Skip to content
A9322Assembly2023-2024 Session

Hold Car Owners Liable

Official title

“Relates to owner liability for failure of operator to stop for a school bus displaying a red visual signal and stop-arm”

Sponsor William MagnarelliAD-129+1 co-sponsorAffects Transportation
Status
In Assembly Committee
Transportation
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Transportation

What's happening

This bill extends and updates the authority for New York localities to use school bus camera systems to enforce and penalize illegal passing of stopped school buses, with new administrative procedures, cost provisions, and privacy protections, and extends the program through 2029.

Why it matters

  1. Clearer financial responsibilities and program suspension for non-payment. The bill explicitly requires that all costs for installing and maintaining school bus camera systems be paid by the local government (county, city, town, or village), not the school district. If payment is not made on time, the camera enforcement program is automatically suspended in that locality until the payment is received—creating a strong incentive for timely compliance and ensuring school districts are not financially burdened.

  2. New administrative hearing and appeal process. Localities are authorized to set up their own administrative hearings for disputed violations, with a simplified "substantial evidence" standard and clear deadlines for decisions. If a locality does not provide this process, or after a decision is made, vehicle owners have the right to seek adjudication in a traditional traffic court, increasing due process protections and clarity for ticketed drivers.

  3. Expanded privacy and signage rules with “reasonable effort” clauses. The law strengthens privacy requirements for images captured by cameras and mandates destruction of data after its use. However, it now specifies that violations will not be dismissed solely because identifying details (like vehicle interiors) are visible, as long as the locality made a reasonable effort to comply with privacy safeguards. It also moves the signage requirement out of the privacy section and makes clear that tickets stand if reasonable efforts to install warning signs were made, thus balancing privacy and enforcement.

  4. Clarifies intergovernmental cooperation and limits on agreements. The bill clarifies which local governments can enter into agreements with school districts for camera use, sets boundaries for overlapping jurisdictions, and prevents double-coverage or confusion in large cities—making implementation more orderly and reducing bureaucratic disputes.

  5. These changes matter because they not only extend the duration of the school bus camera enforcement program, but also refine the financial, administrative, privacy, and intergovernmental frameworks, aiming to make the program fairer, more efficient, and more legally robust for all parties involved.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Hold Car Owners Liable

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
William Magnarelli

Assembly Member · Assembly District 129

Chair, Transportation

1 Co-sponsor

History

  1. Referred to transportation

Full text

9 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

9322

IN ASSEMBLY

February 29, 2024

Introduced by M. of A. MAGNARELLI -- read once and referred to the Committee on Transportation

AN ACT to amend the vehicle and traffic law and the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to owner liability for failure of operator to stop for a school bus displaying a red visual signal and stop-arm; and to amend chapter 145 of the laws of 2019 amending the vehicle and traffic law relating to school bus photo violation monitoring systems and owner liability for failure of operator to stop for a school bus displaying a red visual signal, in relation to the effectiveness thereof

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 1174-a of the vehicle and traffic law, as added by chapter 145 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:

§ 1174-a. Owner liability for failure of operator to stop for a school bus displaying a red visual signal and stop-arm. (a) 1. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a county, city, town or village located within a school district ("district") is hereby authorized and empowered to adopt and amend a local law or ordinance establishing a demonstration program imposing monetary liability on the owner of a vehicle for failure of an operator thereof to comply with section eleven hundred seventy-four of this [chapter] article when meeting a school bus marked and equipped as provided in subdivisions twenty and twenty-one-c of section three hundred seventy-five of this chapter and operated in such county, city, town or village, in accordance with the provisions of this section. Such demonstration program shall empower such county, city, town or village to install and operate school bus photo violation monitoring systems which may be stationary or mobile, and which may be installed, pursuant to an agreement with a school district within such county, city, town or village, on school buses owned and operated by such school district or privately owned and operated for compensation under contract with such district. Provided, however, that (a) no stationary school bus photo violation monitoring system shall be installed or operated by a county, city, town or village except on roadways under the jurisdiction of such county, city, town or village, and (b) no mobile school bus photo violation monitoring system shall be installed or operated on any such school buses unless such county, city,

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD14558-01-4

town or village and such district enter into an agreement for such installation and operation.

