Skip to content
S2192Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA641

Reform Criminal Property Seizures

Official title

“Enacts the "criminal forfeiture process act"; repealer”

Sponsor Jamaal BaileySD-36+2 co-sponsorsAffects Finance
Status
In Senate Committee
Finance
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Finance

What's happening

This bill repeals and replaces New York's criminal forfeiture laws to limit seizures, require a criminal conviction, and protect property owners' rights.

Why it matters

  1. Raises the standard and limits scope of forfeiture. Property can only be forfeited after a criminal conviction and only if the state proves by clear and convincing evidence that the property is directly connected to the crime, reducing risk of wrongful or arbitrary seizures.

  2. Enhances due process and owner protections. Requires prompt hearings, detailed notice, and access to counsel for property owners and third parties; innocent owners and secured interest holders have clear avenues to reclaim property, and procedural protections make it harder for authorities to seize assets without solid legal grounds.

  3. Restricts law enforcement incentives and practices. Forfeiture proceeds are directed away from law enforcement budgets (with restrictions on use and sales), and local police are barred from bypassing state law by transferring smaller-value cases to federal agencies, reducing profit motives and closing major loopholes.

  4. Shields low-value and essential property. Exempts small amounts of cash and low-value vehicles from forfeiture, and mandates courts to consider hardship on defendants and their families, helping prevent disproportionate impacts on lower-income individuals and ensuring seizures don’t undermine livelihoods.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Reform Criminal Property Seizures

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Jamaal Bailey

Senator · Senate District 36

Chair, Codes

History

  1. Reported and committed to finance
  2. Referred to codes
  3. Reported and committed to finance
  4. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A641Assembly

Reform Criminal Asset Forfeiture

In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Pamela J. Hunter

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

12 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

2192

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 19, 2023

Introduced by Sen. BAILEY -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the penal law and the criminal procedure law, in relation to enacting the "criminal forfeiture process act"; and to repeal certain provisions of the penal law relating thereto

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "criminal forfeiture process act".

§ 2. Article 480 of the penal law is REPEALED and a new article 480 is added to read as follows:

ARTICLE 480

CRIMINAL FORFEITURE PROCESS Section 480.00 Legislative intent.

480.05 Definitions.

480.10 Jurisdiction.

480.15 Seizure of personal property with process.

480.20 Seizure of personal property without process.

480.25 Seizure or restraint of real property with process.

480.30 Contraband and stolen property.

480.35 Receipt.

480.40 Property exempt from seizure and forfeiture.

480.45 Waiver prohibition.

480.50 Title.

480.55 Counsel.

480.60 Notice to other known owners.

480.65 Prompt post-seizure hearing.

480.70 Notice of proposed forfeiture.

480.75 Notice of proposed forfeiture after indictment.

480.80 Discovery.

480.85 Trial, conviction, and standard of proof.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD03347-01-3

480.90 Exceptions to the conviction requirement.

480.95 Proportionality.

480.100 Secured interest holder.

480.105 Innocent owner.

480.110 Judgment.

480.115 Substitution of assets.

480.120 No additional remedies.

480.125 No joint-and-several liability.

480.130 Appeals.

480.135 Attorney fees.

480.140 Return of property; damages and costs.

480.145 Disposition of property and proceeds.

480.150 Sale restrictions.

480.155 Preemption.

480.160 Limitation on federal adoption.

480.165 Limitation on state and federal joint task forces.

480.170 Guidance.

480.175 Severability. § 480.00 Legislative intent.

The legislature hereby finds that forfeiture is disfavored. The purpose of this article is to:

1. Deter criminal activity by reducing its economic incentives;

2. Confiscate property used in the violation of law and restrain profits from illegal conduct; and

3. Protect the due process rights of property owners. § 480.05 Definitions.

For the purposes of this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

1. "Abandoned property" means personal property left by an owner who relinquishes all rights to control of such property. Abandoned property shall not include real property.

2. "Actual knowledge" means direct and clear awareness of information, a fact, or a condition.

3. "Contraband" means any article or thing which a person is prohibited from obtaining or possessing by law, rule, or regulation, including, but not limited to, illegal drugs or firearms.

4. "Motor vehicle" means a motor vehicle as defined by section one hundred twenty-five of the vehicle and traffic law, except that such term shall include any trailer, snowmobile, airplane, vessel, or any equipment attached to one of such devices. "Motor vehicle" shall not include stolen property.

