Skip to content
S9225Senate2021-2022 Session

Promote Racial Equity in Schools

Official title

“Relates to enacting the public education racial equity and diversity act”

Sponsor Leroy ComrieSD-14+2 co-sponsorsAffects Education
Status
In Senate Committee
Education
Impact
9/10
Transformational
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Education

What's happening

This bill, the "public education racial equity and diversity act," expands charter school authorizations, creates a new charter school commission prioritizing minority-led schools, eases teacher certifications for minorities, boosts teacher loan forgiveness, and provides state income tax exemptions for minority teachers in high-need schools.

Why it matters

  1. Shifts charter school growth and oversight power toward minority leadership. By reserving hundreds of new charter school slots for organizations led by ethnic minorities and creating a new, independent Charter School Commission with mandated minority representation, the bill aims to reshape who gets to open and run new schools, potentially changing the educational landscape and who holds institutional power.

  2. Introduces alternative teacher certification pathways tailored for minorities. The bill allows schools to develop their own rigorous instructional programs for certifying minority teachers, bypassing some traditional state requirements if approved. This could lower entry barriers for minority educators, address teacher shortages, and diversify school staff, but also raises questions about consistency and oversight in teacher quality.

  3. Expands financial incentives for minority teachers in high-need areas. By doubling loan forgiveness maximums and making minority teachers in “significantly high-need” schools eligible for full state income tax exemption, the bill seeks to aggressively recruit and retain teachers from underrepresented backgrounds in schools that most need them, which could impact student outcomes and school culture.

  4. Raises issues of accountability, equity, and precedent. The bill creates new systems for tracking, evaluating, and revoking alternative certification programs, while making it explicit that these new pathways are not universally transferable. This establishes a novel, parallel structure within public education, raising questions about long-term impacts on teacher pipelines, educational equity, and the relationship between traditional and charter schools.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Minority-led community organizations seeking charters

    The bill would raise the statewide charter cap to 796 and reserve 336 charters for schools whose boards and school-based leadership teams each have at least 51% minority membership.

  • Minority teachers and teacher candidates

    The bill would create an alternative certification pathway, expand loan-forgiveness eligibility and exempt qualifying minority teachers in significantly high-need schools from state income and local taxes.

  • Charter school operators

    A new independent state charter school commission could hear appeals of charter denials, revocations and nonrenewals and become the schools’ authorizer after reversing those decisions.

  • Teachers with student loan debt

    The bill would double the maximum loan-forgiveness award from $5,000 to $10,000 and remove the $20,000 cumulative award cap, subject to available funding and remaining debt.

Headline styles

Promote Racial Equity in Schools

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Leroy Comrie

Senator · Senate District 14

Chair, Corporations, Authorities And Commissions

History

  1. Referred to education

Full text

13 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9225

IN SENATE

May 12, 2022

Introduced by Sen. COMRIE -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Education

AN ACT to amend the education law and the tax law, in relation to enacting the public education racial equity and diversity act

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "public education racial equity and diversity act".

§ 2. Subdivision 6, paragraph (a) of subdivision 7, the opening paragraph and paragraph (a) of subdivision 9, paragraph (a), the opening paragraph of paragraph (b) and subparagraph (viii) of paragraph (c) of subdivision 9-a of section 2852 of the education law, subdivision 6 as added by chapter 4 of the laws of 1998, paragraph (a) of subdivision 7 as amended by section 2 of part D2 of chapter 57 of the laws of 2007, the opening paragraph and paragraph (a) of subdivision 9 and paragraph (a), the opening paragraph of paragraph (b) and subparagraph (viii) of paragraph (c) of subdivision 9-a as amended by section 2 of subpart A of part B of chapter 20 of the laws of 2015, are amended and a new subdivision 11 is added to read as follows:

6. The denial of an application, or the denial of a request for revision to an application, for a charter school by a charter entity shall be in writing and shall state the reasons for the denial. Notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, such denial is final and shall not be reviewable in any court or by any administrative body with the exception of the New York state charter school commission established pursuant to the provisions of subdivision eleven of this section.

(a) A revision of a charter shall be made only upon the approval of the charter entity and the board of regents in accordance with the provisions of subdivisions five-a and five-b of this section, or as authorized under subdivision eleven of this section.