1-a. Any county, city, town or village, [located within a school district,] that has adopted a local law or ordinance pursuant to this section establishing a demonstration program imposing liability on the owner of a vehicle for failure of an operator thereof to comply with section eleven hundred seventy-four of this [chapter] article when meeting a school bus marked and equipped as provided in subdivisions twenty and twenty-one-c of section three hundred seventy-five of this chapter and operated in such county, city, town or village may enter into an agreement with [the applicable] a school district that operates school buses within the county, city, town or village for the installation, maintenance and use of school bus photo violation monitoring systems on school buses pursuant to this section and section twenty-two of [the] chapter one hundred forty-five of the laws of two thousand nineteen [which added this section], for the proper handling and custody of photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data produced by such systems, and for the forwarding of such photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data to the applicable county, city, town or village. Any agreement entered into hereunder shall be approved by each participating county, city, town or village by a majority vote of the voting strength of its governing body and by resolution of the district pursuant to section sixteen hundred four, section seventeen hundred nine, section twenty-five hundred three, section twenty-five hundred fifty-four or section twenty-five hundred ninety-h of the education law, as applicable. Provided, however, that where a district has entered an agreement as provided hereunder with a county, no cities, towns or villages within the same county may enter into, or be a party to, any agreement with such district pursuant to this section. Provided further, however, that no county shall enter into an agreement with any city school district [wholly contained within a city] in a city with a population over one million. Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent a county, city, town, village or district at any time to withdraw from or terminate an agreement entered pursuant to this section and section twenty-two of [the] chapter one hundred forty-five of the laws of 2019 [which added this section].

1-b. A county, city, town or village that has adopted a local law or ordinance pursuant to this section that has entered into an agreement with a school district located within such county, city, town or village, may enforce section eleven hundred seventy-four of this article pursuant to this section within its boundaries without necessitating additional agreements with overlapping jurisdictions.

1-c. The total cost to the district of the installation, maintenance and use of school bus photo violation monitoring systems pursuant to this section shall be borne entirely by the county, city, town or village within the district which is a party to such agreement. On or before September first of each year, the district shall determine and certify to each county, city, town or village with which it has entered into an agreement pursuant to this section the total cost to the district for the school year ending the preceding June thirtieth of installing, maintaining and using such systems within each such county, city, town or village, respectively, for the proper handling and custody of photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data produced by such systems, and for the forwarding of such photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data to the applicable county, city, town or village. On or before the following December first of each year, each such county, city, town or village shall pay to the district such cost so certified to it on or before the preceding September first. Not later than twenty days after each such payment is submitted or is due, whichever occurs first, the district shall submit to the director of the budget and the chairpersons of the fiscal committees of the legislature a report for each such county, city, town and village showing the amount of costs so certified and the amount of payments so received or due. If a county, city, town or village fails to make the payment required to the district by the twentieth day after the date such payment was due, (i) the district shall notify the director of the budget and the chairpersons of the fiscal committees of the legislature of such occurrence within twenty-four hours of such day; and (ii) the demonstration program shall be suspended within such county, city, town, or village until such time as such county, city, town, or village makes the payment required to the district. The district shall notify the director of the budget and the chairpersons of the fiscal committees of the legislature of such payment within seven business days of its receipt. Provided, however, that any notice of liability issued prior to such date shall not be voided.

2. Any image or images captured by school bus photo violation monitoring systems shall be inadmissible in any disciplinary proceeding convened by any school district or any school bus contractor thereof, and any proceeding initiated by the department involving licensure privileges of school bus operators. Any school bus photo violation monitoring device mounted on a school bus shall be directed outwardly from such school bus to capture images of vehicles operated in violation of section eleven hundred seventy-four of this [chapter] article, and images produced by such device shall not be used for any other purpose.

