Skip to content
S2277Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA3308

Protect Digital Privacy Rights

Official title

“Enacts the "digital fairness act"”

Sponsor Brian KavanaghSD-27Affects Technology
Status
In Senate Committee
Internet And Technology
Impact
9/10
Transformational
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Internet And Technology

What's happening

The Digital Fairness Act creates new privacy, consent, anti-discrimination, and transparency requirements for personal data use, targeted advertising, biometric information, automated decision systems, and digital literacy education in New York.

Why it matters

  1. Strong, actionable privacy rights for individuals. The Act establishes broad definitions of personal information—including biometric data and device identifiers—and requires "freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous" opt-in consent for most data processing. Individuals must be given clear, concise, and accessible privacy notices, with the right to access, correct, delete, and transfer their personal data. This means New Yorkers would have far more meaningful control over how companies use their data, compared to current norms.

  2. Robust anti-discrimination and transparency in digital systems. The bill targets algorithmic discrimination and bias, especially in high-stakes areas like employment, housing, credit, and education. It bans using personal data or proxies for targeted advertising or automated decisions that discriminate on protected class grounds. It also mandates detailed impact assessments, public notice, and human review for government use of automated decision systems—making these processes more transparent and accountable.

  3. Special protection for biometric information and surveillance. The Act treats biometric data (like fingerprints, facial recognition, DNA, etc.) as especially sensitive. It sets strict requirements for notice, consent, retention, destruction, and prohibits its sale or profit. Surreptitious activation of device sensors (like microphones or cameras) without clear notice and consent is also prohibited, aiming to prevent covert surveillance and misuse of deeply personal data.

  4. Broad enforcement and education provisions. The Act creates a private right of action and significant penalties for violations, empowering individuals to sue and the Attorney General to pursue large-scale enforcement. It also mandates that schools teach digital literacy and privacy, ensuring that all students are educated about how their data can be used and the risks of online activity—potentially raising the baseline of digital awareness across the state.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Businesses handling personal information

    Covered entities processing and maintaining information on at least 500 individuals would face opt-in consent requirements, privacy and security duties, annual audits of data processors and third parties, and private lawsuits.

  • Advertising platforms and advertisers

    The bill would prohibit discriminatory targeting of housing, employment, credit and other specified opportunities, including targeting through proxies for protected characteristics, and require advertiser compliance certifications.

  • State and local agencies and technology vendors

    Government use of automated decision systems would require independent impact assessments and published use policies, with additional approval, notice and human-review requirements for systems affecting individual rights, benefits, opportunities or services.

  • Public and charter schools

    The bill would require digital literacy, digital privacy and internet safety instruction for all pupils beginning in the 2025–2026 school year.

Headline styles

Protect Digital Privacy Rights

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Brian Kavanagh

Senator · Senate District 27

Chair, Housing, Construction And Community Development

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to internet and technology
  2. Referred to internet and technology

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A3308Assembly

Protect Digital Privacy Rights

In Assembly Committee · Consumer Affairs And Protection · Sponsor Catalina Cruz

Impact 9 · Transformational0% to pass

Full text

27 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

2277

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 19, 2023

Introduced by Sen. KAVANAGH -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Internet and Technology

AN ACT to amend the general business law, the executive law, the state finance law and the education law, in relation to enacting the "digital fairness act"

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Short title. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "digital fairness act".

§ 2. Legislative findings. The legislature finds that privacy violations and misuse of personal information in the digital age can lead to a range of harms, including discrimination in employment, healthcare, housing, access to credit, and other areas; unfair price discrimination; and financial, emotional, or reputational harms. Misuse of personal information can limit awareness of and access to opportunities, exacerbate information disparities, erode public trust and free expression, disincentivize individuals from participating fully in digital life and utilizing online services, and increase the risk of future harms.

The legislature additionally finds that individuals in New York state, like individuals across the nation, do not know or consent to the manner in which entities collect, use, retain, share, and monetize their personal information. This misunderstanding is, at least in part, due to obfuscation on the part of the entities leveraging individuals' personal information. Researchers at Carnegie Mellon found that it would take seventy-six work days for individuals to read all of the privacy policies they encounter in a year. Although the advertising industry developed a common logo and slogan to notify individuals of the opportunity to opt-out of targeted advertising, following market research, the industry selected the slogan and logo that few individuals understood, seemingly to discourage opt-out.

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD06719-01-3

The legislature further finds that entities that collect, use, retain, share, and monetize personal information have specialized knowledge about the algorithms and data security measures they use, as well as about how they collect, use, retain, share, and monetize personal information, that the average individual is unlikely to understand. Just as banks, lawyers, and medical providers, given their specialized knowledge, have special obligations to individuals, entities collecting intimate personal information in the digital age and benefiting from similarly specialized knowledge should have similar obligations.

