Skip to content
S1099Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA8923

Protect Kids During Police Questioning

Official title

“Relates to procedures required for the custodial interrogation of children”

Sponsor Jamaal BaileySD-36+31 co-sponsorsAffects Finance
Status
In Senate Committee
Finance
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Finance

What's happening

This bill strengthens protections for juveniles during police interrogations by requiring legal counsel consultation and timely parental notification.

Why it matters

  1. Mandates that juveniles must consult with legal counsel before any police questioning can occur, and explicitly prohibits waiving this consultation. ensuring that young people cannot be interrogated without legal advice, regardless of their or their guardian’s wishes.

  2. Requires immediate parental or guardian notification before transporting a juvenile to a police station. , enhancing timely family involvement and potentially reducing the risk of coercion or misunderstanding during the legal process.

  3. Establishes that any statements made by juveniles without required legal consultation or before parents are properly notified and advised will be automatically suppressed (excluded) from evidence. , raising the standard for admissibility and reducing the likelihood of wrongful or coerced confessions.

  4. Standardizes and clarifies procedures for police interactions with juveniles across multiple laws. , aiming to reduce ambiguity for law enforcement, improve procedural fairness, and promote more consistent protection of minors’ rights statewide.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Protect Kids During Police Questioning

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Reported and committed to finance
  2. Reported and committed to codes
  3. Print number 1099a
  4. Amend and recommit to children and families
  5. Referred to children and families
  6. Reported and committed to finance
  7. Reported and committed to codes
  8. Referred to children and families

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A8923Assembly

Protect Kids During Police Questioning

Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor Andrew Hevesi

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

7 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

1099--A

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 10, 2023

Introduced by Sens. BAILEY, BRESLIN, BRISPORT, BROUK, CLEARE, COMRIE, COONEY, FERNANDEZ, GIANARIS, GONZALEZ, GOUNARDES, HARCKHAM, HINCHEY, HOYLMAN-SIGAL, JACKSON, KAVANAGH, KENNEDY, KRUEGER, LIU, MAY, MAYER, MYRIE, PARKER, RAMOS, RIVERA, SALAZAR, SANDERS,… Show all

Introduced by Sens. BAILEY, BRESLIN, BRISPORT, BROUK, CLEARE, COMRIE, COONEY, FERNANDEZ, GIANARIS, GONZALEZ, GOUNARDES, HARCKHAM, HINCHEY, HOYLMAN-SIGAL, JACKSON, KAVANAGH, KENNEDY, KRUEGER, LIU, MAY, MAYER, MYRIE, PARKER, RAMOS, RIVERA, SALAZAR, SANDERS, SEPULVEDA, SERRANO, STAVISKY, THOMAS, WEBB -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Children and Families -recommitted to the Committee on Children and Families in accordance with Senate Rule 6, sec. 8 -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee

AN ACT to amend the family court act and the criminal procedure law, in relation to the custodial interrogation of juveniles by law enforcement

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 3 of section 305.2 of the family court act, as added by chapter 920 of the laws of 1982, is amended to read as follows:

3. If an officer takes such child into custody or if a child is delivered to him or her under section 305.1, he or she shall immediately, before transporting the child to the police station house, notify the parent or other person legally responsible for the child's care, or if such legally responsible person is unavailable the person with whom the child resides, that the child has been taken into custody.

§ 2. Paragraph (a) of subdivision 4 of section 305.2 of the family court act, as added by chapter 920 of the laws of 1982, is amended to read as follows:

(a) when the officer reasonably believes such parent or other person legally responsible for the child's care will appear, take the child to his or her home, the station house, or another location agreed upon with the parent or person legally responsible, and release the child to the custody of [his parents or other person legally responsible for his care] such person upon the issuance in accordance with section 307.1 of

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD03283-03-4

a family court appearance ticket to the child and the person to whose custody the child is released; or

§ 3. Paragraph (b) of subdivision 4 of section 305.2 of the family court act, as amended by section 63 of part WWW of chapter 59 of the laws of 2017, is amended to read as follows:

(b) when the officer does not reasonably believe the parent or other person legally responsible for the child's care will appear for the child, forthwith and with all reasonable speed take the child directly, and without his or her first being taken to the police station house, to the family court located in the county in which the act occasioning the taking into custody allegedly was committed, or, when the family court is not in session, to the most accessible magistrate, if any, designated by the appellate division of the supreme court in the applicable department to conduct a hearing under section 307.4 [of this part, unless the officer determines that it is necessary to question the child, in which case he or she may take the child to a facility designated by the chief administrator of the courts as a suitable place for the questioning of children or, upon the consent of a parent or other person legally responsible for the care of the child, to the child's residence and there question him or her for a reasonable period of time]; or

§ 4. Paragraph (c) of subdivision 4 of section 305.2 of the family court act, as amended by section 3 of part G of chapter 58 of the laws of 2010, is amended to read as follows:

(c) when the officer does not release the child pursuant to paragraph (a) of this subdivision, or take the child to family court or to a magistrate pursuant to paragraph (b) of this subdivision, take the child to a place certified by the office of children and family services as a juvenile detention facility for the reception of children; or

§ 5. Subdivision 5 of section 305.2 of the family court act, as amended by chapter 398 of the laws of 1983, is amended to read as follows:

5. If such child has allegedly committed a designated felony act as defined in subdivision eight of section 301.2, and the family court in the county is in session, the officer shall forthwith take the child directly to such family court[, unless the officer takes the child to a facility for questioning in accordance with paragraph (b) of subdivision four. If such child has not allegedly committed a designated felony act and such family court is in session, the officer shall either forthwith take the child directly to such family court, unless the officer takes the child to a facility for questioning in accordance with paragraph (b) of subdivision four or release the child in accordance with paragraph (a) of subdivision four] or, when the family court is not in session, to the most accessible magistrate, if any, designated by the appellate division of the supreme court in the applicable department to conduct a hearing under section 307.4.

§ 6. Subdivision 6 of section 305.2 of the family court act, as added by chapter 920 of the laws of 1982, is amended to read as follows:

6. [In all other cases] If such child has not allegedly committed a designated felony act, and in the absence of special circumstances, the officer shall release the child in accordance with paragraph (a) of subdivision four.

§ 7. Subdivisions 7 and 8 of section 305.2 of the family court act, subdivision 7 as amended by chapter 398 of the laws of 1983 and subdivision 8 as amended by chapter 299 of the laws of 2020, are amended and a new subdivision 10 is added to read as follows:

7. If the officer determines that questioning of the child is necessary prior to taking action authorized by subdivision four or five, the officer may take the child to a facility designated by the chief administrator of the courts as a suitable place for the questioning of children or, upon the consent of a parent or other person legally responsible for the care of the child, to the child's residence and there, subject to the requirements of subdivision eight, question him or her for a reasonable period of time.

8. A child shall not be questioned pursuant to this section unless [he] or until:

(a) the child and a person required to be notified pursuant to subdivision three if present, have been advised:

[(a)] (i) of the child's right to remain silent;

[(b)] (ii) that the statements made by the child may be used in a court of law;

[(c)] (iii) of the child's right to have an attorney present at such questioning; and

[(d)] (iv) of the child's right to have an attorney provided for him or her without charge if he or she is indigent; and

(b) the child has consulted with legal counsel in person, by telephone, or by video conference. This consultation may not be waived.

[8.] 9. In determining the suitability of questioning and determining the reasonable period of time for questioning such a child, the child's age, the presence or absence of his or her parents or other persons legally responsible for his or her care, notification pursuant to subdivision three and, where the child has been interrogated at a facility designated by the chief administrator of the courts as a suitable place for the questioning of juveniles, whether the interrogation was in compliance with the video-recording and disclosure requirements of subdivision five-a of this section shall be included among relevant considerations.