3. (i) Any participating school district shall be prohibited from accessing any photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images or data from school bus photo violation monitoring systems but shall provide, pursuant to an agreement with a county, city, town or village as provided in this section, for the proper handling and custody of such photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data produced by such systems, and for the forwarding of such photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data to the applicable county, city, town or village for the purpose of determining whether a motor vehicle was operated in violation of subdivision (a) of section eleven hundred seventy-four of this [title] article and imposing monetary liability on the owner of such motor vehicle therefor.

(ii) Photographs, microphotographs, videotapes, other recorded images and data produced by school bus photo violation monitoring systems shall be destroyed (A) ninety days after the date of the alleged imposition of liability if a notice of liability is not issued for such alleged imposition of liability pursuant to this section or (B) upon final disposition of a notice of liability issued pursuant to this section.

4. A county, city, town or village establishing a demonstration program pursuant to this section shall adopt and enforce measures to protect the privacy of drivers, passengers, pedestrians and cyclists whose identity and identifying information may be captured by a school bus photo violation monitoring device. Provided, however, that no notice of liability issued pursuant to this section shall be dismissed solely because a photograph or photographs allow for the identification of the contents of a vehicle, provided that such county, city, town or village has made a reasonable effort to comply with the provisions of this paragraph. Such measures shall include:

(i) utilization of necessary technologies to ensure, to the extent practicable, that photographs produced by such school bus photo violation monitoring systems shall not include images that identify the driver, the passengers, the contents of the vehicle, pedestrians and cyclists[. Provided, however, that no notice of liability issued pursuant to this section shall be dismissed solely because a photograph or photographs allow for the identification of the contents of a vehicle, provided that such county, city, town or village has made a reasonable effort to comply with the provisions of this paragraph];

(ii) a prohibition on the use or dissemination of vehicles' license plate information and other information and images captured by school bus photo violation monitoring systems except: (A) as required to establish liability under this section or collect payment of penalties; (B) as required by court order; or (C) as otherwise required by law; and

(iii) [the installation of signage in conformance with standards established in the MUTCD at each roadway entrance of the jurisdictional boundaries of such county, city, town or village giving notice that school bus photo violation monitoring systems are used to enforce restrictions on vehicles violating section eleven hundred seventy-four of this chapter. For the purposes of this paragraph, the term "roadway" shall not include state expressway routes or state interstate routes but shall include controlled-access highway exit ramps that enter the jurisdictional boundaries of a county, city, town or village; and

(iv)] oversight procedures to ensure compliance with the aforementioned privacy protection measures.

5. A county, city, town or village establishing a demonstration program pursuant to this section shall install signage in conformance with standards established in the MUTCD at each roadway entrance of the jurisdictional boundaries of such county, city, town or village giving notice that school bus photo violation monitoring systems are used to enforce restrictions on vehicles violating section eleven hundred seventy-four of this article. For the purposes of this paragraph, the term "roadway" shall not include state expressway routes or state interstate routes but shall include controlled-access highway exit ramps that enter the jurisdictional boundaries of a county, city, town or village. Provided, however, that no notice of liability issued pursuant to this section shall be dismissed if such county, city, town or village has made a reasonable effort to comply with the provisions of this paragraph.

(b) In any such county, city, town or village which has adopted a local law or ordinance pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section, the owner of a vehicle shall be liable for a penalty imposed pursuant to this section if such vehicle was used or operated with the permission of the owner, express or implied, in violation of subdivision (a) of section eleven hundred seventy-four of this article, and such violation is evidenced by information obtained from a school bus photo violation monitoring system; provided however that no owner of a vehicle shall be liable for a penalty imposed pursuant to this section where the operator of such vehicle has been convicted of the underlying violation of subdivision (a) of section eleven hundred seventy-four of this article.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.