The legislature also finds that individuals in New York state, like individuals across the country, value privacy and wish to control who has access to their personal information. Ninety-two percent of Facebook users alter the social network's default privacy settings, demonstrating that they wish to choose with whom they share personal information. Similarly, ninety-two percent of Americans believe companies should obtain individuals' permission before sharing or selling their personal information.

The legislature additionally finds that biometric information is unlike other unique identifiers, because biometric information is biologically unique to an individual and cannot be changed if compromised. As a result, biometric information merits special protections.

The legislature also finds that it has had a decades long interest in protecting New Yorkers' privacy. For example, since 1996, section 79-l of the New York civil rights law has protected the privacy of genetic information, requiring an individual's informed, written consent prior to genetic testing and restricting the disclosure and retention of genetic information.

The legislature further finds that the use of automated decision systems to make core government and business decisions raises concerns around due process, fairness, accountability, and transparency, as well as other civil rights and liberties. Reliance on automated decision systems without adequate transparency, oversight, or safeguards can undermine market predictability, harm consumers, and deny historically disadvantaged or vulnerable groups the full measure of their civil rights and liberties.

The legislature finally finds that New York has the longest standing human rights law in the nation and that the state has prioritized rooting out discrimination in employment, housing, credit, public accommodations, and educational institutions based on age, race, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, and other protected classes. Ensuring that sophisticated algorithms cannot be used to circumvent the state's civil and human rights laws is an important exercise of the legislature's authority.

§ 3. The general business law is amended by adding a new article 39-FF to read as follows:

ARTICLE 39-FF

DIGITAL FAIRNESS ACT Section 899-cc. Definitions.

899-dd. Meaningful notice.

899-ee. Opt-in consent.

899-ff. Affirmative obligations.

899-gg. Biometric information; retention, collection, disclosure

and destruction.

899-hh. Surreptitious surveillance.

899-ii. Enforcement.

§ 899-cc. Definitions. For the purposes of this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:

1. "Biometric information" shall mean a record of one or more measurable biological or behavioral characteristics that can be used singularly or in combination with other characteristics, or with other information, for automated recognition of a known or unknown individual. Examples of such term shall include, but not be limited to: fingerprints, retina and iris patterns, voiceprints, DNA sequence, facial characteristics, gait, handwriting, key stroke dynamics, and mouse movements.

2. "Collect" shall mean to buy, rent, gather, obtain, receive, or access any personal information pertaining to an individual by any means, online or offline, including but not limited to, receiving information from the individual or from a third party, actively or passively, or obtaining information by observing such individual's behavior.

3. "Conduct business in New York" shall mean to produce, solicit, or offer for use or sale any product or service in a manner that intentionally targets, or may reasonably be expected to contact, New York residents, or to engage in any activity that would subject the actor to personal jurisdiction under section three hundred one or section three hundred two of the civil practice law and rules, whether or not for profit.

4. "Covered entity" shall mean a legal entity that conducts business in New York state and as part of such business, processes and maintains the personal information of five hundred or more unique individuals.

5. "Data processor" shall mean a person that processes personal information on behalf of a covered entity.

6. "De-identified information" shall mean information that cannot reasonably identify, relate to, describe, be capable of being associated with, or be linked, directly or indirectly, to a particular individual; provided that a covered entity that uses de-identified information:

(a) Has implemented technical safeguards that prohibit reidentification of the individual to whom such information may pertain;

(b) Has implemented business processes that specifically prohibit reidentification of such information;

(c) Has implemented business processes that prevent inadvertent release of such de-identified information; and

(d) Makes no attempt to reidentify such information.

7. "Device" shall mean a product that is capable of sending, routing, or receiving communications to or from another device and intended for use by a single individual or single household or, if used outside of a home, for use by the general public.

8. "Device fingerprinting" shall mean information passively collected for the purpose of identifying a device through a combination of device identifiers, wireless or cellular networks, language settings, software versions, time zone, frequently visited sites, drivers, or other specifications.

9. "Device indicator" shall mean any identifier tied to an individual, household, or device, including but not limited to a combinatory method such as device fingerprinting or a technical identifier such as internet protocol address, device advertisement identifier, serial number, international mobile equipment identity, media access control address, cookie identifier, or subscriber identification module card serial number, whether resettable or persistent.

10. "Disclose" shall mean any action, set of actions, or omission in which a covered entity, data processor, or third party makes personal information available to another person, intentionally or unintentionally, including but not limited to, sharing, publishing, releasing, transferring, disseminating, making available, selling, leasing, providing access to, failing to restrict access to, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, electronically, or by any other means.