The total number of charters issued pursuant to this article statewide shall not exceed [four] seven hundred [sixty] ninety-six. (a) All charters issued on or after July first, two thousand fifteen and counted

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD14934-01-2

toward the numerical limits established by this subdivision shall be issued by the board of regents upon application directly to the board of regents or on the recommendation of the board of trustees of the state university of New York pursuant to a competitive process in accordance with subdivision nine-a of this section. Fifty of such charters issued [on or after] between July first, two thousand fifteen and July first, two thousand twenty-two, and no more, shall be granted to a charter for a school to be located in a city having a population of one million or more. To promote equity and diversity in educational leadership and prioritize the issuance of new charters to community-based organizations run by individuals from historically underrepresented communities, three hundred thirty-six of such charters issued on or after July first, two thousand twenty-two, and no more, shall be granted to a charter for a school to be managed by a board of trustees and school-based management or leadership team, where both of which will be comprised of at least fifty-one percent of members who meet the ethnic definition of minority group member set forth in article fifteen-A of the executive law. The failure of any body to issue the regulations authorized pursuant to this article shall not affect the authority of a charter entity to propose a charter to the board of regents or the board of regents' authority to grant such charter. A conversion of an existing public school to a charter school, or the renewal or extension of a charter approved by any charter entity, shall not be counted toward the numerical limits established by this subdivision.

(a) The board of regents is hereby authorized and directed to issue [four] seven hundred [sixty] ninety-six charters statewide upon either applications submitted directly to the board of regents or upon the recommendation of the board of trustees of the state university of New York pursuant to a competitive request for proposals process.

The board of regents shall make a determination to issue a charter pursuant to a request for proposals no later than December thirty-first of each year.

The board of regents and the board of trustees of the state university of New York shall each develop such request for proposals in a manner that facilitates a thoughtful review of charter school applications, considers the demand for charter schools by the community, promotes equity and diversity in educational leadership, and seeks to locate charter schools in a region or regions where there may be a lack of alternatives and access to charter schools would provide new alternatives within the local public education system that would offer the greatest educational benefit to students. Applications shall be evaluated in accordance with the criteria and objectives contained within a request for proposals. The board of regents and the board of trustees of the state university of New York shall not consider any applications which do not rigorously demonstrate that they have met the following criteria:

(viii) promoting diversity in educational leadership and increasing the number of education leaders from historically underrepresented communities by establishing a board of trustees and school-based management or leadership team of at least fifty-one percent of members who meet the ethnic definition of minority group member set forth in article fifteen-A of the executive law;

(ix) demonstrating the support of the school district in which the proposed charter school will be located and the intent to establish an ongoing relationship with such school district.

11. (a) For the purposes of this subdivision the term "commission" shall mean the New York state charter school commission established pursuant to this subdivision. A New York state charter school commission is established as an independent commission with statewide chartering jurisdiction and authority. The commission shall only be under the authority of the board of regents for administrative purposes. The board of regents shall provide administrative support to the commission as needed and requested by the commission.

(b) The commission shall be responsible for approving charter schools statewide with a focus on approving charters to community-based organizations run by individuals from historically underrepresented communities.

(c) The commission shall consist of nine members to be comprised of three members proposed by the board of regents, three members proposed by the board of trustees of the state university of New York, and three members proposed by the governor. The board of regents shall approve these appointments subject to a majority vote of approval for each proposed appointee by the education committee for the Black, Puerto Rican and Asian legislative caucus of the New York state assembly, within sixty days after the effective date of this subdivision and sixty days prior to the expiration of the term of a member thereafter. If the board of regents, the board of trustees of the state university of New York, or the governor fails to timely propose a slate of candidates according to the provisions of this subdivision, then the education committee for Black, Puerto Rican and Asian legislative caucus of the New York state assembly shall appoint the member or members of the commission.

(d) Members appointed to the commission shall collectively possess strong experience and expertise in public and nonprofit governance, management and finance, public school leadership, higher education, assessments, curriculum and instruction, and public education law. All members of the commission shall have demonstrated understanding of and a commitment to public education, including without limitation charter schooling. At least six members shall have past experience with urban charter schools, and at least six members shall meet the ethnic definition of minority group member as defined in article fifteen-A of the executive law.

(e) To establish staggered terms of office, the initial term of office for three commission members shall be four years and thereafter shall be four years; the initial term of office for another three members shall be three years and thereafter shall be four years; and the initial term of office for the remaining three members shall be two years and thereafter shall be four years. The initial appointments shall be made no later than October first, two thousand twenty-two.