5. "Innocent owner" means an owner, an owner-in-joint-tenancy, or the defendant's heir or other owner of property subject to forfeiture who does not have actual knowledge of the use of his or her property in a crime which authorizes the forfeiture of such property. "Innocent owner" shall not include the defendant or a secured interest holder.

6. "Instrumentality" means property otherwise lawful to possess that is used in a crime that authorizes the forfeiture of such property. "Instrumentality" includes, but is not limited to, land, buildings, containers, conveyances, equipment, materials, products, tools, computers, computer software, telecommunications devices, firearms, ammunition and ammunition-and-firearm accessories.

7. "Law enforcement agency" means any state or local police force, or any other local, county, or state agency that has the authority under state law to engage in seizure and forfeiture.

8. "Proceeds" means money, securities, negotiable instruments or other means of exchange obtained from the sale of property or contraband.

9. "Prosecuting authority" means a municipal attorney, solicitor, district attorney, attorney general and other attorney acting under specific direction and authority, appointed or charged by law with the responsibility for prosecuting crime.

10. "Secured interest holder" means a person who is a secured creditor, mortgagee, lienholder, or other person who has a valid claim, security interest, mortgage, lien, leasehold, or other interest in property that is subject to forfeiture. "Secured interest holder" shall not include the defendant or an innocent owner. § 480.10 Jurisdiction.

1. This article shall only apply to property seized in relation to the following:

(a) a felony controlled substance offense under article two hundred twenty of this chapter or a felony offense involving cannabis under article two hundred twenty-two of this chapter;

(b) a felony prostitution offense under article two hundred thirty of this chapter;

(c) a felony offense involving driving under the influence of a controlled substance or alcohol; or

(d) an arrest or search conducted immediately subsequent to the hot pursuit of a person suspected of a felony offense for which property is subject to seizure and forfeiture.

2. There shall be no civil forfeiture under this article.

3. The court that has jurisdiction in the related criminal matter shall have jurisdiction over the forfeiture proceeding.

4. The forfeiture proceeding shall be part of the trial of the related crime. It shall follow a finding of the defendant's guilt or be conducted at the court's discretion. Such proceeding shall be conducted by the court without a jury. § 480.15 Seizure of personal property with process.

At the request of the prosecuting authority, the court may issue an ex parte order to attach, seize or secure personal property for which forfeiture is sought and to provide for its custody. Application, issuance, execution, and return are subject to state law and court rules. § 480.20 Seizure of personal property without process.

Personal property may be seized, as part of a lawful search, without a court order if:

1. The personal property subject to forfeiture is seized incident to a lawful arrest;

2. The state has probable cause to believe the delay caused by the necessity of obtaining process would result in the removal or destruction of the personal property that is forfeitable under this chapter; or

3. The personal property is the subject of a prior and valid judgment of forfeiture in favor of the state. § 480.25 Seizure or restraint of real property with process.

1. Real property shall not be seized or restrained without a court order.

2. A court shall not issue an order to seize real property unless the defendant and any other person with a known interest in such real property receive proper notice and are given an opportunity for a contested hearing to determine the existence of probable cause for such seizure.

3. Nothing in this section shall prohibit the prosecuting authority from seeking a lis pendens or restraining order to hinder the sale or destruction of real property otherwise authorized by law. If the prosecuting authority obtains a lis pendens or restraining order, such prosecuting authority shall notify the defendant and any other person with a known interest in the property within thirty days.

4. Application, filing, issuance, execution, and return of any order shall be subject to the laws of the state of New York and any court rules generally applicable to such orders. § 480.30 Contraband and stolen property.

No property right shall exist in contraband or stolen property. Contraband and stolen property shall be subject to seizure. Contraband shall be disposed of according to the applicable state law for such article or thing. Stolen property shall be returned to its owner. § 480.35 Receipt.

1. When property is seized, the law enforcement officer shall give an itemized receipt to the person possessing such property at the time of seizure, or otherwise pursuant to section 690.50 of the criminal procedure law.

2. The receipt shall be numbered for future reference and shall constitute notice of seizure. § 480.40 Property exempt from seizure and forfeiture.

1. The following shall be exempt from seizure and forfeiture:

(a) United States currency totaling two hundred dollars or less; and

(b) A motor vehicle with a market value of less than two thousand dollars.

