of the complaint; or

(3) the attorney was unable to obtain the consultation required by paragraph one of this subdivision because the attorney had made three separate good faith attempts with three separate physicians, dentists or podiatrists, in accordance with the provisions of paragraph one of this subdivision to obtain such consultation and none of those contacted would agree to such a consultation] the physician in a medical malpractice action, or the dentist in a dental malpractice action, or the podiatrist in a podiatric malpractice action has reviewed the complaint in the malpractice action and all medical records supplied by the plaintiff's attorney, or plaintiff if not represented by an attorney, and states each of the following with individual particularization to the specifically named defendant or defendants:

(1) The applicable standard of practice or care concerning the allegations contained in the complaint.

(2) The applicable standard of practice or care breached.

(3) The actions that should have been taken or omitted in order to have complied with the applicable standard of care.

(4) The manner in which the breach of the standard of practice or care was the proximate cause of the plaintiff's injury.

(b) [Where a certificate is required pursuant to this section, a single certificate shall be filed for each action, even if more than one defendant has been named in the complaint or is subsequently named] Where an affidavit of merit is required pursuant to this section, an individual affidavit shall be filed for each named defendant who is a physician, dentist or podiatrist named in the complaint.

(c) Where the attorney intends to rely solely on the doctrine of "res ipsa loquitur", this section shall be inapplicable. In such cases, the complaint shall be accompanied by [a certificate] an affidavit, executed by the attorney, declaring that the attorney is solely relying on such doctrine and, for that reason, is not filing [a certificate] the affidavit of merit required by this section.

(d) [If a request by the plaintiff for the records of the plaintiff's medical or dental treatment by the defendants has been made and such records have not been produced, the plaintiff shall not be required to serve the certificate required by this section until ninety days after such records have been produced] The plaintiff may, in lieu of serving the affidavit of merit required by this section, provide the defendant or defendants with the information required by paragraph one of subdivision (d) of section thirty-one hundred one of this chapter within the period of time prescribed by this section, provided that the disclosure be executed by the physician in a medical malpractice action, or the dentist in a dental malpractice action, or the podiatrist in a podiatric malpractice action who has reviewed the complaint in the malpractice action and all medical records supplied by the plaintiff's attorney.

(e) [For purposes of this section, and subject to the provisions of section thirty-one hundred one of this chapter, an attorney who submits a certificate as required by paragraph one or two of subdivision (a) of this section and the physician, dentist or podiatrist with whom the attorney consulted shall not be required to disclose the identity of the physician, dentist or podiatrist consulted and the contents of such consultation; provided, however, that when the attorney makes a claim under paragraph three of subdivision (a) of this section that he was unable to obtain the required consultation with the physician, dentist or podiatrist, the court may, upon the request of a defendant made prior to compliance by the plaintiff with the provisions of section thirty-one hundred of this chapter, require the attorney to divulge to the court the names of physicians, dentists or podiatrists refusing such consultation] The plaintiff's attorney or, the plaintiff if not represented by an attorney, may with good cause shown, file a motion to extend the period of time to file the required affidavit of merit. The motion shall be filed together with the complaint. The court may grant reasonable time to file the affidavit of merit, not to exceed ninety days, except the time may be extended beyond ninety days if the court determines that a defendant or non-party has failed to cooperate with access to medical or dental records necessary for the affidavit of merit or that other circumstances warrant extension of time.

(f) [The provisions of this section shall not be applicable to a plaintiff who is not represented by an attorney.

(g) The plaintiff may, in lieu of serving the certificate required by this section, provide the defendant or defendants with the information required by paragraph one of subdivision (d) of section thirty-one hundred one of this chapter within the period of time prescribed by this section] Any complaint alleging medical, dental, or podiatric malpractice that is not accompanied by an affidavit of merit as required by this section shall be deemed defective as a matter of law and, upon motion by the defendant, be dismissed on the merits by the court. Such dismissal shall be with prejudice.

§ 4. Paragraphs 3 and 4 of subdivision (a) of section 3101 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 98 of the laws of 1993, are amended and a new paragraph 5 is added to read as follows:

(3) a person about to depart from the state, or without the state, or residing at a greater distance from the place of trial than one hundred miles, or so sick or infirm as to afford reasonable grounds of belief that he or she will not be able to attend the trial, or a person authorized to practice medicine, dentistry or podiatry who has provided medical, dental or podiatric care or diagnosis to the party demanding disclosure, or who has been retained by such party as an expert witness; [and]

(4) any other person, upon notice stating the circumstances or reasons such disclosure is sought or required[.]; and

