Skip to content
S1266Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA5992

Give Judges More Bail Power

Official title

“Relates to providing judges more discretion regarding securing orders and limiting the lengths of certain orders; repealer”

Sponsor George BorrelloSD-57+3 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Codes
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Codes

What's happening

This bill expands judicial discretion over bail and pretrial detention, limits mandatory appearance tickets, and repeals certain bail reform provisions.

Why it matters

  1. Restores and expands judicial discretion in bail decisions. By removing many of the recently enacted restrictions on when judges can set bail or detain someone pretrial, this bill gives judges broader authority to consider not just risk of flight, but also the safety of individuals and the community when deciding on release, bail, or detention. This could lead to more defendants being held pretrial, especially in cases involving violence or repeat offenses.

  2. Limits mandatory appearance ticket issuance. Police will have more flexibility to arrest and detain individuals for a wider range of offenses, rather than being required to issue appearance tickets (which amount to a summons to court) for most misdemeanors and nonviolent felonies. This may result in more custodial arrests, impacting how quickly people are released after arrest and potentially increasing pretrial jail populations.

  3. Repeals or modifies major bail reform provisions. The bill eliminates requirements that courts use the “least restrictive” release conditions and removes many limits on monetary bail. It also repeals non-monetary condition mandates and electronic monitoring restrictions, making it easier for courts to require cash bail or jail detention, even for lower-level offenses if certain risk factors are found.

  4. Implements ongoing judicial review of detention. For those detained pretrial, the bill requires periodic judicial reviews based on offense severity to determine if continued detention is still warranted. This could offer additional opportunities for release as cases progress but also formalizes longer detention periods for more serious charges.

  5. *Why it matters:** These changes could lead to more people being detained before trial, with the potential for both increased public safety responses and greater risk of pretrial incarceration for nonviolent or low-income defendants. The bill marks a significant policy shift from recent bail reforms, potentially reversing efforts aimed at reducing jail populations and addressing unequal impacts of cash bail.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Give Judges More Bail Power

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
George Borrello

Senator · Senate District 57

History

  1. Referred to codes
  2. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A5992Assembly

Give Judges More Bail Power

In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Andrew Goodell

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

23 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

1266

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 11, 2023

Introduced by Sen. BORRELLO -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to providing judges more discretion regarding securing orders and limiting the lengths of certain orders; and to repeal certain provisions of the criminal procedure law, the judiciary law and the executive law relating thereto

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 3 of section 150.10 of the criminal procedure law is REPEALED.

§ 2. Subdivision 1 of section 1.20 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by chapter 450 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:

1. "Accusatory instrument" means[: (a)] an indictment, an indictment ordered reduced pursuant to subdivision one-a of section 210.20 of this chapter, an information, a simplified information, a prosecutor's information, a superior court information, a misdemeanor complaint or a felony complaint. Every accusatory instrument, regardless of the person designated therein as accuser, constitutes an accusation on behalf of the state as plaintiff and must be entitled "the people of the state of New York" against a designated person, known as the defendant[; and

(b) an appearance ticket issued for a parking infraction when (i) such ticket is based on personal knowledge or information and belief of the police officer or other public servant who issues the ticket, (ii) the police officer or other public servant who issues such ticket verifies that false statements made therein are punishable as a class A misdemeanor, (iii) the infraction or infractions contained therein are stated in detail and not in conclusory terms so as to provide the defendant with sufficient notice including, but not limited, to the applicable provision of law allegedly violated, and the date, time and particular

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD03909-01-3

place of the alleged infraction, and (iv) such ticket contains: (1) the license plate designation of the ticketed vehicle, (2) the license plate type of the ticketed vehicle, (3) the expiration of the ticketed vehicle's registration, (4) the make or model of the ticketed vehicle, and (5) the body type of the ticketed vehicle, provided, however, that where the plate type or the expiration date are not shown on either the registration plates or sticker of a vehicle or where the registration sticker is covered, faded, defaced or mutilated so that it is unreadable, the plate type or the expiration date may be omitted, provided, further, however, that such condition must be so described and inserted on the instrument].

§ 3. Subdivision 1 of section 150.20 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by section 1-a of part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019, subparagraph (viii) of paragraph (b) as amended and subparagraphs (ix), (x) and (xi) of paragraph (b) as added by section 1 of subpart B of part UU of chapter 56 of the laws of 2022, is amended to read as follows:

1. [(a)] Whenever a police officer is authorized pursuant to section 140.10 of this title to arrest a person without a warrant for an offense other than a class A, B, C or D felony or a violation of section 130.25, 130.40, 205.10, 205.17, 205.19 or 215.56 of the penal law, he [shall, except as set out in paragraph (b) of this subdivision] or she may, subject to the provisions of subdivisions three and four of section 150.40 of this [title] article, instead issue to and serve upon such person an appearance ticket.

