Skip to content
S3426Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA4238

Expand Youthful Offender Protections

Official title

“Relates to granting certain individuals youthful offender status or young adult offender status; repealer”

Sponsor Zellnor MyrieSD-20+15 co-sponsorsAffects Legal
Status
In Senate Committee
Codes
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Codes

What's happening

This bill expands youthful offender status and creates a new young adult offender status for people up to age 25, allowing certain convictions to be replaced with non-criminal adjudications and sealed records.

Why it matters

  1. Broader eligibility and automatic relief. By raising the age for “youthful offender” status and creating a “young adult offender” status up to age 25, the bill recognizes that brain development and rehabilitation potential extend into the mid-20s. This could significantly reduce lifelong consequences for young adults who commit certain offenses, giving more people access to record sealing, non-criminal adjudications, and second chances.

  2. Presumption in favor of relief. The legislation introduces a presumption that eligible youths and young adults should receive this status (except for the most serious offenses), shifting the burden to prosecutors to prove why it should be denied. This means more young people will automatically benefit unless there is a strong reason not to, reflecting a shift toward rehabilitation over punishment.

  3. Retroactive application and automatic resentencing. The bill applies retroactively, offering both automatic and petition-based opportunities for people previously convicted as youths or young adults to have their records sealed and convictions vacated. This could help thousands who have already served their sentences, improving access to jobs, housing, and education by removing barriers created by criminal records.

  4. Limits on collateral consequences. Young adult and youthful offender adjudications under the new law are not considered criminal convictions, and related records are sealed and confidential. This reduces negative impacts such as employment discrimination, loss of public benefits, and obstacles to professional licensing, supporting reintegration and reducing recidivism risks.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Defendants ages 19 through 25

    The bill would create young adult status for eligible defendants, replacing convictions with noncriminal adjudications, protecting records and limiting sentences.

  • Youths eligible for youthful offender status

    The bill would require that status for specified charges, establish a presumption in favor of it in other covered cases and remove certain eligibility barriers.

  • District attorneys and criminal courts

    The bill would change sentencing determinations and require prosecutors challenging presumptive youthful offender or young adult status to meet a clear-and-convincing-evidence standard.

  • People with prior convictions and the Division of Criminal Justice Services

    The bill would provide retroactive relief for eligible convictions, including automatic replacement of covered misdemeanor and violation convictions within six months under standards established by the division.

Headline styles

Expand Youthful Offender Protections

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

History

  1. Referred to codes
  2. Referred to codes

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A4238Assembly

Expand Youthful Offender Status

In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Daniel O'Donnell

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

10 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

3426

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

January 31, 2023

Introduced by Sens. MYRIE, BRISPORT, CLEARE, RIVERA -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes

AN ACT to amend the criminal procedure law and the penal law, in relation to granting certain individuals youthful offender status; to add a new category of individuals eligible for young adult offender status; and to repeal certain provisions of the criminal procedure law relating thereto

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 720.10 of the criminal procedure law, as added by chapter 981 of the laws of 1971, subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 411 of the laws of 1979, subdivision 2 as amended by chapter 416 of the laws of 1986, paragraph (a) of subdivision 2 as amended by chapter 316 of the laws of 2006, subdivision 3 as amended by chapter 264 of the laws of 2003, and subdivisions 4, 5 and 6 as renumbered by chapter 481 of the laws of 1978, is amended to read as follows: § 720.10 Youthful offender procedure; definition of terms.

As used in this article, the following terms have the following meanings:

1. "Youth" means a person charged with a crime alleged to have been committed when he or she was at least sixteen years old and less than nineteen years old or a person charged with being a juvenile offender as defined in subdivision forty-two of section 1.20 of this chapter.

2. "Eligible youth" means a youth who is eligible to be found a youthful offender. Every youth is so eligible unless:

(a) the conviction to be replaced by a youthful offender finding is for (i) a class A-I or class A-II felony, or (ii) [an armed felony as defined in subdivision forty-one of section 1.20, except as provided in subdivision three, or (iii)] rape in the first degree, criminal sexual

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD06207-01-3

act in the first degree, or aggravated sexual abuse, except as provided in subdivision three, or

(b) such youth has previously been convicted and sentenced for a felony[, or

(c) such youth has previously been adjudicated a youthful offender following conviction of a felony or has been adjudicated on or after September first, nineteen hundred seventy-eight a juvenile delinquent who committed a designated felony act as defined in the family court act].

