What's happening
The bill requires New York state agencies to conduct oversight, impact assessments, and maintain human review for automated decision-making systems affecting individuals' rights or benefits.
Why it matters
Requires agencies to justify and regularly reassess automated systems. By mandating detailed impact assessments before and during the use of automated decision-making, the bill forces agencies to continuously evaluate whether these systems are working as intended, are free from bias, and are not causing harm—pushing for higher transparency and accountability.
Protects individuals from unchecked algorithmic harm. The law ensures that no automated system can make critical decisions affecting people's rights or benefits without real human oversight, reducing the risk of computer errors, discrimination, or impersonal denials that can severely impact lives.
Guards public sector employees from job loss due to automation. The legislation explicitly prohibits state agencies from using automated systems to displace workers, reduce hours, or erode union protections—addressing concerns that automation could undermine public sector jobs and collective bargaining agreements.
Demands public and legislative transparency. By requiring disclosure of all automated systems in use, publication of impact assessments, and submission of these documents to state leadership, the bill empowers public and legislative scrutiny, making it harder for agencies to quietly deploy potentially harmful or biased technologies.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
State agencies and public authorities
They would face human-review requirements for covered automated decisions, recurring impact assessments and public reporting, and would have to stop using systems found to produce biased or discriminatory outcomes.
State employees and public-sector unions
The bill would prohibit automated systems from displacing workers, reducing non-overtime hours, wages or benefits, taking over employee duties or impairing collective bargaining agreements.
Recipients of state public assistance benefits
Automated decisions affecting covered benefits would require ongoing review by trained people with authority to approve, deny or modify those decisions.
Government software vendors
Agencies could not acquire covered automated decision-making systems without ongoing meaningful human review, and disclosures of existing systems would have to identify related software vendors.
Headline styles
Monitor Government AI Decisions
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Substituted by S7543B
- Ordered to third reading rules cal.459
- Rules report cal.459
- Reported
- Amend and recommit to rules 9430b
- Reported referred to rules
- Print number 9430a
- Amend and recommit to science and technology
- Referred to science and technology
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Limit AI in Government
Signed by Governor · Sponsor Kristen Gonzalez
Full text
4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
9430--B
IN ASSEMBLY
March 14, 2024
Introduced by M. of A. OTIS, SANTABARBARA, REYES, HEVESI, L. ROSENTHAL, SLATER -- read once and referred to the Committee on Science and Technology -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee -- reported and referred to the Committee on Rules -- Rules Committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to the Committee on Rules
AN ACT to amend the state technology law, in relation to automated decision-making by state agencies
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "legislative oversight of automated decision-making in government act (LOADinG Act)".
§ 2. The state technology law is amended by adding a new article 4 to read as follows:
ARTICLE IV
AUTOMATED DECISION-MAKING IN STATE GOVERNMENT Section 401. Definitions.
402. Use of automated decision-making systems by agencies.
403. Impact assessments.
404. Submission to the governor and legislature.
§ 401. Definitions. For the purpose of this article:
1. "Automated decision-making system" shall mean any software that uses algorithms, computational models, or artificial intelligence techniques, or a combination thereof, to automate, support, or replace human decision-making and shall include, without limitation, systems that process data, and apply predefined rules or machine learning algorithms to analyze such data, and generate conclusions, recommendations, outcomes, assumptions, projections, or predictions without meaningful human discretion. "Automated decision-making system" shall not include any software used primarily for basic computerized processes, such as calculators, spellcheck tools, autocorrect functions, spreadsheets, electronic communications, or any tool that relates only to internal management affairs such as ordering office supplies or processing
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD11734-10-4
payments, and that do not materially affect the rights, liberties, benefits, safety or welfare of any individual within the state.
2. "Meaningful human review" means review, oversight and control of the automated decision-making process by one or more individuals who understand the risks, limitations, and functionality of, and are trained to use, the automated decision-making system and who have the authority to intervene or alter the decision under review, including but not limited to the ability to approve, deny, or modify any decision recommended or made by the automated system.
3. "State agency" shall mean any department, public authority, board, bureau, commission, division, office, council, committee or officer of the state. Such terms shall not include the legislature or judiciary.
4. "Public assistance benefit" shall mean any service or program within the control of the state, or benefit provided by the state to individuals or households, including but not limited to public assistance, cash assistance, grants, child care assistance, housing assistance, unemployment benefits, transportation benefits, education assistance, domestic violence services, and any other assistance or benefit within the authority of the state to grant to individuals within the state. This shall not include any federal program that is administered by the federal government or the state.
§ 402. Use of automated decision-making systems by agencies. 1. No state agency, or any entity acting on behalf of such agency, which utilizes or applies any automated decision-making system, directly or indirectly, in performing any function that: (a) is related to the delivery of any public assistance benefit; (b) will have a material impact on the rights, civil liberties, safety or welfare of any individual within the state; or (c) affects any statutorily or constitutionally provided right of an individual, shall utilize such automated decisionmaking system, unless such automated decision-making system is subject to continued and operational meaningful human review.
2. No state agency shall authorize any procurement, purchase or acquisition of any service or system utilizing, or relying on, automated decision-making systems in performing any function that is: (a) related to the delivery of any public assistance benefit; (b) will have a material impact on the rights, civil liberties, safety or welfare of any individual within the state; or (c) affects any statutorily or constitutionally provided right of an individual unless such automated decision-making system is subject to continued and operational meaningful human review.
