Skip to content
S9284Senate2021-2022 Session

Improve Struggling Public Schools

Official title

“Establishes school registration and support and assistance for designated schools; repealer”

Sponsor James SkoufisSD-39+19 co-sponsorsAffects Education
Status
In Senate Committee
Education
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Education

What's happening

This bill repeals and replaces sections of education law to reform how New York identifies, supports, and intervenes in struggling public schools, establishing new processes for school registration, improvement plans, and state oversight.

Why it matters

  1. Stronger and More Transparent School Accountability. By requiring annual reviews of every public school (excluding charter schools) using both academic and non-academic measures, the bill aims to create a more nuanced and transparent system for identifying schools that need help, rather than relying solely on test scores or infrequent assessments.

  2. Community Engagement and Local Input. The legislation mandates the formation of "community engagement teams"—including parents, teachers, students, and other stakeholders—for any identified struggling school. This is designed to ensure that improvement plans reflect local needs and perspectives, and to foster buy-in from those most affected.

  3. Clearer, Tiered Intervention Pathway. The bill defines a step-by-step process for intervention, starting with improvement plans, escalating to "intensive support," and—if necessary—appointing expert educational support specialists, conducting registration reviews, and ultimately allowing for external management or school closure if improvement targets are not met. This approach is intended to provide struggling schools with multiple opportunities and tailored supports before drastic measures are taken.

  4. Limits on Unilateral Changes and Safeguards for Staff. The law protects against abrupt district decisions—like closing or restructuring a school—without state approval, and sets rules to prevent changes to staff collective bargaining agreements without union consent. This balances the need for improvement with protections for educators' rights and community stability.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Improve Struggling Public Schools

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Referred to education

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9284

IN SENATE

May 12, 2022

Introduced by Sen. SKOUFIS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Education

AN ACT to amend the education law, in relation to establishing school registration and support and assistance for designated schools; and to repeal certain sections of the education law relating thereto

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Sections 211-a, 211-b, and 211-f of the education law are REPEALED and a new section 211-a is added to read as follows:

§ 211-a. School registration and support and assistance for designated schools. 1. Registration of public schools. All public schools in the state shall be registered by the board of regents, provided, however, that charter schools shall not be subject to registration pursuant to this section, but shall be held accountable for meeting or exceeding the student performance standards and student assessment requirements applicable to other public schools in accordance with the provisions of article fifty-six of this chapter. Once registered, a school district shall not close, merge, split, change the grade configuration, or substantially change the enrollment of the registered school without the prior consent of the commissioner. The commissioner shall deny or require modifications to a request only where approving the request shall have a demonstrable and substantial negative impact on the learning environment for students.

2. Annual determination of school need for support and assistance. The commissioner shall determine annually whether each public school is in need of additional support and assistance based on multiple measures, including academic and non-academic measures, as determined by the commissioner.

3. Identification of schools for additional support and assistance. If based on the annual determination, pursuant to subdivision two of this section, the commissioner determines that a school would benefit from additional support and assistance based on academic performance and other measures, the commissioner may designate the school for additional support and assistance. Each school identified under this subdivision shall develop an improvement plan to address the identified academic performance and other measures. Such plan shall be developed in consultation with a community engagement team appointed in accordance with

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15859-01-2

subdivision thirteen of this section, in such form and in accordance with such format as may be prescribed by the commissioner, and approved by the board of education or chancellor, in a school district in a city of one million or more inhabitants, by such date as the commissioner may establish.

4. Identification of schools for intensive support and assistance. If based on the annual determination, pursuant to subdivision two of this section, a school is among those in the state as determined by the commissioner that would most benefit from intensive support and assistance, the commissioner may designate the school for intensive support and assistance. Each school identified under this subdivision shall develop an improvement plan to address the identified academic performance and other measures. Such plan shall be developed in consultation with a community engagement team appointed in accordance with subdivision thirteen of this section, in such form and in accordance with such format as may be prescribed by the commissioner, and approved by the board or education or chancellor, in a school district in a city of one million or more inhabitants, by such date as the commissioner may establish.