[(b) An officer is not required to issue an appearance ticket if:

(i) the person has one or more outstanding local criminal court or superior court warrants;

(ii) the person has failed to appear in court proceedings in the last two years;

(iii) the person has been given a reasonable opportunity to make their verifiable identity and a method of contact known, and has been unable or unwilling to do so, so that a custodial arrest is necessary to subject the individual to the jurisdiction of the court. For the purposes of this section, an officer may rely on various factors to determine a person's identity, including but not limited to personal knowledge of such person, such person's self-identification, or photographic identification. There is no requirement that a person present photographic identification in order to be issued an appearance ticket in lieu of arrest where the person's identity is otherwise verifiable; however, if offered by such person, an officer shall accept as evidence of identity the following: a valid driver's license or non-driver identification card issued by the commissioner of motor vehicles, the federal government, any United States territory, commonwealth or possession, the District of Columbia, a state government or municipal government within the United States or a provincial government of the dominion of Canada; a valid passport issued by the United States government or any other country; an identification card issued by the armed forces of the United States; a public benefit card, as defined in paragraph (a) of subdivision one of section 158.00 of the penal law;

(iv) the person is charged with a crime between members of the same family or household, as defined in subdivision one of section 530.11 of this chapter;

(v) the person is charged with a crime defined in article 130 of the penal law;

(vi) it reasonably appears the person should be brought before the court for consideration of issuance of an order of protection, pursuant to section 530.13 of this chapter, based on the facts of the crime or offense that the officer has reasonable cause to believe occurred;

(vii) the person is charged with a crime for which the court may suspend or revoke his or her driver license;

(viii) it reasonably appears to the officer, based on the observed behavior of the individual in the present contact with the officer and facts regarding the person's condition that indicates a sign of distress to such a degree that the person would face harm without immediate medical or mental health care, that bringing the person before the court would be in such person's interest in addressing that need; provided, however, that before making the arrest, the officer shall make all reasonable efforts to assist the person in securing appropriate services;

(ix) the person is eighteen years of age or older and charged with criminal possession of a weapon on school grounds as defined in section 265.01-a of the penal law;

(x) the person is eighteen years of age or older and charged with a hate crime as defined in section 485.05 of the penal law; or

(xi) the offense is a qualifying offense pursuant to paragraph (t) of subdivision four of section 510.10 of this chapter, or pursuant to paragraph (t) of subdivision four of section 530.40 of this chapter.]

§ 4. The criminal procedure law is amended by adding a new section 150.30 to read as follows: § 150.30 Appearance ticket; issuance and service thereof after arrest

upon posting of pre-arraignment bail.

1. Issuance and service of an appearance ticket by a police officer following an arrest without a warrant, as prescribed in subdivision two of section 150.20 of this article, may be made conditional upon the posting of a sum of money, known as pre-arraignment bail. In such case, the bail becomes forfeit upon failure of such person to comply with the directions of the appearance ticket. The person posting such bail must complete and sign a form which states (a) the name, residential address and occupation of each person posting cash bail; and (b) the title of the criminal action or proceeding involved; and (c) the offense or offenses which are the subjects of the action or proceeding involved, and the status of such action or proceeding; and (d) the name of the principal and the nature of his or her involvement in or connection with such action or proceeding; and (e) the date of the principal's next appearance in court; and (f) an acknowledgement that the cash bail will be forfeited if the principal does not comply with the directions of the appearance ticket; and (g) the amount of money posted as cash bail. Such pre-arraignment bail may be posted as provided in subdivision two or three of this section.

2. A desk officer in charge at a police station, county jail, or police headquarters, or any of his or her superior officers, may in such place, fix pre-arraignment bail, in an amount prescribed in this subdivision, and upon the posting thereof must issue and serve an appearance ticket upon the arrested person, give a receipt for the bail, and release such person from custody. Such pre-arraignment bail may be fixed in the following amounts:

(a) If the arrest was for a class E felony, any amount not exceeding seven hundred fifty dollars.

(b) If the arrest was for a class A misdemeanor, any amount not exceeding five hundred dollars.

