Skip to content
S2108Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA376

Give CCRB Final Say

Official title

“Provides final discipline authority over civilian complaints to the civilian complaint review board”

Sponsor Jamaal BaileySD-36+5 co-sponsorsAffects Local Government
Status
In Senate Committee
Cities 1
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Cities 1

What's happening

This bill gives the New York City Civilian Complaint Review Board final authority over police discipline in civilian complaint cases, removing discretion from the police commissioner.

Why it matters

  1. Strengthens civilian oversight. by ensuring that decisions about police discipline in civilian complaint cases are made by an independent board, rather than police leadership, which may increase public trust in the accountability process.

  2. Changes the disciplinary process. so that substantiated complaints lead to mandatory disciplinary action as determined by the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB), including potential fines, suspensions, or dismissals, with no override by the police commissioner.

  3. Establishes clearer, more transparent procedures. for investigating and prosecuting police misconduct, including the creation of an administrative prosecution unit and independent civilian hearing officers, which could reduce perceptions of bias or internal cover-ups.

  4. Limits the influence of law enforcement within oversight bodies. , as the CCRB must be composed primarily of non-law enforcement civilians, making its decisions more representative of community perspectives rather than police culture.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Give CCRB Final Say

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Jamaal Bailey

Senator · Senate District 36

Chair, Codes

History

  1. Referred to cities 1
  2. Referred to cities 1

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A376Assembly

Discipline Power to Civilian Board

In Assembly Committee · Cities · Sponsor Catalina Cruz

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

6 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

2108

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 18, 2023

Introduced by Sens. BAILEY, RIVERA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Cities 1

AN ACT to amend the New York city charter and the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to providing final discipline authority over civilian complaints to the civilian complaint review board

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Subdivision a of section 434 of the New York city charter is amended to read as follows:

a. The commissioner shall have cognizance and control of the government, administration, disposition and discipline of the department, and of the police force of the department, with the exception of disciplinary determinations and adjudications made by the civilian complaint review board, which shall not be within the discretion of the police commissioner.

§ 2. Section 440 of the New York city charter, as added by local law number 1 of the city of New York for the year 1993, paragraphs 1, 3 and 4 of subdivision (b) as amended by section 1, paragraph 3 of subdivision (d) as amended by section 4 and subdivision (g) as added by section 5 of question 2 of local law number 215 of the city of New York for the year 2019, paragraphs 1, 2 and 5 of subdivision (c) as amended by local law number 24 of the city of New York for the year 2022, paragraphs 3 and 6 of subdivision (c) and paragraphs 1 and 2 of subdivision (d) as amended by local law 47 of the city of New York for the year 2021, is amended to read as follows:

§ 440. Public complaints against members of the police department. (a) It is in the interest of the people of the city of New York and the New York city police department that the investigation and prosecution of complaints concerning misconduct by officers of the department towards members of the public be complete, thorough and impartial. These

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD02350-01-3

inquires must be conducted fairly and independently, and in a manner in which the public and the police department have confidence. An independent civilian complaint review board is hereby established as a body comprised solely of members of the public with the authority to investigate and prosecute allegations of police misconduct as provided in this section.

(b) Civilian complaint review board.

1. The civilian complaint review board shall consist of 15 members of the public. Members shall be residents of the city of New York and shall reflect the diversity of the city's population. The members of the board shall be appointed as follows: (i) five members, one from each of the five boroughs, shall be appointed by the city council; (ii) one member shall be appointed by the public advocate; (iii) three members with experience as law enforcement professionals shall be designated by the police commissioner and appointed by the mayor; (iv) five members shall be appointed by the mayor; and (v) one member shall be appointed jointly by the mayor and the speaker of the council to serve as chair of the board.

2. No member of the board shall hold any other public office or employment. No members, except those designated by the police commissioner, shall have experience as law enforcement professionals, or be former employees of the New York city police department. For the purposes of this section, experience as a law enforcement professional shall include experience as a police officer, criminal investigator, special agent, or a managerial or supervisory employee who exercised substantial policy discretion on law enforcement matters, in a federal, state, or local law enforcement agency, other than experience as an attorney in a prosecutorial agency.