5. Alignment of federal and state accountability requirements. To the greatest extent practicable, the commissioner shall align the process for identification of schools for additional support and assistance and intensive support and assistance and the actions that are required to be taken as a result of such identifications with the state's plan approved by the United States secretary of education for meeting the requirements of section one thousand one hundred eleven of the elementary and secondary education act of nineteen hundred sixty-five, as amended, and the federal regulations implementing such statute.

6. Demonstrable improvement targets for selected intensive support and assistance schools. The commissioner shall assign school demonstrable improvement targets to a school that:

a. is determined by the commissioner to be farthest from state standards upon the school's initial identification for intensive support and assistance.

b. has remained identified for intensive support and assistance for three consecutive years.

7. Removal of schools from designation. The commissioner shall establish performance targets for schools identified as in need of additional support and assistance pursuant to subdivision three of this section or intensive support and assistance pursuant to subdivision four of this section. Schools that achieve their performance targets shall be removed from their designation.

8. Educational support specialist. a. If a school is unable to make demonstrable improvement, as determined by the commissioner, the commissioner may appoint an educational support specialist to provide support and assistance to the school and district in implementing the school's improvement plan. The educational support specialist shall have:

(i) either:

(A) New York state certification as a school district administrator, school district leader or a substantially equivalent certification, as determined by the commissioner, issued by a jurisdiction outside the state; or

(B) a doctorate in education, doctorate in philosophy in education or other comparable advanced degree and a minimum of five years working directly in low performing districts or dramatically raising the achievement of high needs students in moderate to high performing districts;

(ii) experience as a principal assistant superintendent, deputy superintendent, superintendent, or comparable administrator in a school district, charter school, BOCES or a nonprofit educational organization within the past three years or, where applicable, within the immediately preceding three years from the date of appointment as an educational support specialist;

(iii) demonstrated an ability to successfully work with at risk populations in closing achievement gaps; and

(iv) experience in school turnaround and sustaining the academic success of at risk students.

b. The educational support specialist shall be neither a current employee of the school district nor be permitted to do other compensated work for the school district without the approval of the commissioner. The educational support specialist shall be appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the commissioner. The commissioner shall establish the rate of compensation for the educational support specialist to be paid by the school district. Such compensation may not exceed the salary of the school district's superintendent except in extraordinary circumstances which shall be outlined by the commissioner to the board of education. The educational support specialist shall be entitled to defense and indemnification by the school district to the same extent as a school district employee. The contract between the educational support specialist and the school district shall be subject to approval by the commissioner.

(i) The educational support specialist shall:

(A) Support and assist the school in implementing an improvement plan for such school working with the district administration and the community engagement team.

(B) Annually report to the board of education or chancellor, in a school district in a city of one million or more inhabitants, and to the commissioner on findings and recommendations regarding the school's implementation of its improvement plan. Subject to the provisions of a district's collective bargaining agreements, the educational support specialist may recommend that the district take the following actions regarding the school and provide a rationale for why these changes will assist the school in meeting demonstrable improvement targets:

(1) expand, alter, or replace the curriculum and program offerings;

(2) replace principals and assistant principals who the educational support specialist determines are unable or unwilling to implement the school's improvement plan;

(3) increase the budget, subject to the availability of funds, or reallocate the uses of the existing budget of the school;

(4) expand the school day, or school year, or both;

(5) for a school that offers first grade, add pre-kindergarten and full-day kindergarten classes, if the school does not already have such classes; and

(6) expand, alter, or replace the professional development program for school staff, with an emphasis on strategies that involve teacher input and feedback.