10. In addition to statements that must be suppressed as involuntarily made within the definition in subdivision two of section 344.2, a statement shall be suppressed: when the child has not consulted with legal counsel as required by paragraph (b) of subdivision eight; or when a person notified pursuant to subdivision three, if present, has not been advised of and voluntarily waived the rights delineated in paragraph (a) of subdivision eight.

§ 8. Section 724 of the family court act, the section heading and subdivisions (b) and (c) as amended by chapter 843 of the laws of 1980, subdivision (a) as amended by chapter 920 of the laws of 1982, paragraphs (i) and (ii) as amended and paragraph (iv) of subdivision (b) as added by section 4 of part E of chapter 57 of the laws of 2005, paragraph (iii) of subdivision (b) as amended by section 7 of part M of chapter 56 of the laws of 2017, and subdivision (d) as added by chapter 809 of the laws of 1963, is amended to read as follows:

§ 724. Duties of police officer or peace officer after taking into custody or on delivery by private person. (a) If a peace officer or a police officer takes into custody or if a person is delivered to him or her under section seven hundred twenty-three, the officer shall immediately, before transporting the child to any other location, notify the parent or other person legally responsible for his or her care, or the person with whom he or she is domiciled, that he or she has been taken into custody.

(b) After making every reasonable effort to give notice under [paragraph] subdivision (a) of this section, the officer shall

(i) when the officer reasonably believes such parent or other person legally responsible for the child's care will appear, take the child to his or her home, the police station house, or another location agreed upon with the parent or person legally responsible, and release the youth to the custody of [his or her parent or other] such person [legally responsible for his or her care] upon the written promise, without security, of the person to whose custody the youth is released that he or she will produce the youth before the lead agency designated pursuant to section seven hundred thirty-five of this article in that county at a time and place specified in writing; or

(ii) when the officer does not reasonably believe such parent or other person legally responsible for the child's care will appear for the child, forthwith and with all reasonable speed take the youth directly, and without first being taken to the police station house, to the designated lead agency located in the county in which the act occasioning the taking into custody allegedly was done[, unless the officer determines that it is necessary to question the youth, in which case he or she may take the youth to a facility designated by the chief administrator of the courts as a suitable place for the questioning of youth or, upon the consent of a parent or other person legally responsible for the care of the youth, to the youth's residence and there question him or her for a reasonable period of time]; or

(iii) take a youth in need of crisis intervention or respite services to a runaway and homeless youth crisis services program or other approved respite or crisis program; or

(iv) take the youth directly to the family court located in the county in which the act occasioning the taking into custody was allegedly done, provided that the officer affirms on the record that he or she attempted to exercise the options identified in paragraphs (i), (ii) and (iii) of this subdivision, was unable to exercise these options, and the reasons therefor.

(c) In the absence of special circumstances, the officer shall release the child in accord with paragraph [(b)] (i) of subdivision (b) of this section.

(d) If the officer determines that questioning of the child is necessary prior to taking action authorized by subdivision (b) of this section, the officer may take the child to a facility designated by the chief administrator of the courts as a suitable place for the questioning of children or, upon the consent of a parent or other person legally responsible for the care of the child, to the child's residence and there, subject to the requirements of subdivision (e) of this section, question him or her for a reasonable period of time.

(e) In determining the suitability of questioning and determining what is a "reasonable period of time" for questioning a child, the child's age [and], the presence or absence of his or her parents or other person legally responsible for his or her care and notification pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section shall be included among the relevant considerations.

(f) No statement made to a peace officer or a police officer prior to the commencement of a fact-finding hearing may be admitted into evidence at a fact-finding hearing.

§ 9. Subdivision 6 of section 140.20 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by section 20 of part WWW of chapter 59 of the laws of 2017, is amended to read as follows:

6. (a) Upon arresting a juvenile offender or a person sixteen or [commencing October first, two thousand nineteen,] seventeen years of age without a warrant, the police officer shall immediately, before transporting the child to the police station house, notify the parent or other person legally responsible for his or her care or the person with whom he or she is domiciled, that such juvenile offender or [person] sixteen or seventeen year old has been arrested, and the location of the facility where he or she [is being] will be detained.

