What's happening
This bill creates impartial, randomly assigned pools of doctors for utilization reviews and independent medical exams, with conflict-of-interest rules and regular audits.
Why it matters
Reduces risk of biased medical decisions. By mandating random assignment of doctors from impartial pools, the bill aims to minimize the influence of insurance companies, employers, or claimants over who reviews or examines cases, which can help ensure more neutral and credible outcomes for patients and workers.
Strengthens conflict-of-interest safeguards. The bill expands what counts as a conflict of interest and requires disclosure of financial or professional ties that might compromise a reviewer’s objectivity, giving parties a formal mechanism to challenge potentially biased examiners.
Increases accountability and transparency. Regular, random audits of utilization review agents and independent medical examiners—with potential removal from the pool for repeated deficiencies—create ongoing oversight, incentivizing higher standards and deterring rubber-stamp or careless reviews.
Empowers both patients and insurers. By allowing both parties to reject up to two names from the randomly generated pool, the process respects the interests of all sides while preventing “doctor shopping” and ensuring both parties have some input without undermining impartiality.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Require Fair Medical Reviewers
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Enacting clause stricken
- Referred to insurance
- Referred to insurance
Full text
8 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
7730
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN ASSEMBLY
June 6, 2023
Introduced by M. of A. JOYNER -- read once and referred to the Committee on Insurance
AN ACT to amend the public health law, the insurance law and the workers' compensation law, in relation to utilization review agents and independent medical examiners
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 206 of the public health law is amended by adding two new subdivisions 32 and 33 to read as follows:
32. The commissioner is hereby directed to establish and periodically update from available applicants an independent pool of physicians and professional health service providers in each medical and professional health service specialty to serve as independent utilization review agents as defined by subdivision nine of section forty-nine hundred of this chapter. Such applicant shall, upon submitting their name to the commissioner, certify in writing that they will make all decisions on cases before them in a fair and unbiased manner, based upon the facts presented to them, and without any preconceived bias, pressure or influences asserted from outside elements or prior experiences or work. A licensed physician shall presume to be eligible to apply for inclusion in the pool, unless the commissioner finds extenuating circumstances dictate their disqualification.
33. (a) The commissioner shall assign physicians or other professional health service providers authorized to examine or evaluate injury or illness from the pool in the appropriate medical or professional health service specialty and who practices in the same area or region, to conduct physical examinations and review medical records of covered persons exclusively on a random, rotating basis to eliminate bias or preference in the selection of independent utilization review agents, or alternatively, the commissioner may select a not-for-profit organization to assign providers from the pool on the same basis. Such assignment may
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD10457-01-3
be done through a process whereby a list of randomly selected, appropriate medical or professional health service providers is compiled by geographic region throughout the state and provided to the insurance carrier and the claimant for the purposes of providing both parties equal opportunity to reject no more than two names off such list before the next available utilization review agent on the list is selected to conduct the medical examination or review of medical records. Where a person is rejected by either party such name shall however retain its place in the rotation for purposes of future assignments.
(b) When a utilization review agent is selected from the pool of qualified utilization review agents maintained by the department, the commissioner shall remove such assignee from its then current place in the rotation and place such agent's name at the end of the pool so that such agent may be available for another regional utilization review agent assignment as needed.
(c) A practitioner is not eligible to perform a utilization review of a covered person when the appearance of or an actual conflict of interest exists. A conflict of interest shall include, but not be limited to, instances where the utilization review agent or someone in their office or place of employment or practice has treated or examined the covered person. A conflict of interest may be presumed to exist when the utilization review agent and a treating provider that previously treated the covered person have a relationship which involves a direct or substantial financial interest.
(d) A utilization review agent shall not become the treating provider for the covered person unless authorized to do so by the commissioner, or ordered to by an administrative law judge.
(e) A party may, within five business days of the appointment as a utilization review agent for a particular covered person, request that the utilization review agent disclose all potential conflicts of interest to the commissioner that may result from any relationship between the utilization review agent and the insurance carrier, self-insured employer, or the covered person. A potential conflict of interest exists when the utilization review agent, or someone in their immediate family, receives something of material value from the insurance carrier whether in the form of stock, royalties, consultantship, funding by a research grant, or other payment by the insurance carrier for any additional service other than the utilization review, or if the utilization review agent receives more than fifty percent of his or her total earned income by providing utilization reviews. Such request shall be submitted, in writing, to the commissioner and a copy shall be sent, delivered, or submitted to any other parties at substantially the same time. The commissioner shall determine whether any conflict of interest is sufficiently material as to require disqualification of the utilization review agent from performing any utilization review under this article, after prompt disclosure pursuant to this subdivision.
§ 2. Subdivision 2 of section 4902 of the public health law, as added by chapter 705 of the laws of 1996, is amended to read as follows:
2. Each utilization review agent shall assure adherence to the requirements stated in subdivision one of this section by all contractors, subcontractors, subvendors, agents and employees affiliated by contract or otherwise with such utilization review agent, and shall conduct all reviews in an objective and impartial manner. Utilization review agents shall have their records randomly reviewed and audited periodically by the commissioner. The commissioner shall be authorized to conduct a random review of no more than five utilization review agent records during an agent's registration period. If, in the opinion of the commissioner, three or more of the agent's records and documentation out of the five records that may be audited annually are judged to be deficient, the commissioner shall be authorized to audit additional records during such registration period and shall be authorized to institute a remedial program prior to the expiration of the registrant's current registration period. If during any two consecutive annual audit periods an agent's records and documentation are judged to be deficient in spite of any program of remedial action directed on the part of the commissioner, the commissioner may remove the utilization review agent from the pool of names available to conduct utilization reviews. Once a registrant's name has been removed from the pool, in order to re-register as an agent the registrant shall seek authorization in accordance with this chapter and in the same manner as a practitioner who has not previously been authorized.
