What's happening
This bill creates a secure, state-run opioid rehabilitation facility for certain criminal defendants as an alternative to incarceration, with specific admission criteria and post-treatment procedures.
Why it matters
Creates a new, secure (locked) state-run opioid rehabilitation facility as an alternative to prison for eligible nonviolent defendants. offering long-term (1-2 years) residential treatment, with judges able to refer defendants who have repeatedly relapsed or who petition for reconsideration after sentencing.
Establishes strict eligibility and exclusion criteria. defendants charged with serious (Class A/B or violent) felonies, those deemed high flight risks, or with serious unrelated mental illness, are not eligible; the facility can also refuse candidates unlikely to benefit from the program.
Sets up detailed post-treatment procedures. successful participants must transition to halfway houses and may receive continued relapse prevention counseling, with opportunities for probation and sentence reduction if they comply, but risk loss of credit and re-incarceration if they fail to engage or relapse.
Aims to fill the gap between drug court and incarceration. promoting a public health approach over criminal punishment for opioid addiction, with the goal of reducing recidivism, prison costs, and overdose deaths, while mandating a five-year program evaluation to assess effectiveness and cost savings.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Defendants whose primary addiction is to opioids
Eligible defendants could agree to one to two years in a locked treatment facility instead of prison, with potential loss of sentence credit for noncompliance or insufficient progress.
Office of Addiction Services and Supports
The agency would establish, operate and supervise the facility, with site preference near the Buffalo or Bronx opioid courts and in former correctional or mental health facilities.
Drug court judges, prosecutors and defense attorneys
They would handle sentencing agreements for the new diversion option, while defendants who relapse twice in another drug court treatment program would face referral to the facility or incarceration.
- Likely support
Department of Corrections and Community Supervision and corrections officers
The department would support facility operations and arrange security staffing, with officers assigned to maintain order and deter residents from fleeing.
Headline styles
Opioid Rehab Instead of Prison
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Held for consideration in alcoholism and drug abuse
- Referred to alcoholism and drug abuse
- Referred to alcoholism and drug abuse
Full text
14 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
4146
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN ASSEMBLY
February 10, 2023
Introduced by M. of A. LEMONDES -- read once and referred to the Committee on Alcoholism and Drug Abuse
AN ACT to amend the mental hygiene law, in relation to the establishment and operations of a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility and the personal needs allowance for residents of a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility; to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to the diversion of certain defendants to a mandatory opioid rehabilitation facility; and to amend the correction law, in relation to the establishment of a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility and the provision of corrections officers to such facilities
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as "the Jessica Nicole Gentile law".
§ 2. Legislative intent. (a) Opioid addiction is a chronic disease that can cause major health, social and economic problems. Opioids are a class of drugs that act in the nervous system to produce feelings of pleasure and pain relief. Some opioids are legally prescribed by health care providers to manage severe and chronic pain. Commonly prescribed opioids include oxycodone, fentanyl, buprenorphine, methadone, oxymorphone, hydrocodone, codeine, and morphine. Other opioids, such as heroin, are illegal drugs of abuse.
Opioid addiction is characterized by a powerful, compulsive urge to use opioid drugs, even if or when they are no longer required medically. Opioids have a high potential for causing addiction in some people, even when the medications are prescribed appropriately and taken as directed. Many prescription opioids are misused or diverted to others. Individuals who become addicted may prioritize getting and using these drugs over other activities in their lives, often negatively impacting their professional and personal relationships. It is unknown why some people are more likely to become addicted than others.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD01335-01-3
Opioids change the chemistry of the brain and lead to drug tolerance, which means that over time the dose needs to be increased to achieve the same effect. Taking opioids over a long period of time produces dependence, such that when people stop taking the drug, they have physical and psychological symptoms of withdrawal (such as muscle cramping, diarrhea and anxiety). Dependence is not the same thing as addiction; although everyone who takes opioids for an extended period will become dependent, only a small percentage also experience the compulsive, continuing need for the drug that characterizes addiction.
Opioid addiction can cause life-threatening health problems, including the risk of overdose. Overdose occurs when high doses of opioids cause breathing to slow or stop, leading to unconsciousness and death if the overdose is not treated immediately. Both legal and illegal opioids carry a risk of overdose if a person takes too much of the drug, or if opioids are combined with other drugs (particularly tranquilizers called benzodiazepines).