(c) If the arrest was for a class B misdemeanor or an unclassified misdemeanor, any amount not exceeding two hundred fifty dollars.

(d) If the arrest was for a petty offense, any amount not exceeding one hundred dollars.

3. A police officer, who has arrested a person without a warrant pursuant to subdivision two of section 150.20 of this article for a traffic infraction, may, where he or she reasonably believes that such arrested person is not licensed to operate a motor vehicle by this state or any state covered by a reciprocal compact guaranteeing appearance as is provided in section five hundred seventeen of the vehicle and traffic law, fix pre-arraignment bail in the amount of fifty dollars; provided, however, such bail shall be posted by means of a credit card or similar device. Upon the posting thereof, said officer must issue and serve an appearance ticket upon the arrested person, give a receipt for the bail, and release such person from custody.

4. The chief administrator of the courts shall establish a system for the posting of pre-arraignment bail by means of credit card or similar device, as is provided by section two hundred twelve of the judiciary law. The head of each police department or police force and of any state department, agency, board, commission or public authority having police officers who fix pre-arraignment bail as provided herein may elect to use the system established by the chief administrator or may establish such other system for the posting of pre-arraignment bail by means of credit card or similar device as he or she may deem appropriate.

§ 5. Subdivision 1 of section 150.40 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by section 8 of part UU of chapter 56 of the laws of 2020, is amended to read as follows:

1. An appearance ticket must be made returnable [at a date as soon as possible, but in no event later than twenty days from the date of issuance; or at the next scheduled session of the appropriate local criminal court if such session is scheduled to occur more than twenty days from the date of issuance; or at a later date, with the court's permission due to enrollment in a pre-arraignment diversion program. The appearance ticket shall be made returnable] in a local criminal court designated in section 100.55 of this title as one with which an information for the offense in question may be filed.

§ 6. Subdivision 1 of section 150.50 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by chapter 450 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:

1. A police officer or other public servant who has issued and served an appearance ticket must, at or before the time such appearance ticket is returnable, file or cause to be filed with the local criminal court in which it is returnable a local criminal court accusatory instrument charging the person named in such appearance ticket with the offense specified therein[; provided, however, that no separate accusatory instrument shall be required to be filed for an appearance ticket issued for a parking infraction which conforms to the requirements set forth in paragraph (b) of subdivision one of section 1.20 of this chapter]. Nothing herein contained shall authorize the use of a simplified information when not authorized by law.

§ 7. Section 150.80 of the criminal procedure law is REPEALED.

§ 8. Subdivisions 3-a, 3-b, 21 and 22 of section 500.10 of the criminal procedure law are REPEALED.

§ 9. Subdivisions 5, 6, 7 and 9 of section 500.10 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by section 1-e of part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019, are amended to read as follows:

5. "Securing order" means an order of a court committing a principal to the custody of the sheriff or fixing bail, [where authorized,] or releasing the principal on the principal's own recognizance [or releasing the principal under non-monetary conditions].

6. "Order of recognizance or bail" means a securing order releasing a principal on the principal's own recognizance or [under non-monetary conditions or, where authorized,] fixing bail.

7. "Application for recognizance or bail" means an application by a principal that the court, instead of committing the principal to or retaining the principal in the custody of the sheriff, either release the principal on the principal's own recognizance[, release under nonmonetary conditions, or, where authorized,] or fix bail.

9. "Bail" means cash bail[,] or a bail bond [or money paid with a credit card].

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the criminal procedure law, in relation to providing judges more discretion regarding securing orders and limiting the lengths of certain orders; and to repeal certain provisions of the crim- inal procedure law, the judiciary law and the executive law relating thereto

Purpose or general idea of bill

The purpose of this legislation is to restore judicial discretion in setting appropriate bail for criminal defendants to ensure their timely appearance for trial, taking into account the defendant's risk of flight to avoid prosecution, the risk of failing to appear based on the defend- ant's record of prior criminal convictions or prior failures to appear for court, the danger the defendant poses to the safety of other persons or the community. These criteria track the federal standards that have been used successful in federal criminal proceedings across the nation.

In addition, this legislation would require judges to review the Status of every defendant that is being held pending bail on a regular basis to ensure that defendants are not incarcerated for an extended time period simply because of an inability to post bail. These scheduled reviews would occur every 4 weeks for Class A misdemeanors, every 6 weeks for Class E felonies, every 8 weeks for Class D Felonies, every 10 weeks for Class C felonies, and every 12 weeks for Class B Felonies.

