Skip to content
S9292Senate2021-2022 SessionSame asA10512

Gender-Neutral Bar Admission Rules

Official title

“Relates to making technical corrections to ensure gender neutrality for the admission to practice law and preventing required disclosure of prior interaction with law enforcement or the criminal justice system”

Sponsor Brad Hoylman-SigalSD-27Affects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Judiciary
Impact
4/10
Low
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Judiciary

What's happening

This bill updates language for gender neutrality in New York law admission procedures and prohibits certain disclosures of past law enforcement interactions.

Why it matters

  1. Promotes inclusivity. By updating legal language to be gender-neutral (e.g., replacing "his" with "the member's" or "they"), the bill ensures that New York's law admission procedures are more inclusive of non-binary and gender-diverse individuals, reflecting modern understandings of gender.

  2. Protects applicant privacy. The bill prohibits bar admission questionnaires from requiring disclosure of certain past interactions with law enforcement or the criminal justice system, specifically if the matter is no longer pending and did not result in conviction, involved juvenile/youthful offender adjudication, or resulted in a sealed conviction. This reduces stigma and barriers for applicants with such histories.

  3. Reduces discrimination risk. By restricting mandatory disclosure of resolved or sealed criminal justice interactions, the legislation aims to prevent bias in the law admission process against individuals who have legally moved on from their past or were involved in youth proceedings.

  4. Aligns with broader justice reforms. These changes are consistent with ongoing efforts in New York and elsewhere to expand opportunities for people with criminal justice histories, particularly where the law has already recognized rehabilitation or confidentiality (e.g., sealing of records, youthful offender status).

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Bar applicants with criminal justice histories

    The bill would bar admission questionnaire questions requiring disclosure of resolved interactions that did not result in conviction, juvenile proceedings, youthful offender adjudications or convictions that are now sealed.

  • Appellate Division justices

    The bill would limit the criminal justice history questions they may prescribe for bar admission questionnaires.

  • Character and fitness committees

    The bill would restrict the information applicants must disclose through questionnaires used in their character and fitness investigations.

  • Lawyers and bar applicants

    The bill would replace gendered references in admission rules with gender-neutral language.

Headline styles

Gender-Neutral Bar Admission Rules

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Senator · Senate District 27

Chair, Judiciary

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Print number 9292a
  2. Amend and recommit to judiciary
  3. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A10512Assembly

Gender Neutral Law Admissions

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Jeffrey Dinowitz

Impact 4 · Low0% to pass

Full text

3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9292--A

IN SENATE

May 12, 2022

Introduced by Sen. HOYLMAN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Judiciary -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to making technical corrections to ensure gender neutrality for the admission to practice law and preventing any required disclosure of prior interaction with law enforcement or the criminal justice system under certain circumstances

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Rule 9401 of the civil practice law and rules is amended to read as follows:

Rule 9401. Committee. The appellate division in each judicial department shall appoint a committee of not less than three practicing lawyers for each judicial district within the department, for the purpose of investigating the character and fitness of every applicant for admission to practice as an attorney and counselor at law in the courts of this state. Each member of such committee shall serve until [his] the member's death, resignation or the appointment of [his] the member's successor. A lawyer who has been or who shall be appointed a member of the committee for one district may be appointed a member of the committee for another district within the same department.

§ 2. The opening paragraph and subdivision 1 of rule 9403 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 226 of the laws of 1985, are amended to read as follows:

Notwithstanding rule 9402, any application for admission to practice pending before a committee, may be referred to the committee for another judicial district in the same or another department by order or direction of the presiding justice of the appellate division of the department embracing the district in which the application is pending. Such order or direction may be made only upon the written request of the [chairman] chairperson or acting [chairman] chairperson of the committee

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD15871-02-2

before which the application is pending and only upon [his] the chairperson or acting chairperson's written certification either:

1. that the applicant, since [he] they applied to take the bar examination or to dispense with such examination or since [he] they applied on motion to be admitted to practice, has changed [his] their actual residence to such other judicial district in the same or other department, or, if not a resident of the state, has acquired full-time employment in or changed [his] their place of full-time employment to such other judicial district in the same or other department; or

§ 3. Rule 9404 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by judicial conference proposal number 7 for the year 1973, is amended to read as follows:

Rule 9404. Certificate of character and fitness. Unless otherwise ordered by the appellate division, no person shall be admitted to practice without a certificate from the proper committee that it has carefully investigated the character and fitness of the applicant and that, in such respects, [he] the applicant is entitled to admission. To enable the committee to make such investigation, the justices of the appellate division are authorized to prescribe and from time to time to amend a form of statement or questionnaire to be submitted by the applicant, including specifically [his] the applicant's present and such past places of actual residence as may be required therein, listing the street and number, if any, and the period of time [he] the applicant resided at each place. Such questionnaire shall not include any questions requiring the disclosure of the applicant's history of interaction with law enforcement or the criminal justice system if such interaction (i) is no longer pending and did not result in a conviction, (ii) resulted in a juvenile proceeding or youthful offender adjudication, or (iii) resulted in a conviction which is now sealed.

§ 4. Rule 9405 of the civil practice law and rules is amended to read as follows:

Rule 9405. Prior application. In the event that any applicant has made a prior application for admission to practice in this state or in any other jurisdiction, then upon said statement or questionnaire or in an accompanying signed statement, [he] the applicant shall set forth in detail all the facts with respect to such prior application and its disposition. If such prior application had been filed in any appellate division of this state and if the applicant failed to obtain a certificate of good character and fitness from the appropriate character committee or if for any reason such prior application was disapproved or rejected either by said committee or said appellate division, [he] the applicant shall obtain and submit the written consent of said appellate division to the renewal of [his] their application in that appellate division or in any other appellate division.