(f) Whenever a vacancy on the commission exists, the education committee for the Black, Puerto Rican and Asian legislative caucus of the New York state assembly shall appoint a member for the remaining portion of the term.

(g) The commission shall have the responsibility to review denials of applications as well as denials of requests for revisions to applications issued pursuant to subdivision six of this section upon receipt of written appeal from the denied applicant. Such responsibility takes effect immediately upon appointment of the initial members of the commission pursuant to paragraph (e) of this subdivision. Appeals pending at the time of initial appointment shall be determined by the commission. The commission may extend the time for review as necessary for thorough review, but in no case shall the extension exceed the time that would have been available had the appeal been submitted to the commission on the date of appointment of its initial members. In any appeal filed with the commission under this article, both the applicant and the charter entity that issued the denial shall have the right to request a hearing before the commission. If more than one entity requests a hearing, then the commission shall hold only one hearing, wherein the applicant and the charter entity shall have an equal opportunity to present their respective positions.

(h) Any charter school authorized by the commission shall have its authorization transferred to the commission, which shall then become the school's authorizer for all purposes under this article. Any charter school authorized by charter entities other than the commission may seek transfer of authorization to the commission during its current term with the approval of a majority of the trustees or members of the board of education for the school district in which the school is located. Notice of a charter entity's decision to deny, revoke, or not renew a charter shall be provided to the commission, as shall a charter entity's decision to deny a request for revision to an application for a charter school. Upon receipt of written appeal from the denied applicant and in accordance with paragraph (g) of this subdivision, the commission may reverse a charter entity's decision if the commission finds that the charter school, the charter school proposal, or the charter school's request for a revision to its application is (i) in compliance with this article; and (ii) in the best interests of the students it is designed to serve.

(i) Notwithstanding other provisions of this article, if the commission on appeal reverses a charter entity's decision to deny, revoke, or not renew a charter or a charter's request for revision to its application, or if a charter school successfully seeks transfer of authorization to the commission pursuant to paragraph (h) of this subdivision, the commission shall act as the authorized chartering entity for the charter school. The commission shall approve the charter or the request for revision to the charter's application and shall perform all charter entity functions set forth in this article.

§ 3. Section 679-j of the education law, as added by section 1 of part AA of chapter 56 of the laws of 2018, is amended to read as follows:

§ 679-j. The New York state teacher loan forgiveness program. 1. Purpose. The president shall grant student loan forgiveness awards for the purpose of increasing the number of teachers serving in the state, generally, and the number of teachers serving in the state who meet the ethnic definition of minority group member, specifically.

2. Eligibility. To be eligible for an award pursuant to this subdivision, applicants shall (a) be certified as a teacher; (b) be employed full time in this state in an elementary or secondary school; (c) comply with subdivisions three and five of section six hundred sixty-one of this part; (d) have an outstanding student loan debt; and (e) meet one of the following criteria:

(i) teach in a shortage subject area;

(ii) teach in a hard to staff district; [or]

(iii) the applicant is economically disadvantaged, as defined by the corporation[.]; or

(iv) the applicant meets the ethnic definition of minority group member as defined in article fifteen-A of the executive law.

3. Definitions. For the purposes of this section[,]:

(a) the term "shortage subject area" shall mean a curriculum subject matter or practice of teaching where there is a shortage of teachers in New York state, as designated by the department[, and];

(b) the term "hard to staff school districts" shall mean school districts that have a shortage of teachers, as designated by the department[.]; and

(c) the term "minority group member" shall mean a United States citizen or permanent resident alien who is and can demonstrate membership in one of the following groups:

(i) Black persons having origins in any of the Black African racial groups;

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the education law and the tax law, in relation to enact- ing the public education racial equity and diversity act

Purpose

To promote, equity and diversity in educational leadership and prior- itize the issuance of new charters to community-based organizations run by individuals from historically, underrepresented communities

Summary of provisions

Section 1 enacts the "Public Education Racial Equity and Diversity act"

Read the full memo (1,072 words)

Section 2 amends subdivision 6, paragraph (a) of subdivision 7, the opening paragraph and paragraph (a) of subdivision 9, paragraph (a), the opening 5 paragraph of paragraph (b) and subparagraph (viii) of para- graph (c) of 6. subdivision 9-a of section 2852 of the education law, subdivision 6 as 7 added by chapter 4 of the laws of 1998, paragraph (a) of subdivision 7 8 as' amended by section 2 of part D2 of chapter 57 of the laws of 2007, 9 the opening paragraph and paragraph (a) of subdivi- sion 9 and paragraph 10 (a), the opening paragraph of paragraph (b) and subparagraph (viii) of 11 paragraph (c) of subdivision 9-a as amended by section 2 of subpart A of 12 part B of chapter 20 of the laws as follows:

Adds a new subdivision subpart b of chapter 20 of the laws of 2015.for the denial of an application, request for revision to an application, or revision to a.charter school application reviewed by the New York State Charter School Commission established by subdivision eleven of this legislation.

