Gaveled in 12:19 PM · Albany, New York · 2021–22 session
NEW YORK STATE SENATE
THE STENOGRAPHIC RECORD
ALBANY, NEW YORK
January 5, 2022
12:19 p.m.
REGULAR SESSION
LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR BRIAN A. BENJAMIN, President
ALEJANDRA N. PAULINO, ESQ., Secretary
P R O C E E D I N G STHE PRESIDENT:The Senate will come to order.
I ask everyone present to please rise and recite the Pledge of Allegiance.
(Whereupon, the assemblage recited the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag.)
THE PRESIDENT:Pastor David Traynham, chairman of the board of the ALERT Partnership in Albany, will deliver today's invocation.
PASTOR TRAYNHAM:Thank you, Lieutenant Governor.
Heavenly Father, we come today as servants of both the people of this great state and You, as sovereign over this world. Thank You for calling each of these public servants by Your will and by Your purpose.
We invoke Your presence in these chambers today, and we acknowledge our need for help beyond our own gifts, talents and our abilities. As they conduct the business of the people, Father God, we ask that You will take charge by leading them, guiding them, and directing the steps of Your servants so they can accomplish the mandates that are before them.
Father, as King Solomon asked for wisdom to judge Your people, I ask the same for each of these great men and women gathered in these chambers.
Hear from heaven, O Lord: Forgive our sin and heal our land of COVID-19, of violence, hatred, of bitterness, division, racism and murder. Father God, heal our land of the hopelessness that many people may feel.
Father, renew our faith in You, renew our hope in You, and renew our love for You. Let Your elected officials govern as fine-tuned instruments in Your hand. Let their moral and ethical convictions guide their decisions every day. Let godly character give each of them the longevity in these offices that they hold.
We pray that You will have the preeminence in this season. Let Your unity amongst the leaders, O God, prevail as they put aside the things that would distract them, and that they may operate as one people under Your guidance.
We pray for their safety as You guide them through this COVID pandemic, as they travel the roads, and when they meet in public assemblies. We pray for their families as they serve our families. We trust that You will bring health and healing to their lives. Father, give them strength and endurance as they give their lives to make the lives of our residents of this great state even better.
And lastly, we pray that these servants would have spiritual eyes to see from Your perspective, spiritual ears to hear what You would have to say, and give them a tongue like that of a skillful poet and use them as Your spokespersons in the earth.
We ask these things in Your mighty name, and we thank You for it.
Amen and amen. God bless you.
THE PRESIDENT:The Secretary will call the roll to ascertain a quorum.
THE SECRETARY:Senator Addabbo.
Senator Akshar.
Senator Bailey.
Senator Biaggi.
Senator Borrello.
Senator Breslin.
Senator Brisport.
Senator Brooks.
Senator Brouk.
Senator Cleare.
Senator Comrie.
Senator Cooney.
Senator Felder.
Senator Gallivan.
Senator Gaughran.
Senator Gianaris.
Senator Gounardes.
Senator Griffo.
Senator Harckham.
Senator Helming.
Senator Hinchey.
Senator Hoylman.
Senator Jackson.
Senator Jordan.
Senator Kaminsky.
Senator Kaplan.
Senator Kavanagh.
Senator Kennedy.
Senator Krueger.
Senator Lanza.
Senator Liu.
Senator Mannion.
THE PRESIDENT:Senator Gianaris, a quorum is present.
In keeping with the tradition of this chamber, it is my honor as President of the Senate to welcome you to the 2022 session.
It is great to be back. And I just want to start off with a few acknowledgements.
To our Majority Leader, Andrea Stewart-Cousins, who has just been an amazing force for good in the state, helped me to get to where I am now, and will continue to do great work for our state. Thank you, Majority Leader.
To our Minority Leader, Robert Ortt, who is continuing to fight for his constituents and for this state and who I believe understands that you can disagree without being disagreeable.
To our floor leaders, Mike Gianaris -- who has just been a rock -- and to Senator Lanza, who's not here but has worked well with the Democratic side of the aisle, thank you for all of your hard work.
