Skip to content
A1967Assembly2023-2024 SessionSame asS5400

Disclose Flood Insurance to Renters

Official title

“Requires disclosure of information concerning flood insurance on residential leases; repealer”

Sponsor Robert C. CarrollAD-44+11 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
Signed by Governor
Impact
7/10
Significant
Outcome
Signed into law

Bill progress

Signed into law

What's happening

This bill requires sellers of residential property in New York to disclose detailed flood risk and flood insurance information to buyers.

Why it matters

  1. Buyers gain access to detailed, standardized information about a property’s flood risk. including whether it is in a FEMA-designated floodplain, subject to federal flood insurance requirements, or has a history of flood damage and claims. This can help buyers make more informed financial and safety decisions, especially as flooding risks increase due to climate change.

  2. Sellers must disclose the existence and details of any flood insurance policies, claims, and federal disaster assistance. (such as from FEMA or SBA), and provide documents like elevation certificates if available. This level of transparency could help buyers anticipate ongoing insurance costs and eligibility for future disaster relief.

  3. The traditional $500 penalty option for not providing a disclosure is eliminated. ; instead, the law allows buyers to pursue damages if a seller willfully fails to disclose, potentially increasing legal accountability and incentivizing full compliance.

  4. By requiring explicit disclosure of climate-related and floodplain risks, the bill may influence property values, insurance eligibility, and mortgage lending practices. affecting both buyers and sellers, and potentially driving greater awareness and adaptation to evolving environmental hazards.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Sellers of one- to four-family homes

    They would face expanded disclosure questions about known flood risks, insurance, claims and disaster assistance, while the bill would eliminate the $500 credit for failing to deliver a disclosure statement.

  • Homebuyers

    They would receive more information before signing a binding sale contract about flood exposure, past water damage and flood insurance obligations.

  • Real estate agents

    They would handle expanded property condition disclosure forms that sellers must deliver to buyers or buyers’ agents before a binding contract is signed.

  • Flood insurance providers

    The bill would require sellers to attach existing flood insurance policies and available FEMA elevation certificates, which buyers may be able to use for their own coverage.

Headline styles

Disclose Flood Insurance to Renters

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Signed chap.484
  2. Delivered to governor
  3. Returned to assembly
  4. Passed senateVote 42–21
  5. 3rd reading cal.1806
  6. Substituted for S5400
  7. Referred to judiciary
  8. Delivered to senate
  9. Passed assembly
  10. Ordered to third reading rules cal.187
  11. Rules report cal.187
  12. Reported
Show 2 earlier actions
  1. Reported referred to rules
  2. Referred to judiciary

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

S5400Senate

Disclose Flood Insurance to Renters

Senate Floor Calendar · Sponsor Brad Hoylman-Sigal

Impact 7 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

11 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

1967

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN ASSEMBLY

January 23, 2023

Introduced by M. of A. CARROLL -- read once and referred to the Committee on Judiciary

AN ACT to amend the real property law, in relation to requiring disclosure of information concerning flood insurance on property condition disclosure statements; and to repeal section 467 of the real property law relating to liability with respect to property disclosures

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 2 of section 462 of the real property law, as added by chapter 456 of the laws of 2001, is amended to read as follows:

2. The following shall be the disclosure form:

PROPERTY CONDITION DISCLOSURE STATEMENT

NAME OF SELLER OR SELLERS:

PROPERTY ADDRESS:

THE PROPERTY CONDITION DISCLOSURE ACT REQUIRES THE SELLER OF RESIDEN- TIAL REAL PROPERTY TO CAUSE THIS DISCLOSURE STATEMENT OR A COPY THEREOF TO BE DELIVERED TO A BUYER OR BUYER'S AGENT PRIOR TO THE SIGNING BY THE BUYER OF A BINDING CONTRACT OF SALE.

PURPOSE OF STATEMENT: THIS IS A STATEMENT OF CERTAIN CONDITIONS AND INFORMATION CONCERNING THE PROPERTY KNOWN TO THE SELLER. THIS DISCLOSURE STATEMENT IS NOT A WARRANTY OF ANY KIND BY THE SELLER OR BY ANY AGENT REPRESENTING THE SELLER IN THIS TRANSACTION. IT IS NOT A SUBSTITUTE FOR ANY INSPECTIONS OR TESTS AND THE BUYER IS ENCOURAGED TO OBTAIN HIS OR HER OWN INDEPENDENT PROFESSIONAL INSPECTIONS AND ENVIRONMENTAL TESTS AND ALSO IS ENCOURAGED TO CHECK PUBLIC RECORDS PERTAINING TO THE PROPERTY.