Read the full memo (2,078 words)

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1 repeals section 150.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 2 amends section 1.20(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law to restore the language that existed prior to the adoption of chapter 450 of the laws of 2019.

Section 3 amends section 150.20(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law to restore the language that existed prior to the adoption of part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019.

Section 4 amends section 150.30 of the Criminal Procedure Law regarding the issuance of appearance tickets.

Section 5 amends section 150.40 of the Criminal Procedure Law to restore the language that existed prior to the adoption of part UU of chapter 56 of the laws of 2020.

Section 6 amends section 150,50 of the Criminal Procedure Law to restore the language that existed prior to the adoption of chapter 450 of the laws of 2019.

Section 7 repeals section 150.80 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 8 repeals sections 500.10(3-a), 500.10(3-b), 500.10(21), and 500.10(22) of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 9 amends section 500.10 subdivisions 5, 6, 7, and 9 to restore the language that existed prior to the adoption of part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019.

Section 10 amends section 510.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law to repeal the changes made by part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019 and part UU of chapter 56 of the laws of 2020. provide that a court shall release a criminal defendant on personal recognizance unless the court makes an individualized determination that the defendant poses a risk of flight to avoid prosecution, poses a risk of failing to appear in court based on prior criminal convictions or prior failures to appear, or poses a risk of endangering the safety of any other person or the community.

If the court determines that the criminal defendant poses a risk of flight to avoid prosecution or poses a risk of failing to appear in court based on prior criminal convictions or prior failures to appear, but does not pose a risk of endangering the safety of any other person or the community, then the court shall release the defendant subject to the lowest reasonable bail and/or least restrictive further conditions that will reasonable ensure the appearance of the defendant at trial after considering the seriousness of the charges, the weight of the evidence, the history and characteristics of the defendant, and the nature and seriousness of the danger posed by the defendant's release.

If the court determines that no condition or combination of conditions will reasonably assure the appearance of the defendant for trial and the safety of other persons or the community, the court shall order detention without bail.

If a defendant is arrested while out on bail, the court shall revoke the bail for the first arrest and reconsider the amount of bail, the terms and conditions for any release, or whether bail should be revoked.

All bail orders would be reviewed every 4 weeks for Class A misdemea- nors, every 6 weeks for Class E felonies, every B weeks for Class D Felonies, every 10 weeks for Class C felonies, and every 12 weeks for Class B Felonies to ensure that the bail order should be changed in the best interest of justice, taking into consideration the length of time the defendant has been in jail awaiting trial, the likely sentence if the defendant is convicted, the nature and circumstances of the alleged offense, the weight of evidence, the history and characteristics of the defendant, the danger the defendant poses to others, and whether there are any other conditions that would justify a change in the bail.

Section 11 amends section 510.20 of the Criminal Procedure Law to restore the language that existed prior to the adoption of part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019.

Section 12 makes conforming amendments to section 510.30 of the Criminal Procedure Law to specify, inter alia, that a bail determination must take into consideration the defendants' character, reputation, habits and mental condition; employment and financial resources; family ties and length of residence in the community; previous record of responding to court appearances; history of use of a firearm; weight of the evidence; the possible sentence that could be imposed.

Section 13 makes conforming changes to section 510.40 of the Criminal Procedure Law. Section 14 repeals section 510.43 and section 510.45 of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 15 amends section 510.50 of the Criminal Procedure Law to delete subsection 2 thereof.

Section 16 amends section 520.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law to make conforming changes.

Section 17 amends section 530.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law to allow either bail or lease on recognizance of a defendant.

Section 18 amends section 530.11(4) of the Criminal Procedure Law to allow a judge to order bail for a defendant charged with committing a family offense and may consider the bail previously set by the supreme or family court.

Section 19 amends section 530.12(11) of the Criminal Procedure Law spec- ify that a court may revoke an order of recognizance, restore a case to the calendar when there was an adjournment in contemplation of dismiss- al, revoke a conditional discharge, or revoke probation if a defendant violates an order issued under section 530.12 of the Criminal. Procedure Law.

Section 20 amends section 530.13 of the Criminal Procedure Law to authorize a court to issue a temporary order of protection in connection with a bail determination or as a condition for pre-trial release.

Section 21 amends section 530.13(8)(a) of the Criminal Procedure Law to authorize a court to revoke an order of recognizance.

Section 22 repeals section 530.20 of the Criminal Procedure Law replaces section 530.20 of the Criminal Procedure Law to specify the authority of a local criminal court to order recognizance or bail after considering the factors specified in section 10 of this Bill (see above).