You know, one of the things that I had the pleasure to do for a few years was to be Acting Temporary President up here. And I spent so much time hearing from so many of the Senators in this chamber. And the one thing I'm convinced is that every Senator cares about their district, takes their job seriously. And I got the opportunity to watch and participate as you did that.
And so as I have now moved on to become Lieutenant Governor, just know that behind me is a Senator from Harlem, her name is Cordell Cleare, and she takes her oath very seriously. And she will join you in making sure that this body, the New York State Senate, continues to be a place where ideas can be debated, conversations can be had. We can disagree, but we can do so respectfully. That is, at the end of the day, what our constituents want us to do.
A couple of priorities. First, COVID. The reason why we're gathered here remotely in most of the chamber is because COVID has really taken a serious impact on our state. First it was COVID-19 itself, then Delta, now Omicron. I'm hearing of a new variant.
So COVID is going to be with us. The question is what are we doing to make sure that we fight back and we protect as many lives as humanly possible and we reduce hospitalizations and deaths across this state.
We have provided tests, we have provided the vaccine, everyone can get boosted, we have on our N95 masks. We are doing the things we need to do. But we have to work together, across party lines, to make sure that communities that are resistant to the vaccine, resistant to being boosted, resistant to wearing masks, that we convince them that our future, our kids' future, is only going to be strong if we fight through this together and we do the uncomfortable things that need to be done.
Second, public safety. COVID is not the only epidemic that we have been dealing with. Gun violence has been a scourge on our state, on our nation. And the one thing that I have seen as I have traveled around this state is how many communities are impacted by gun violence, knowing fully well that in no part of this state are we manufacturing guns.
Guns are being brought to our state and they are being used to hurt too many of us, particularly in communities of color. Rochester just has declared a state of emergency because of this. State of emergency is the natural course when it comes to gun violence.
What are we going to do about it? Couple of things. One, we must support and work with law enforcement to track down these guns and root them out wherever they are. Secondly, we must focus on prevention. One of the things that I feel very strongly about is when you think about issues of poverty, you think about mental health, you think about addiction issues, there's a correlation between those issues and some of the violence that we see.
We have to invest in our community centers, education, workforce development and give people a chance to do something with their lives. And that is something that we are going to focus on. And one of the things I want to commend Pastor David Traynham on is that he's been working on these issues. He just spoke as pastor, and those community partnerships with our religious leaders, our violence interrupters, are a part of the solution -- not the solution, a part of the solution. And we all have a role to play.
Next I want to talk about economic development, something that should be a bipartisan issue. We need jobs, jobs, and more jobs. But what we need to make sure is that as we create these jobs, that every community participates. That is not just communities in terms of racially, but also across this entire state.
I have been to a number of the different regions upstate, around the state, and I continue to believe that we have great people -- we just need to make sure that the opportunities are flowing and everyone can participate.
And the other thing I know for a fact is that we need broadband all over this state. It is completely challenging to drive around this state and do business and make sure that as we're talking about COVID, our kids can learn, get the opportunities that they need.
That is not possible when you can't connect. You've got to be able to connect to the internet highway. That is something that we have to focus on, and we will focus on together.
And let me just say as it relates to education: We need to make sure that we have a quality education for every single child all across this state. We need to make sure that people have access to quality higher education who live in this state. We also need to make sure that we have opportunities for those who do not go to college. We need to have apprenticeship programs, we need to invest in certificate programs, and we need to make sure that no one is left behind in New York State.
We cannot have a model that only assumes that everyone is going to go off to college. There are some of us who are not. And it is our responsibility to make sure there's productivity in our workforce, and the only way to do that is to make sure that everyone participates.
And if we're going to talk about gun violence, we're going to talk about community issues, we can't do that when we leave so many people out of the economic pipeline, and we have to focus on that as we go forward.
Let me also say, as a new father -- I call three years ago new. And now I have a second one, she's now two months -- childcare, childcare, childcare. We talk about these issues; they're all connected. How can you go to work when you're worried about where your child is going to be, if you can't afford adequate, decent childcare? We need to make sure that we're thinking about these things as a comprehensive package, not as one-off activities to address.