A KNOWINGLY FALSE OR INCOMPLETE STATEMENT BY THE SELLER ON THIS FORM MAY SUBJECT THE SELLER TO CLAIMS BY THE BUYER PRIOR TO OR AFTER THE

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD04357-01-3

TRANSFER OF TITLE. [IN THE EVENT A SELLER FAILS TO PERFORM THE DUTY PRESCRIBED IN THIS ARTICLE TO DELIVER A DISCLOSURE STATEMENT PRIOR TO THE SIGNING BY THE BUYER OF A BINDING CONTRACT OF SALE, THE BUYER SHALL RECEIVE UPON THE TRANSFER OF TITLE A CREDIT OF FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS AGAINST THE AGREED UPON PURCHASE PRICE OF THE RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPER- TY.]

"RESIDENTIAL REAL PROPERTY" MEANS REAL PROPERTY IMPROVED BY A ONE TO FOUR FAMILY DWELLING USED OR OCCUPIED, OR INTENDED TO BE USED OR OCCU- PIED, WHOLLY OR PARTLY, AS THE HOME OR RESIDENCE OF ONE OR MORE PERSONS, BUT SHALL NOT REFER TO (A) UNIMPROVED REAL PROPERTY UPON WHICH SUCH DWELLINGS ARE TO BE CONSTRUCTED OR (B) CONDOMINIUM UNITS OR COOPERATIVE APARTMENTS OR (C) PROPERTY ON A HOMEOWNERS' ASSOCIATION THAT IS NOT OWNED IN FEE SIMPLE BY THE SELLER.

INSTRUCTIONS TO THE SELLER:

(a) ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS BASED UPON YOUR ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE.

(b) ATTACH ADDITIONAL PAGES WITH YOUR SIGNATURE IF ADDITIONAL SPACE IS REQUIRED.

(c) COMPLETE THIS FORM YOURSELF.

(d) IF SOME ITEMS DO NOT APPLY TO YOUR PROPERTY, CHECK "NA" (NON-AP- PLICABLE). IF YOU DO NOT KNOW THE ANSWER CHECK "UNKN" (UNKNOWN).

SELLER'S STATEMENT: THE SELLER MAKES THE FOLLOWING REPRESENTATIONS TO THE BUYER BASED UPON THE SELLER'S ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE AT THE TIME OF SIGN- ING THIS DOCUMENT. THE SELLER AUTHORIZES HIS OR HER AGENT, IF ANY, TO PROVIDE A COPY OF THIS STATEMENT TO A PROSPECTIVE BUYER OF THE RESIDEN- TIAL REAL PROPERTY. THE FOLLOWING ARE REPRESENTATIONS MADE BY THE SELLER AND ARE NOT THE REPRESENTATIONS OF THE SELLER'S AGENT.

GENERAL INFORMATION

1. HOW LONG HAVE YOU OWNED THE PROPERTY?

2. HOW LONG HAVE YOU OCCUPIED THE PROPERTY?

3. WHAT IS THE AGE OF THE STRUCTURE OR STRUCTURES? NOTE TO BUYER--IF

THE STRUCTURE WAS BUILT BEFORE 1978 YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO INVESTI-

GATE FOR THE PRESENCE OF LEAD BASED PAINT.

4. DOES ANYBODY OTHER THAN YOURSELF HAVE A LEASE, EASEMENT OR ANY

OTHER RIGHT TO USE OR OCCUPY ANY PART OF YOUR PROPERTY OTHER THAN

THOSE STATED IN DOCUMENTS AVAILABLE IN THE PUBLIC RECORD, SUCH AS

RIGHTS TO USE A ROAD OR PATH OR CUT TREES OR CROPS[.]? YES NO UNKN

NA

5. DOES ANYBODY ELSE CLAIM TO OWN ANY PART OF YOUR PROPERTY? YES NO

UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

6. HAS ANYONE DENIED YOU ACCESS TO THE PROPERTY OR MADE A FORMAL LEGAL

CLAIM CHALLENGING YOUR TITLE TO THE PROPERTY? YES NO UNKN NA (IF

YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

7. ARE THERE ANY FEATURES OF THE PROPERTY SHARED IN COMMON WITH

ADJOINING LAND OWNERS OR A HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, SUCH AS WALLS,

