What's happening
This bill expands and strengthens the Correctional Association of New York’s authority to access, inspect, and obtain information from state correctional facilities for independent oversight purposes.
Why it matters
Broader, real-time access for oversight. The Correctional Association (CA) would gain the right to enter, inspect, and examine all state prisons at any time, including during lockdowns and emergencies, without advance notice or restrictions—except for limited areas in active emergencies, increasing transparency and accountability.
Expanded interview and confidentiality rights. CA staff may now privately interview any incarcerated person, staff, or third-party service provider, without corrections officials or other agency representatives present. This removes previous consent and attendance requirements and prohibits retaliation, empowering more candid disclosures of conditions.
Vastly increased data and document access. The bill mandates quarterly, detailed sharing of individual-level data on admissions, releases, deaths, incidents, grievances, staff discipline, and more, plus annual budget information. This enables the CA to identify systemic issues, trends, and facility-specific problems with far more precision and regularity.
New tools for direct communication. The CA can distribute and collect confidential surveys, receive privileged mail, calls, and emails, and set up confidential hotlines for incarcerated individuals and staff—without prior DOCCS approval. This could surface previously hidden problems and amplify the voices of those inside prisons.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Correctional Association of New York
The bill would eliminate advance notice for prison inspections, expand access to records and confidential interviews, and let the association prioritize inspections based on systemic issues.
Department of Corrections and Community Supervision
The bill would require quarterly data disclosures, annual budget records, and a written response with an action plan within 30 days of receiving the association’s tentative reports.
People incarcerated in state prisons
The bill would provide free confidential calls and emails to the association, confidential survey responses, and private meetings without notice to the department.
Correctional employees and Office of Mental Health service providers
The bill would expand confidential interview access and protections against retaliation for speaking with the association, while requiring requested meetings with service-provider representatives upon 24 hours’ notice.
Headline styles
Allow Prison Watchdog More Access
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
History
- Print number 312b
- Amend and recommit to crime victims, crime and correction
- Print number 312a
- Amend and recommit to crime victims, crime and correction
- Referred to crime victims, crime and correction
- Referred to crime victims, crime and correction
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Expand Prison Oversight Access
Assembly Floor Calendar · Sponsor David Weprin
Full text
5 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
312--B
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE (Prefiled)
January 4, 2023
Introduced by Sens. SALAZAR, BRISPORT, CLEARE, FERNANDEZ, KRUEGER, RIVERA, SEPULVEDA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Crime Victims, Crime and Correction -- recommitted to the Committee on Crime Victims, Crime and Correction in accordance with Senate Rule 6, sec. 8 -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee -- committee discharged, bill amended, ordered reprinted as amended and recommitted to said committee
AN ACT to amend the correction law, in relation to correctional facility visits by the correctional association
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Legislative findings. Founded in 1844 by concerned citizens of the state and deputized by the state to provide independent monitoring and oversight of the state's prisons in 1846, the Correctional Association of New York is one of the first organizations in the country created to administer civilian oversight of prisons to ensure greater transparency of correctional institutions in the state. The Correctional Association of New York's on-site access to the state's prisons and to information on state prisons is critical for the organization to provide insight into the policies and procedures of the state's prisons through its monitoring and reporting on prison conditions, policies, and procedures for the executive, legislature, and public, playing an important role in informing debates on correctional reform and incarcerated individuals' rights.
