Skip to content
S2942Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA3729

Allow Retail Clinic Services

Official title

“Authorizes retail clinics to provide certain services”

Sponsor Gustavo RiveraSD-33Affects Finance
Status
In Senate Committee
Finance
Impact
7/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Finance

What's happening

This bill establishes regulations and standards for retail health clinics in New York, defining their scope, oversight, and patient protections.

Why it matters

  1. Limits retail clinics to minor, short-term care. Retail clinics can only provide treatment for acute, non-chronic conditions (like minor illnesses/injuries or immunizations), and cannot monitor or treat patients over multiple visits or for long-term health issues. This means they supplement, but do not replace, primary care providers.

  2. Establishes robust oversight and standards. The bill requires retail clinics to become accredited, comply with new operational and physical standards, and be subject to regular state review and enforcement. These regulations are tailored to the unique setting of retail clinics (e.g., inside pharmacies or stores), aiming to ensure safety and quality.

  3. Promotes continuity of care and connection to primary care. Retail clinics must ask every patient about their primary care provider, give lists of local (including Medicaid and safety net) providers to patients without one, and send records to the patient’s primary provider when possible. They are also restricted from treating the same patient for the same issue more than three times a year, encouraging patients to seek ongoing care elsewhere.

  4. Protects clinical independence and patient choice. Host businesses (like pharmacies or retail stores) are prohibited from influencing the medical decisions of clinic staff, especially regarding prescriptions or recommended treatments. Clinics must also clearly inform patients that they are not required to buy medications or supplies on-site, supporting transparency and preventing conflicts of interest.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Headline styles

Allow Retail Clinic Services

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Gustavo Rivera

Senator · Senate District 33

Chair, Health

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Reported and committed to finance
  2. Referred to health
  3. Reported and committed to finance
  4. Referred to health

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A3729Assembly

Allow Retail Clinics to Treat

In Assembly Committee · Health · Sponsor Amy Paulin

Impact 7 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

2942

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 25, 2023

Introduced by Sen. RIVERA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Health

AN ACT to amend the public health law, in relation to retail clinics

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. The public health law is amended by adding a new section 230-f to read as follows:

§ 230-f. Retail clinics. 1. As used in this section, "retail clinic" means a facility or portion of a facility that is operated by any entity that is authorized under the laws of this state to provide professional services to the public and that provides health care services or treatment provided by a health care practitioner licensed, certified, registered or authorized to practice under title eight of the education law, acting within his or her lawful scope of practice, that: (a) operates within the space of a retail business operation, such as a pharmacy or a store open to the general public; (b) is labeled, branded, advertised or marketed with the name or symbol of a retail business entity; or (c) is labeled, branded, advertised or marketed with the name or symbol of a business entity, other than a business entity that provides health care services or treatment provided at the facility. However, a facility or portion of a facility shall not be deemed to be a retail clinic if it ordinarily is used only for providing health care services to employees of the retail business operation. A facility shall not be deemed to be a retail clinic if the health care service under title eight of the education law it provides is limited to pharmacy or ophthalmic dispensing and ophthalmologic or optometric services provided in connection with ophthalmic dispensing.

2. The treatments and services that may be provided by a retail clinic shall be limited to the provision of treatment and services to patients for acute episodic illness or condition; episodic preventive treatment and services such as immunizations; ophthalmic dispensing and ophthalmo-

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD02423-01-3

logic or optometric services provided in connection with ophthalmic dispensing; or treatment and services for minor injuries that are not reasonably likely to be life-threatening or potentially disabling or have complications if ambulatory care within the capacity of the retail clinic is provided; but the treatments and services provided by a retail clinic shall not include monitoring or treatment and services over multiple visits over prolonged periods.

3. A retail clinic shall be deemed to be a "health care provider" for the purposes of title two-D of this article. A prescriber practicing in a retail clinic shall not be deemed to be in the employ of a pharmacy or practicing in a hospital for purposes of subdivision two of section sixty-eight hundred seven of the education law.

4. (a) The commissioner shall make regulations setting forth operational and physical plant standards for retail clinics, which may be different from the regulations otherwise applicable to diagnostic and treatment centers, including, but not limited to:

(i) requiring that retail clinics attain and maintain accreditation by an appropriate accrediting entity approved by the commissioner and requiring timely reporting to the department if a retail clinic loses its accreditation;

(ii) designating or limiting the treatments and services that may be provided, including limiting the scope of services to the following, provided that such services shall not include monitoring or treatment and services over multiple visits or prolonged periods:

(A) the provision of treatment and services to patients for minor acute episodic illnesses or conditions;

(B) episodic prevention and wellness treatments and services such as immunizations;