3. Notwithstanding the provisions of subdivision two of this section, a youth who has been convicted of [an armed felony offense or of] rape in the first degree, criminal sexual act in the first degree, or aggravated sexual abuse is an eligible youth if the court determines that [one or more of the following factors exist:] the interest of justice would be served by relieving the youth from the onus of a criminal record and by not imposing an indeterminate sentence of more than four years. In making such determination, the court shall weigh the following factors: (i) the circumstances and seriousness of the offense with due regard to the extent of the harm caused by it; (ii) any mitigating circumstances that bear [directly upon] on the manner in which the crime was committed; [or (ii)] (iii) where the [defendant] youth was not the sole participant in the crime, the [defendant's participation was relatively minor although not so minor as to constitute a defense to the prosecution] level and extent of his or her direct involvement in the criminal activity; (iv) the history and background of the youth; and (v) prospects for rehabilitation of the youth or opportunities for interventions that would assist the youth in leading a law-abiding life. Where the court determines that the eligible youth is a youthful offender, the court shall make a statement on the record of the reasons for its determination, a transcript of which shall be forwarded to the state division of criminal justice services, to be kept in accordance with the provisions of subdivision three of section eight hundred thirty-seven-a of the executive law.

4. "Youthful offender finding" means a finding, substituted for the conviction of an eligible youth, pursuant to a determination that the eligible youth is a youthful offender.

5. "Youthful offender sentence" means the sentence imposed upon a youthful offender finding.

6. "Youthful offender adjudication". A youthful offender adjudication is comprised of a youthful offender finding and the youthful offender sentence imposed thereon and is completed by imposition and entry of the youthful offender sentence.

§ 2. Subdivision 3 of section 720.15 of the criminal procedure law is REPEALED.

§ 3. Subdivision 1 of section 720.20 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by chapter 652 of the laws of 1974, is amended to read as follows:

1. Upon conviction of an eligible youth, the court must order a presentence investigation of the defendant. After receipt of a written report of the investigation and at the time of pronouncing sentence the court must determine whether or not the eligible youth is a youthful offender. Such determination shall be in accordance with the following criteria:

(a) If [in the opinion of the court the interest of justice would be served by relieving the eligible] the eligible youth is charged with a misdemeanor offense, a class D or E felony offense, a class C felony as described in subdivision one of section 160.10 of the penal law or any offense contained in article two hundred twenty of the penal law other than a class A-I or A-II felony offense, the court shall find that he or she is a youthful offender.

(b) In all other cases, except when the youth is charged with rape in the first degree, and aggravated sexual abuse, there shall be a presumption to grant youthful offender status to an eligible youth in order to relieve such youth from the onus of a criminal record [and by not imposing], other consequences of a criminal conviction, and the imposition of an indeterminate term of imprisonment of more than four years[, the court may, in its discretion, find the eligible youth is a youthful offender; and

(b) Where the conviction is had in a local criminal court and the eligible youth had not prior to commencement of trial or entry of a plea of guilty been convicted of a crime or found a youthful offender, the court must find he is a youthful offender]. Upon motion of not less than seven days' notice, the prosecutor may challenge the presumption to grant youthful offender status. The court shall grant youthful offender status unless the prosecutor rebuts the presumption and establishes by clear and convincing evidence that the criteria set forth in subdivision two of section 720.10 of this article require that youthful offender status be denied.

§ 4. Section 720.35 of the criminal procedure law, as added by chapter 981 of the laws of 1971, subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 23 of the laws of 2021, subdivisions 2 and 4 as amended by section 87 of subpart B of part C of chapter 62 of the laws of 2011 and subdivision 3 as amended by chapter 181 of the laws of 2000, is amended to read as follows: § 720.35 Youthful offender adjudication; effect thereof; records.

1. A youthful offender or young adult adjudication is not a judgment of conviction for a crime or any other offense, and does not operate as a disqualification of any person so adjudged to hold public office or public employment or to receive any license granted by public authority but shall be deemed a conviction only for the purposes of transfer of supervision and custody pursuant to section two hundred fifty-nine-m of the executive law. A defendant for whom a youthful offender adjudication was substituted, who was originally charged with prostitution as defined in section 230.00 of the penal law, shall be deemed a "sexually exploited child" as defined in subdivision one of section four hundred forty-seven-a of the social services law and therefore shall not be considered an adult for purposes related to the charges in the youthful offender proceeding or a proceeding under section 170.80 of this chapter.