11. "Division" shall mean the consumer protection division, unless context clearly indicates otherwise.

12. "Governmental entity" shall mean a department or agency of the state or a political subdivision thereof, or an individual acting for or on behalf of the state or a political subdivision thereof.

13. "Harm" shall mean potential or realized adverse consequences to an individual or to society, including but not limited to:

(a) Direct or indirect financial harm.

(b) Physical harm or threats to persons or property, including but not limited to bias-related crimes and threats, harassment, and sexual harassment.

(c) Discrimination in goods, services, or economic opportunity, including but not limited to housing, employment, credit, insurance, education, or health care on the basis of an individual or class of individuals' actual or perceived age, race, national origin, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, marital status, disability, military status, and/or membership in another protected class.

(d) Interference with or surveillance of first amendment-protected activities by state actors.

(e) Interference with the right to vote or with free and fair elections.

(f) Interference with due process or equal protection under law.

(g) Loss of individual control over personal information, nonconsensual sharing of private information, and data breach.

(h) The nonconsensual capture of information or communications within an individual's home or where an individual has a reasonable expectation of seclusion or access control.

(i) Other effects on an individual that may not be reasonably foreseeable to, contemplated by, or expected by the individual to whom the personal information relates, that are nevertheless reasonably foreseeable, contemplated by, or expected by the covered entity that alter or limit such individual's choices or predetermine results.

14. "Individual" shall mean a natural person whom a covered entity knows or has reason to know is located within New York state.

15. "Personal information" shall mean information that is captured in exchange for any kind of value provided to the individual to whom the information pertains, including but not limited to a good or service, the placement of targeted advertisements, or a membership; as a result of an individual, household, or device's establishment or maintenance of an account with a covered entity; or as a result of an individual, household, or device's interaction with a covered entity. Such term shall also include information that directly or indirectly identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked to a particular individual, household, or device that provides or provided information to a covered entity in exchange for any kind of value provided to the individual to whom such information pertains or that established, maintained, establishes or maintains an account with a covered entity. Information is reasonably linkable to an individual, household, or device if it can be used on its own or in combination with other reasonably available information, regardless of whether such other information is held by the covered entity, to identify an individual, household, or device.

16. "Monetize" shall mean to sell, rent, release, disclose, disseminate, make available, transfer, or otherwise communicate orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, an individual's personal information by a covered entity, a third party, or a data processor in exchange for monetary or other consideration, as well as to leverage or use an individual's personal information to place a targeted advertisement or to otherwise profit, regardless of whether such individual's personal information changes hands.

17. "Process" or "processing" shall mean any action or set of actions performed on or with personal information, including but not limited to, collection, access, use, retention, sharing, monetizing, analysis, creation, generation, derivation, decision-making, recording, alternation, organization, structuring, storage, disclosure, transmission, sale, licensing, disposal, destruction, de-identifying, or other handling of personal information.

18. "Reasonably understandable" shall mean of a length and complexity such that an individual with a fourth-grade reading level, as established by the New York department of education's fourth grade English language arts learning standards, can read and comprehend the contents in two minutes or less.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the general business law, the executive law, the state finance law and the education law, in relation to enacting the "digital fairness act"

Summary of provisions

Article 1 of the legislation adds a new article to the general business law protecting privacy through affirmative obligations. This article requires any entity that conducts business in New York and as part of that business processes and maintains the personal information of 500 or more individuals to provide meaningful notice about their use of personal information. That notice must be concise and intelligible, prominently displayed, and written in clear and plain language to make complex information understandable by the ordinary user. Article 1 further requires individuals' affirmative opt-in consent before covered entities collect, use, retain, share, or monetize their personal infor- mation. This article also limits the personal information that may be collected and requires covered entities to secure that information from unauthorized access and share it only with authorized parties who will treat the information with similar care. It also provides individuals with the ability to access and delete their personal information when it is held by a covered entity and to transfer that personal information to another covered entity. Finally, this article heightens protections for biometric information, prohibits surreptitious surve illance by consumer devices, and offers a private right of action to consumers whose rights are violated.