3. The use of an automated decision-making system shall not affect (a) the existing rights of employees pursuant to an existing collective bargaining agreement, or (b) the existing representational relationships among employee organizations or the bargaining relationships between the employer and an employee organization. The use of an automated decision-making system shall not result in the: (1) discharge, displacement or loss of position, including partial displacement such as a reduction in the hours of non-overtime work, wages, or employment benefits, or result in the impairment of existing collective bargaining agreements; (2) transfer of existing duties and functions currently performed by employees of the state or any agency or public authority thereof to an automated decision-making system; or (3) transfer of future duties and functions ordinarily performed by employees of the state or any agency or public authority. The use of an automated decision-making system shall not alter the rights or benefits, and privileges, including but not limited to terms and conditions of employment, civil service status, and collective bargaining unit membership status of all existing employees of the state or any agency or public authority thereof shall be preserved and protected.
§ 403. Impact assessments. 1. State agencies seeking to utilize or apply an automated decision-making system permitted under section four hundred two of this article with continued and operational meaningful human review shall conduct or have conducted an impact assessment substantially completed and bearing the signature of one or more individuals responsible for meaningful human review for the lawful application and use of such automated decision-making system. Following the first impact assessment, an impact assessment shall be conducted in accordance with this section at least once every two years. An impact assessment shall be conducted prior to any material change to the automated decision-making system that may change the outcome or effect of such system. Such impact assessments shall include:
(a) a description of the objectives of the automated decision-making system;
(b) an evaluation of the ability of the automated decision-making system to achieve its stated objectives;
(c) a description and evaluation of the objectives and development of the automated decision-making including:
(i) a summary of the underlying algorithms, computational modes, and artificial intelligence tools that are used within the automated decision-making system; and
(ii) the design and training data used to develop the automated decision-making system process;
(d) testing for:
(i) accuracy, fairness, bias and discrimination, and an assessment of whether the use of the automated decision-making system produces discriminatory results on the basis of a consumer's or a class of consumers' actual or perceived race, color, ethnicity, religion, national origin, sex, gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, familial status, biometric information, lawful source of income, or disability and outlines mitigations for any identified performance differences in outcomes across relevant groups impacted by such use;
(ii) any cybersecurity vulnerabilities and privacy risks resulting from the deployment and use of the automated decision-making system, and the development or existence of safeguards to mitigate the risks;
(iii) any public health or safety risks resulting from the deployment and use of the automated decision-making system;
(iv) any reasonably foreseeable misuse of the automated decision-making system and the development or existence of safeguards against such misuse;
(e) the extent to which the deployment and use of the automated decision-making system requires input of sensitive and personal data, how that data is used and stored, and any control users may have over their data; and
(f) the notification mechanism or procedure, if any, by which individuals impacted by the utilization of the automated decision-making system may be notified of the use of such automated decision-making system and of the individual's personal data, and informed of their rights and options relating to such use.
2. Notwithstanding the provisions of this article or any other law, if an impact assessment finds that the automated decision-making system produces discriminatory or biased outcomes, the state agency shall cease any utilization, application, or function of such automated decisionmaking system, and of any information produced using such system.
§ 404. Submission to the governor and legislature. 1. Each impact assessment conducted pursuant to this article shall be submitted to the governor, the temporary president of the senate, and the speaker of the assembly at least thirty days prior to the implementation of the automated decision-making system that is the subject of such assessment.
2. (a) The impact assessment of an automated decision-making system shall be published on the website of the relevant state agency.
(b) If the state agency makes a determination that the disclosure of any information required in the impact assessment would result in a substantial negative impact on health or safety of the public, infringe upon the privacy rights of individuals, or significantly impair the state agency's ability to protect its information technology or operational assets, such state agency may redact such information, provided that an explanatory statement on the process by which the state agency made such determination is published along with the redacted impact assessment.
(c) If the impact assessment covers any automated decision-making system that includes technology that is used to prevent, detect, protect against or respond to security incidents, identity theft, fraud, harassment, malicious or deceptive activities or other illegal activity, preserve the integrity or security of systems, or to investigate, report or prosecute those responsible for any such malicious or deceptive action, such state agency may redact such information for the purposes of this subdivision, provided that an explanatory statement on the process by which the state agency made such determination is published along with the redacted impact assessment.
§ 3. Disclosure of existing automated decision-making systems. Any state agency, that directly or indirectly, utilizes an automated decision-making system, as defined in section 401 of the state technology law, shall submit to the legislature a disclosure on the use of such system, no later than one year after the effective date of this section. Such disclosure shall include:
(a) a description of the automated decision-making system utilized by such agency;
(b) a list of any software vendors related to such automated decision-making system;
(c) the date that the use of such system began;
(d) a summary of the purpose and use of such system, including a description of human decision-making and discretion supported or replaced by the automated decision-making system;
(e) whether any impact assessments for the automated decision-making system were conducted and the dates and summaries of the results of such assessments where applicable; and
(f) any other information deemed relevant by the agency.
§ 4. This act shall take effect immediately, provided that section two of this act shall take effect one year after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.