(ii) Upon receipt of any recommendations from the educational support specialist, the board of education, or chancellor, in a school district in a city of one million or more inhabitants working with the community engagement team, shall either take such actions as are necessary to implement the recommendations or provide a written explanation to the commissioner of its reasons for not implementing such recommendations. No recommendations may be adopted by the school district that alters the collective bargaining agreement without the approval of the affected collective bargaining unit. The commissioner shall review the educational support specialist's report and either direct the district to take the actions recommended by the educational support specialist and any other actions that the commissioner deems appropriate or, if the written explanation provided by the district has merit, as determined by the commissioner, excusing the district from such recommendations.

9. Disagreement with preliminary determination. Prior to designating a school as needing additional support and assistance pursuant to subdivision three of this section, intensive support and assistance pursuant to subdivision four of this section, placing the school under registration review pursuant to subdivision ten of this section, or making a determination that a school has been unable to make annual progress or demonstrable improvement, the commissioner shall notify the district of their preliminary determination and offer the district an opportunity to disagree in writing before they make a final determination in regard to the school.

10. Placement of schools under registration review. If, after three school years from the commissioner assigning the school demonstrable improvement targets, the commissioner determines that a school has been unable to make demonstrable improvement, the commissioner shall place the school's registration under review, unless the commissioner finds there are extenuating or extraordinary circumstances that warrant providing the school with more time to achieve such demonstrable improvement targets. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this section, the commissioner shall not place under registration review schools within a special act school district as defined in subdivision eight of section four thousand one of this chapter.

11. Public notification. a. Upon placing the registration of a school under review pursuant to subdivision ten of this section, the commissioner shall notify the board of education or chancellor, in a school district in a city of one million or more inhabitants, that the school has been placed under registration review, and that the school is at risk of having its registration revoked. Upon receipt of such notification, the board of education, or chancellor, in a school district in a city of one million or more inhabitants, shall take appropriate action to notify the general public and school community of the issuance of such notification pursuant to commissioner's regulations and provide information on the school district's plan to improve the school's performance.

b. Each year that a school remains under registration review, the school district shall offer parents an opportunity to enroll their children in a different registered school operated by the school district in which seats in the same grade as the child will attend the following school year are available. Districts shall adopt such enrollment policies as are necessary to give priority to parents who wish to transfer their child from a school that has been placed under registration review.

12. Registration review team. Upon the placement of a school's registration under review pursuant to subdivision ten of this section, the commissioner, after consultation with the school district, shall assign a registration review team. The registration review team shall conduct resource and program and planning audits and examine the quality of curriculum, instructional plans, and teaching in the school, the learning opportunities and support services available to students, and the organization and operations of the school. After such review the team shall provide diagnostic recommendations for school improvement, which may include administrative and operational improvements. The superintendent shall consider the recommendation of the team for inclusion in the school improvement plan. The superintendent shall provide annually a report to the commissioner on the school's progress on the implementation of the improvement plan.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the education law, in relation to establishing school registration and support and assistance for designated schools; and to repeal certain sections of the education law relating thereto

Purpose

This legislation establishes a system by which the New York State Department of Education will identify schools in need of additional support and assistance. The legislation requires schools to establish a community engagement team, comprised of stakeholders to consult and engage in the process of developing an improvement plan for schools identified under this law.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 of the bill repeals sections 211-a 211-b and 211-f of the education law and adds a new section 211-a that requires all public schools, with the exemption of charter schools, to be registered by the Board of Regents. Upon registration with the Board of Regents, school districts cannot close, merge, split, change the grade configuration or substantially change the enrollment without first receiving permission from the commissioner. The commissioner may consider the potential nega- tive impact to student learning when approving or denying such modifica- tions.

Read the full memo (1,188 words)

The commissioner must determine annually whether or not each school requires additional support and assistance.

Schools that require additional support and assistance must develop an improvement plan to address the issues identified by the commissioner. These plans must be developed with input from a community engagement team.

Schools that would benefit from intensive support and assistance, as determined by the commissioner must develop an improvement plan to address the issues identified by the commissioner. These plans must be developed with input from a community engagement team.