§ 2. Subdivision 3 of section 146 of the correction law, as amended by chapter 32 of the laws of 2021, paragraph b of subdivision 3 as amended by chapter 486 of the laws of 2022, is amended to read as follows:
3. a. Notwithstanding any other provision of law to the contrary, the correctional association shall be permitted to access, visit, inspect,
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD00661-10-4
and examine all state correctional facilities [with seventy-two hours advance notice to the department]. Up to twelve people may comprise the visiting party[; provided, however, that only four people from the party may enter a special housing facility or unit at the same time]. Prior to the visitation authorized pursuant to this subdivision, the correctional association shall provide to the department on, at least, an annual basis a list of people who will be visiting the facility or facilities, including names, dates of birth, driver's license numbers and their designation as an employee, board member, or designee in order for the department to perform prompt background checks. The department may not place restrictions on such visits and inspections, including during periods when a facility is locked down or experiencing a facility wide emergency. [In addition] However, the department may restrict access to a portion of a facility in an emergency situation for the duration of the emergency. For the purpose of this subdivision, an emergency shall be determined by the commissioner or his or her designee and defined as a significant risk to the safety or security of the facility, or the health, safety or security of staff or incarcerated individuals, or an event that significantly compromises the operations of the facility.
b. Upon twenty-four hours advance notice, at the commencement and conclusion of any visits to, or inspections and examinations of, state correctional facilities, the superintendent and executive team, [to the extent practicable] upon request by the correctional association, shall meet with the correctional association. Upon twenty-four hours advance notice, [the] privately without representatives of the central office present, representatives of the office of mental health and any other entities or agencies providing services in a facility shall meet with the correctional association upon request during the course of any visit. The correctional association may meet privately with the incarcerated individual liaison committee and representatives of the incarcerated individual grievance resolution committee or any other organization of incarcerated individuals recognized by the department.
c. [During the course of any such visit, inspection or examination, upon consent of the person being interviewed, the] The correctional association shall have the power to interview and converse publicly or confidentially with any correctional employee or administrator, any incarcerated individual, and any other person providing, supervising, or monitoring services in a correctional facility, whether or not employed by such facility. Such interviews shall not be restricted by the department or the office of mental health or any other agency or attended by anyone on behalf of the department or the office of mental health or any other agency, nor shall there be any retaliation or adverse action taken by the department or other state agency against [any incarcerated individual] anyone who [agrees to speak] speaks with the correctional association. The department may not limit the number of individuals the correctional association may interview or the duration of the interviews[, in any manner unreasonable under the circumstances]. The correctional association shall have the power to conduct private, confidential meetings [reasonable in number under the circumstances] at their pleasure and without notice to the department with incarcerated people in housing units and in attorney visiting rooms or other rooms in the facility in which their conversations will remain confidential. No department employee may attend or listen to any such meeting without the consent of the correctional association.
d. The correctional association may request and receive from the department information and data as will enable the correctional association to carry out its functions, powers and duties.
(i) The correctional association shall have access to the following information and records on a quarterly basis:
(A) individuals admitted into custody, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records of all individuals admitted to custody, including the individual's departmental ID, demographic information, admission type, reception facility name and housing unit, reception date, sentencing, and crime information;
(B) individuals under custody, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records of all individuals presently under custody, including the individual's departmental ID, demographic information, current facility name and housing unit, date of original and latest reception at the facility, out counts, sentencing and crime information, and parole eligibility and relevant dates;
(C) individuals released from custody, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records of all individuals released from custody, including the individual's departmental ID, demographic information, releasing facility name and housing unit, release date, release county, sentencing and crime information, and parole eligibility and relevant dates;
(D) individuals on parole, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records of all individuals on parole, including the individual's departmental ID, demographic information, discharging facility name and housing unit, start and release date, sentencing and crime information, custody status, and voting pardon status;
(E) programming, education, vocational, and work assignment requirements, enrollment, and fulfillment, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records of all individuals under custody, including the individual's departmental ID, fields indicating the requirements of their sentence, and indicators of whether the individual is not enrolled, is on the waitlist, or has already completed any such requirement;