§ 3. The insurance law is amended by adding a new section 4901-a to read as follows:
§ 4901-a. Impartiality of utilization review agents. (a) The superintendent is hereby directed to establish and periodically update from available applicants an independent pool of physicians and professional health service providers in each medical and professional health service specialty to serve as independent utilization review agents as defined by subsection (i) of section forty-nine hundred of this title. Such applicant shall, upon submitting their name to the superintendent, certify in writing that they will make all decisions on cases before them in a fair and unbiased manner, based upon the facts presented to them, and without any preconceived bias, pressure or influences asserted from outside elements or prior experiences or work. A licensed physician shall presume to be eligible to apply for inclusion in the pool, unless the superintendent finds extenuating circumstances dictate their disqualification.
(b)(1) The superintendent shall assign physicians or other professional health service providers authorized to examine or evaluate injury or illness from the pool in the appropriate medical or professional health service specialty and who practices in the same area or region to conduct physical examinations and review medical records of covered persons exclusively on a random, rotating basis to eliminate bias or preference in the selection of the independent utilization review agents, or alternatively, the superintendent may select a not-for-profit organization to assign providers from the pool on the same basis. Such assignment may be done through a process whereby a list of randomly selected, appropriate medical or professional health service providers is compiled by geographic region throughout the state and provided to the insurance carrier and the claimant for the purposes of providing both parties equal opportunity to reject no more than two names off such list until one utilization review agent remains to conduct the medical examination or review of medical records. When a person is rejected by either party such name shall however retain its place in the rotation for purposes of future assignments.
(2) When a utilization review agent is selected from the pool of qualified utilization review agents maintained by the department, the superintendent shall remove such utilization review agent's name from its then current place in the rotation and place such agent's name at the end of the pool so that such agent may be available for another regional utilization review agent assignment as needed.
(3) A practitioner is not eligible to perform a utilization review of a covered person when the appearance of or an actual conflict of interest exists. A conflict of interest shall include, but not be limited to, instances where the utilization review agent or someone in their office or place of employment or practice has treated or examined the covered person. A conflict of interest may be presumed to exist when the utilization review agent and a treating provider that previously treated the covered person have a relationship which involves a direct or substantial financial interest.
(4) A utilization review agent shall not become the treating provider for the covered person unless authorized to do so by the commissioner of health, or ordered to by an administrative law judge.
(5) A party may, within five business days of the appointment as a utilization review agent for a particular covered person, request that the utilization review agent disclose all potential conflicts of interest to the superintendent that may result from any relationship between the utilization review agent and the insurance carrier, self-insured employer, or the covered person. A potential conflict of interest exists when the utilization review agent, or someone in their immediate family, receives something of material value from the insurance carrier whether in the form of stock, royalties, consultantship, funding by a research grant, or other payment by the insurance carrier for any additional service other than the utilization review, or if the utilization review agent receives more than fifty percent of his or her total earned income by providing utilization reviews. Such request shall be submitted, in writing, to the superintendent and a copy shall be sent, delivered, or submitted to any other parties at substantially the same time. The superintendent shall determine whether any conflict of interest is sufficiently material as to require disqualification of the utilization review agent from performing any utilization review under this article, after prompt disclosure pursuant to this subdivision.
§ 4. Subsection (b) of section 4902 of the insurance law, as added by chapter 705 of the laws of 1996, is amended to read as follows:
(b) Each utilization review agent shall assure adherence to the requirements stated in subsection (a) of this section by all contractors, subcontractors, subvendors, agents and employees affiliated by contract or otherwise with such utilization review agent, and shall conduct all reviews in an objective and impartial manner.
§ 5. Section 4902 of the insurance law is amended by adding two new subsections (c) and (d) to read as follows:
(c) Utilization review agents shall have their records randomly reviewed and audited periodically by both the superintendent of financial services and the commissioner of health. The superintendent and commissioner shall be authorized to conduct a random review of no more than five utilization review records annually during a utilization review agent's registration period. If, in the opinion of the superintendent and commissioner, three or more of the utilization review agent's records and documentation out of the five records that may be audited annually are judged to be deficient, such superintendent and commissioner shall be authorized to audit additional records during such registration period and shall be authorized to institute a remedial program prior to the expiration of the registrant's current registration period. If during any two consecutive annual audit periods a utilization review agent's records and documentation are judged to be deficient in spite of any program of remedial action directed on the part of the superintendent and commissioner, they may remove the utilization review agent from the pool of names available to conduct utilization reviews. Once a registrant's name has been removed from the pool, in order to re-register as a utilization review agent the registrant shall seek authorization in accordance with this article and in the same manner as a practitioner who has not previously been authorized.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.