What's happening
This bill establishes an indefinite moratorium on building or placing wind turbines in New York's freshwater bodies and related infrastructure.
Why it matters
Effectively halts freshwater wind development. By indefinitely blocking construction or placement of wind turbines on New York’s lakes, rivers, and other freshwater bodies, this bill significantly restricts the expansion of renewable energy infrastructure in these areas, potentially impacting the state’s clean energy goals and related industries.
Broad reach includes supporting infrastructure. The moratorium isn’t limited to the turbines themselves; it also covers any infrastructure (such as cables or transmission lines) related to wind projects in federal or other states’ waters if that infrastructure crosses through New York’s freshwater bodies, potentially affecting multi-state or offshore projects.
Moratorium can only be lifted by legislative action. The ban remains in place unless both chambers of the state legislature vote to end it, making it a durable and hard-to-reverse policy that could deter future investment or planning for wind energy projects in affected regions.
May create legal and regulatory uncertainty. While the law recognizes existing environmental, zoning, and permitting rules, the indefinite moratorium introduces a layer of uncertainty for developers, local governments, and communities interested in renewable energy or concerned about environmental impacts from wind energy installations.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Pause New Wind Turbines
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
3 Co-sponsors
History
- Referred to environmental conservation
- Defeated in environmental conservation
- Notice of committee consideration - requested
- Referred to environmental conservation
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Pause Wind Turbine Construction
In Assembly Committee · Environmental Conservation · Sponsor Brian Manktelow
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
1223
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
January 10, 2023
Introduced by Sens. BORRELLO, ORTT -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Environmental Conservation
AN ACT to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to establishing a moratorium on the building or placing of any permanent or semi-permanent wind turbine on bodies of freshwater located within the state or off the coastline
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The environmental conservation law is amended by adding a new section 13-0107 to read as follows: § 13-0107. Moratorium on building or placing wind turbines.
1. For purposes of this section, "federal waters" shall mean those waters and submerged lands lying seaward to the state waters of New York that appertain to the United States and are subject to federal jurisdiction and control.
2. (a) Notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, there is hereby established a moratorium, for an indefinite period of time, upon the building or placing of any permanent or semi-permanent wind turbine on all bodies of freshwater located within the state and within the jurisdiction and control of the state.
(b) Notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, there is hereby established a moratorium, for an indefinite period of time, upon the building or placing of any infrastructure used to support a permanent or semi-permanent wind turbine located in federal waters or waters under the jurisdiction and control of another state, when such infrastructure enters or passes through a body of freshwater within the jurisdiction and control of the state.
3. This section shall be subject to any applicable provisions of the state environmental quality review act, article ten of the public service law, and any local zoning or permitting laws or ordinances.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD03936-01-3
4. Such moratorium shall not be lifted without the consent of both houses of the legislature by a majority vote in each house. The legislature may require any additional data or information that it deems necessary to make a decision if such moratorium shall be lifted.
§ 2. This act shall take effect immediately.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the environmental conservation law, in relation to establishing a moratorium on the building or placing of any permanent or semi-permanent wind turbine on bodies of freshwater located within the state or off the coastline
Purpose
To establish a moratorium on the building or placing of any permanent or semi-permanent wind turbine on bodies of freshwater in New York State or any freshwater located within the jurisdiction and control of the state.
Summary of specific provisions
Section one amends environmental conservation law by adding section 13-0107 to create a moratorium on the building or placing of permanent or semi-permanent wind turbines on bodies of freshwater in New York State or any freshwater within the jurisdiction and control of the state. A moratorium is also established for the placement of any infras- tructure used to support any wind turbines located in federal waters or waters within the jurisdiction and control of another state.
Read the full memo (1,288 words)
Section two provides the effective date.
Justification
Only about 0.4% of the Earth's total water is accessible and drinkable, according to worldatlas.com. Although water covers more than 70% of the Earth's surface, the vast majority (approximately 97.5%) is salt water. Salt water, abundant on our planet, is not only undrinkable, but is also lethal if consumed in large enough quantities, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).
Freshwater, critically important for life, is actually rare on our plan- et, because it is mostly inaccessible or nearly impossible to obtain and use. More than two-thirds of the planet's freshwater is frozen, located in the polar ice caps or glaciers. Some freshwater is located at depths too far underground to reach. Thus, less than half of one percent of all the Earth's water is actually drinkable.