Let me just say, on the environment: As many of us know, we passed in this chamber a policy that will require us going to 100 percent renewable energy. My question for us is as we do that, who's going to be building the offshore wind turbines? Who's going to make sure that the transmission lines are set up? Who's going to put the solar panels on the rooftops?
We need to make sure that we get to 100 percent renewable energy, we want to make sure that we do that right, but we have to make sure that everyone gets to participate. And I believe there's an equity issue here that I'm focusing on in my office to ensure that that happens.
Also, $27 billion from the infrastructure bill that is going to be coming to New York State -- at least -- to rebuild roads, bridges, tunnels, the Second Avenue Subway, which I'm very excited about. We want to make sure that we've got jobs, skills training, workforce development embedded in all of that for our communities. And that is something that I am very excited about.
Affordable housing. You cannot live in New York and not know about the affordable housing crisis that we have. We have an affordable housing crisis, we have a homelessness crisis. Today more than 50 percent of New York City residents are rent-burdened. And tonight as many as 90,000 New Yorkers will seek -- will fall into the shelter system.
We cannot allow this to continue. We must invest and we must work with our municipal partners to ensure that we deal with the crisis of homelessness and provide adequate affordable housing for everyone.
Last, let me say as I've traveled the state over the last four months -- I can't believe it's been four months, I had to stop on that -- I've seen firsthand that the solutions to the problems that New York faces are right in front of us. They're right in our grasp. The urban food deserts in New York City can be fed by New York farmers. New York residents who vacation -- not right now as much, but when we vacation, we can be hiking in the Adirondacks, we can be skiing on Hunter Mountain. The green energy revolution in New York can be powered by our Atlantic winds and the raging waters of the mighty Niagara Falls.
New York's economy can be rebuilt better than ever by the hardworking New Yorkers who make this state what it is. And it is our job to give them the opportunity and the support to get that done as we get through this pandemic and whatever else comes our way.
Thank you very much.
Next --
SENATOR GIANARIS:Mr. President, please proceed to the regular order of business.
THE PRESIDENT:Perfect.
Presentation of petitions.
Messages from the Assembly.
Messages from the Governor.
The Secretary will read.
THE SECRETARY:"Dear Majority Leader Stewart-Cousins:
"I would appreciate the privilege of the presence of the Members of the New York State Senate to view a live broadcast on January 5, 2022, at 1:00 p.m., as I deliver the 2022 State of the State.
"Very truly yours, Kathy Hochul."
THE PRESIDENT:To be filed in the Journal.
Reports of standing committees.
Reports of select committees.
Communications and reports from state officers.
Motions and resolutions.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:At this time, Mr. President, please recognize Senator Ortt for his opening remarks.
THE PRESIDENT:Senator Ortt.
SENATOR ORTT:Mr. Lieutenant Governor, it's good to see you -- in a very familiar spot, but good to see you nonetheless.
I wish everyone a Happy New Year. And it really is good to see everyone. First I certainly -- the staff, it's good to see you're back and everyone is doing healthy.
I want to recognize my colleague Senator Andrea Stewart-Cousins, Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins; Senator Gianaris. Good to see them both back here in this chamber, doing well, and looking forward to a session hopefully not totally like last session -- hopefully it gets a little better and it opens up and we get through this surge that we're seeing post-holiday.
It's good to see my colleagues who are here: Senator Borrello, Senator Serino, Senator Helming and, of course, filling in for Senator Lanza -- as the Lieutenant Governor noted, he is not with us today, so it's a little bit quieter here in the chamber. But Senator O'Mara is here pulling duty, and I want to thank him for his effort. And Shontell and Kristin.
But the bottom line is we are back, it is a new year. And it's always -- no matter what's going on, I think it's always a time when we should be optimistic and hopeful about the future. And there's certainly no shortage of challenges.