3. The members shall be appointed for terms of three years. The public advocate shall make the public advocate's first appointment to the board on or before May 6, 2020. The board member so appointed shall assume office on July 6, 2020. The mayor and the speaker of the council shall make their initial joint appointment to the board on or before May 6, 2020. The member so appointed shall serve as the board's chair and shall assume office on July 6, 2020.

4. Members of the board shall serve until their successors have been appointed and qualified. In the event of a vacancy on the board during the term of office of a member by reason of removal, death, resignation, or otherwise, a successor shall be chosen in the same manner as the original appointment within 60 days from the date such vacancy occurred. A member appointed to fill a vacancy shall serve for the balance of the unexpired term. During any period in which the office of the chair is vacant, the mayor shall select a member of the board to serve as interim chair until such vacancy has been filled.

(c) Powers and duties of the board.

1. The board shall have the power to receive, investigate, hear, make findings and recommend action upon complaints filed by members of the public, or information received by the board or complaints initiated by the board against members of the police department that allege misconduct involving excessive use of force, abuse of authority including bias-based policing and racial profiling, discourtesy, or use of offensive language, including, but not limited to, slurs relating to race, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation and disability. The board shall also have the power to investigate, hear, make findings and recommend action regarding the truthfulness of any material official statement made by a member of the police department who is the subject of a complaint received or initiated by the board, if such statement was made during the course of and in relation to the board's resolution of such complaint. The findings and recommendations of the board, and the basis therefor, shall be submitted to the police commissioner, who shall have no discretion in whether to impose the recommended discipline. Where the board substantiates one or more allegations against a member of the police department and recommends a level of discipline that would subject the member of the department to being fined, reprimanded, removed, suspended or dismissed from the force, the complaint shall be adjudicated by a hearing officer pursuant to subdivision (d) of this section. No finding or recommendation shall be based solely upon an unsworn complaint or statement, nor shall prior unsubstantiated, unfounded or withdrawn complaints be the basis for any such finding or recommendation.

2. The board shall promulgate rules of procedure in accordance with the city administrative procedure act, including rules that prescribe the manner in which investigations and prosecutions are to be conducted and recommendations made and the manner by which, when a member of the public is the complainant, such member of the public is to be informed of the status of his or her complaint. Such rules may provide for the establishment of panels, which shall consist of not less than three members of the board, which shall be empowered to supervise the investigation of matters within the board's jurisdiction pursuant to this section, and to hear, make findings and recommend action on such matters. No such panel shall consist exclusively of members appointed by the council, or designated by the police commissioner, or appointed by the mayor.

3. The board, by majority vote of its members, may compel the attendance of witnesses and require the production of such records and other materials as are necessary for the investigation and prosecution of matters within its jurisdiction pursuant to this chapter. The board may request the corporation counsel to institute proceedings in a court of appropriate jurisdiction to enforce the subpoena power exercised pursuant to this chapter, and the board itself may, subject to chapter 17 of the charter, institute such proceedings. The board may, subject to any conditions it deems appropriate, delegate to and revoke from its executive director such subpoena authority and authority to institute proceedings.

4. The board shall establish a mediation program pursuant to which a complainant may voluntarily choose to resolve a complaint by means of informal conciliation.

5. The board is authorized, within appropriations available therefor, to appoint such employees as are necessary to exercise its powers, including but not limited to the power to initiate complaints in accordance with paragraph 1 of this subdivision, and fulfill its duties. The board shall employ civilian investigators to investigate all matters within its jurisdiction. The board shall create an administrative prosecution unit, staffed by attorneys and the necessary support staff, that shall handle the prosecution of substantiated cases before a hearing officer.

6. The board shall issue to the mayor and the city council a semi-annual report which shall describe its activities and summarize its actions. Such report shall include, for each investigation initiated pursuant to section 441, such investigation's date of initiation, current status and any date of completion or termination, a description of any investigative findings and recommendations set forth in a written statement of final determination and a description of any written reports from the police commissioner in response to a written statement of final determination.