§ 5. Rule 9406 of the civil practice law and rules, as amended by chapter 226 of the laws of 1985, is amended to read as follows:

Rule 9406. Proof. No person shall receive said certificate from any committee and no person shall be admitted to practice as an attorney and counselor at law in the courts of this state, unless [he] they shall furnish satisfactory proof to the effect:

1. that [he supports] they support the constitutions of the United States and of the state of New York; and

2. that [he has] they have complied with all the requirements of the applicable statutes of this state, the applicable rules of the court of appeals and the applicable rules of the appellate division in which [his] their application is pending, relating to the admission to practice as an attorney and counselor at law.

§ 6. This act shall take effect on the sixtieth day after it shall have become a law.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to making technical corrections to ensure gender neutrality for the admission to practice law and preventing any required disclosure of prior interaction with law enforcement or the criminal justice system under certain circumstances

Purpose of bill

To prohibit unnecessary and discriminatory questioning of bar appli- cants.

Summary of provisions

Sections 1, 2, 4, and 5 amend rules 9401, 9402, 9405, and 9406 of the CPLR to make them gender neutral.

Read the full memo (916 words)

Section 3 amends rule 9404 of the CPLR to make it gender neutral and to prohibit the questioning of applicants about interactions with law enforcement or the criminal justice system if such interaction (i) is no longer pending and did not result in a conviction, (ii) resulted in a juvenile proceeding or youthful offender adjudication, or (iii) resulted in a conviction which is now sealed.

Section 6 provides the effective date.

Justification

New York State's application for admission to the Bar must be revised to eliminate impermissible questions about criminal justice involvement so that it conforms to the requirements for licensing agencies set forth in the New York Human Rights Law and Family Court Act.

The four departments of the Appellate Division of the New York Supreme Court, pursuant to the authority granted in C.P.L.R. 9404, use question- naires to screen the character and fitness of applicants seeking admis- sion to practice law in New York State. Criminal justice involvement must be disclosed in response to several questions, including Question 26, which currently asks:

"Have you ever, either as an adult or a juvenile, been cited, ticketed, arrested, taken into custody, charged with, indicted, convicted or tried for, or pleaded guilty to, the commission of any felony or misdemeanor or the violation of any law, or been the subject of any juvenile delin- quency or youthful offender proceeding? Traffic violations that occurred more than ten years before the filing of this application need not be reported, except alcohol or drug-related traffic violations, which must be reported in all cases, irrespective of when they occurred. Do not report parking violations."

These questions are inconsistent with Section 296(16) of the New York Human Rights Law, which provides, "It shall be an unlawful discriminato- ry practice, unless specifically required or permitted by statute ... for any person, ... including the state and any political subdivision thereof ... to make any inquiry about, whether in any form of applica- tion or otherwise, .. . any arrest or criminal accusation of such indi- vidual not then pending against that individual which was followed by a termination ... in favor of such individual .. . or by a youthful offen- der adjudication ..." The bar application questions are also improper under Section 380.1 of the New York Family Court Act which provides, "Except where specifically required by statute, no person shall be required to divulge information pertaining to the arrest of the (juve- nile) respondent or any subsequent proceeding under this article." Neither the Human Rights Law nor the Family Court Act exempts from the prohibition against criminal record inquiries any of the administrative agents of the New York Supreme Court who handle the licensing of attor- neys.

Requiring disclosure of criminal justice involvement on the bar applica- tion has an adverse impact on the representation of people of color in New York law schools, which require disclosure on their application forms to conform to the bar application's required disclosure. According to recent New York State Bar Association Report, criminal record screen- ing has a chilling effect on college and law school applicants from communities of color due to the greater likelihood that they will be arrested, and if arrested convicted, than their similarly-situated white counterparts. The Report noted with concern that of the approximately 4,500 students admitted in 2021 to the 15 law schools in New York, fewer than 400 identified as African American, Native American, Alaskan or Pacific Islander. This disturbing under-representation of students of color in law schools is reflected in the well-documented under-represen- tation of people of color among lawyers admitted to practice in New York.

The Report also noted that criminal record screening does not protect the public from lawyers who go on to violate the ethical requirements of the profession. The most prominent academic study of the effect of crim- inal record screening in Connecticut on the rate of lawyer discipline shows that such screening has no statistically-significant protective effect for the members of the public who seek legal services. That conclusion has not been contradicted by any data or study from the New York Office of Court Administration.

Consistent with the findings and recommendations of the NYSBA, this bill would conform the bar application to the requirements of current New York law by eliminating questions that require disclosure of arrests that are not pending at the time of application which had terminated in the arrestee's favor, adjournments in contemplation of dismissal (which are tantamount to dismissals), sealed convictions, juvenile delinquency proceedings, and youthful offender adjudications. The bill will not affect questions concerning convictions of adult offenders that have not been sealed.

If adopted, New York would become a leader, along with California, in eliminating over-broad and burdensome criminal record screening as a barrier to aspiring lawyers from poor and under-represented communities.

Legislative history

New bill, 2022.

Fiscal implications for state and local governments

None.

Effective date

On the sixtieth day after it becomes a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.