And as the Lieutenant Governor was talking, I thought about the number of challenges he was laying out, and it struck me that a lot of times in this chamber we don't often -- sometimes we do, but not often -- disagree with the challenge, with the issue, with the problem or the obstacle facing the people in New York.
Crime, gun violence, economic development, obviously public health, agriculture, energy costs, the exodus of people, our workforce -- all those things I think you would find on the issue: Is that an issue facing the people of New York? Whether you represent Harlem or Niagara Falls or everywhere in between, you would hear consensus that yes, those are issues that we and our constituents are concerned about.
Obviously where the disagreement comes is very often on the solution to those issues. And that's not new, and that's not going to go away. And that's kind of part of also why we're here, why we've been elected to represent our constituents and to disagree without being disagreeable where appropriate, and to try to find some shared commonality to get things done, where appropriate, for the people of New York.
So whether it's -- you know, it was mentioned about gun violence. I often will tell people that gun violence is perpetrated by human beings, not by guns. And so we need to do something about the root causes of what prompts someone to commit gun violence. Many times they're committed by career criminals who are using illegal guns, which are already a crime, obviously. Murder is also already a crime.
So we have to ask ourselves, what are the other things that are playing into the increasing crime, particularly violent crime, plaguing not only our major cities but a lot of other places in between? We have to ask ourselves, What are the root causes of why New York leads the nation in outmigration? How do we change that metric? We all have a responsibility to change that metric, because as we lose people, those are our future workforce, those are the future human capital that we need to bring the state back to economic vitality and greatness.
Obviously we've been facing a pandemic the last several years, so economic development and the future of New York's economy weighs heavily, I know, on all of us, whether you represent New York City or the North Country. It may be more acute in different areas, but the reality is we all have an obligation to put forward ideas and policies and support legislation that is going to bring back New York economically, that's going to make it more affordable for people to live here and for people to stay here.
We have an obligation to make sure that our education system still is a pathway to success and still promotes achievement for people who are achieving, and not to use our education system as a road to any kind of social experimentation.
I think it is important that education, especially for first-generation Americans, that is the ladder to a better future. For people who are in poverty, that is the ladder to a better future. And our conference supports that, and it will be a major focus of our agenda and my members' agenda as we go forward.
And I guess just last, the Lieutenant Governor mentioned -- I think we all -- this is -- we know what year it is, we know what year it is in the political calendar. But hopefully, I think -- I will do my utmost on this floor, in this chamber, where there's been -- and I've been privy and sat and listened to a lot of very good debates over the years, intellectual debates, debates that were -- I think would have made our constituents proud. I think we have to be able to disagree without being disagreeable here.
I think we need to be able to disagree, even vehemently, but we can still recognize that both Senators, both conferences are here to do what they think their constituents want, need, and what they think is in the best interests of the State of New York.
I know our conference stands ready to do that. We stand ready to work with the Majority where we can, and certainly to disagree where we need to as well.
So, Lieutenant Governor, it is good to see you. I thank you for your indulgence. I thank the Majority Leader for her indulgence. And I wish everyone a happy, healthy and prosperous 2022.
THE PRESIDENT:Thank you, Senator Ortt.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:And now, Mr. President, please recognize Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins for her opening remarks.
THE PRESIDENT:Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins.
SENATOR STEWART-COUSINS:Thank you so much, Mr. President. How often I've said that, but now it's a little bit different. But we will get to that.
I just want to say, again: Happy, Healthy New Year to everyone. It is really good to see everybody and to be back in the chamber. Although it wasn't that many months ago that we were here, I think we thought that our reunion would be a little different, that we'd be more opened up.
But obviously COVID had other plans for us, so -- so here we are. But we are looking forward to being able to get back together in full force.
But, you know, even though we are in this phase, I will say that this is not a repeat of March of 2020. We now, as you've indicated, have a strong arsenal of tools to fight the virus, to limit the human and economic toll that the pandemic has taken on us. And in order to do that, I will do my public service announcement: We need people to get vaccinated, to get boosted, wear masks as we push through this phase of the crisis.