(b) If the officer determines that it is necessary to question a juvenile offender or [such person] sixteen or seventeen year old, the officer must take him or her to a facility designated by the chief administrator of the courts as a suitable place for the questioning of children or, upon the consent of a parent or other person legally responsible for the care of the juvenile or [such person] sixteen or seventeen year old, to his or her residence and there, subject to the requirements of paragraph (c) of this subdivision, question him or her for a reasonable period of time.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the family court act and the criminal procedure law, in relation to the custodial interrogation of juveniles by law enforcement

Purpose

This bill makes several changes to the Family Court Act to clarify and protect the rights of children in the custody of law enforcement and makes corresponding changes to the Criminal Procedure Law to address children arrested as juvenile offenders and consult with an attorney before they can be subjected to custodial interrogation by law enforce- ment, thereby ensuring any waiver of rights under Miranda is genuinely knowing, voluntary, and intelligent. The bill also requires that a child arrested without a warrant be brought directly to court, as opposed to the police station, if a parent or legally responsible adult is not expected to appear for them and they are not being questioned, unless otherwise required under the Criminal Procedure Law.

Summary of provisions

Section One amends FCA § 305.2(3) to make clear that law enforcement's obligation to "immediately" notify a parent. or person legally responsi- ble (PLR) that their child has been taken into custody requires that this notification take place before that child can be taken from the location at which he or she was taken into custody to the police station or any other location. Section Two amends FCA § 305.2(4) (a) to state that when law enforcement has notified an arrested child's pare t or PLR' and reasonably believes that the parent or PLR will appear for the child, law enforcement shall take that child to his home, the station house, or another agreed upon location to release him to his parent-or PLR.

Read the full memo (3,750 words)

Section Three amends FCA § 305.2(4) (b) to state that when law enforce- ment does not reasonably believe that an arrested child's parent or PLR will appear for the child, law enforcement shall take that child to family court or, if family court is not in session, to the designated magistrate for the child's initial appearance under FCA § 307.4.

Section Four amends FCA § 305.2(4) (c) to conform with other amended subsections and clarify that an arrested child shall only be taken to detention if the officer did not release the child or bring the child to family court or the designated magistrate.

Section Five amends FCA § 305.2(5) to require that when a child has allegedly committed a designated felony act and the family court is not in session that law enforcement to take such youth to the most accessi- ble magistrate to conduct a hearing under FCA section 307.4

Section Six amends FCA § 305.2(6) for conformity only, by deleting the phrase "In all other cases."

Section Seven amends and renumbers FCA § 305.2(7) to FCA § 305.2(8) and adds a new FCA § 305.2(7) which clarifies that if an officer determines that questioning of a child necessary prior to taking certain actions the officer may take the child to a facility designated as suitable for questioning by the chief administrator of the courts. Section Seven also amends FCA § 305.2(8) to state that no child shall be questioned under this section unless and until "the child has consulted with an attorney in person, by telephone, or by video conference," and establishes that this consultation may not be waived. Also, section seven establishes that a child's statement shall be suppressed when the child has not consulted with an attorney; when a parent or person legally responsible, if present, has not been advised of and voluntarily waived Miranda; or when the questioning of the child was not necessary.

Section 8 amends FCA § 724(a) to make clear that law enforcement's obli- gation with respect to a child taken into custody as a person in need of supervision to "immediately" notify a parent or person legally responsi- ble that their child has been taken into Custody requires that this notification takes place before that child can be taken from the location at which he or she was taken into custody to the police station or any other location. Section 8 also mends FCA § 724(b) by removing language relating to when law enforcement deems questioning of the child necessary, renumbers FCA § 724(d) to FCA § 724(e), and inserts a new FCA § 724(d), which clarifies that if an officer determines that questioning in necessary prior to taking certain actions the officer may take the child to a facility designated as suitable for questioning by the chief administrator of the courts. FCA § 724(e) now provides that in addition to the child's age and the presence or absence of his parents or other person legally responsible for his care, parental notification shall be a factor considered in determining the suitability and reasonable period of time for questioning the child.

