What's happening
This bill protects individuals and entities involved in providing or receiving reproductive health care services in New York from out-of-state legal actions and information disclosures.
Why it matters
Creates a legal pathway for New Yorkers (and others) sued in another state for providing, supporting, or receiving reproductive health care (including abortion) that is legal in New York to recover damages and legal costs from those who brought or enforced the out-of-state judgment. this discourages the use of civil lawsuits from anti-abortion states against New York providers or patients.
Prohibits New York health care providers and related entities from disclosing patient information about reproductive health care services to out-of-state parties, unless the patient specifically consents or under narrow exceptions. this protects patient privacy and shields New York medical providers from being compelled to participate in out-of-state investigations or prosecutions.
Prevents New York courts, officials, and state/local agencies from participating in or assisting with out-of-state legal actions or investigations (civil or criminal) related to reproductive health care that is lawful in New York, including the issuance of subpoenas or extradition requests, unless the underlying conduct would also be a crime in New York. this blocks the use of New York’s legal system as a tool for enforcing more restrictive abortion laws from other states.
Specifically restricts the extradition of abortion providers to other states unless it can be shown that the provider was physically present in the demanding state at the time of the alleged offense and then fled. this makes it significantly harder for other states to prosecute New York providers under their own laws for actions that are legal in New York.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Reproductive health care providers and patients
The bill would let people facing judgments over care permitted in New York seek damages and legal costs from those who brought the case or sought enforcement, subject to exceptions.
Hospitals and other covered health care entities
The bill would restrict disclosure of patient information about reproductive care permitted in New York in specified proceedings without written consent, with exceptions.
State and local agencies
The bill would bar them from using information or resources to assist interstate proceedings targeting reproductive care legal in New York, unless the conduct would also create liability under New York law.
Abortion providers facing extradition
The bill would bar the governor from recognizing an extradition demand unless the demanding state alleges in writing that the provider was present there during the alleged offense and later fled.
Headline styles
Protect Reproductive Health Providers
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
1 Co-sponsor
History
- Referred to judiciary
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Protect Reproductive Health Providers
In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Charles Lavine
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9265
IN SENATE
May 12, 2022
Introduced by Sen. KRUEGER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary
AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules and the criminal procedure law, in relation to protections for persons receiving and providing reproductive health care services and access to reproductive health care services in New York state
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. 1. As used in this act:
(a) "Reproductive health care services" includes all medical, surgical, counseling or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including, but not limited to, services relating to pregnancy, contraception or the termination of a pregnancy; and
(b) "Person" includes an individual, a partnership, an association, a limited liability company or a corporation.
2. Notwithstanding any other law or rule to the contrary, when any person has had a judgment entered against such person, in any state, where liability, in whole or in part, is based on the alleged provision, receipt, assistance in receipt or provision, material support for, or any theory of vicarious, joint, several or conspiracy liability derived therefrom, for reproductive health care services that are permitted under the laws of this state, such person may recover damages from any party that brought the action leading to that judgment or has sought to enforce that judgment. Recoverable damages shall include: (a) Just damages created by the action that led to that judgment, including, but not limited to, money damages in the amount of the judgment in that other state and costs, expenses and reasonable attorney's fees spent in defending the action that resulted in the entry of a judgment in another state; and (b) costs, expenses and reasonable attorney's fees incurred in bringing an action under this section as may be allowed by the court.
3. The provisions of this section shall not apply to a judgment entered in another state that is based on: (a) an action founded in tort, contract or statute, and for which a similar claim would exist under the laws of this state, brought by the patient who received the
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD15729-01-2
reproductive health care services upon which the original lawsuit was based or the patient's authorized legal representative, for damages suffered by the patient or damages derived from an individual's loss of consortium of the patient; (b) an action founded in contract, and for which a similar claim would exist under the laws of this state, brought or sought to be enforced by a party with a contractual relationship with the person that is the subject of the judgment entered in another state; or (c) an action where no part of the acts that formed the basis for liability occurred in this state.
§ 2. 1. Except as provided in subdivision two of this section, in any civil action or any proceeding preliminary thereto or in any probate, legislative or administrative proceeding, no covered entity, as defined in 45 CFR 160.103, shall disclose (a) any communication made to such covered entity, or any information obtained by such covered entity from, a patient or the conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative of a patient relating to reproductive health care services, as defined in section one of this act, that are permitted under the laws of this state, or (b) any information obtained by personal examination of a patient relating to reproductive health care services, as defined in section one of this act, that are permitted under the laws of this state, unless the patient or that patient's conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative explicitly consents in writing to such disclosure. A covered entity shall inform the patient or the patient's conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative of the patient's right to withhold such written consent.