I want to thank Governor Hochul for stepping up during uncertain times. Although this will be our first session with Governor Hochul at the helm, we've already accomplished a lot together. And I am eager, frankly, for a year of continued collaboration.
I want to thank my deputy, Senator Gianaris, who's always stood by my side in all of these endeavors.
And of course, you know, I want to thank all of the members of certainly my Majority, as well as all the members here in the chamber, for the work that we do.
I do want to acknowledge my counterpart, Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie. And again, he's somebody who stands on the side of justice and has always been seeking to make New York a better place.
And here back -- thank you, Senator Ortt -- we do have -- you know, we've had an opportunity to work together. And again, I think that we have been -- you know, it's been easy, collegial, and I look forward to continuing that relationship as we move forward.
And certainly, again, Senator O'Mara, it's good to see you. Thank you for, you know, doing the important work that you do and standing in for Senator Lanza at this point. And I look forward to the continued efforts to make sure this chamber moves smoothly.
And of course to Kristin and our own Shontell and all the staff. We couldn't do it without all of you, and we certainly acknowledge the power that you give us to do our jobs.
And, you know, with that I want to formally address my friend and colleague Senator Benjamin. I want to say goodbye to Senator Benjamin and welcome Lieutenant Governor Brian Benjamin.
You know, you've always been one of my main presiding officers. And quite honestly, it is great to see you in this role as Lieutenant Governor -- although I think you might have seen what I was going to say today, because so much of what you hit upon is in my speech.
But again, thank you for continuing to serve the people of New York State, and thank you for making the seat available in the 30th District for our great new Senator, Cordell Cleare.
Usually we have an opportunity to give people formal introductions, and we all clap and we're happy to have you. But just so people know that Senator Cleare is a long-time activist, she's a former Senate staffer. She has a heart for service to the people, and I know she will be a tremendous asset. Thank you for joining our ranks.
So the new year presents an opportunity for a natural reset where we can reflect on previous events and apply new insight to the tasks ahead. We as a state have plenty to reflect upon. This past year tested us in new ways, revealed the depths of old wounds, and challenged each and every one of us as elected officials to step up on behalf of all New Yorkers.
2022 will mark the second anniversary of COVID-19. The hardships that we've endured cannot be overstated. To date we've lost 61,000 New Yorkers -- 61,000 New Yorkers. And at this point we continue to offer our condolences to those who have lost loved ones.
This once-in-a-lifetime crisis amplified preexisting inequalities and brought our economic and social systems to a grinding halt. Despite these historic challenges, however, the Senate Majority proved that we were up to the task of meeting them with decisive action.
We stabilized our healthcare system and rolled out one of the largest and fastest vaccine initiatives in the country. We bolstered the economy from the ground up, with the help of our federal partners, through the Emergency Rental Assistance Program. We were also able, here in this state, to provide a billion dollars in small business grants, 2 billion to excluded workers, and the most progressive budget in history, which successfully jump-started the most devastated sectors of our society.
And we didn't stop there. Because COVID-19 did not just devastate our health system and economy, it revealed deep inequalities that had gone unaddressed for too long. Last year we moved in New York closer to a reality where every person has an equal shot regardless of their zip code, their background and their circumstances. We took major steps to level the playing field for all New Yorkers by investing record funds in education, requiring the wealthy to pay their fair share in taxes, strengthening our gun safety laws, and recommitting ourselves to a greener future.
We may never return to our old sense of normal, but that's only because we are becoming more exceptional. Our conference has laid a strong foundation from which to grow. It's time for us to continue our collaborative work and deliver even bolder policies that will make New York a fairer haven for opportunity and success.
This is our chance to step into a promising new era. That begins with moving our state towards social and economic policies that acknowledge the changing nature of work and gives New Yorkers the tools they need for the jobs of the future.
In order to fully support the workers, we need to ensure that parents -- very much what you said -- aren't forced to choose between a paycheck and raising their children. Under this current system, our children ultimately pay the price. It's time for us to make universal, affordable childcare a reality in this state, because this commonsense policy will transform labor and gives kids a head start that will change the course of their lives.
