What's happening
This bill restores "medical futility" as a legal basis for do not resuscitate (DNR) orders in New York, including for patients without surrogates and those who are developmentally disabled.
Why it matters
Restores clear legal guidance for physicians. in cases where resuscitation is deemed medically futile, allowing doctors to issue DNR orders even if a patient cannot consent and no surrogate is available—helping avoid unnecessary, invasive procedures in end-of-life situations.
Explicitly includes developmentally disabled patients. under the same medical futility standard as others, addressing concerns about both over-treatment and under-protection for this vulnerable group by making standards more consistent.
Reduces legal ambiguity and risk of litigation. for healthcare providers by re-establishing a specific, objective medical futility criterion (two physicians’ concurrence) for DNR decisions, rather than relying solely on broader, less clear end-of-life standards.
May affect families and patient advocates. by clarifying when and how DNR orders can be issued without family or court approval, potentially reducing emotional and ethical conflicts but also raising debate about patient autonomy and safeguards for those unable to speak for themselves.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Restore DNR for Medical Futility
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to health
- Delivered to assembly
- Passed senateVote 35–24
- Advanced to third reading
- 2nd report cal.
- 1st report cal.559
- Referred to health
- Returned to senate
- Died in assembly
- Referred to health
- Delivered to assembly
- Passed senateVote 36–22
Show 4 earlier actions
- Advanced to third reading
- 2nd report cal.
- 1st report cal.687
- Referred to health
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Allow DNR for Futility
In Assembly Committee · Health · Sponsor Jeffrey Dinowitz
Full text
3 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
2894
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
January 25, 2023
Introduced by Sen. RIVERA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Health
AN ACT to amend the public health law and the surrogate's court procedure act, in relation to restoring medical futility as a basis for both surrogate consent to a do not resuscitate order and for a do not resuscitate order for a patient without a surrogate
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Legislative findings. Under New York's former do not resuscitate (hereinafter "DNR") law, article 29-B of the public health law, a surrogate could consent to a DNR order if the patient met any one of four clinical criteria, one of which was a finding by two physicians that resuscitation was "medically futile," which was defined to mean that resuscitation "will be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs." The former DNR law also allowed a DNR order to be entered for a patient who did not have a surrogate on that basis. That law applied to all patients, including developmentally disabled patients.
In 2010, the former DNR law was superseded by the Family Health Care Decisions Act (hereinafter "FHCDA") which established standards for the withdrawal or withholding of a broad range of life-sustaining treatments. Accordingly, the FHCDA did not have a standard specifically relating to medically futile resuscitation. Similarly, Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (hereinafter "SPCA") §1750-b does not have a standard specifically relating to medically futile resuscitation for developmentally disabled patients.
The legislature finds that the broader FHCDA and SPCA §1750-b standards are difficult to apply to situations in which resuscitation would be medically futile. Accordingly, this bill restores the former DNR
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD05246-01-3
law's medical futility standard as an alternative basis for writing a DNR order under the FHCDA and under SCPA §1750-b.
§ 2. Subparagraphs (i) and (ii) of paragraph (a) of subdivision 5 of section 2994-d of the public health law, as amended by chapter 708 of the laws of 2019, are amended and a new subparagraph (iii) is added to read as follows:
(i) Treatment would be an extraordinary burden to the patient and an attending practitioner determines, with the independent concurrence of another physician, nurse practitioner or physician assistant, that, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty and in accord with accepted medical standards, (A) the patient has an illness or injury which can be expected to cause death within six months, whether or not treatment is provided; or (B) the patient is permanently unconscious; [or]
(ii) The provision of treatment would involve such pain, suffering or other burden that it would reasonably be deemed inhumane or extraordinarily burdensome under the circumstances and the patient has an irreversible or incurable condition, as determined by an attending practitioner with the independent concurrence of another physician, nurse practitioner or physician assistant to a reasonable degree of medical certainty and in accord with accepted medical standards[.]; or
(iii) With respect to a decision to enter an order not to resuscitate, an attending physician determines, with the independent concurrence of a second physician, to a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that in the event of a cardiac or respiratory arrest, resuscitation would be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs.
§ 3. Paragraph (b) of subdivision 5 of section 2994-g of the public health law, as amended by chapter 708 of the laws of 2019, is amended to read as follows:
(b) If the attending practitioner, with independent concurrence of a second physician, nurse practitioner or physician assistant designated by the hospital, determines to a reasonable degree of medical certainty that:
(i) (A) life-sustaining treatment offers the patient no medical benefit because the patient will die imminently, even if the treatment is provided; and
[(ii)] (B) the provision of life-sustaining treatment would violate accepted medical standards, then such treatment may be withdrawn or withheld from an adult patient who has been determined to lack decision-making capacity pursuant to section twenty-nine hundred ninetyfour-c of this article, without judicial approval. This [paragraph] subparagraph shall not apply to any treatment necessary to alleviate pain or discomfort; or
(ii) in the event of cardiac or respiratory arrest, resuscitation will be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs, then an order not to resuscitate may be entered for an adult patient who has been determined to lack decision-making capacity pursuant to section twenty-nine hundred ninety-four-c of this article, without judicial approval.