2. Written consent of the patient or the patient's conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative shall not be required for the disclosure of such communication or information (a) pursuant to the laws of this state or the rules of court prescribed by the chief administrator of the courts, (b) by a covered entity against whom a claim has been made, or there is a reasonable belief will be made, in such action or proceeding, to the covered entity's attorney or professional liability insurer or such insurer's agent for use in the defense of such action or proceeding, (c) to the commissioner of health for records of a patient of a covered entity in connection with an investigation of a complaint, if such records are related to the complaint, or (d) if child abuse, abuse of an elderly individual, abuse of an individual who is physically disabled or incompetent or abuse of an individual with intellectual disability is known or in good faith suspected.
3. Nothing in this section shall be construed to impede the lawful sharing of medical records as permitted by state or federal law or the rules of the court prescribed by the chief administrator of the courts, except in the case of a subpoena commanding the production, copying or inspection of medical records relating to reproductive health care services, as defined in section one of this act.
§ 3. Notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary, a judge, justice of the peace, notary public or court clerk shall not issue a subpoena, appointed according to the laws or usages of any other state or government, or by any court of the United States or of any other state or government, when such subpoena relates to reproductive health care services, as defined in section one of this act, that are permitted under the laws of this state, unless the subpoena relates to: (a) an out-of-state action founded in tort, contract or statute, for which a similar claim would exist under the laws of this state, brought by a patient or the patient's authorized legal representative, for damages suffered by the patient or damages derived from an individual's loss of consortium of the patient; or (b) an out-of-state action founded in contract, and for which a similar claim would exist under the laws of this state, brought or sought to be enforced by a party with a contractual relationship with the person that is the subject of the subpoena requested by a commissioner appointed according to the laws or usages of another state.
§ 4. No state or local department, division, office, bureau or public authority, or any employee, appointee, officer or official or any other person acting on behalf thereof, may provide any information or expend or use time, money, facilities, property, equipment, personnel or other resources in furtherance of any interstate investigation or proceeding seeking to impose civil or criminal liability upon a person or entity for (a) the provision, seeking or receipt of or inquiring about reproductive health care services, as defined in section one of this act, that are legal in this state, or (b) assisting any person or entity providing, seeking, receiving or responding to an inquiry about reproductive health care services, as defined in section one of this act, that are legal in this state. This section shall not apply to any investigation or proceeding where the conduct subject to potential liability under the investigation or proceeding would be subject to liability under the laws of this state if committed in this state.
§ 5. Section 3119 of the civil practice law and rules is amended by adding a new subdivision (g) to read as follows:
(g) Out-of-state abortion proceedings. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this section or any other law, no court or county clerk shall issue a subpoena or a summons in a case where prosecution is pending, or where a grand jury investigation has commenced or is about to commence for a criminal violation of a law of such other state involving the provision or receipt of or assistance with reproductive health care services that are legal in this state, unless the acts forming the basis of the prosecution or investigation would also constitute an offense in this state. For the purposes of this subdivision, "reproductive health care services" means and includes all medical, surgical, counseling or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including, but not limited to, services relating to pregnancy, contraception or the termination of a pregnancy.
§ 6. The criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new section 570.17 to read as follows: § 570.17 Extradition of abortion providers.
No demand for the extradition of a person charged with providing an abortion shall be recognized by the governor unless the executive authority of the demanding state shall allege in writing that the accused was present in the demanding state at the time of the commission of the alleged offense, and that thereafter he, she or they fled from that state.
§ 7. This act shall take effect immediately.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the civil practice law and rules and the criminal proce- dure law, in relation to protections for persons receiving and providing reproductive health care services and access to reproductive health care services in New York state
Purpose
To protect persons receiving and providing reproductive health care services in New York state.
Summary of provisions
Section 1. 1. Defines (a) "Reproductive health care services" to include all medical, surgical, counseling or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including, but not limited to, services relating to pregnancy, contraception or the termination of a pregnancy (b) "Person" includes an individual, a partnership, an association, a limited liability company or a corporation.
Read the full memo (1,479 words)
2. When any person has had a judgment entered against such person, in any state, where liability, in whole or in part, is based on the alleged provision, receipt, assistance in receipt or provision, material support for, or any theory of vicarious, joint, several or conspiracy liability for reproductive health care services that are permitted under the laws of this state, such person may recover damages from any party that brought the action leading to that judgment or has sought to enforce that judgment. Recoverable damages shall include:
(a) Just damages created by the action that led to that judgment, including, but not limited to, money damages in the amount of the judg- ment in that other state and costs, expenses and reasonable attorney's fees spent in defending the action that resulted in the entry of a judg- ment in another state
(b) Costs, expenses and reasonable attorney's fees incurred in bringing an action under this section as may be allowed by the court.