Section 23 amends section 530.30(1) and section 530(2) of the Criminal. Procedure Law to specify that a superior court judge may order release on recognizance or bail where the local criminal lacks authority to make such an order, has denied an application for release on recognizance, has fixed bail in an excessive amount, or has imposed non-monetary conditions that are unnecessarily restrictive.

Section 24 repeals section 530.40 of the Criminal Procedure Law and adds a new section 530.40 of the Criminal Procedure Law to make conforming changes consistent with Section 10 of this bill (see above).

Section 25 amends section 530.45(1) of the Criminal Procedure Law to authorize a review of any bail determination by a higher court judge.

Section 26 repeals section 530.45(2-a) of the Criminal Procedure Law.

Section 27 amends section 530.50 of the Criminal Procedure Law to make conforming changes.

Section 28 amends section 530.60 of the Criminal Procedure Law to speci- fy the procedures for a review and possible revocation of an order setting bail or release on recognizance during the course of a criminal action or proceeding where the defendant is at liberty, including situ- ations where the defendant has persistently and willfully failed to appear for court proceedings, violated an order of protection, intim- idated a witness or victim, or committed another felony.

Section 29 amends section 216.05(a) of the Criminal Procedure Law to specify the procedures for a review and possible revocation of an order setting bail or release on recognizance during the course of a criminal action or proceeding where the defendant is at liberty pursuant .to a judicial diversion program where the defendant has failed to appear before the court or has violated a condition of their release, such as refusing to participate in court-ordered drug abuse treatment.

Section 30 amends section 420.60 of the Criminal Procedure Law to provide for the possible imposition of bail or revocation of release where the defendant violates the terms of probation or conditional discharge.

Section 31 amends section 620.50 of the Criminal Procedure Law to make conforming changes for a material witnesses who are subject to bail.

Section 32 repeals section 216 of the Judiciary Law. Section 33 repeals section 837-u of the Executive Law.

Section 34 provides that this bill shall take effect immediately upon its enactment.

Justification

Part JJJ of chapter 59 of the laws of 2019 eliminated the availability of bail for over 400 crimes, including many serious felonies. Part UU of chapter 56 of the laws of 2020 expanded the list of offenses for which bail could be required, but still prohibited any bail for many serious criminal offenses. Other bail amendments were made by chapter 450 of the laws of 2019.

As a result of these changes, New York judges cannot impose bail on the initial arrest of a defendant for crimes such as robbery 2P-1, burglary 2nd, making a terroristic threat, criminal drug sales in the 2rd, drug sale on school grounds, grand larceny 2nd, assault 3rd, reckless assault of a child, stalking 2nd, menacing, reckless endangerment, criminal obstruction of breathing, unlawful imprisonment, labor trafficking, criminal trespass, coercion, criminal tampering, cemetery desecration, arson 3rd, petit larceny, auto stripping, forgery, falsifying business records, health insurance fraud, residential mortgage fraud, perjury, killing a police dog, promoting prison contraband, bribing a witness, tampering with a juror, promoting prostitution in a school zone, harass- ment, endangering the welfare of a child, and many other serious crimes.

By eliminating all bail for hundreds of serious crimes, many dangerous criminals are released back onto the streets within hours after being arrested. The stories abound of these criminals then committing other crimes while awaiting trial. Without any bail to ensure that they return to court, many criminals simply skip their court appearances. Not surprisingly, the number and severity of criminal activity has exploded across New York State, with double digit increases in violent crime.

This legislation would reinstate judicial discretion in imposing bail after considering the defendant's flight risk, the seriousness of the crime, and the danger to others and the community. These standards are similar to the bail standards used successful in federal criminal courts for many years.

Allowing New York courts to consider the dangerousness of a criminal would bring New York State in line with the rest of the nation. New York is current the only state in the nation that does not allow judges to consider public safety when releasing dangerous criminals. The Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that pretrial detention on public safety grounds is constitutionally permitted.

To ensure that the defendants are not held in jail pending bail for an unreasonable amount of time, this legislation also requires courts to routinely review the status of any pre-trial detainees to ensure that they should remain in jail pending trial. Thus, the legislation balances the need to protect the public with the need to ensure that poor defend- ants do not remain in jail for extended time periods while awaiting trial.

Prior legislative history

2022: S.1802 Referred to Codes

2020: S.8987/A.11047 Referred to Rules

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

This Act would take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.