What's happening
This bill requires New York to create and maintain a centralized waitlist and placement report for people seeking community residence opportunities for developmental disabilities.
Why it matters
Transparency and Accountability. By mandating a centralized waitlist (CROW) and regular placement reports, the bill increases transparency about who is seeking community residence placements and how opportunities are allocated, making it easier for families, advocates, and policymakers to monitor progress and identify gaps.
Standardized Access and Equity. The CROW must enroll individuals regardless of the nature, type, or urgency of need, which helps ensure fairer and more consistent access to residential services across New York, potentially reducing favoritism or local disparities in placement.
Faster and Clearer Placement Process. The bill outlines strict timelines for application processing, appeals, and enrollment, aiming to reduce bureaucratic delays and provide applicants with clearer expectations and recourse if their applications are denied.
Immediate Inclusion for Current Applicants. Anyone already on a related waitlist is automatically transferred to the new CROW system without needing to reapply, minimizing disruption for individuals and families already waiting for residential opportunities.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Create Housing Waitlist for Disabilities
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
2 Co-sponsors
History
- Referred to disabilities
- Referred to disabilities
Full text
2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
3142
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
January 27, 2023
Introduced by Sens. MANNION, HELMING -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Disabilities
AN ACT to amend the mental hygiene law, in relation to requiring the office for people with developmental disabilities to develop and maintain a community residence opportunities waitlist
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The mental hygiene law is amended by adding a new section 16.15 to read as follows: § 16.15 Community residence opportunities waitlist and placement report.
(a) The office shall develop and maintain a community residence opportunities waitlist, hereinafter referred to as the CROW, which includes the names and contact information of all individuals seeking placement in a community residence as defined in subdivision twenty-eight of section 1.03 of this chapter, who have been determined by the office to require a level of supervision provided in a community residence and have been enrolled or are eligible to be enrolled in the home and community-based services waiver for persons with developmental disabilities. Enrollment in the CROW shall be without regard to the nature, type or urgency of need of the individual seeking enrollment in the CROW. A CROW placement report containing information about individuals who are actively looking for housing and who have been determined by the office to be in need of certified residential opportunity shall be distributed at least monthly and upon request to providers of services as defined in subdivision five of section 1.03 of this chapter.
(b) A provider of services that has vacancies in one or more of its supervised living facilities as defined in subdivision twenty-eight-a of section 1.03 of this chapter may review the individuals listed in the CROW placement report to identify an individual which the provider deems appropriate for placement in the vacancy in its supervised living facility.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD04910-01-3
(c) If a provider identifies an individual on the CROW placement report who the provider, following a person-centered planning process, deems appropriate for placement in one of its supervised living facilities, the provider may accept such person for placement in the community residence facility and shall notify the office in writing of such acceptance. Such individual shall be deemed accepted and enrolled in such program for all purposes including eligibility for reimbursement for the provision of residential habilitation services under the New York state medicaid program, including under the home and community based services waiver program pursuant to subsection (c) of section one thousand nine hundred fifteen of the federal social security act and eligibility for payment or reimbursement of all other funding provided for operation of a community residence.
(d) (1) If the office receives an application for enrollment in the CROW, the office shall act on such application within thirty days of receipt. If an individual who has applied for enrollment in the CROW is denied enrollment, such individual may appeal such denial to the commissioner within thirty days of receipt of notification of such denial.
(2) Upon receipt of such appeal, the commissioner shall personally or by way of a hearing officer conduct a hearing within fifteen days of such a request and render a decision by thirty days after the conclusion of such hearing. A review of the decision rendered by a commissioner pursuant to this section by the individual may be had in a proceeding pursuant to article seventy-eight of the civil practice law and rules commenced within four months of the determination of the commissioner.
§ 2. As of the effective date of this act, any individual who is then listed on any community or certified residential opportunity waitlist or the equivalent maintained by the office shall be deemed automatically to be placed on the CROW without any further action or application by the individual and without any review or approval by the office.
§ 3. This act shall take effect April 1, 2024.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the mental hygiene law, in relation to requiring the office for people with developmental disabilities to develop and main- tain a community residence opportunities waitlist
Purpose
The purpose of this bill is to require the Office of People with Devel- opmental Disabilities (OPWDD) to develop and maintain a Community Resi- dential Opportunity Waitlist (CROW) and a CROW placement report identi- fying all individuals eligible for obtaining a certified residential opportunity in the OPWDD certified setting.
Summary of provisions
-
Read the full memo (1,312 words)
Section 1 of this bill would add a new section 16.15 to the Mental Hygiene Law providing statutory authority for OPWDD do develop and main- tain a community residence opportunities waitlist and placement report, procedures for providers of residential services to offer eligible indi- viduals a placement in a supervised living facility and provide due process appeal rights to individuals seeking enrollment on the CROW.
Section 2 of this bill would provide a transition of individuals currently on a OPWDD developed Certified Residential Opportunity Process list to the new statutorily created CROW.
Section 3 of this bill provides that the effective date shall take effect April 1, 2024.