7. The board shall have the responsibility of informing the public about the board and its duties, and shall develop and administer an on-going program for the education of the public regarding the provisions of this chapter.

(d) Hearings.

1. The executive director shall appoint at least one hearing officer, who shall be a civilian with no law enforcement background, to preside over and adjudicate disciplinary proceedings and make final determinations in cases where the board has substantiated one or more allegations against a police officer and recommended command discipline or charges and specifications.

2. The hearing officer, upon approval of the board chair, shall have the power to punish an officer, upon a plea of guilty or a finding of guilty after an administrative trial, by reprimand, forfeiting and withholding pay for a specified time, suspension, suspension without pay, or by dismissal from the force. No more than thirty days' salary shall be forfeited or deducted for any offense. Members of the police department may be fined, reprimanded, removed, suspended or dismissed from the force only on written charges made and preferred against them, after such charges have been examined, heard and investigated by the hearing officer, by a preponderance of the evidence, upon such reasonable notice to the member of service charged, and in such manner or procedure, practice, examination and investigation as prescribed, to the extent applicable under sections 15-03 and 15-04 of the Rules of the City of New York.

3. The conduct of such hearings shall follow, to the extent applicable, the parameters specified in sections 15-03 and 15-04 of the Rules of the City of New York.

4. Attorneys from the board's administrative prosecution unit shall be responsible for the prosecution of cases before the hearing officer.

(e) Cooperation of police department.

1. It shall be the duty of the police department to provide such assistance as the board may reasonably request, to cooperate fully with investigations by the board, and to provide to the board upon request records and other materials which are necessary for investigations undertaken pursuant to this chapter, except such records or materials that cannot be disclosed by law.

2. The police commissioner shall ensure that officers and employees of the police department appear before and respond to inquiries of the board and its civilian investigators in connection with investigations and prosecutions undertaken pursuant to this chapter, provided that such inquiries are conducted in accordance with department procedures for interrogation of members.

[3. The police commissioner shall report to the board in writing on any action taken, including the level of discipline and any penalty imposed, in all cases in which the board submitted a finding or recommendation to the police commissioner with respect to a matter within its jurisdiction pursuant to this section. In any case substantiated by the board in which the police commissioner intends to impose or has imposed a different penalty or level of discipline than that recommended by the board or by the deputy commissioner responsible for making disciplinary recommendations, the police commissioner shall provide such written report, with notice to the subject officer, no later than 45 days after the imposition of such discipline or in such shorter time frame as may be required pursuant to an agreement between the police commissioner and the board. Such report shall include a detailed explanation of the reasons for deviating from the board's recommendation or the recommendation of the deputy commissioner responsible for making disciplinary recommendations and, in cases in which the police commissioner intends to impose or has imposed a penalty or level of discipline that is lower than that recommended by the board or such deputy commissioner, shall also include an explanation of how the final disciplinary outcome was determined, including each factor the police commissioner considered in making his or her decision.

(e)] (f) The provisions of this section shall not be construed to limit [or impair the authority of the police commissioner to discipline members of the department. Nor shall the provisions of this section be construed to limit] the rights of members of the department with respect to disciplinary action, including but not limited to the right to notice and a hearing, which may be established by any provision of law or otherwise.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the New York city charter and the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to providing final discipline authori- ty over civilian complaints to the civilian complaint review board

Purpose or general idea of bill

To increase, transparency and public trust in the police disciplinary process by removing the Police Commissioner's discretion to modify or reject a. determination or recommendation made by the civilian complaint review board. This bill also provides due process and a fair and impar- tial determination of civilian complaints by a hearing officer who is independent of the police department, and removes the requirement that a civilian file a complaint before the civilian complaint review board can begin to investigate alleged misconduct, despite the board being aware that alleged misconduct may have been committed against a member of the public.

Summary of specific provisions

Section 434 (a) of the Charter of the City of New York is amended to reflect that the Police Commissioner does not have discretion over disciplinary determinations and adjudications made by the civilian complaint review board: The title clause of Section 440 .of the Charter of the City of New York is amended to reflect that the board will have the power to investigate public complaints and as other allegations of misconduct against members of the New York City Police Department.