FENCES OR DRIVEWAYS? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES DESCRIBE BELOW)

8. ARE THERE ANY ELECTRIC OR GAS UTILITY SURCHARGES FOR LINE EXTEN-

SIONS, SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS OR HOMEOWNER OR OTHER ASSOCIATION FEES

THAT APPLY TO THE PROPERTY? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

9. ARE THERE CERTIFICATES OF OCCUPANCY RELATED TO THE PROPERTY? YES

NO UNKN NA (IF NO, EXPLAIN BELOW)

ENVIRONMENTAL

NOTE TO SELLER - IN THIS SECTION, YOU WILL BE ASKED QUESTIONS REGARD- ING PETROLEUM PRODUCTS AND HAZARDOUS OR TOXIC SUBSTANCES THAT YOU KNOW TO HAVE BEEN SPILLED, LEAKED OR OTHERWISE BEEN RELEASED ON THE PROPERTY OR FROM THE PROPERTY ONTO ANY OTHER PROPERTY. PETROLEUM PRODUCTS MAY INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, GASOLINE, DIESEL FUEL, HOME HEATING FUEL, AND LUBRICANTS. HAZARDOUS OR TOXIC SUBSTANCES ARE PRODUCTS THAT COULD POSE SHORT- OR LONG-TERM DANGER TO PERSONAL HEALTH OR THE ENVIRON- MENT IF THEY ARE NOT PROPERLY DISPOSED OF, APPLIED OR STORED. THESE INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, FERTILIZERS, PESTICIDES AND INSECTI- CIDES, PAINT INCLUDING PAINT THINNER, VARNISH REMOVER AND WOOD PRESERVA- TIVES, TREATED WOOD, CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS SUCH AS ASPHALT AND ROOFING MATERIALS, ANTIFREEZE AND OTHER AUTOMOTIVE PRODUCTS, BATTERIES, CLEANING SOLVENTS INCLUDING SEPTIC TANK CLEANERS, HOUSEHOLD CLEANERS AND POOL CHEMICALS AND PRODUCTS CONTAINING MERCURY AND LEAD.

NOTE TO BUYER - IF CONTAMINATION OF THIS PROPERTY FROM PETROLEUM PRODUCTS AND/OR HAZARDOUS OR TOXIC SUBSTANCES IS A CONCERN TO YOU, YOU ARE URGED TO CONSIDER SOIL AND GROUNDWATER TESTING OF THIS PROPERTY.

10. IS ANY OR ALL OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED IN A FEDERAL EMERGENCY

MANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA) DESIGNATED FLOODPLAIN? YES NO UNKN NA

(IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

11. IS ANY OR ALL OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED WHOLLY OR PARTIALLY IN THE

SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA ("SFHA"; "100-YEAR FLOODPLAIN") ACCORD-

ING TO THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY'S (FEMA'S) CURRENT

FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS FOR YOUR AREA? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES,

EXPLAIN BELOW)

12. IS ANY OR ALL OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED WHOLLY OR PARTIALLY IN A

MODERATE RISK FLOOD HAZARD AREA ("500-YEAR FLOODPLAIN") ACCORDING

TO FEMA'S CURRENT FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS FOR YOUR AREA? YES NO

UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

13. IS THE PROPERTY SUBJECT TO ANY REQUIREMENT UNDER FEDERAL LAW TO

OBTAIN AND MAINTAIN FLOOD INSURANCE ON THE PROPERTY? YES NO UNKN

NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

HOMES IN THE SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD AREA, ALSO KNOWN AS HIGH RISK

FLOOD ZONES, ON FEMA'S FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS WITH MORTGAGES

FROM FEDERALLY REGULATED OR INSURED LENDERS ARE REQUIRED TO OBTAIN

AND MAINTAIN FLOOD INSURANCE. EVEN WHEN NOT REQUIRED, FEMA ENCOUR-

AGES HOMEOWNERS IN HIGH RISK, MODERATE RISK, AND LOW RISK FLOOD

ZONES TO PURCHASE FLOOD INSURANCE THAT COVERS THE STRUCTURE(S) AND

THE PERSONAL PROPERTY WITHIN THE STRUCTURE(S). ALSO NOTE THAT

HOMES IN COASTAL AREAS MAY BE SUBJECT TO INCREASED RISK OF FLOOD-

ING OVER TIME DUE TO PROJECTED SEA LEVEL RISE AND INCREASED

EXTREME STORMS CAUSED BY CLIMATE CHANGE WHICH MAY NOT BE REFLECTED

IN CURRENT FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAPS.