New York stood -- we must remember in 2016 we stood in the forefront by enacting the country's strongest and most comprehensive paid family leave program. We must lead again in this way.
I want New York to be a state that invests in the next generation from the cradle to college to whatever the training they need to have. This can only happen, however, with statewide, fully funded pre-K to accompany universal childcare. I'm proud of the advances we've made, but let's go that final mile and ensure every district has the resource for generations to come.
COVID showed us the vast untapped potential of remote working and learning. Unfortunately, roughly 1 million New Yorkers live without broadband access. A huge sector of our state is being excluded from the growing digital economy because they lack the utility. Just as the New Deal brought more Americans out of the darkness, we will have to do the same again with the internet.
As we strive for greater prosperity, we must remember that small businesses and workers alike are still suffering from the economic devastation of the pandemic. Our historic investments in small business grants and unemployment benefits helped stop the bleeding and kept shops open and families fed. But now we need to help businesses and the workers that power them not only survive but thrive.
We need to stem the rising costs of unemployment insurance for small businesses while ensuring that workers receive benefit increases that have been delayed for years. We need to look at the tax rates of both small businesses and working- and middle-class taxpayers. And we need to provide mental health support for front-line personnel who bore the emotional brunt of the COVID-19 cases -- and fair compensation to essential workers, who are still being stretched to their limits.
Ultimately, we cannot reliably invest in our future without taking drastic steps to reverse climate change. We're running out of time to avoid the most catastrophic impacts of rising CO2, which would alter life as we know it. These once-in-a-lifetime climate events are occurring every year with increasing ferocity. This does not have to be our new normal. New York's been a trailblazer on environmental policy ever since we took the majority in 2019, and we are not slowing down.
And as always, our conference will continue to fight for bedrock legislation that will protect the rights and freedoms of every New Yorker. We've seen other state legislatures take unprecedented steps to roll back voting rights and reproductive care. These antidemocratic attacks on our constitutional rights will not stand in New York.
As in the past, our conference will be expanding access to absentee ballots, increasing the number of polling sites, particularly on college campuses, and always working to curtail voter suppression wherever we see it. We will continue to rise up as a destination state for women's reproductive care so that every individual can make the choice best suited for their body. There is no alternative.
I know this is an ambitious agenda. That's because we are ambitious people. Since taking the majority in 2019, we've proven time and again that no mandate is too big, no issue too small. That's why New Yorkers have chosen us to fight for them.
After the events of the past two years, and in the wake of our own government revelations, we've had a lot of healing to do. And I thank Pastor Traynham -- and thank you, Senator Breslin, for bringing him -- because I think he really set the tone of what we can do as people who are doing what the people of New York need for us to do.
It has been an incredible, incredible period. But although it's been difficult, it's also an incredible period of growth. New York has never shied away from a challenge. We know as leaders we're meant to challenge the status quo and continuously build towards a bigger and brighter future. That's why I'm so excited to open up what I know will be another historic legislative session and work with each and every one of you to reach the growing light at the end of the tunnel. Together we will emerge stronger than ever before.
We have so much to look forward to, so much to do. We'll do it together on behalf of New Yorkers. I look forward to getting the work done. And so therefore I say: Let's get to work.
Thank you so much, Mr. President.
THE PRESIDENT:Thank you, Madam Majority Leader.
Senator Gianaris.
SENATOR GIANARIS:Mr. President, on behalf of the Majority Leader, there are some hand-ups related to Majority Conference membership changes. I ask that they be filed with the Journal, please.
THE PRESIDENT:So ordered.
Senator Gianaris.
THE PRESIDENT:Is there any further business at the desk?
THE PRESIDENT:There is no further business at the desk.
SENATOR GIANARIS:In that case, in order for us to move over to the Assembly chamber to hear the Governor's speech, I move to adjourn until Monday, January 10th, at 3:00 p.m.
THE PRESIDENT:On motion, the Senate stands adjourned until Monday, January 10th, at 3:00 p.m.
(Whereupon, at 12:56 p.m., the Senate adjourned.)