Section 8 also creates FCA § 724(f), which provides that statements made to law enforcement prior to the commencement of a fact-finding hearing may not be admitted into evidence at a fact-finding hearing.

Section 9 amends CPL § 140.20(6) to create separate paragraphs and in paragraph (a) makes clear that law enforcement's obligation with respect to a child taken into, custody as a juvenile offender or as a person sixteen (or as of October 1, 2019, seventeen) to "immediately" notify a parent or person legally responsible that their child has been taken into custody requires that this notification takes place before that child can be taken from the location at which he/she was taken into custody to the police station or any other location.

Section 9 also, in proposed CPL § 140.20(6) (c), adds the provision that no child snail be questioned under this section unless and until 'The child has consulted with an attorney in person, by telephone, or by video conference," and establishes that this consultation may not be waived.

Section 9 also creates CPL § 140.20(6) (e) to establish that a child's statement shall be suppressed when the child haS not consulted with an attorney; when a parent or person legally responsible, if present, has not been advised of and voluntarily waived Miranda; or when the ques- tioning of the child was not necessary.

Section 10 amends CPL § 140.27(5) to create separate paragraphs and in paragraph (a) makes clear that law enforcement's obligation with respect to a child taken into custody as a juvenile offender or as a person sixteen (or as of October 1, 2019, seventeen) to "immediately" notify a parent or person legally responsible that their child has been taken into custody requires that this notification takes place before that child can be taken from the location at which he or she was taken into custody to the police station or any other location.

Section 10 also, in proposed CPL § 140.27(5) (c) adds the provision that no child shall be questioned under this section unless and until "the child-has consulted with an attorney in person, by telephone, or by video conference," and establishes that this consultation may not be waived.

Section 10 also creates CPL.§ 140.27(5)(e) to establish that a child's statement shall be suppressed when the child has not consulted with an attorney; when a parent or person legally responsible, if-present, has not been advised of and voluntarily waived Miranda; or when the ques- tioning of the child was not necessary. sk 1 Section 11 amends CPL § 140.40(5) to create separate paragraphs and in paragraph (a) makes clear that law enforcement's obligation with respect to a child taken into custody as a juvenile offender or as a person sixteen (or as of October 1, 2019, seventeen) to "immediately" notify a parent or person legally responsible that their child has been taken into custody requires that this notification takes place before that child can be taken from the location at which he or she was taken into custody to the police station or any other location.

Section 11 also, in proposed CPL § 140.40(5) (c) adds the provision That the child shall be questioned under this section unless and until "the child has consulted with an attorney in person, by telephone, or by video conference," and establishes that this consultation may not be waived.

Section 11 also creates CPL § 140.40(5) (e) to establish that a child's statement shall be suppressed when the child has not consulted with an attorney; when a parent or person legally responsible, if present, has not been advised of and voluntarily waived Miranda; or when the ques- tioning of the child was not necessary.

Section 12 establishes the effective date of April 1, 2025.

Existing law

Existing law in New York State does not ensure that children under 18 years old - with all of their inherent developmental limitations - are adequately and appropriately able to protect their right to remain silent pursuant to the 5th Amendment of the United States Constitution. The Family Court Act and the Criminal Procedure Law already require law enforcement to "immediately" notify the parent or person legally respon- sible of a child's arrest. The term "immediate," however, is undefined under current law, and in practice, law enforcement regularly brings arrested children to the police station house before notifying parents or persons legally responsible The statutes also state that law enforce- ment may only interrogate children when "necessary," but do not define that crucial term. This ambiguity not only places vulnerable youth at risk of being unreasonably interrogated, but it also forces law enforce- ment to contend with uncertainty about what they are permitted to do under the law and leaves the courts with little guidance when called upon to interpret this requirement. Also,. under current law, when the police take a youth into custody and wish to interrogate that youth, the police must advise the child of his/her right to remain silent and, whenever possible, notify a parent or responsible adult to assist the youth in deciding whether to waive this right. Family Court; Act § 305.2; Criminal Procedure Law § 140.20(6). This process does not prevent youth from waiving their Miranda rights nor does it ensure that waiver is knowing, voluntary and intelligent, as required by the Constitution.