The process for identifying schools that require additional support and assistance, intensive or otherwise, must, to the greatest extent practi- cable, align with various provisions of the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act.

The bill authorizes the commissioner to establish targeted improvement standards for schools that require additional support and assistance and are particularly deficient in meeting the state's standards; or remain classified as requiring intensive support and assistance for three consecutive years.

Schools identified as those requiring additional support and assistance or intensive support and assistance can be removed from such designation by the commissioner upon such time as an identified school has achieved their performance target set by the commissioner.

If the commissioner determines that a school is unable to make demon- strable improvement, the commissioner may appoint an educational support specialist to assist the school in implementing the school's improvement plan. The bill lays out minimum standards and qualifications the educa- tional support specialist must meet to obtain such position and further outlines the duties and responsibilities of this position.

The bill requires the commissioner to notify schools identified as those requiring additional support and assistance or intensive support and assistance and provide such districts with an opportunity to disagree in writing before the commissioner renders his or her final determination on the status of the school.

The bill authorizes the commissioner to place schools that are not able to make demonstrable improvement under registration review, however the commissioner may consider extenuating or extraordinary circumstances that warrant additional time.

The bill sets forth criteria for public notification that a school has been placed under registration review.

The bill authorizes the commissioner, in consultation with the local school district, to establish a registration review team to conduct resource, program and planning audits and examine the quality of the school's curriculum and instructional plans, as well as the services available to students and the organization and operation of the school, which shall inform additional diagnostic recommendations for school improvement. The bill requires the superintendent to report annually, to the commissioner, on the school's progress with regard to the implemen- tation of the plan.

The bill authorizes the creation of a community engagement team comprised of stakeholders, such as principals, parents, guardians, teachers and other school staff. This team shall develop recommendations for improvement of the school and solicit input through public engage- ment. This team will present its recommendations periodically to the school leadership and the educational support specialist.

The bill allows the commissioner to require school board members to undergo conflict resolution training and up to fifteen hours of profes- sional development annually to support the implementation of a school improvement plan for any school that has been placed under registration review.

The bill allows the commissioner to remove schools from registration review if they make demonstrable improvement for two consecutive years, or if they are removed from designation as intensive support and assist- ance schools.

If, after two full school years under registration review, the commis- sioner determines that the school is unable to make demonstrable improvement in meeting performance targets established by the commis- sioner, the commissioner can require the district to enter into a contract to have the school managed by an educational partnership organ- ization, or to close or phase out the school. However, the commissioner may consider extenuating or extraordinary circumstances that warrant additional time.

The bill authorizes the conversion to a community school model in any school that is managed by an educational partnership organization, pursuant to subdivision sixteen of this section.

If a school district fails to take one of the actions pursuant to subdi- vision sixteen of this section, the commissioner may designate the school as an unacceptable learning environment, revoke the registration of the school, and cause the district to implement a plan for the educa- tion of the students who attend such school. However, before taking such action, the commissioner shall offer the school district an oppor- tunity to provide justification for why the commissioner should not take such actions.

The bill maintains all existing collective bargaining agreements for affected schools.

The bill requires all schools that were in receivership in the two thou- sand twenty-one - two thousand twenty-two school year shall be placed under registration review.

Section 2: Sets effective date.

Justification

In 2015, the education law was amended to include the receivership model. This model, which is not required by the United States Department of Education (USDOE) or the federal Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), established a system of appointing a receiver for the state's lowest performing schools. No other state has enacted such a model, which only serves to label public schools as failing. Schools identified under this law do not receive additional funding or interventions to support the implementation of programs to help students in these school.

Amending this law will continue to allow the New York State Education Department's (NYSED) to identify the lowest performing schools and assist them with the implementation of academic performance measures that to ensure academic success of their students. ESSA also requires New York State to identify the lowest performing schools and to increase interventions if they do not improve.

Legislative history

New bill.

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

This act shall take effect July 1, 2022. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.