Read the full memo (1,959 words)

-Subsection (a)expands the jurisdiction of the board to include prose- cution of civilian complaints and the investigation of allegations of misconduct other than those filed directly by members of the public.

-Subsection (c)(1) is amended to give the board the power to receive, investigate, hear, and make findings upon allegations of misconduct upon information the board receives from sources other than a complaint filed by a member of the public. This obviates the need for a civilian to file a formal complaint before the board can begin its investigation into alleged misconduct. This subsection also provides, in line with the amendments made to section 434 of the Charter of the City of New York as part of this legislation, that the Police Commissioner shall not have discretion to change a finding or recommendation made by the board or by a hearing officer hired by the board to adjudicate matters handled by the board. Amendments to this subsection further provide to adjudi- cations of matters handled by the board must be adjudicated by a hearing officer employed by the board. The purpose of this change is to bring transparency and increase public confidence in the outcomes of matters handled by the board by having substantiated allegations against a police officer adjudicated by a hearing officer who is not employed by the Police Department of the City of New York.

-Subsection (c)(2) is amended to allow the board to promulgate rules and procedures for the prosecution of matters by the board.

-Subsection (c)(3) is amended to provide the board with subpoena power for the purpose of conducting prosecutions. -Subsection (c)(4) is amended to allow mediation of any allegation handled by the board.

-Subsection (c)(5) is amended to create an administrative prosecution unit that will handle the prosecution of substantiated allegations before the board's hearing officer(s).

-Subsection (d) (1) delegates the administrative adjudication of matters handled by the board to a hearing officer or officers employed by the board. To ensure that hearings are fair and impartial, the hearing offi- cer must be a civilian with no law enforcement background.

-Subsection (d)(2) gives the hearing officer or officers the authority, subject to approval by the chair of the board, to impose discipline on a member of the police department who either pleads guilty or is found guilty after an administrative trial Of misconduct.

-Subsection (d)(3) provides that civilian complaint review board hear- ings should follow the guidelines of other police department administra- tive procedures.

-Subsection (d)(4) delegates the responsibility for prosecution of matters before the hearing officer to the civilian complaint review board's administrative prosecution unit.

-Subsection (e) (1) provides that the police department comply with board requests to provide records and materials that can be disclosed by law.

-Subsection (e)(2) adds that the Police Commissioner shall ensure employees of the police department appear before the board.

-Subsection (e)(3), which discussed the process for the Police Commis- sioner's deviation from the board's findings and recommendations, is deleted.

-Subsection (f) is amended to remove language about final authority of Police Commissioner over discipline of members of the police force.

Section 14-115 of the Administrative Code of the City of New York

-Subsection (a) is amended to reflect that the Police Commissioner will no longer have discretion over the discipline of officers in matters handled by the civilian complaint review board.

-Subsection (b) now mandates that the administrative prosecution unit handle all prosecutions of members of the police force who are subject to discipline in a matter investigated by the civilian complaint review board.

-Subsection (c) is amended to specify that the Police Commissioner no longer has discretion to determine whether to impose monetary fines in discipline matters determined by the civilian complaint review board.

-Subsection (d) is amended to reflect that in matters handled by the civilian complaint review board, the Police Commissioner no longer has the discretion, in matters where a member of service pleads guilty or is

found guilty after an administrative trial, to suspend judgment and place the member of service on dismissal probation.

The final clause explains that the changes to the Police Commissioner's authority over discipline in cases handled by the civilian complaint review board, as specified in this bill, in no way subjects the disci- pline of members of the police department of the City of New York to collective bargaining, or removes authority over discipline from gover- nance by a local body, nor should it be interpreted as such.

Justification

Transparency and. public confidence in the discipline of members of the. Police Department of the City of New York has long been a topic of discussion in New York City and in the State Legislature. Discussion heightened during the spring and summer of 2020 following the death of George Floyd while he was in the custody of the Minneapolis Police Department. Worldwide public protests were sparked as a result of Mr. Floyd's death, and resulted in legislative action around the issues of policing and police misconduct.