The Great Lakes are the single largest source of drinking water in the world, accounting for approximately one fifth of the freshwater on the entire planet. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) claims that 84% of the North America's surface freshwater is contained in these five lakes, including Lakes Erie and Ontario that each border New York State. About eleven million people rely on Lake Erie for their drinking water. It is also a primary source of fresh water needed for manufactur- ing and food processing, which are both major industries for NYS. Since so many depend on the freshwater provided by these lakes, one must ask, are the alleged benefits associated with placing offshore induStrial wind turbines in the lakes worth the risk?
Currently, there are many unanswered questions and tremendous evidence that suggests industrial wind turbines present a threat to our environ- ment, including threatening drinking water, wildlife and the delicate ecosystem of our freshwater lakes. Concerns have been raised regarding large sediment plumes created by offshore wind farms in the North Sea and can be observed by NASA satellites. More importantly are the unan- swered questions, regarding the effects that these plumes, sometimes more than one-hundred feet long, have on wildlife including fish and birds. It is not unreasonable to ask, if wind turbines will create simi- lar sediment plumes on freshwater? If so, what effect, if any, will the transport of large amounts of sediment have on the fish and birds living in and around the Great Lakes? What effect, if any, will the transport of sediment have for those that fish professionally or recreationally in the Great Lakes? Even though the lakes are seemingly vast, they are relatively small in comparison to the oceans and any impacts from the industrialization of the waters of our Great Lakes would be magnified.
The history of the Great Lakes has seen the vital freshwater it provides threatened in the not-so-distant past. By the late 1960s, Lake Erie was declared a "dead lake" by several publications because it was so polluted. We have come a long way in the last 50 years to bring Lake Erie back from the brink of death, as outline in the best-selling book 'The Death and Life of the Great Lakes', by Dan Eagan.
Our industrial past is what brought about the near death of Lake Erie. And while the lake has rebounded, the toxins that poured into the lake for over a century are still buried not far below the surface of the lakebed. Disturbing the lakebed with the construction of industrial wind turbines and pouring millions of tons of concrete, along with steel, fiberglass, oil and other needed materials, into the water will have unpredictable and potentially disastrous results. The environmental devastation and threat to the drinking water of millions is unknown because nowhere in the world has this ever been done on any large scale in fresh water.
With so many unanswered questions, the Province of Ontario (Cana- da)decided to issue a moratorium on the placement of wind turbines on Lake Ontario in 2011. In a formal statement pertaining to the moratori- um, Former Minister of the Environment for Ontario, John Wilkinson said, "I was concerned about how this might displace the historically contam- inated sediment on the lakebed and whether it would end up in the drink- ing water system." Mr. Wilkinson also voiced concerns related to"...noise emissions, disturbance of benthic life forms, navigation, potential structural failure, safety hazards and decommissioning."
Although numerous studies have been conducted, none has shown conclu- sively, that offshore industrial wind turbines create no adverse impact for freshwater lakes and those that rely on them. One reason for scant research on wind farms and freshwater is that nearly all of the world's off shore wind turbines are located in salt water. For this reason, the Government of Ontario has decided against removing the moratorium on wind turbines.
An issue specific to the Great Lakes and its international border is the detrimental impact a major offshore industrial wind turbine array in the Great Lakes would have on border security. Specifically, representatives from the Department of Homeland Security state that industrial wind turbines in Lake Erie would impede radar systems along the US coastline - a critical tool to prevent the illegal transport of people and contra- band into our Country as well as the fight against terrorism.
From a cost-benefit standpoint, the tremendous cost of constructing and maintaining offshore industrial wind turbines results in generating electricity that cost more than double that of land-based wind turbines and three to five times more than electricity generated by natural gas powered energy plants.
These are just a few of the questions pertaining to offshore industrial wind turbines. Further concerns regarding commercial fishing, noise, the inadvertent killing of birds and bats, harmful effects on scenic views, potential decreases to property values and the loss of property tax revenue, as well as the questionable benefit in increased energy production when fully considered with these unanswered questions and concerns, explains why, at the very least, additional information is needed. Right now, without answers to these critical questions, placing wind turbines on bodies of fresh water, including Lakes Erie and Ontar- io, is far too dangerous. When one considers that the vast majority, more than 97% of this planet's water is salt water, one must also ques- tion the need to place offshore wind turbines on freshwater bodies, rather than on one of the Earth's immense oceans. For all of these reasons, the first freshwater wind farm in North America should not be located in New York waters, without first obtaining evidence that indus- trial wind turbines pose no threat to the environment and our vital freshwater supply that is essential for all life.
Prior legislative history
2022: S. 6314 Referred to Environmental Conservation
2019/20: S.6718 Referred to Environmental Conservation
Fiscal implications
None
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.