2. The prosecuting authority shall advise as to which publications that law enforcement agencies may use to establish the value of a motor vehicle in the prosecuting authority's jurisdiction.

3. A prosecuting authority may establish a minimum-dollar amount larger than those in paragraphs (a) and (b) of subdivision one of this section in the prosecuting authority's jurisdiction.

4. The presence or possession of United States currency, without other indicia of a crime that authorizes the forfeiture of property, shall be insufficient probable cause for the seizure of such currency. § 480.45 Waiver prohibition.

1. A law enforcement officer, other than the prosecuting authority, shall not request, require or induce a person to waive, for purpose of seizure or forfeiture, such person's interest in seized property.

2. A document purporting to waive interest or rights in seized property shall be void and inadmissible in court. § 480.50 Title.

1. Title to seized property subject to forfeiture shall vest with the state when the court issues a forfeiture judgment and shall relate back to the time when such property was seized or restrained.

2. Title to substitute assets shall vest when the court issues an order forfeiting such substitute assets. § 480.55 Counsel.

1. If a defendant in a criminal prosecution is represented by a public defender, such public defender's office may authorize representation of such defendant in the forfeiture proceeding and any other related proceeding.

2. If a defendant and any other person with an interest in seized property engages in pro se representation in a forfeiture-related proceeding before a judge, the court shall not be bound by the common law, court rules of evidence, statutory rules of evidence, technical or formal rules of evidence, pleading or procedure in the litigation related to the forfeiture of such property. § 480.60 Notice to other known owners.

1. The prosecuting authority shall perform a reasonable search of public records to identify any person, other than the defendant, known to have an interest in seized property subject to forfeiture.

2. The prosecuting authority shall give notice to any person identified to have an interest in seized property subject to forfeiture, who is not charged or indicted. The notice shall include, if available, the seizure receipt number pursuant to subdivision two of section 480.35 of this article. Notice shall be given as provided by the rules of the court.

3. The following language shall substantially and conspicuously appear in the notice required by this section: "WARNING: You may lose the right to be heard in court if you do not file promptly a statement of interest or ownership. You do not have to pay a filing fee to file your notice."

4. If notice is not served on any persons appearing to have an interest in seized property and no time extension is granted or the extension period has expired, the prosecuting authority or court shall order the return of such property to the person from whom such property was seized upon the request of such person. Contraband shall not be returned. § 480.65 Prompt post-seizure hearing.

1. Following a seizure of property, a defendant or other person with an interest in such seized property shall have a right to a prompt postseizure hearing.

2. A person with an interest in seized property may petition the court for a hearing.

3. At the court's discretion, the court may hold a post-seizure hearing:

(a) as a separate hearing; or

(b) at the same time as a probable-cause determination, a post-arraignment omnibus hearing or other pretrial hearing.

4. A party, by agreement or for good cause, may move for one extension of no more than ten days. Any motion shall be supported by affidavits or other submissions.

5. The court shall order the return of seized property if it finds:

(a) the seizure was invalid;

(b) a criminal charge has not been filed and no extension of the filing period is available;

(c) the seized property is not reasonably required to be held as evidence;

(d) the final judgment likely will be in favor of the defendant or any other person with an interest in the property; or

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the penal law and the criminal procedure law, in relation to enacting the "criminal forfeiture process act"; and to repeal certain provisions of the penal law relating thereto

Purpose

To abolish the use of civil asset forfeiture and replace it with the process of criminal forfeiture in order to ensure due process when prop- erty and/or currency is confiscated by law enforcement.

Summary of specific provisions

Section 1: Establishes the act title as the "criminal forfeiture act".

Read the full memo (1,985 words)

Section 2: Repeals article 480 of the penal law and replaces it with a new article 480.

480.00: Legislative intent establishes that forfeiture is disfavored and that the purpose of article 480 is to deter criminal activity by reduc- ing its economic incentives; confiscate property used in the violation of law and restrain profits from illegal conduct; and protect the due process rights of property owners.

480.05: Defines terms for Article 480.

480.10: Establishes jurisdiction. This article will only apply to prop- erty seized under the conditions outlined.

480.15: Provides for the seizure of personal property with process.

480.20: Establishes the conditions for the seizure of personal property without process.

480.25: Establishes that real property can only be seized or restrained with process.