In New York, the State legislature acted in June 202,0 to repeal Civil Rights Law § 50-a, which had for decades shielded. the disciplinary records of members of the New York City Police Department. Debate over Civil Rights Law § 50-a had occurred for years, but Mr. Floyd's death and the ensuing protests finally resulted in legislative action to allow the public access to the disciplinary records of the police officers who are sworn to protect .and serve their communities.

Public discourse about police discipline in New York City revealed that the public did not have confidence that members of the New York City. Police Department who commit misconduct were adequately. punished The Police Commissioner's final authority over the outcome of all discipli- nary matters was of particular concern, as the Police Commissioner could reject or modify the findings and recommendations of the civilian complaint review board or the trial commissioners employed by the New York City Police Department. The release of records by the civilian complaint review board following the repeal of Civil Rights Law § 50-a allowed the public for the first time to see the ultimate dispositions of thousands of civilian complaints, including whether any discipline was imposed by the Police Commissioner in a case where misconduct was substantiated by the civilian complaint review board or-resulted in a guilty plea or verdict in a case handled by the civilian complaint review board's administrative prosecution.

The Police Commissioner's unfettered discretion to reject or modify findings and recommendations in those cases removes the independence that the civilian complaint review board was designed to have from the police department. This bill would amend Section 434 of the Charter of the City of New York, to take away the Police Commissioner's discretion in matters handled by the civilian complaint review board. Other police disciplinary matters would still remain within the full purview of the Police Commissioner. By their very nature, matters handled by the civil- ian complaint review board involve police conduct towards members of the public. This category of complaints warrants scrutiny and independence because the discipline of officers who commit misconduct against members of the public strikes at the heart of public confidence in the police

officers who are sworn to protect and protect the people of the City of New York.

To further ensure that allegations of misconduct involving civilians are fairly and independently scrutinized and adjudicated, this bill amends section 440 of the Charter of the City of New York, to allow the hiring of a hearing officer(s) who are employed by the civilian complaint review board, not the police department as is currently the case. These hearing officer(s) would preside over the administrative prosecution of all matters where the civilian complaint review board substantiated allegations of misconduct against a member of the police department and recommended certain levels of discipline. Allowing independent hearing officers, rather than those employed by the police department, to preside over these prosecutions will ensure that the adjudication of these matters is for and independent, and that the public has confidence that the police department is not protecting its officers and either not disciplining or imposing unwarrantedly low levels of discipline on police officers who have committed misconduct.

This legislation also codifies the administrative prosecution unit, which was established in its current form pursuant to a 2012 memorandum of understanding between the police department and the civilian complaint review board. This memorandum of understanding permits the administrative prosecution unit, which is a division of the civilian complaint review board, to prosecute most cases where the board has voted to substantiate at least one allegation of misconduct against an officer and recommended that charges and specifications be preferred, but allows the Police Commissioner to retain the case in certain situ- ations. The memorandum of understanding is merely an agreement that can be terminated at the whim of the Police Commissioner upon 30-days' notice. By amending the City Charter to provide that the administrative prosecution unit will have to authority to prosecute every as where command discipline or charges and specifications was the discipline recommended by the board, the administrative prosecution unit will no longer exist at the will of the Police Commissioner, nor can the Police Commissioner retain a case from prosecution by an independent hearing officer not employed by the police department.

Finally, this legislation expands the jurisdiction of the civilian complaint review board to allow it to investigate allegations of police misconduct against a civilian, even where a member of the public has not filed a formal complaint. Under the current construction and interpreta- tion of the Charter provisions governing the civilian complaint review board, the board cannot commence an investigation unless a member of the public first, files a complaint, even if the agency has information that indicates that an officer may have engaged in misconduct. This small clarification of the board's jurisdiction will help ensure that suspected misconduct does not go unpunished simply because a civilian has not contacted the board to file a complaint. Furthermore, with this investigative authority, the civilian complaint review board can start investigations more quickly, which will allow for the identification of more witnesses and victims, and the collection of evidence when it is most fresh..

Prior legislative history

2021-22: S5252/A6012 (Cruz) - Referred to Cities 1

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.