In many cases, addiction requires a gateway drug. Gateway drugs are substances that, when consumed, give way to harder, more dangerous drugs. These milder substances, such as nicotine or alcohol, are believed to open the door to the use of drugs such as meth, heroin and cocaine, which can lead to addiction. Opioid abuse does not always entail prior use of a gateway drug as opioids themselves are gateway drugs.
Opioid abuse, along with the resulting overdose deaths, has risen to the point of being one of the worst drug epidemics in the history of the United States. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) more than 750,000 people have died since 1999 from a drug overdose. Two out of three drug overdose deaths in 2018 involved an opioid. The CDC reports that opioids were involved in more than 47,600 overdose deaths in 2017 alone.
Rarely do people abusing or addicted to opioids seek treatment for their addiction problems until they run into problems with the law. According to research, opioid abusers do not believe that quitting is even an option, as the addiction is so powerful, they cannot even comprehend being free of it. For the most part, there are no volunteers in current opioid recovery programs, just forced participants ordered into the programs by the court. This makes the legal system, in particular the drug courts, an important part of this societal mental health crisis.
(b) New York state leads the nation in the expansion and implementation of drug courts into daily court operations.
Drug courts use a collaborative approach to treatment involving defense attorneys, prosecutors, treatment and education providers, and law enforcement officials. Article 216 of the criminal procedure law authorizes a criminal drug court to divert eligible felony offenders into substance abuse treatment programs in lieu of incarceration in a correctional facility. Non-violent offenders voluntarily enter the program in which rules are clearly defined and a contract between the offender, attorneys, the district attorney and the court is signed.
There are 141 drug courts in operation statewide. Defendants facing certain felony or misdemeanor charges where drug addiction is a component of their offense may be eligible to participate in a criminal drug treatment court program. Those who successfully complete their drug treatment court program may have their charges dismissed or reduced or may receive a reduction in their sentence.
Young adult drug treatment courts are operational in several of the criminal courts. These courts target defendants in the 16- to 21-year-old population.
In 2017, New York state opened the first opioid court in the nation. The Buffalo Opioid Intervention Court provides immediate intervention, treatment and medication for defendants who screen positive for opioids and who staff feel are at risk of overdose or addiction. The University of Buffalo School of Family Medicine (UBFM), a grant partner, contributes key staff positions. Those staff members provide daily case management for program participants and link those participants to medication assisted treatment (MAT) within 48 hours of arraignment when indicated.
In the Bronx, which has one of the highest number of opioid-related overdoses and deaths in the state, the Bronx Opioid Avoidance and Recovery Court is a collaboration between the court, prosecutors, and the defense bar. Defendants charged with misdemeanor drug possession are diverted to existing treatment services. Because only misdemeanor offenders are eligible, charges are generally dismissed upon completion of the recommended intervention.
Results from these diversion treatment programs have been positive. A 2003 study of six drug courts conducted by the Center for Court Innovation demonstrated that the rates at which drug court graduates re-offend were significantly reduced as compared to rates at which incarcerated individuals re-offended. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an additional treatment option is required.
Unfortunately, a percentage of defendants passing through drug courts and their treatment options have a difficult time remaining free of drugs after completing treatment, particularly those individuals who abuse or are addicted to opioids. As the American Medical Association has declared substance abuse a disease, it can be assumed some people are sicker than others. After completing treatment in a rehabilitation program and returning into society, usually in the same town where their drug contacts were, these individuals have a difficult time remaining drug-free.
The current model of drug court will tolerate relapse after relapse, to a certain point. When judges get weary of these chronically addicted defendants, they place them directly into the criminal system of the court to serve prison time. There is no middle ground between "drug court" rehabilitation referral and "criminal court system" incarceration. Once in the criminal court system, each opioid abuser or addict will cost the state approximately $65,000 to $80,000 a year (the average cost of maintaining a prisoner). The recidivism rate for those sentenced to prison is approximately 45%.
The cost of maintaining long-term or even lifelong inmates in prison and the destruction of many lives could be reduced by adding an option to the system between drug court and the criminal system: a mandatory state-run opioid rehabilitation center, where people could voluntarily sign away their right to leave for one year or longer in exchange for not being put into the prison system. In other words, a lock-up treatment center.