480:30: Property rights as outlined in the bill do not apply to contra- band.

480.35: When property is seized, law enforcement must provide an item- ized receipt of the property at the time of the seizure.

480.40: Establishes the types of property and the value of certain types of property or currency that are exempt from seizure and forfeiture.

480.45: Only a prosecuting authority may require or induce a person to waive interest in seized property.

480.50: A title to seized property will vest with the state when the court issues a forfeiture judgement and shall relate back to the time when such property was seized or restrained. Titles to substitute assets will vest when the court issues an order forfeiting such substitute assets.

480.55: A public defender's office may authorize representation of a defendant in a forfeiture proceeding or any related proceeding.

480.60: Prosecuting authorities must perform a reasonable search for other people, outside of the defendant, that have an interest in seized property subject to forfeiture. Notice to interested parties must be provided to inform that they may state interest of ownership without a filing fee. If there is no notice, an interested party may have property returned upon request.

480.65: Outlines the right to prompt post-seizure hearings. A defendant or any person with interest in seized property has the right to a prompt post-seizure hearing. A post-seizure hearing can be held at the court's discretion as a separate hearing or at the same time as a probable-cause determination, a post-arraignment omnibus hearing or other pretrial hearing. A party may move for one extension of no more than 10 days. Any motion shall be supported by affidavits or other submissions.

A court must return the property if it finds the seizure was invalid, a criminal charge has not been filed and no extension of the filing period is available, the seized property is not reasonably required to be held as evidence, the final judgement likely will be in favor of the defend- ant or any other person with an interest in the property, or the seized property is the only reasonable means for the defendant to pay for legal representation unless the prosecuting authority convincingly shows that the seized property is the instrumentality of or proceeds derived directly from the crime for which the defendant is charged. At the court's discretion, it may order the return of enough funds and proper- ty, not needed as evidence, for the defendant to obtain counsel of choice, but less than the total amount seized.

480.70: If the state seeks forfeiture of property, other than under section 480.75 of this article (indictment), the prosecuting authority shall include a description of the property seized, the time, date and place of seizure; and a description of how the seized property was used in or derived from the alleged crime. The prosecuting authority may allege the forfeiture of seized property as a sanction related to the crime for which the defendant is charged. The state, with the consent of the court and a defendant with an interest in seized property, may amend the charging document or file an ancillary charge alleging that such property is subject to criminal forfeiture at any time prior to trial. The court may grant an unlimited number of 90-day extensions if probable cause is shown and additional time is warranted. The prosecut- ing authority shall serve the charging document or amendment and notice of the proposed forfeiture as provided by the rules of the court.

The court shall order the return of seized property to the owner if the prosecutor does not file a charging document, the period of an extension expires, or the court does not grant an extension.

480.75: Provides for notice of proposed forfeiture after indictment. The notice shall not be read to a jury. The prosecuting authority may allege, in the notice, the forfeiture as a sanction related to the crim- inal charge, a part of a sentencing consideration, or as other means to effectuate the criminal forfeiture of the property. The property related allegation shall identify the specific property to be forfeited, if known, or the relevant forfeiture statutes if the specific property is not known at the time of the indictment. The prosecutor may apply for or the court may enter a restraining order or injunction to preserve the property under certain circumstances.

480.80: Establishes that discovery related to the forfeiture proceeding shall be subject to procedures set forth by pursuant to the criminal procedure law.

480.85: Establishes standards for trial, conviction and standard of proof. 480.90: Establishes exceptions to the conviction requirement.

480.95: Establishes proportionality in regard to forfeiture. The defend- ant may petition the court to determine whether the forfeiture is uncon- stitutionally excessive under the state or federal constitution. The defendant shall have the burden of establishing unconstitutionality through a preponderance of evidence through a hearing. The court shall consider all relevant factors. The court shall consider the fair market value to determine instrumentality but shall not consider the value of the property to the state when determining if the forfeiture is uncon- stitutionally excessive.

480.100: Establishes the rights of a secured interest holder and the means by which a determination shall be made on returning property to that interest holder.

480.105: The property of an innocent owner cannot be forfeited. If the forfeited property is not returned, an innocent owner has a right to a hearing to be held before the court without a jury.

480.110: Outlines the parameters of a judgement. Property is returned if a prosecutor fails to meet their burden in the criminal or forfeiture proceeding or if the court dismisses the proceeding. If the burden is met, the property is forfeited

480.115: Establishes the circumstances in which assets can be substi- tuted to complete a justified forfeiture.