(C) ophthalmic dispensing and ophthalmologic or optometric services provided in connection with ophthalmic dispensing;

(D) treatment and services for minor injuries that are not reasonably likely to be life threatening or potentially disabling or have complications if ambulatory care within the capacity of the retail clinic is provided;

(E) prohibiting the provision of services to patients twenty-four months of age or younger;

(iii) requiring retail clinics to accept walk-ins and offer extended business hours;

(iv) setting forth guidelines for advertising and signage, which shall include signage indicating that prescriptions and over-the-counter supplies may be purchased by a patient from any business and do not need to be purchased on-site;

(v) setting forth guidelines for informed consent, record keeping, referral for treatment and continuity of care, case reporting to the patient's primary care or other health care providers, design, construction, fixtures, and equipment.

(b) Such regulations also shall promote and strengthen primary care by requiring retail clinics to:

(i) inquire of each patient whether he or she has a primary care provider;

(ii) maintain and regularly update a list of local primary care providers and provide such list to each patient who indicates that he or she does not have a primary care provider. Such roster (A) shall be drawn from a list of primary care providers maintained and periodically updated by the department on its website (in searchable form) including the information required in clauses (B) and (C) of this subparagraph, located in the zip code area and adjacent zip code areas of the retail clinic, and may include additional primary care providers added by the retail clinic; (B) shall identify preferred providers who have achieved recognition as a patient centered medical home (pcmh) or other similar designation and a description of what such designation means; and (C) shall include federally qualified health centers and other providers who serve medicaid, low-income and uninsured patients, and people with disabilities and shall identify cultural and linguistic capabilities when available;

(iii) refer patients to their primary care providers or other health care providers where appropriate;

(iv) transmit by electronic means whenever possible, records of services to patients' primary care providers;

(v) decline to treat any patient for the same condition or illness more than three times in a year; and

(vi) report to the department relevant data, as may be deemed necessary by the department, related to services provided and patients served, provided that such reporting shall comply with all privacy laws related to patient data.

(c) Retail clinics already in operation at the time this section takes effect must comply with accreditation requirements under this subdivision within one year after the effective date of this section.

(d) The department shall routinely review the compliance by retail clinics with the provisions of this section and if a retail clinic fails to comply with the provisions of this section, or regulations adopted pursuant to this section, the department shall have the authority to take enforcement actions under title two of article one of this chapter.

(e) In making regulations under this section, the commissioner may consult with a workgroup including, but not limited to, representatives of health care consumers and representatives of professional societies of appropriate health care professionals, including those in primary care and other specialties.

5. A retail clinic shall provide treatment without discrimination as to source of payment.

6. The department shall provide an annual report which it shall make available on its website; the report shall include locations of retail clinics in the state and shall indicate which clinics are located in medically underserved areas; such report shall also include an analysis as to whether retail clinics have improved access to health care in underserved areas, recommendations related thereto and any other information the department may deem necessary.

7. This section does not authorize any form of ownership or organization of a retail clinic or practice of any profession that would not otherwise be legal, and does not expand the scope of practice of any health care practitioner. Where any regulation under this section would affect the scope of practice that may be provided in a retail clinic a health care practitioner licensed, registered, certified or authorized to practice under title eight of the education law, the regulation shall be made in consultation with the commissioner of education.

8. The host business entity of a retail clinic shall not, directly or indirectly, by contract, policy, communication, incentive or otherwise, influence or seek to influence any clinical decision, policy or practice of any health care practitioner providing any health care service in the retail clinic, including prescribing or recommending drugs, devices or supplies. This subdivision shall not preclude the host business entity from establishing, consistent with this section and applicable law, limitations on or requirements as to the scope of health care services to be provided in the retail clinic or activities to assure maintaining quality standards of health care services. As used in this section, "host business entity" means any retail business organization, retail business entity or business entity within whose space the retail clinic is located or with whose name or symbol the retail clinic is labeled, branded, advertised or marketed.

§ 2. This act shall take effect on the one hundred eightieth day after it shall have because a law. Effective immediately, the commissioner of health shall make regulations and take other actions reasonably necessary to implement this act on that date.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the public health law, in relation to retail clinics

Purpose or general idea of bill

To limit the services that may be offered by a health care practice that is operated within a retail business space or is labeled, branded, or marketed by a retail business entity.

Summary of specific provisions

The bill would add a new Public Health Law § 230-e to define "retail clinics" as professional health care practices that operate within the space of a retail business, such as a pharmacy or a store open to the general public; or is labeled, branded, advertised, or marketed with the name or symbol of a retail business; or is labeled, branded, advertised, or marketed with the name or symbol of a business other than the health care practice itself. The definition would exclude facilities that only provide healthcare to employees of a retail business, as well as pharma- cy and ophthalmic dispensing and ophthalmologic or optometric services provided in connection with ophthalmic dispensing. Current restrictions on referrals considered self-dealing would apply.