§ 4. Subparagraphs (i) and (ii) of paragraph (b) of subdivision 4 of section 1750-b of the surrogate's court procedure act, as amended by chapter 198 of the laws of 2016, are amended to read as follows:
(i) the person who is intellectually disabled has a medical condition as follows:
A. a terminal condition[, as defined in subdivision twenty-three of section twenty-nine hundred sixty-one of the public health law] which shall mean an illness or injury from which there is no recovery, and which can reasonably be expected to cause death within one year; or
B. permanent unconsciousness; or
C. a medical condition other than such person's intellectual disability which requires life-sustaining treatment, is irreversible and which will continue indefinitely; [and] or
D. in the case of a decision to enter an order not to resuscitate, that in the event of cardiac or respiratory arrest such resuscitation would be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs; and
(ii) except in the case of a decision to enter an order not to resuscitate based on clause D of subparagraph (i) of this paragraph, the life-sustaining treatment would impose an extraordinary burden on such person, in light of:
A. such person's medical condition, other than such person's intellectual disability; and
B. the expected outcome of the life-sustaining treatment, notwithstanding such person's intellectual disability; and
§ 5. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the public health law and the surrogate's court proce- dure act, in relation to restoring medical futility as a basis for both surrogate consent to a do not resuscitate order and for a do not resus- citate order for a patient without a surrogate
Purpose
Restores medical futility as a basis for do not resuscitate orders.
Summary of specific provisions
Section 1 describes the intention of the legislation which is to rees- tablish the basis for do not resuscitate orders based on medical futili- ty.
Read the full memo (720 words)
Section 2 amends subparagraphs (i) and (ii) of paragraph (a) of subdivi- sion 5 of section 2994-d as it relates to orders not to resuscitate. With respect to a decision of a do not resuscitate order, decisions to withhold or withdraw life-sustaining treatment can be made if an attend- ing physician determines resuscitation would be unsuccessful in restor- ing cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs.
Section 3 amends paragraph (b) of subdivision 5 of section 2994-g of the public health law as it relates to orders not to resuscitate. According to this section, an order not to resuscitate may be entered for an adult patient who has been determined to lack decision-making capacity if the patients enters cardiac or respiratory arrest and if resuscitation will be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs.
Section 4 amends subparagraph (i) and (ii) of paragraph (b) of subdivi- sion 4 of section 1750-b of the surrogate's court procedure act as it relates to orders not to resuscitate terminally ill patients. This section adds a definition for the term 'terminally ill' as an illness or injury from which there is no recovery and which can reasonably be expected to cause death within one year. The added definition of 'termi- nally ill' also includes, in the case of a decision to enter an order not to resuscitate, that in the event of cardiac or respiratory arrest such resuscitation would be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs.
Section 5 gives the effective date.
Justification
For over 20 years under the former do not resuscitate (DNR) law (PHL Art 29-B), a surrogate could consent to a DNR order if the patient met any one of four clinical criteria, one of which being a finding by two physicians that resuscitation "will be unsuccessful in restoring cardiac and respiratory function or that the patient will experience repeated arrest in a short time period before death occurs." The former DNR law also allowed a DNR order to be entered on that basis for a patient who did not have a surrogate. That law applied to all patients, including developmentally disabled patients.
The Family Health Care Decision Act (FHCDA), in contrast, establishes standards for the withdrawal or withholding of a broad range of life- sustaining treatment. Accordingly it does not have a standard specif- ically relating to medically futile resuscitation. Chapter 8 of the laws of 2010 made the FHCDA apply to DNR orders for most patients in hospi- tals and nursing homes.
Similarly, SCPA § 1750-b does not have a standard specifically relating to medically futile resuscitation. Chapter 8 of the laws of 2010 made SCPA § 1750-b apply to DNR orders for developmentally disabled patients. This loss of the long-established "medical futility" grounds for a DNR was inadvertent. Experience has shown that the broader FHCDA and SCPA § 1750-b standards, especially the standards for patients who do not have surrogates, can be difficult to apply to decisions about resuscitation. This bill would restore the former DNR law's medical futility standard as an alternative basis for writing a DNR order under the FHCDA and under SCPA § 1750-b, with the addition of nurse practitioners to conform with chapter 430 of 2017, which added them as eligible practitioners to execute DNRs.
Legislative history
2013-2014: S7156A (Hannon)/A9648 Gottfried
2015-2016: S4796 (Hannon)/A6966 Gottfried
2019-2020: S5834/A1203 Gottfried
2021-2022: S4685/A204 Gottfried
Fiscal implications
None
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall become a law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.