480.120: Prosecutors cannot seek personal money judgements related to forfeiture of property not provided for by this article.

480.125: Establishes no joint-and-several liability. A defendant shall not be liable for forfeiture owed by other defendants.

480.130: A party to a forfeiture proceeding or the defendant may appeal the court's decision regarding forfeitures following the final judgement in the forfeiture proceeding.

480.135: Establishes circumstances for which attorney fees may be recov- ered.

480.140: Establishes return of property; damages and costs. Law enforce- ment must return property within 5 days of an order to release such property. The rightful owner is not subject to expenses of storage, towing or preservation of property. The law enforcement agency is responsible for any damages, storage fees, and related costs for return- ing property.

480.145: Establishes disposition of property and proceeds. If contraband is no longer needed as evidence, it may be destroyed. Abandoned ' prop- erty or the property of a defendant who fled the jurisdiction may be ordered to be sold if it is no longer needed as evidence. If forfeiture is granted, property may be ordered to be sold. The court may order forfeited currency and sale proceeds to pay restitution to victims, satisfy debts related to the property, pay reasonable costs for things such as towing or storage, reimburse law enforcement for non-personnel operating costs, be disbursed statewide public safety grants, or be deposited into the state's general fund.

480.150: Establishes restrictions on sales of forfeited properties. A law enforcement agency shall not sell forfeited property directly or indirectly to an employee of that agency or their relatives or to anoth- er law enforcement agency.

480.155: Establishes preemption. This article shall preempt local laws that regulate civil and criminal forfeiture.

480.160: Establishes limitation on federal adoption. Law enforcement may not offer forfeited property for federal adoption unless such seized property includes U.S. currency that exceeds $20,000.

480.165: Establishes limitations on state and federal joint task forces. A joint task force shall transfer seized property to the prosecuting authority unless seized property includes U.S. currency in excess of $20,000. Law enforcement cannot accept payment from the federal govern- ment if the federal government requires currency totaling less that $20,000 be transferred to them. Nothing in the subdivisions of

480.160 should be construed to restrict law enforcement from collaborat- ing with a federal agency to lawfully seize contraband. Nothing shall be construed from prohibiting the federal government from acting alone to lawfully seize contraband. A prosecuting authority may establish guidelines for joint task forces and multijurisdictional collaboration in that prosecuting authority's jurisdiction.

480.170: Establishes guidance. A prosecuting authority may establish guidelines for joint task forces after consulting with the responsible U.S. Attorney. The office of public safety will publish best practices for training on seizure and forfeiture.

480.175: Establishes severability of the article.

Section 3: Amends subdivision 4 of section 690.10 of the criminal proce- dure law and adds a new subdivision 5 to reference article 480 of the penal law.

Section 4: Paragraph (a) of subdivision 1 of section 690.55 of the crim- inal procedure law is amended to include reference to article 480 of the penal law.

Section 5: Establishes the effective date as the 1st of November next- succeeding the date on which it shall. have become law.

Justification

Originally intended to undermine the proceeds of criminal enterprises, civil asset forfeiture has led to perverse incentives by police depart- ments and abuse across the nation. Because of the lack of due process involved, there is an incredibly low bar necessary for goods or money to be confiscated. In many municipalities across the country, departments often use forfeited money and assets to increase policing budgets. Low income communities and communities of color are disproportionately impacted because they do not have the means to pay for the litigation necessary to recover their assets. Often an individual will never be charged with a criminal offense after goods are stolen, leaving it the responsibility of that individual to make the case that assets were not involved with a crime.

When federal COVID-19 relief funding was uncertain, many municipalities were unfortunately considering revenue raisers such as ticketing and asset forfeiture to close the gap. These practices are entirely regres- sive and impact those that are the most economically vulnerable the most. This legislation ensures due process in asset forfeiture and removes harmful incentives to confiscate assets unlawfully while also leaving this law enforcement tool available when it is truly needed. Reform to asset forfeiture is long overdue and converting civil asset forfeiture to criminal forfeiture processing ensures due process and fairness.

Prior legislative history

2021-22: S6440 - Reported to Finance

Fiscal implications

To be determined.

Effective date

This act shall take effect on the 1st of November next succeeding the date on which it shall have become law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.