3. The provisions of this section shall not apply to a judgment entered in another state that is based on:
(a) an action founded in tort, contract or statute, and for which a similar claim would exist under the laws of this state, brought by the patient who received the reproductive health care services which the original lawsuit was based or the patient's authorized legal represen- tative, for damages suffered by the patient or damages derived from an individual's loss of consortium of the patient
(b) an action founded in contract, and for which a similar claim would exist under the laws of this state, brought or sought to be enforced by a party with a contractual relationship with the person that is the subject of the judgment entered in another state
(c) an action where no part of the acts that formed the basis for liability occurred in this state. Section 2. 1. Except as provided in subdivision two of this section, in any civil action or any proceeding preliminary thereto or in any probate, legislative or administrative proceeding, no covered entity, as defined in 45 CFR 160.103, shall disclose:
(a) any communication made to such covered entity, or any information obtained by such covered entity from, a patient or the conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative of a patient relating to reproductive health care services that are permitted under the laws of this state.
(b) any information obtained by personal examination of a patient relat- ing to reproductive health care services that are permitted under the laws of this state unless the patient or that patient's conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative explicitly consents in writing to such disclosure.
2. Written consent of the patient or the patient's conservator, guardian or other authorized legal representative shall not be required for the disclosure of such communication or information
(a) pursuant to the laws of this state or the rules of court prescribed by the chief administrator of the courts
(b) by a covered entity against whom a claim has been made, or there is a reasonable belief will be made, in such action or proceeding, to the covered entity's attorney or professional liability insurer or such insurer's agent for use in the defense of such action or proceeding.
(c) to the commissioner of health for records of a patient of a covered entity in connection with an investigation of a complaint, if such records are related to the complaint.
(d) if child abuse, abuse of an elderly individual, abuse of an individ- ual who is physically disabled or incompetent or abuse of an individual with intellectual disability is known or in good faith suspected.
3. Nothing in this section shall be construed to impede the lawful shar- ing of medical records as permitted by state or federal law or the rules of the court prescribed by the chief administrator of the courts, except in the case of a subpoena commanding the production, copying or inspection of medical records relating to reproductive health care services.
Section 3. A judge, justice of the peace, notary public or court clerk shall not issue a subpoena, appointed according to the laws or usages of any other state or government, or by any court of the United States or of any other state or government, when such subpoena relates to repro- ductive health care services. Outlines exceptions to issuing subpoenas.
Section 4. No state or local department, division, office, bureau or public authority, or any employee, appointee, officer or official or any other person acting on behalf thereof, may provide any information or expend or use time, money, facilities, property, equipment, personnel or other resources in furtherance of any interstate investigation or proceeding seeking to impose civil or criminal liability upon a person or entity
Section 5. Section 3119 of the civil practice law and rules is amended to add new subdivision (g) Out of state abortion proceedings. no court or county clerk shall issue a subpoena or a summons in a case where prosecution is pending, or where a grand jury investigation has commenced or is about to commence for a criminal violation of a law of such other state involving the provision or receipt of or assistance with reproductive health care services that are legal in this state, unless the acts forming the basis of the prosecution or investigation would also constitute an offense in this state.
Section 6. Amends the criminal procedure law adding new section 570.17 Extradition of abortion providers. No demand for the extradition of a person charged with providing an abortion shall be recognized by the governor unless the executive authority of the demanding state shall allege in writing that the accused was present in the demanding state at the time of the commission of the alleged offense, and that thereafter he, she or they fled from that state.
Section 7. Effective date.
Justification
The U.S. Supreme Court is expected to decide by June whether to overturn its 1973 Roe v. Wade decision legalizing abortion. Currently, 23 states have laws that could be used to restrict the legal status of abortion. This bill will protect medical providers and patients seeking abortion care in New York who may be traveling from other states that have outlawed abortion.
This legislation aims to combat strict abortion laws in other states by allowing people who face legal liability for violating other states' abortion laws to sue for damages in New York courts. Last year Texas passed a law that allows any individual to sue anyone who knowingly performs or aids in an abortion after a fetal heartbeat has been detected, removing the responsibility of enforcement from the state's executive branch and placing it into the hands of citizens. Plaintiffs can earn up to $10,000 in damages through litigation.
Anyone from out of state who is sued for having aided and abetted an abortion, such as the parent or guardian who goes with the patient to New York for the procedure, can legally fight back. This means that a mother who is sued for taking her daughter out of state for an abortion can countersue, collecting damages and attorneys' fees, including those spent defending herself in her home state and the fees spent on bringing suit in New York. The bill would also allow the state to protect the medical records of women who travel to the state for an abortion.
This bill would bar New York state courts or county clerks from issuing subpeonas and from enforcing penalties set by courts in other states with the civil enforcement mechanism in place, providing anyone who performed or facilitated an abortion in New York with legal protections. Under current law, if an abortion provider was found guilty in Texas and ordered to pay $10,000 but flees to New York, New York would then be required to send that person back to Texas to face the consequences. Under this bill, the abortion provider would not be extradited to Texas for performing the procedure, which is legal in New York.
Legislative history
New Bill
Financial implications
To be determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.