Allocates 336 new charters to minority-led community-based organiza- tions, raising the statewide limit on charter schools from 460 to a new cap of 796.

Charter schools issued after July 1, 2022 shall be granted to a school to be managed by a board of trustees and school based management or leadership team where both of which will be comprised of at least 51 percent of members who will meet the ethnic definition of minority group. member set forth in article 15-A of the executive law.

The board of regents is authorized and directed to issue 796 charters statewide either upon applications submitted directly to board of regents or upon the recommendation of the SUNY.board of trustees pursu- ant to a competitive request for proposals.

Both above stated entities will have a legal commitment to develop requests for proposals in a manner that is consistent with state law and additionally promotes equity and diversity in educational leadership.

Subdivision 11 establishes an independent charter school commission with statewide jurisdiction and authority. The board of regents shall provide support to the commission for administrative purposes and as requested by the commission. The commission will be responsible for approving charter schools statewide with a focus on approving charters to communi- ty-based organizations run by individuals from historically underrepre- sented communities. The commission shall be comprised of three members proposed by the board of regents, three members proposed by the SUNY board of trustees, and three members proposed by the governor. The board of regents shall approve these, appointments subject to a majority vote. The board of regents shall approve these appointments subject to a majority vote of approval for each proposed appointee by the education committee for the Black, Puerto Rican and Asian legislative caucus of the New York state assembly within 60 days prior to the expiration of the term of a member thereafter. If the board of regents, board of trus- tees (SUNY), or governor fail to timely proposes a slate of candidates according to the provisions of this subdivision, then the education committee for Black, Puerto Rican and Asian legislative caucus of the New York State Assembly. shall appoint a member or members of the commission.

Two thirds of the Commission's nine members must have experience with urban charter schools, and two-thirds must be minority-group members. The mechanism presented in this legislation borrows moving pieces from Illinois legislation that enacted the Illinois State Charter School Commission

Section 3 changes section 679-j of the education law:

NYS law currently allows teachers in shortage Subject areas and hard to staff districts to apply for student loan forgiveness of up to $5,000 a year and 520,000 in total. To increase the number of teachers in New York State who meet. the definition of minority group members, the proposed legislative change adds minority teachers to the list of groups eligible for student loan forgiveness, raises the annual ceiling on loan relief to $10,000 a year, and eliminates the maximum amount of loan relief a teacher can receive.

Section-4 amends education law to add sections 3004-d, 3004-e, and 3004 f:

To help address the current shortage of teachers from historically underrepresented communities, this proposition grants both charter and district schools an alternative school-based teacher certification path- way for minority teachers. The mechanism presented this document draws from a school-based alternative certification framework proposed by SUNY in mid-2017, which allows charters to submit applications to their authorizers to run their own school-based alternative certification programs.

To address the current shortage of teachers from historically underrep- resented backgrounds in communities with the highest need, this proposi- tion would create an. 100% state and local income tax exemption for eligible minority teachers serving significantly high-need schools. The mechanism presented in this document draws from a 2019 bill to amend the tax law to exempt firefighters from income taxes and incorporates ethnic and school designations codified elsewhere in state law.

Section 5 establishes severability.

Section 6 establishes the effective date of 60 days after this bill is signed into law.

Justification

The seven legislative changes that comprise this bill (Public Education Racial Equity And Diversity Act (the "READ Act") are designed to promote equity and diversity in educational leadership, increase the number of education leaders from historically underrepresented communities, increase the number of teachers serving in the State who meet the ethnic definition of minority group members, and create the NYS Charter School Commission.

NYS law currently states that the denial of any charter application is final and cannot be appealed. This bill establishes a NYS Charter School Commission as an equity authorizer empowered to review any decision to deny, revoke, or not renew a charter. If the Commission overturns a decision, it becomes the applicant's authorizer.

These changes are necessary to foster an educational framework in New York that ensures racial equity and diversity in educational leadership.

Legislative history

This is a new bill.

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.