Read the full memo (1,115 words)

Retail clinics would be limited to providing episodic services that do not require multiple visits, such as minor acute conditions, episodic prevention and wellness services such as immunizations, and treatment of minor injuries. Retail clinics would be prohibited from treating chil- dren under age two. They would be required to have access to walk-ins and extended business hours. Retail clinics would be prohibited from treating any patient for the same condition or illness more than three times in a year.

The Commissioner of Health would be directed to make regulations that: require accreditation; provide guidelines for advertising and signage that prescriptions and supplies do not need to be purchased on-site; issue guidelines for informed consent, record keeping, referral, conti- nuity of care, and case reporting; and address design, construction, fixtures, and equipment.

The regulations would promote and strengthen primary care by requiring retail clinics to inquire of each patient whether they have a primary care provider and for those who do not have one, the retail clinic would be required to provide a list drawn from a searchable website list of primary care providers maintained by the Department of Health, which would include providers who serve Medicaid, low-income and uninsured patients, and people with disabilities, and identify cultural and linguistic capabilities.

Retail clinics would be required to refer patients and transmit records to patients' primary care and other health care providers; report to data required by the department, provided that such reporting shall comply with all privacy laws related to patient data; and participate in the statewide health information network of New York (SHIN-NY).

Retail clinics already in operation would be given an additional year to comply with accreditation requirements. If a retail clinic fails to comply with the law or regulations, the Department of Health (DOH) would be directed to take enforcement actions under title two of article one of the Public Health Law.

The Commissioner would be authorized to consult with a workgrouP includ- ing representatives of health care consumers and representatives of professional societies of appropriate health care professionals, includ- ing those in primary care and other specialties.

A retail clinic would be required to provide treatment without discrimi- nation as to source of payment.

DOH would be directed to post an annual report on its website showing locations of retail clinics, including which clinics are located in medically underserved areas, and analysis as to whether retail clinics have improved access to health care in underserved areas, with recommen- dations or other information the DOH may deem necessary.

The bill would not authorize any form of ownership or organization of a retail clinic or practice of any profession that would not otherwise be legal, and would not expand the scope of practice of any health care practitioner. The host business entity of a retail clinic would be prohibited from directly or indirectly, by contract, policy, communi- cation, incentive, or otherwise, influencing or seeking to influence any clinical decision, policy, or practice of any health care practitioner providing any health care service in the retail clinic, including prescribing or recommending drugs, devices, or supplies.

Justification

Retail clinics already exist in several locations throughout New York State. One concern is that high-profile retail branding may influence clinical judgment, such as prescribing, or skew public perception of the value of a retail clinic's services to the detriment of primary care providers who instead choose a normal neighborhood location.

Today there is nothing to limit the scope of services offered by a retail clinic. Around the country, they are purporting themselves to be full-service medical practices. With the marketing power and capital support they receive, they would out-compete more conventional prac- tices. Health care would become increasingly dominated by corporate- controlled providers. As retail entities become merged with insurers, health care providers could become controlled by health insurers. Curtailing retail clinics is necessary to prevent this scenario.

New York law does not permit business corporations to actually own health care practices or health care providers. However, a corporation can rent them space. The corporation can provide marketing services, rent equipment, provide management support, provide electronic health record systems, etc. Combined with the power of a commercial landlord, the corporation virtually owns the retail clinic, undermining profes- sional independence. This makes it all the more compelling to limit the scope of services that these clinics are allowed to offer and provide.

The consolidation of pharmacies and insurers, with pharmacy benefit managers influencing clinical decisions and costs, adds concern that without sufficient regulation retail clinics become the final link in a vertically integrated closed loop. Even if the host business is only renting space to the practice, the proximity and branding may blur how the practice is perceived. Patients deserve unfettered power to consent to or refuse treatment, and to purchase prescribed drugs or supplies at their own discretion, free of the overwhelming influence that retailers seek to exert over the public.

This bill will ensure that all retail clinics are operated according to set standards that assure convenience, clinical autonomy, and support rather than detract from regional primary care.

Family practice and primary care are already stressed by a health care delivery system that is disproportionately driven by hospitals, special- ists, drug manufacturers, and insurers. Population health improves when access to preventative and.necessary care is available and timely, which retail clinics can offer, and even more so when such care is connected to systems that offer continuity and follow-up, which this bill will assure.

Prior legislative history

2022: S9276 (Rivera) - Referred to Health

Fiscal implications

None

Effective date

180 days after enactment.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.