(F) departmental staffing levels, which shall contain, at minimum, facility-level records of budgeted fill level, recommended staffing level, and actual filled items split by job category, including data on staff on long-term leave, workers compensation leave, and on the average of daily closed posts for each quarter;
(G) deaths, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records of all individuals who died while under custody, including the individual's departmental ID, date and time of death, date of report, demographic information, facility name and housing unit at time of death, location of terminal incident, reported immediate cause of death, and an indicator of whether an autopsy was performed;
(H) unusual incidents, which shall contain, at minimum, report-level information for all unusual incidents, as defined by the department at the current time, including the incident code, the name and code of the facility where the incident took place, the date and time of the incident, the location within the facility, the name and code of the categories and subcategories indicated in the report, the roles of all individuals involved in the report (including incarcerated and nonincarcerated individuals), the weapons used by each individual, the type of force applied by department staff on each individual, if applicable, and the degree of injury to staff and incarcerated individuals;
(I) disciplinary charges and penalties, which shall contain, at minimum, charge-level information for all disciplinary incidents, including: the incarcerated individual's departmental ID and facility name; the location, date, and time of the incident; the tier, code, and description of each charge; the date of the hearing; and the outcome and penalty associated with each charge;
(J) grievances and appeals, which shall contain, at minimum, grievance-level information for all grievances filed with the department, including those resolved informally, including: the incarcerated individual's departmental ID; ID, date filed, category, type, and facility of the grievance; and the outcomes and outcome dates for all reviews, including those by the incarcerated grievance resolution committee, superintendent, and central office review committee;
(K) department employee disciplinary records, which shall contain, at minimum, incident-level information for all employee discipline issued by the department, including the incident facility, date, position of the relevant employee, a brief description of the incident, and the resulting penalty; and
(L) parole eligibility and hearing outcomes, which shall contain, at minimum, individual-level records for all incarcerated individuals currently under custody, including the incarcerated individual's departmental ID, parole eligibility date, type and date of interview, and date and outcome of interview.
(ii) The correctional association shall have access to the annual budget of correctional facilities and records on a yearly basis. Such records shall contain facility and spending category-level information of the departmental budget for the year.
e. The correctional association shall periodically[, but not less than every five years,] conduct inspections of each state correctional facility, prioritized based on the correctional association's assessment of systemic issues, and [shall] issue reports and recommendations to the governor, the legislature and the public about the conditions and issues at [each such facility] correctional facilities. When preparing such formal reports and recommendations, the correctional association shall submit a tentative copy of such report and recommendations to the commissioner. The commissioner [may] shall submit a written response to such tentative report within [sixty] thirty days of the receipt thereof, including a plan of action for addressing the findings and recommendations. When the correctional association thereafter submits its final report and recommendations, it shall contain a complete copy of the response, if any, submitted to the tentative report and recommendations.
[e.] f. The correctional association may send, and distribute during prison visits, confidential written and electronic surveys or questionnaires to people in custody or employees concerning conditions of confinement, working conditions, or other subjects within the scope of their mission without prior approval of the department. People incarcerated shall be permitted to confidentially complete and return to the correctional association such surveys either in written format or electronically. The correctional association may also receive free confidential phone calls and emails from incarcerated individuals and/or set up a confidential hotline for individuals to use if they choose to contact them. Physical mail received and sent to the correctional association is defined as privileged correspondence, and any and all processing controls, allowances for limited free postage, and advances of incarcerated individual funds for postage shall apply to privileged correspondence received and sent to the correctional association. For the purposes of this section, identical incoming blank surveys and questionnaires shall not be defined as privileged correspondence.
[f.] g. The access, visits, and inspection of state correctional facilities by the correctional association pursuant to this subdivision shall be undertaken solely in furtherance of the correctional association's lawful powers, duties and obligations, and information obtained pursuant to these powers shall be used solely in furtherance of the correctional association's mission. Employees, board members and designees shall be required to sign [a waiver] an acknowledgement of the foregoing as a condition of entry into a correctional facility pursuant to this subdivision.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the correction law, in relation to correctional facility visits by the correctional association
Purpose or general idea of the bill
This legislation seeks to provide the Correctional Association of NY with the tools needed to properly fulfill its unique role as a watchdog of the state's correctional system. This bill restores some of the powers the legislature adopted in 2020 that were removed during the chapter amendment process by the then-Governor, address roadblocks that have restricted CANY's ability to perform its mandated role, and further seeks to bring CANY's access authority in line with nationally recog- nized best practices for correctional monitoring.