This approach stands in contrast to current rehabilitation referral measures which entail outpatient treatment or residential treatment for limited periods of time. For some individuals, rehabilitation options are determined by their insurance plan, not their actual needs.
A state-run residential rehabilitation center would provide drug court judges with another alternative to criminal court. It would provide ongoing treatment over an extended period of time; participants would not be released until health care providers believed they could successfully refrain from drug use. Drug court judges would have another alternative to criminal court. They would no longer have to tolerate relapse after relapse. Participants would benefit from an environment where recovery would be easier for them.
(c) The legislature finds and declares that it is in the best interest of the people of the state of New York to reduce the burden on the drug courts, the cost to the state and the amount of time needed by the judicial system to handle drug cases by referring opioid-abusing or opioidaddicted criminal defendants to a facility under the supervision of the Office of Addiction Services and Supports, while at the same time providing desperately needed treatment to such individuals. As opposed to incarceration, a mental health response is more likely to reduce recidivism, saving both lives and taxpayer money.
§ 3. The mental hygiene law is amended by adding a new article 23 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 23
DEDICATED OPIOID REHABILITATION TREATMENT FACILITY Section 23.01 Definitions.
23.02 Establishment of a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facili-
ty.
23.03 Dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility.
23.04 Admission to a dedicated opioid rehabilitation treatment
facility.
23.05 Referral to a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility by
an opioid court.
23.06 Sentencing agreement.
23.07 Minors.
23.08 Discharge from a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility.
23.09 Treatment following discharge from a dedicated opioid
rehabilitation facility.
23.10 Court appearances.
23.11 Records.
23.12 Limitations.
23.13 Study. § 23.01 Definitions.
As used in this article:
1. "commissioner" means the commissioner of the office of addiction services and supports;
2. "correctional institution" includes state, county and federal institutions or facilities of corrections and juvenile facilities;
3. "court" or "drug court" means a state drug court, a young adult drug treatment court, the Buffalo Opioid Intervention Court and the Bronx Opioid Avoidance and Recovery Court;
4. "dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility" or "facility" means a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility established pursuant to section 23.02 of this article;
5. "defendant" means an individual referred to a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility pursuant to an agreement entered into in drug court;
6. "eligible defendant" means a defendant who qualifies as an eligible defendant as defined in section 216.00 of the criminal procedure law;
7. "licensed health care provider" means an individual licensed pursuant to title eight of the education law;
8. "minor" means a defendant at least sixteen years of age, but under eighteen years of age, but does not include a person who is the parent of a child or has married or who is emancipated; and
9. "office" means the office of addiction services and supports. § 23.02 Establishment of a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility.
1. The commissioner of addiction services and supports, in consultation with the commissioner of health, the commissioner of corrections and community supervision, the chief administrator of the courts and the commissioner of the office of general services, shall establish a dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility for the purpose of providing longterm residential treatment of opioid abusing or addicted defendants referred to such facility from a drug court.
2. Such facility shall be operated and supervised by the office of addiction services and supports, with support from the department of corrections and community supervision.
3. Such facility shall be a secured (locked) facility established for the purpose of providing long-term residential treatment of opioid abuse and opioid addiction as an alternative to incarceration.
4. In selecting the location of the facility, preference shall be given to a site near the Buffalo Opioid Intervention Court or the Bronx Opioid Avoidance and Recovery Court and to facilities previously utilized as part of the corrections system or the mental health system. Consideration shall be given to the mental health resources available in the area of the site. § 23.03 Dedicated opioid rehabilitation facility.
1. A dedicated opioid rehabilitation treatment facility shall be a secure (locked) facility.
2. Staff at the facility shall include, but not be limited to:
(a) qualified and licensed health care providers, counselors and support staff as determined by the office;
(b) administrative, maintenance, custodial and other staff as determined by the office; and
(c) corrections officers, in a number as agreed upon by the office and the department of corrections and community supervision sufficient to maintain order and remove the temptation of defendants residing at the facility to flee.
3. Living quarters for defendants referred to the facility shall be arranged in dormitories housing between four and six defendants.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.