Justification

The bill makes three crucial changes to § 305.2 .of the Family Court Act and to. § 140.20(6), 140.27(5) and 140.40(5) of the Criminal Procedure Law. First, it clarifies that law enforcement cannot take a child to the station house until they have notified a parent or person legally responsible. Second, it requires that juveniles consult with counsel before they can waive their rights under Miranda. The bill also makes the first two changes to Family Court Act § 724.

Family Court Act §§ 305.2 and 724 and Criminal Procedure Law § 140.20(6), 140.27(5) and 140.40(5) already require that law enforcement immediately notify an arrested child's parent or legally responsible adult that the child has been taken into custody; this proposal clari- fies that immediate notification must take place before the officer takes the child to another location. In an era in which all officers are equipped with mobile phones, they are able to make contact with parents without first taking children to the station house. In most cases, this will also mean the officer will be able to make a more immediate deter- mination whether to bring the child to the station house, to the family court, or to another location permitted by statute.

Under this proposal, unless questioning is necessary, after notifying a parent, the officer may transport a child to his home, to another greed upon location, or to the station house for purposes of releasing the child to the parent with a desk appearance ticket under Family Court Act § 305.2 or after securing a written promise from the parent to bring the child to the designated lead agency at specified time and place under Family Court Act § 724. When the officer does not have reason to believe that the parent will appear for the child, unless questioning is neces- sary, the officer may bring the child straightaway to family court, before a designated magistrate, to the designated lead agency, or to another location specified in § 305.2(4) or § 724. Under the proposed Criminal Procedure Law provisions, unless questioning is necessary, after notifying the parent, the officer may release the youth with a desk appearance ticket or bring the youth to the appropriate court or otherwise proceed according to the provisions of the CPL.

This bill would also establish that under Family Court Act § 3052 and Criminal Procedure Law § 140.20(6), 140.27(5) and 140.40(5), a child suspect can only be questioned after consulting with an attorney by phone, video, or in person. That consultation would be non-waivable, and the taking of a statement without consultation with counsel, necessity, or waiver of Miranda rights by a parent if present, would result in suppression of the statement. Under Family Court Act § 724, a statement would not be admissible into evidence at a fact-finding hearing since the petitioner is usually a parent -and thus the child can never have the advice and assistance of a parent who does not have a conflict of interest. This treatment is comparable to those statements given to the designated lead agency before fact finding.

The decision to waive one's constitutional right to be silent has enor- mous consequences, which is why the law requires. that the decision be "knowing, voluntary, and intelligent." See Miranda v. Arizona 384 U.S.

436 (1966). Because children are fundamentally different from adults, different safeguards are required in order for a child to make .a know- ing, voluntary, and intelligent decision about a Miranda waiver.

The importance of additional Miranda protections for adolescents is well-grounded in science. It is firmly established that brain develop- ment continues into adulthood, and in recent years, the scientific community has come to a resounding consensus that the prefrontal cortex of the brain which largely governs decision-making, and judgment gener- ally does not mature until well after the teenage years.* In fact, the research demonstrates that the brain undergoes a "rewiring" process that is not complete until approximately 25 years of age.** As a result, youth are not yet able to consider the longterm consequences of their actions or to resist environmental pressures as well as adults. The ability to consider the consequences of one's actions and vulnerability to environmental pressure are precisely the kinds of issues at play in a custodial interrogation setting.*** Adolescents especially struggle to process information and make sound decisions in stressful situations, such as during interrogation.**** Additionally, research shows that adolescents especially those in the justice system, who have high rates of intellectual disability - often do not have the cognitive skills necessary to understand the words or concepts in the Miranda warnings.