2. Except where specifically required or permitted by statute or upon specific authorization of the court, all official records and papers, whether on file with the court, a police agency or the division of criminal justice services, relating to a case involving a youth or young adult who has been adjudicated a youthful offender or granted a young adult status finding, are confidential and may not be made available to any person or public or private agency, other than the designated educational official of the public or private elementary or secondary school in which the youth or young adult is enrolled as a student provided that such local educational official shall only have made available a notice of such adjudication and shall not have access to any other official records and papers, such youth or young adult or such youth's or young adult's designated agent (but only where the official records and papers sought are on file with a court and request therefor is made to that court or to a clerk thereof), an institution to which such youth or young adult has been committed, the department of corrections and community supervision and a probation department of this state that requires such official records and papers for the purpose of carrying out duties specifically authorized by law; provided, however, that information regarding an order of protection or temporary order of protection issued pursuant to section 530.12 of this chapter or a warrant issued in connection therewith may be maintained on the statewide automated order of protection and warrant registry established pursuant to section two hundred twenty-one-a of the executive law during the period that such order of protection or temporary order of protection is in full force and effect or during which such warrant may be executed. Such confidential information may be made available pursuant to law only for purposes of adjudicating or enforcing such order of protection or temporary order of protection and, where provided to a designated educational official, as defined in section 380.90 of this chapter, for purposes related to the execution of the student's educational plan, where applicable, successful school adjustment and reentry into the community. Such notification shall be kept separate and apart from such student's school records and shall be accessible only by the designated educational official. Such notification shall not be part of such student's permanent school record and shall not be appended to or included in any documentation regarding such student and shall be destroyed at such time as such student is no longer enrolled in the school district. At no time shall such notification be used for any purpose other than those specified in this subdivision.

3. If a youth or young adult who has been adjudicated a youthful offender or granted a young adult status finding is enrolled as a student in a public or private elementary or secondary school the court that has [adjudicated the youth as a] made the youthful offender or young adult adjudication shall provide notification of such adjudication to the designated educational official of the school in which such youth or young adult is enrolled as a student. Such notification shall be used by the designated educational official only for purposes related to the execution of the student's educational plan, where applicable, successful school adjustment and reentry into the community. Such notification shall be kept separate and apart from such student's school records and shall be accessible only by the designated educational official. Such notification shall not be part of such student's permanent school record and shall not be appended to or included in any documentation regarding such student and shall be destroyed at such time as such student is no longer enrolled in the school district. At no time shall such notification be used for any purpose other than those specified in this subdivision.

4. Notwithstanding subdivision two of this section, whenever a person is adjudicated a youthful offender or granted young adult status and the conviction that was vacated and replaced by the youthful offender or young adult status finding was for a sex offense as that term is defined in article ten of the mental hygiene law, all records pertaining to the youthful offender or young adult adjudication shall be included in those records and reports that may be obtained by the commissioner of mental health or the commissioner of developmental disabilities, as appropriate; the case review panel; and the attorney general pursuant to section 10.05 of the mental hygiene law.

§ 5. Subparagraph (i) of paragraph (b) of subdivision 3 of section 220.30 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by chapter 410 of the laws of 1979, is amended to read as follows:

(i) A plea of guilty, whether to the entire indictment or to part of the indictment for any crime other than a class A felony, may not be accepted on the condition that it constitutes a complete disposition of one or more other indictments against the defendant wherein is charged a class A-I felony as defined in article two hundred twenty of the penal law or the attempt to commit any such class A-I felony, except that [an eligible youth, as defined in subdivision two of section 720.10, may plea to a class B felony, upon consent of the district attorney, for purposes of adjudication as a youthful offender] this restriction shall not apply to an eligible youth, as defined in subdivision two of section 720.10 of this chapter, or an eligible young adult, as defined in subdivision two of section 721.10 of this chapter.

§ 6. Subdivision 3 of section 420.30 of the criminal procedure law, as amended by chapter 144 of the laws of 2020, is amended to read as follows:

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the criminal procedure law and the penal law, in relation to granting certain individuals youthful offender status; to add a new category of individuals eligible for young adult offender status; and to repeal certain provisions of the criminal procedure law relating thereto

Purpose

To update New York's criminal law to reflect twenty-first century under- standing of the adolescent brain and criminal culpability, by creating a new Young Adult Offender status to apply to those who are 19 to 25 years old at the time of the alleged offense, as well as a new First Offender status for those 22 or older at the time of the alleged offense.

Summary of provisions

Section 1 of the bill amends section 720.10 of the Criminal Procedure Law ("CPL"). Section 2 of the bill repeals CPL section 720.15, subdivi- sions 3 and 4. Section 3 of the bill amends subdivision 1 of CPL section 720.20. It defines "youth" as anyone who has committed a crime when they were at least sixteen and younger than nineteen years old. Along with that it defines "eligible youth" as anyone who fits the classification of "youth" unless the crime committed was a Class A-I, Class A-II felo- ny, rape, criminal sexual act in the first degree, aggravated sexual abuse.