Summary of specific provisions
Section 1 provides legislative findings that detail CANY's history and purpose and emphasizes the unique, critical, and necessary civilian oversight role that CANY plays in NY State and the positive impact CANY has had on informing public discourse relating to correctional reform and the rights of incarcerated individuals.
Read the full memo (834 words)
Section 2 amends Correction Law section 146 (3) to provide the CANY with the ability to access, visit, inspect, and examine all correctional facilities. This section further provides CANY with access to all records of the Department (except as limited by state or federal law). The only time DOCCS can restrict access is during an emergency as defined in this section, and even in an emergency situation, they may only restrict access to the impacted portion of the facility. This section also mandates the CANY to periodically issue public reports and recommendations based on their inspections, after having provided draft reports to the Department in advance and allowing the Department to respond with a plan of action to address the findings. The finalized CANY report must contain the Department's response, if any. This section also requires that all mail sent to CANY be considered privileged corre- spondence, and that all rules for privileged correspondence apply.
Section 3 provides for an effective date.
Justification
The Correctional Association of NY serves a unique and vital role in shedding light on conditions within NY's prisons and in advocating for reforms. Founded in 1844, CANY was granted authority two years later by the New York State Legislature to monitor prisons and to report findings to the legislature and the broader public. The only private organization in New York with such access to prisons, CANY has remained steadfast in its commitment to inform the public debate on criminal justice for more than 175 years. CANY has also played a role in shaping and securing major criminal justice reforms in New York, on topics ranging from repealing mandatory minimum sentences for drug crimes to ending the shackling of incarcerated pregnant women during labor. Unfortunately, certain of their powers were limited by a chapter amendment in 2021. The goal of this legislation is to enhance and expand the ability of CANY to monitor state prisons and to make transparent for the public, the legis- lature, and the Governor what is actually happening behind prison walls.
The value of the work performed by CANY can be seen in the in-depth periodic reports CANY issues, after in-person visits and inspections, gathering of data, speaking directly with incarcerated individuals as well as with DOCCS officials and staff, and obtaining input from DOCCS on draft reports prior to the reports being finalized. The reports can be found on CANY's website at https://www.correctionalassociation.org/recent-news
The modifications to existing law in this bill would enable CANY to properly perform its unique role, thereby improving the safety, health, and well-being of incarcerated individuals as well as staff
Social justice impact
This legislation will have a significant social justice impact as it would help to hold DOCCS accountable to the people of NY and would improve the safety, health, and well-being of all incarcerated individ- uals and staff. This legislation would also serve to inform the legisla- ture and the Governor of what is actually taking place in the state's prisons and would provide the basis for further positive and necessary reforms of the state's prison system.
Amended bill
The "B" print makes certain clarifications of the role and powers of CANY, removes language that would require agencies other than DOCCS to provide data to CANY, removes the requirement for DOCCS to meet with CANY on a regular basis to discuss data delivery methods, removes the section detailing the process should the department fail to comply with these provisions, as it is redundant and the department would be subject to the same process as any other state agency that fails to comply, and reestablishes the requirement for CANY to request a meeting with correc- tional facility staff during monitoring visits 24 hours prior to the visit.
Senate
2023: S312A (Salazar)- Referred to Crime Victims, Crime and Correction
2022: S9401 (Salazar)- Referred to Crime Victims, Crime and Correction
Assembly
2023: A6489A (Weprin)- Referred to Correction
2022: A10678 (Weprin)- Referred to Correction
Fiscal impact
None.
Effective date
This bill will take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.