The consensus that adolescents' decision-making capabilities are not fully developed and that, for this reason, young people require unique legal protections has been recognized and embraced by the United States Supreme Court. Children are, in the Court's words, "generally less mature and responsible than adults;" "they often lack the experience, perspective, and judgment to recognize and avoid choices that could be detrimental to them"; and "they are more vulnerable or susceptible to outside pressures than adults." J.D.B.V.North Carolina, 131 S.Ct. 2394, 2397 (2011) (internal quotations omitted). In addition, the Supreme Court has recognized that children "have limited understandings of the criminal justice system and the roles of the institutional actors within it" Graham v. Florida, 560 U.S. 48, 78 (2010). Addressing the specific context of police interrogation, the Supreme Court has observed that events that "would leave a man cold and unimpressed can overawe and overwhelm a lad in his early teens." Haley v. Ohio, 332 U.S. 596, 599(1948). Finally, it has noted that "no matter how sophisticated, a juvenile subject of police interrogation cannot be compared to an adult subject" J.D.B., 131 S.Ct. at 2403 (internal quotations omitted).

In fact, leading professional organizations with expertise about chil- dren agree that attorney consultation is needed during interrogation because of children's developmental limitations. The American Psycholog- ical Association, for example, "recommends that particularly vulnerable suspect populations, including youth, persons with developmental disa- bilities, and persons with mental illness, be provided special and professional protection during interrogations such as being accompanied and advised by an attorney or professional advocate."****** The American Academy on Child and Adolescent Psychiatry similarly believes that youth should have an attorney present during questioning by police and that "when interviewing juvenile suspects, polite should use terms and concepts appropriate to the individual's developmental level. Any writ- ten material should also be geared to the person's grade level and cognitive capacity. in general, it is not sufficient to simply read or recite information to a juvenile."****** Unfortunately, the presence of a parent or responsible adult does not adequately ensure that a child makes a knowing, voluntary and intelligent decision with respect to his or her Miranda rights.

Parents often have conflicting interests and often misunderstand the proceedings. Because parents may teach their children to respect and cooperate with law enforcement, they may find it difficult to advise a child in custody not to cooperate. Similarly, parents teach their chil- dren to tell the truth; but often a refusal to speak - even when the child believes himself to be "innocent"- is in the youth's legal inter- ests. Parents often find it hard to believe that their child could possibly do whatever the child is accused of and therefore urge the child to speak, not realizing that doing so may well undermine the child's legal interests. Furthermore, when children are arrested, it often occurs in the context of intra-familial disputes, discord, or violence. Resulting conflicts of interest force parents to choose between, on the one hand, giving the child in custody the best advice and, on the other, looking out for the best interests of the other fami- ly member involved, which is often the parent him/herself. All of these issues are compounded when, as is often the case, the parent has been summoned to the police station in the middle of the night, is feeling humiliated, resentful, or even angry with the child, and is unable to must er the kind of dispassionate and reflective thought process neces- sary to best advise the child. Finally, often the parent or responsible adult him/herself doesn't understand the meaning and nature of the rights the youth is being asked to waive. Social science research confirms that the existing parental notification process to protect the rights of youth is inadequate. Research has found that. when parents are present during interrogation, they almost always either do not help their children make a decision or actually encourage their children to waive their rights.******* Having a child rely exclusively on the advice of an adult who may have conflicting interests and who likely does not him/herself understand the meaning and nature of the right at stake and the potential consequences of waiving that right undermines the purpose of Family Court Act § 305 2 and Criminal Procedure Law §§ 140.20(6), 140.27(5) and 140.40(5).

Legal counsel would offer expert, objective advice to young people about their Constitutional right to remain silent and their ability to waive this right and speak to the police. Only with the benefit of such a conflict-free consultation can children make any waiver of this bedrock right knowingly,' voluntarily, and intelligently, in keeping with requirements of the state and federal Constitutions. For this reason, youth under 18 years of age facing custodial interrogation must be required to consult with legal counsel to assist in their understanding of their rights and the consequences of waiving those rights prior to waiving their rights under Miranda.