14. HAVE YOU EVER RECEIVED ASSISTANCE, OR ARE YOU AWARE OF ANY PREVI-

OUS OWNERS RECEIVING ASSISTANCE, FROM THE FEDERAL EMERGENCY

MANAGEMENT AGENCY (FEMA), THE U.S. SMALL BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION

(SBA), OR ANY OTHER FEDERAL DISASTER FLOOD ASSISTANCE FOR FLOOD

DAMAGE TO THE PROPERTY? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

FOR PROPERTIES THAT HAVE RECEIVED FEDERAL DISASTER ASSISTANCE, THE

REQUIREMENT TO OBTAIN FLOOD INSURANCE PASSES DOWN TO ALL FUTURE

OWNERS. FAILURE TO OBTAIN AND MAINTAIN FLOOD INSURANCE CAN RESULT

IN AN INDIVIDUAL BEING INELIGIBLE FOR FUTURE ASSISTANCE.

15. IS THERE FLOOD INSURANCE ON THE PROPERTY? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES,

ATTACH A COPY OF THE POLICY)

A STANDARD HOMEOWNER'S INSURANCE POLICY TYPICALLY DOES NOT COVER

FLOOD DAMAGE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO EXAMINE YOUR POLICY TO DETER-

MINE WHETHER YOU ARE COVERED.

16. IS THERE A FEMA ELEVATION CERTIFICATE AVAILABLE FOR THE PROPERTY?

YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, ATTACH A COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE)

AN ELEVATION CERTIFICATE IS A FEMA FORM, COMPLETED BY A LICENSED

SURVEYOR OR ENGINEER. THE FORM PROVIDES CRITICAL INFORMATION ABOUT

THE FLOOD RISK OF THE PROPERTY AND IS USED BY FLOOD INSURANCE

PROVIDERS UNDER THE NATIONAL FLOOD INSURANCE PROGRAM (NFIP) TO

HELP DETERMINE THE APPROPRIATE FLOOD INSURANCE RATING FOR THE

PROPERTY. A BUYER MAY BE ABLE TO USE THE ELEVATION CERTIFICATE

FROM A PREVIOUS OWNER FOR THEIR FLOOD INSURANCE POLICY.

17. HAVE YOU EVER FILED A CLAIM FOR FLOOD DAMAGE TO THE PROPERTY WITH

ANY INSURANCE PROVIDER, INCLUDING THE NATIONAL FLOOD INSURANCE

PROGRAM (NFIP)? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

18. IS ANY OR ALL OF THE PROPERTY LOCATED IN A DESIGNATED WETLAND?

YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[12.] 19. IS THE PROPERTY LOCATED IN AN AGRICULTURAL DISTRICT? YES

NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[13.] 20. WAS THE PROPERTY EVER THE SITE OF A LANDFILL? YES NO UNKN

NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[14.] 21. ARE THERE OR HAVE THERE EVER BEEN FUEL STORAGE TANKS ABOVE

OR BELOW THE GROUND ON THE PROPERTY? YES NO UNKN NA IF YES,

ARE THEY CURRENTLY IN USE? YES NO UNKN NA LOCATION(S) ARE THEY

LEAKING OR HAVE THEY EVER LEAKED? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN

BELOW)

[15.] 22. IS THERE ASBESTOS IN THE STRUCTURE? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES,

STATE LOCATION OR LOCATIONS BELOW)

[16.] 23. IS LEAD PLUMBING PRESENT? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, STATE

LOCATION OR LOCATIONS BELOW)

[17.] 24. HAS A RADON TEST BEEN DONE? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, ATTACH A

COPY OF THE REPORT)

[18.] 25. HAS MOTOR FUEL, MOTOR OIL, HOME HEATING FUEL, LUBRICATING

OIL OR ANY OTHER PETROLEUM PRODUCT, METHANE GAS, OR ANY HAZARDOUS

OR TOXIC SUBSTANCE SPILLED, LEAKED OR OTHERWISE BEEN RELEASED ON

THE PROPERTY OR FROM THE PROPERTY ONTO ANY OTHER PROPERTY? YES NO

UNKN NA (IF YES, DESCRIBE BELOW)

[19.] 26. HAS THE PROPERTY BEEN TESTED FOR THE PRESENCE OF MOTOR FUEL,

MOTOR OIL, HOME HEATING FUEL, LUBRICATING OIL, OR ANY OTHER PETRO-

LEUM PRODUCT, METHANE GAS, OR ANY HAZARDOUS OR TOXIC SUBSTANCE?

YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, ATTACH REPORT(S))

STRUCTURAL

[20.] 27. IS THERE ANY ROT OR WATER DAMAGE TO THE STRUCTURE OR STRUC-

TURES? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[21.] 28. IS THERE ANY FIRE OR SMOKE DAMAGE TO THE STRUCTURE OR STRUC-

TURES? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[22.] 29. IS THERE ANY TERMITE, INSECT, RODENT OR PEST INFESTATION OR

DAMAGE? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[23.] 30. HAS THE PROPERTY BEEN TESTED FOR TERMITE, INSECT, RODENT OR

PEST INFESTATION OR DAMAGE? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, PLEASE ATTACH

REPORT(S))

[24.] 31. WHAT IS THE TYPE OF ROOF/ROOF COVERING (SLATE, ASPHALT,

OTHER.)? ANY KNOWN MATERIAL DEFECTS? HOW OLD IS THE ROOF? IS THERE

A TRANSFERABLE [WARRANTEE] WARRANTY ON THE ROOF IN EFFECT NOW? YES

NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[25.] 32. ARE THERE ANY KNOWN MATERIAL DEFECTS IN ANY OF THE FOLLOWING

STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS: FOOTINGS, BEAMS, GIRDERS, LINTELS, COLUMNS OR

PARTITIONS[.]? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

MECHANICAL SYSTEMS & SERVICES

[26.] 33. WHAT IS THE WATER SOURCE (CIRCLE ALL THAT APPLY - WELL,

PRIVATE, MUNICIPAL, OTHER)? IF MUNICIPAL, IS IT METERED? YES NO

UNKN NA

[27.] 34. HAS THE WATER QUALITY AND/OR FLOW RATE BEEN TESTED? YES NO

UNKN NA (IF YES, DESCRIBE BELOW)

[28.] 35. WHAT IS THE TYPE OF SEWAGE SYSTEM (CIRCLE ALL THAT APPLY -

PUBLIC SEWER, PRIVATE SEWER, SEPTIC OR CESSPOOL)? IF SEPTIC OR

CESSPOOL, AGE? ________ DATE LAST PUMPED? ________ FREQUENCY OF

PUMPING? ________ ANY KNOWN MATERIAL DEFECTS? YES NO UNKN NA (IF

YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[29.] 36. WHO IS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE PROVIDER? ________ WHAT IS THE

AMPERAGE? ________ DOES IT HAVE CIRCUIT BREAKERS OR FUSES?

________ PRIVATE OR PUBLIC POLES? ________ ANY KNOWN MATERIAL

DEFECTS? YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

[30.] 37. ARE THERE ANY FLOODING, DRAINAGE OR GRADING PROBLEMS THAT

RESULTED IN STANDING WATER ON ANY PORTION OF THE PROPERTY? YES NO

UNKN NA (IF YES, STATE LOCATIONS AND EXPLAIN BELOW)

[31. DOES THE BASEMENT HAVE SEEPAGE THAT RESULTS IN STANDING WATER?

YES NO UNKN NA (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)] 38. HAS THE STRUCTURE(S)

EXPERIENCED ANY WATER PENETRATION OR DAMAGE DUE TO SEEPAGE OR A

NATURAL FLOOD EVENT, SUCH AS FROM HEAVY RAINFALL, COASTAL STORM

SURGE, TIDAL INUNDATION OR RIVER OVERFLOW? YES NO UNKN NA (IF

YES, EXPLAIN BELOW)

ARE THERE ANY KNOWN MATERIAL DEFECTS IN ANY OF THE FOLLOWING (IF YES, EXPLAIN BELOW. USE ADDITIONAL SHEETS IF NECESSARY.):

[32.] 39. PLUMBING SYSTEM? YES NO UNKN NA

[33.] 40. SECURITY SYSTEM? YES NO UNKN NA

[34.] 41. CARBON MONOXIDE DETECTOR? YES NO UNKN NA

[35.] 42. SMOKE DETECTOR? YES NO UNKN NA

[36.] 43. FIRE SPRINKLER SYSTEM? YES NO UNKN NA

[37.] 44. SUMP PUMP? YES NO UNKN NA

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.