Skip to content
S135Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA592

Tax Big Profits on Sales

Official title

“Provides for a transfer fee of 75% of the fair market value in dissolution or sales of a rental project or mutual company”

Sponsor Liz KruegerSD-28+5 co-sponsorsAffects Housing
Status
In Senate Committee
Housing, Construction And Community Development
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Housing, Construction And Community Development

What's happening

This bill imposes a 75% transfer fee on certain Mitchell-Lama housing sales to fund affordable housing and repairs.

Why it matters

  1. Targets "windfall profits". By imposing a 75% transfer fee on the fair market value of certain sales, the bill aims to capture large financial gains that would otherwise go to private individuals or entities when Mitchell-Lama housing leaves affordability restrictions or is sold at market rates.

  2. Creates a dedicated affordable housing fund. All proceeds from the transfer fee are directed into a fund managed by public housing agencies, ensuring that money generated from the loss or sale of affordable housing is reinvested into supporting and expanding affordable housing options.

  3. Supports preservation and repair of affordable housing. The fund can be used not only for developing new affordable units, but also for subsidizing existing developments, purchasing land to keep projects affordable, offering zero-interest repair loans, and forgiving repair loan principal over time for participating companies—helping maintain long-term housing quality and affordability.

  4. Incentivizes retention in the Mitchell-Lama program. By offering ongoing subsidies and financial benefits to projects that choose to remain in the Mitchell-Lama affordable housing system, the bill encourages owners and shareholders to keep properties affordable rather than cashing out for private gain.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Rental project owners

    The bill would require a transfer fee of 75% of fair market value upon dissolution or 75% of the sales price on a rental project's first sale.

  • Mutual company shareholders

    Selling shareholders would face a transfer fee of 75% of the sales price on each first market-value sale following dissolution or reconstitution.

  • Likely support

    Mitchell-Lama tenants and housing companies

    Fee proceeds could support continued subsidies, zero-interest capital repair loans with annual principal forgiveness, and public land purchases enabling conversion to limited-profit mutual companies with 99-year leases.

  • New York City Housing Development Corporation and New York State Housing Finance Agency

    The agencies would hold the transfer-fee fund for specified housing subsidies, repairs, land purchases and affordable housing development.

Headline styles

Tax Big Profits on Sales

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Liz Krueger

Senator · Senate District 28

Chair, Finance

History

  1. Referred to housing, construction and community development
  2. Referred to housing, construction and community development

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A592Assembly

Tax Profits From Housing Sales

In Assembly Committee · Housing · Sponsor Linda Rosenthal

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

135

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE (Prefiled)

January 4, 2023

Introduced by Sens. KRUEGER, BAILEY, HOYLMAN, LIU, SERRANO, STAVISKY -read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Housing, Construction and Community Development

AN ACT to amend the private housing finance law, in relation to windfall profits on the dissolution or first sale of rental companies and the dissolution and/or reconstitution of mutual companies

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision 2 of section 35 of the private housing finance law, as amended by chapter 229 of the laws of 1989, is amended to read as follows:

2. A company aided by a loan made after May first, nineteen hundred fifty-nine, may voluntarily be dissolved, sold and/or reconstituted without the consent of the commissioner or of the supervising agency, as the case may be, not less than twenty years after the occupancy date upon the payment in full of the remaining balance of principal and interest due and unpaid upon the mortgage or mortgages [and], of any and all expenses incurred in effecting such voluntary dissolution and of a transfer fee equal to seventy-five percent of the fair market value in the case of dissolution or sales price on the first sale of a rental project, or, in the case of a mutual company seventy-five percent of the sales price on each first sale thereafter for market value by a selling shareholder. The proceeds of the transfer fees are to be paid into a fund held by the New York city housing development corporation and the New York state housing finance agency for the following purposes:

(a) to continue to subsidize the development for as long as the purchaser of a rental development remains in the Mitchell-Lama program;

(b) for the city or state to purchase the land and to lease the land to the tenants and convert the project to a limited profit mutual company, with a ninety-nine year lease;

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD00873-01-3

(c) for repair loans at zero percent interest to fund necessary capital improvements for as long as the company remains in the Mitchell-Lama program;

(d) for each year that the company remains as a limited profit company, to forgive one-thirtieth of the principal of any repair loan each year;

(e) for the subsidization of other limited profit housing companies; and

(f) for the development of other affordable housing.

§ 2. This act shall take effect on the sixtieth day after it shall have become a law.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the private housing finance law, in relation to windfall profits on the dissolution or first sale of rental companies and the dissolution and/or reconstitution of mutual companies

Purpose

The proposal provides for a transfer fee of 75% of the fair market value in dissolution or sales of a rental project or mutual company. This bill is intended to forestall the further loss of Mitchell-Lama afforda- ble rental and co-op units or to compensate for that loss by making funds available by a windfall profit transfer fee for affordable housing purposes.