Legislative history

2023-2024A.1963/Joyner Referred to Ways and Means 8.1099/Bailey Referred to Children and Families

2021-2021: A.5891C/Joyner - Passed Assembly 8.28000/Bailey - Referred to Senate Finance 2019-2020: A.6982B/Joyner - Referred to Children and Families Committee S. 4980C/Bailey - Referred to Children and Families Committee

Fiscal implications

Although the provision of counsel for consultation at interrogation will inevitably impose a cost to the state and local jurisdictions, this bill will also provide an important cost-saving benefit. Under current law, juvenile defense attorneys and criminal defense attorneys often spend significant amounts of time litigating the legality of their clients' interrogation by law enforcement in what are known as Huntley hearings. These hearings can require several lengthy court appearances, consuming significant resources of defense attorneys, prosecutors, law enforcement witnesses, and judges. If this bill becomes law, it will eliminate the need for a Huntley hearing in the vast majority of cases, significantly reducing the strain on the many agencies and individuals involved.

Local fiscal implications

None.

Effective datee

This act shall take effect April 1, 2025.

* Linda B. Chamberlain, The Amazing Teen Brain: What Every Child Advo- cate Needs to Know, 28 A.B.A. CHILD. L. PRAC. No. 2 at 17-18 (April 2009). ** M. Arain et al., Maturation of the Adolescent Brain, 9 NEUROP- SY-CHIATR.DIS.TREAT.449-461(2013),available at httpsJ/www.ncblnlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/ PMC3621648/, citing L. Gavin et al., Sexual and Reproductive Health of persons aged 10-24 years United States, 2002-2007, 58(6) MMWR SURVEILL. SUMM. 1-58 (2009). *** See Gold- stein et al., Waving Good-bye to Waiver: A Developmental Argument Against Youths' Waiver of Miranda Rights, Legislation and Public Policy, vol. 21 (2018); Elizabeth Cauffman & Laurence Steinberg, Emerging Find- ings from Research on Adolescent Development and Juvenile Justice, 7 Victims and Offenders 428, 433 (2012); LaurencSteinberg,Adolescent Development and Juvenile Justice, 5 Ann. Re .Clinical Psycho!. 459, 65-71 (2009); Laurence. Steinberg, The Science of Adolescent Brain Development and Its Implication for Adolescent Rights and Responsibil- ities, in Human Rights and Adolescence 59, 64 (Jacqueline Bhabha. ed., 2014); Dustin Albert & Laurence Steinberg, Judgment and Decision-Making in Adolescence, 21 J. Res. Adolescence 211(2011); Linda Van Leijenhorst et al, Adoles ce nt Risky Decision-Making: Neurocognitive Development of Reward and Control Regions, 51 Neuroimage 345; 353-54 (2010). Sarah- Jayne Blakemore & Trevor W. Robbins, Decision-Making in the Adoleicent Brain, 15 Nature Neuroscience 1184, 1186 (2012). **** See Goldstein et al., supra. ***** Resolution on Interrogations of Criminal Suspects, Am. Psychol.Ass'n (2014), http://www.apa.org/about/policy/interrogations.aspx.Interviewing and Interrogating Juvenile Suspects,Am.Acad. Child&AdolescentPsychiatry(Mar.7, 2013), https://wwvv.aacap.org/ aacapipolicy_statements/2013/ Intervievving_and_Interrogating Juvenile- Suspects. aspx. ******* Jodi L. Viljoen et al., Legal Decisions of Preadolescent and Adolescent Defendants: Predictors of Confessions, Pleas, .Communication with. At torneys, and Appeals, 29 Law & Hum. Behay. 253, 261 (2005). Jennifer L Woolard et al., Examining Adoles- cents' and their Parents' Conceptual & Practical Knowledge of Police Interrogation: A Family Dyad Approach, 37 J. Youth & Adolescence 685, 690-94 (2008).

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.