Article 2 of the legislation adds a new section to the executive law making it unlawful to process personal information or target advertising in ways that discriminate in employment, finance, health care, credit, insurance, housing, educational opportunities, or public accommodations based on an individual or class of individuals' actual or perceived age, race, creed, color, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, sex, disability, predisposing genetic characteristics, or domestic violence victim status. The article also adds a new section to the general business law making the same behavior an unlawful trade practice. Article 2 of the legislation also adds a new section to the state finance law requiring that before any governmental entity in New York acquires or deploys an automated decision system, that decision system must undergo and pass a civil rights audit conducted by a neutral third party; the bill imposes this requirement on existing government automated decision systems as well. In addition, this article requires that individuals subjected to automated decisions that affect their human rights or liberty receive notice of the decision made, the involvement of an automated system, and an opport unity to contest the decision and seek human review. Finally, this article requires govern- ment entities that use automated decision-making systems to have appro- priate governing policies in place, adhere to certain transparency requirements, and have the approval of the relevant governing body, following a public hearing, before acquiring the technology. Article 3 of the legislation adds a new section to the education law requiring the NY Office of State Assessment to update both Elementary/Intermediate-level and Regents-level curriculum to teach

Read the full memo (1,380 words)

digital literacy and digital privacy, beginning in kindergarten and continuing through 12th.

Justification

It is no longer possible to participate in society without sharing personal information with third, parties that may, in and of itself, reveal intimate details of one's life, or, when combined with other data and analyzed, may expose such details. In the digital age, countless websites, apps, services, intemet-connected devices,.and even brick-and- mortar stores collect, retain, use, share, and monetize our personal information - often in ways we do not understand and would not agree to if we did. Misuse of this personal information, and the privacy violations that often result, can lead to a range of harms, including monetary losses, harassment, public exposure of our intimate lives, and reputational damage. Misuse of personal information can limit awareness of and access to opportunities, exacerbate information disparities, erode public trust and free expression, disincentivize individuals from participating fully in digital life and utilizing online services, and increase the risk of future harm.

One of the most pernicious ways personal information is used in the digital age is to discriminate in employment, health care, housing, access to credit, and other areas. Employers have leveraged personal information to ensure that only younger men see certain job postings. Landlords have used personal information to exclude African-Americans from viewing certain housing advertisements. Cambridge Analytica obtained more than 50 million Facebook users' personal information and purported to use that information to convince individuals to vote for Mr. Trump. During the 2016 election, personal information was used to target ads to African-Americans urging them not to vote. In addition, government actors are increasingly using automated decision-making systems for everything from teacher evaluations to child custody deci- sions to sentencing, probation, and parole determinations, giving algo- rithms an outsized role in determining individuals' rights, opportu- nities, and outcomes.

Compounding these problems, individuals do not know or consent to the manner in which entities collect, use, retain, share, and monetize their personal information. Carnegie Mellon researchers found that it would take 76 workdays for individuals to read all of the privacy policies they encounter in a year. Entities that collect, use, retain, share, and monetize personal information have specialized knowledge about the algo- rithms and data security measures they use, as well as about how they collect, use, retain, share, and monetize personal information, that the average individual is unlikely to understand.

Nonetheless, privacy remains popular; individuals in New York State, like individuals across the country, value privacy and wish to control who may access their personal information. Ninety-two percent of Face- book users alter the social network's default privacy settings, demon- strating that they wish to choose with whom they share personal informa- tion. Similarly, ninety-two percent of Americans believe companies should obtain individuals' permission before sharing or selling their personal information.

This bill will put control back in individuals' hands by requiring mean- ingful notice of use of personal information, affirmative consent from individuals before their personal information is captured or used, hard limits on the use of biometric information, and affirmative notice and consent before any surveillance technology in consumer products is acti- vated. And, just as banks, lawyers, and medical providers, given their specialized knowledge, have special obligations to individuals, the bill will require entities collecting intimate personal information in the digital age and benefiting from similarly specialized knowledge to undertake similar obligations. Most importantly, the bill will address many of the tangible harms that arise from the abuse and misuse of personal information in the digital age by addressing privacy and civil rights in the same bill, making clear that it is both discrimination and unfair trade practice when personal information is used to circumvent our civil and human rights laws and providing guardrails for govern- mental use of automated decision systems.

The bill will also help students learn how to protect their digital privacy and how to identify, assess, and evaluate the information they see online - including the misinformation and "fake news" that prolifer- ate in digital spaces. Individuals face increasingly personalized, curated newsfeeds that amplify their points of view or customize recom- mended videos that show increasingly radicalized versions of their perspectives. K-12 digital literacy and digital privacy education will help young New Yorkers to identify online fraud, as well as reliable sources and information, and will also enable them to better understand how online activities are tracked and recorded, where personal informa- tion posted online may go, with whom it may be shared, how it may be used, and how best to protect digital security and digital privacy.

Legislative history

2022: A6042 (Cruz): referred to consumer affairs and protection 2021:

A6042 (Cruz): referred to consumer affairs and protection

Fiscal implications

To be determined

Effective date

This act shall take effect immediately; provided, however, that sections one, two, three, four, five and six of this act shall take effect one year after it shall have become a law and section eight of this act shall take effect two years after it shall have become a law. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regu- lation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.