Summary of provisions

This bill would impose a windfall-profit transfer fee of 75% on the dissolution or first sale of any limited profit rental housing company. In the case of a limited profit mutual company, the 75% windfall-profit transfer fee would be payable on the first sale by each shareholder after dissolution and/or reconstitution of the mutual company. The funds generated by this transfer fee would be used by HOC or the New York State Housing Finance Agency:

Read the full memo (1,045 words)

(a) to continue to subsidize the development for as long as the purchas- er of a rental development remains in the Mitchell-Lama program;

(b) for the City or State to purchase the land and to lease the land to the tenants and convert the project to a limited profit mutual company, with a 99 year lease;

(c) for repair loans at 0% interest for as long as the company remains in the Mitchell-Lama program to fund necessary capital improvements;

(d) for each year that the company remains as a limited profit company, to forgive 1/30 of the principal of any repair loan each year;

(e) for the subsidization of other limited profit housing companies; and, sixth for the development of other affordable housing.

Justification

Mitchell-Lama affordable rental and co-op units were built: to serve a public purpose to provide affordable housing to low income New Yorkers.

At the time Article II of the Private Housing Finance Law was passed there were insufficient units providing decent, safe and affordable housing. This situation is even more acute today since the value of real estate and, consequently, average rents and purchase prices for co-ops have risen to levels which are unaffordable to most New Yorkers. Those who cannot afford to pay privatized rents, unless they receive further government subsidies, have been and will continue to be evicted from the housing they have occupied unless this accelerating trend is reversed. This emergency legislation is intended to counter this trend. Although the Mitchell-Lama legislation provided that owners and co-op sharehold- ers could "buy out" of the program after a certain number of years, it is totally inconsistent with public policy to permit them to "buy out" and render the housing unaffordable without paying back to the govern- ment a large portion of the profits they reap. The government has been a co-investor with them, frequently having assembled the land, always given having real estate tax exemptions, and often having further subsi- dized the development though rent subsidies to the tenants. The windfall profit transfer fee is intended to recapture sonic of increase in value, to which the government contributed so heavily, to maintain the viabil- ity of these units as affordable housing or to provide funds to supply affordable housing alternatives. This legislation is consistent with subsidies under Medicaid which must be repaid when funds are available to the recipient of this government aid.

In the case of Mitchell-Lama rentals and co-ops, all have received New York City real estate tax exemptions since the inception of the program. New York City taxpayers, some with very little income themselves, have subsidized this housing to ensure its affordability. In a number of cases additional federal, state and local subsidies have also been provided. It is estimated that 90% of tenants at Starrett City receive such additional subsidies which are than paid to the landlord to ensure the financial integrity of the project. If these Mitchell-Lama rentals are sold or allowed to privatize without paying out a significant portion of the increase in value to the government, eligible tenants facing Monumental increases in rent frequently will be evicted or must be further subsidized, with the money from these additional subsidies going to the owners. As a consequence, too much of the federal Section 8 money allocated to New York City is going to further subsidize these tenants and, ultimately, their landlords. This leaves insufficient federal subsidy money available to other low income New Yorkers. Funds from the transfer fee will ameliorate this situation.

In the case of co-ops, the situation is similar. For example, a share- holder who paid $5,000 for a three bedroom apartment in a Mitchell-Lama co-op in 1972 and who has been subsidized by the New York City taxpayers for thirty-five years in the form of real estate tax exemption, low cost government financing and very low maintenance charges, can now sell that apartment for $1,000,000 reaping a profit of $993,000 for just having been subsidized. Under this legislation, shareholders, if they voted to privatize the project and make the purchase price unaffordable to their fellow New Yorkers, would only receive $250,000 and the government would receive $750,000 to either subsidize those in the project who could not afford privatized carrying charges or to provide affordable housing alternatives.

Developers end shareholders of limited profit housing companies have benefited from significant subsides in the form of cheap land acquisi- tion, tax exemption, below market rate financing, and, in some cases, federal subsidies to insure the viability of the project. In light of the fact that it is government subsidies that have brought these proper- ties to the point where they now command astronomical prices, it is unconscionable to permit owners who have taken little risk to extract every penny of profit out of these developments and not give back a significant amount to assist those who live in these developments and others in need of affordable housing. This bill would correct this situ- ation.

Legislative history

2007-08: S.4610 Housing Committees

2009-10: S.3851

2011-12: S.456/A.1465

2013-14: S.3162/A.3864

2015-16: S.2799/A.846

2017-18: S.3184/A.4441 Rosenthal

2019-20: S.1917/A.932 Rosenthal

2021-22: S.493/A.1836 Rosenthal

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the sixtieth day.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.