Justification
In 2015 OPWDD brought together a group of stakeholders to examine ques- tions fundamental to the service system regulated and operated by the OPWDD. Between February and December of 2015, the panel met extensively to delve into questions surrounding residential services, care coordi- nation, employment-related transportation, the workforce and self-direc- tion. The Transformation Panel recommendations were released by OPWDD in a report to the Legislature in February of 2016 titled Raising Expecta- tions, Changing Lives. At the same time, OPWDD released a report to the Legislature on its Residential Request List. At that time, OPWDD indi- cated:
OPWDD "as it seeks to evolve its housing strategies to better respond to demand and changing models of support that can be more tailored to the individual, has heard concerns from many individuals and families who fear that they will be unable to access residential supports when they are needed or plan a future for their loved one."
To assist in meeting residential service needs and to further its hous- ing, planning process. OPVVDD surveyed the more than 11,000 individuals on the Residential Request List (RRL). The RRL, formally known as NY CARES (Creating Alternatives in Residential Environments and Services) was launched in 1998 and served for many years as the primary initiative creating certified residential opportunities in the OPWDD system. While OPWDD indicated over time the development on which OPWDD based the development of certified residential opportunities changed as OPWDD's commitment grew to support people in more individualized and person- controlled settings, 62% of the respondents surveyed indicated they would prefer a residential setting where services and supports are provided by an agency and 33% sought to own or rent a home where needed supports and services would be available. 48% of family caregivers reported that their family member on the RRL need help with almost all basic activities and 46% of family caregivers reported being over the age of 60. At the time, OPWDD also indicated the available supply of residential opportunities, consisting of vacancies in existing capacity, and opportunities created through the development of new capacity would meet the priority one demand (now identified as "Emergency Need"). Recognizing the need to address new resources to assist in meeting the needs of individuals living at home with family caregivers, 810 million in new funding was then proposed in the FY 2017 Executive budget dedi- cated for the development of residential opportunities for people with priority two (now Substantial Need) and priority three (now Current Need) status.
In its February 2016 report to the Legislature, OPWDD also reported that in May of 2015, the agency had implemented the Certified Residential Opportunity (CRO) protocol to provide direction and create consistency in the management of certified housing opportunities. OPWDD indicated:
"The CRO process is one tool used to assess overall need for certified residential services and inform the need for new residential service capacity in the system. The CRO protocol is designed to ensure timely response to urgent needs; to understand and address the unique needs of each individual; and to apply consistent, statewide standards that allow equal opportunity."
According to OPWDD, the CRO protocol reinforces the principles of indi- vidual choice and the importance of helping individuals seek opportu- nities to live in the community in the least restrictive environment. The CRO protocol uses a system of priority level determinations based on individual circumstances as determined by the OPWDD Front Door process. In 2016, OPWDD indicated nearly 41,000 individuals received housing supports, with approximately 38,000 individuals receiving services in certified group residences and another 2,800 receiving rental subsidies. In January of 2017, OPWDD provided an update to the Legislature on the progress of the Transformation Panel's recommendations, indicating that it anticipated, in the next three years (FY 2018 - FY2020) "approximate- ly 4,900 individuals living at home may require a certified residential opportunity and 1,400 individuals living at home may require a more independent supportive housing opportunity. OPWDD told the Legislature, "OPWDD intends to meet these residential supports through a mixture of existing and newly developed ooportunites accessed based upon a person- centered process." OFWE.-C, indtated. the FY201.E; Executive Budget would support approxirnately 2 100 1.1:▒vidLaLls req,L4ing certified and non-residential opportunities. OPWDD also indicated it would continue to provide the Legislature with quarterly updates on the progress of the Transformation Panel's recommendations.
Unfortunately, it appears the promise of changed lives and raised expec- tations, especially in relation to an evolving housing strategy as envi- sioned by OPWDD in the winter of 2017 has been dashed. The CRO protocol as implemented by OPWDD has not operated as it was intended when it was created in 2015. Funding and housing opportunities for priority two and priority three individuals have not materialized as the CRO protocol prevents residential opportunities to be offered in a timely. person centered process to individuals living at home with aging caregivers, who are not in "Emergency Need" for a housing opportunity. The current CRO protocol. combined with recently announced reductions in certified residential provider rates are reducing residential opportunities within the OPWDD service system. Recently, in response to questions raised at the FY2022 Executive budget hearing, OPWDD indicated it currently supports "approximately 35,000 certified residential opportunities", a 3.000 bed reduction in certified residential opportunities compared to 2016. At the same time, OPWDD indicates nearly 5300 individuals are currently seeking a certified residential opportunity, far in excess of the current system vacancies that can be filled.
OPWDD has ignored the Transformation Panel recommendations to develop a Five Year Plan for meeting the housing needs of those living in or seek- ing residential services; has failed to update the Residential Request List to assist in long-term planning; has failed to evaluate the priori- tization of access to residential services to ensure that those now at home are treated fairly by reviewing the prioritization criteria which drive the allocation of residential services; has failed to ensure that individuals living at home and those living in institutional settings have access to residential services based upon need. For over 4 years, OPWDD has failed to provide promised updates to the Legislature on the progress of the Transformation Panel's recommendations.
The legislation is necessary in order to reform the CRO process in ways that comport with the needs of individuals and their families, partic- ularly those whose housing needs are not being currently meet because OPWDD has ignored the policy recommendations of the Transformation Panel and to provide appropriate Legislative structure and oversight for the delivery of residential supports in the OPWDD service delivery system.
Legislative history
2021-22: S.6305 (Mannion) - Referred to Disabilities.
FISCAL IMPLICATIONS:.
To be Determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect April 1, 2024.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.