(5) notwithstanding any provision of subparagraph (i) of paragraph one of subdivision (d) of this section to the contrary, in an action for medical, dental or podiatric malpractice, each party shall serve the disclosure described in such subparagraph within sixty days preceding the filing required by rule thirty-four hundred two of this chapter. Further, at any time after joinder of issue, any party may, by written notice made to and served upon all other parties and filed with the court; conduct an examination upon oral deposition of any person who has been disclosed as an expert witness by any other party. Each party shall be required to produce his or her expert witness for examination upon oral deposition upon receipt of a notice to take oral deposition in accordance with rule thirty-one hundred seven of this article and, unless otherwise ordered by the court, all expert witness depositions shall be taken before the filing required by rule thirty-four hundred two of this chapter. If any party, having received such notice, fails to make that party's expert witness available for oral deposition, that party shall be precluded from offering expert testimony at the trial of the action. For purposes of rule thirty-one hundred ten and rule thirty-one hundred seventeen of this article, an expert witness, as provided in this section, shall be considered a party. Each party seeking the deposition of an expert witness shall pay the expert a reasonable fee for the time spent at the deposition.

§ 5. Paragraph 1 of subdivision (d) of section 3101 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 184 of the laws of 1988, subparagraph (ii) as amended by chapter 165 of the laws of 1991, is amended to read as follows:

1. Experts. (i) Upon request, each party shall identify each person whom the party expects to call as an expert witness at trial and shall disclose in reasonable detail the subject matter on which each expert is expected to testify, the substance of the facts and opinions on which each expert is expected to testify, the qualifications of each expert witness and a summary of the grounds for each expert's opinion. However, where a party for good cause shown retains an expert an insufficient period of time before the commencement of trial to give appropriate notice thereof, the party shall not thereupon be precluded from introducing the expert's testimony at the trial solely on grounds of noncompliance with this paragraph. In that instance, upon motion of any party, made before or at trial, or on its own initiative, the court may make whatever order may be just. [In an action for medical, dental or podiatric malpractice, a party, in responding to a request, may omit the names of medical, dental or podiatric experts but shall be required to disclose all other information concerning such experts otherwise required by this paragraph.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to "economic loss" and damages for health care costs in actions for medical, dental or podiatric malpractice

Purpose

To makes various procedural reforms in actions for medical, dental, or podiatric malpractice

Summary of provisions

Section one amends section 1600 of the CPLR to define "economic loss."

Section two amends subdivision 1 of section 1601 of the CPLR to limit a defendant's equitable share of liability.

Section three amends section 3012-a of the CPLR to require that the affidavit of merit come from a healthcare professional that the plain- tiff or plaintiff's attorney reasonably believes is knowledgeable in the relevant issues involved in the malpractice action.

Section four amends section 3101 of the CPLR to provide a process for depositions in malpractice actions.

Section five makes corresponding changes to reflect section four.

Section six limits health care costs to the usual and customary rates of the type of services.

Section seven establishes the effective date.

Justification

As an historical matter, the cost of medical malpractice liability insurance coverage in the state of New York has increased steadily for several decades with occasional leveling off but always short-lived with subsequent sharp increases following. For example, medical malpractice liability insurance costs increased between 55-80% during the years of 2003 to 2008 with an additional increase of 5% in July 2010. Such unsus- tainable cost increases not only threatens access to care for patients, it also has driven up the cost of health care for the public. Notably, former Lieutenant Governor Richard Ravitch highlighted in a September 2010 report the need for medical liability reform as one necessary component to reduce New York's extraordinary Medicaid cost burden. Several studies over the years have detailed the billions of dollars in health care costs that are unnecessarily spent each year due to the practice of "defensive medicine", such as unnecessary MRIs, CT scans and specialty referrals.

More recently, New York's medical malpractice liability insurance payouts, which are an excellent measure of the overall cost of the New York medical malpractice system, have routinely lead the nation by a large amount. According to Diederich Healthcare's report "2020 Medical Malpractice Payout Analysis", New York was the clear leader in medical malpractice payouts in 2019 with a total of $661,703,250 in payments. New York was also second in the nation on a per capita basis, with a per capita amount of $34.01. The second highest state, Pennsylvania, had a payout total that was over $260 million less than New York.

These enormous costs are driven by an unpredictable medical liability adjudication system that numerous studies have concluded results in cases where awards are made despite the absence of any negligence what- soever. While an overwhelming majority of medical liability cases brought result in no payment, even the costs of defending these cases are extensive and significantly add to the astronomical cost of medical professional liability insurance. This bill, by making various common sense reforms to malpractice proceedings, seeks to both create a more level playing field between the parties as well as bring the costs of these adjudications down.

Legislative history

New bill

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall become a law and shall apply to all actions and proceedings commenced on or after such date; provided, however, that sections four and five of this act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.