Read the full memo (1,335 words)

Section 2 of the bill amends subdivision 3 of section 720.15 of the criminal procedure law by repealing it.

Section 3 of the bill amends subdivision 1 of section 720.20 of the criminal procedure law to say that once someone is convicted as an eligible youth the court must order a presentence investigation to determine whether or not they qualify to be considered an "youthful offender". Considerations being that the charge is a misdemeanor offense, a class D or E felony or a class C felony. Anything other than that will result in the failure of the consideration to be considered a "youthful offender".

Section 4 of the bill amends CPL section 220.30, subdivision 3, it also highlights that a youthful offender adjudication is not a judgment of a crime for any other purpose than to highlight it during a custody battle or supervision. The notification of this adjudication will be kept private to all parties unless it is requested by the designated educa- tional official that oversees the person at a private elementary or secondary school. At that point it will be left to the discretion of the official to use this information to help make an educative plan for the child.

Section 5 of the bill amends CPL section 410 of the laws of 1979, which does not allow for a plea of guilty to a part or all aspects of the charge being presented. If the felony that is being charged is a class A-I felony unless the qualify as a "eligible youth"

Section 6 of the bill amends subdivision 3 of section 420.30 which allows for an "eligible youth" not be required to pay the fees charged when needing to complete the sex offender registration fee, DNA Databank fee, or crime victim assistance fee.

Section 7 of the bill amends subdivision 2 of section 420.35 which allows an "eligible youth" not be required to pay the fees charged when needing to complete the sex offender registration fee, DNA Databank fee, or crime victim assistance fee. In any other situation all of these fees will not be allowed to be waived under any condition unless otherwise stated.

Section 8 of the bill adds article 721 which defines what young adult status procedure is, how it is defined and how it can be adjudicated. See the article for further details.

Section 9 of the bill adds a new section 440.49 that focuses on defining what an eligible youth is, and the special stipulations that would grant a convicted person a "young adult" status. It also allows the District Attorney the right to call into question the status that was granted by the committee.

Section 10 of the bill amends Criminal Penal Law {"PL") section 450.10 by adding a new subdivision 6 that allows for the denial of a motion to grant a "youthful offender" status.

Section 11 of the bill amends PL section 60.02, subdivision 2 by adding a new subdivision 3 that states it is only applicable to a juvenile offender or someone who has been granted a "youthful offender" status.

Section 12 of the bill amends Subdivisions 1 and 2 of section 60.02 of the penal law by adding a new subdivision 3 that states if someone is granted a "young adult" sentence" then the punishment must be swapped as long as it is not a felony. If the crime is considered to be a misdemea- nor then the maximum sentence should 'not be bigger than 6 months.

Section 13 amends subdivision 4 of section 80.00 of the penal law with the use of chapter 338 of the laws of 1989 that a corporation is ineli- gible to qualify for a "young adult" status.

Section 14 amends subdivision 6 of section 80.05 of the penal law to restrict a corporation by making them ineligible to qualify for a "young adult" status.

Section 15 amends subdivision 7 of section 340.40 of the criminal proce- dure law with the use of chapter 981 of the laws of 1971 that states that under an "eligible youth" status any trial will automatically be a jury trial unless at the specific request of the person being charged. As such it will become a single judge trial.

Section 16 provides the effective date.

Justification

Modern neuroscience research shows that an adolescent's brain is not fully developed until their mid-twenties. As the United States Supreme Court recognized in Roper v. Simmons, 54.3 U.S. 551 (2005), adolescents have diminished culpability for their actions as compared to adults. "Youth are less mature and have an underdeveloped sense of responsibil- ity; they are more vulnerable to outside pressures, including peer pres- sure, and other negative influences; and their characters are less well formed and still developing." Id. at 569-570. Youthful offender (Y0) status recognizes the differences in legal culpability between adoles- cents and adults and provides a mechanism for different treatment of young offenders when appropriate. Under the existing YO statute, youth benefit from reduced sentencing, including alternatives to incarceration and, because a YO adjudication is sealed to the public, the young person is protected from devastating collateral consequences associated with a permanent criminal record, including deportation, eligibility for student loans, and employment and housing discrimination. All of these protections are appropriate given the age of the offender. Studies reviewed and summarized by the National Conference of St ate Legisla- tures support a conclusion that the neurobiological, psychosocial and developmental differences between juveniles and adults continue into the late teens and early twenties. A longitudinal study conducted by the chief of Brain Imaging in the Child Psychiatry Branch of the National Institute of Mental Health concluded that the average human brain is not fully developed until age 25; critically, the frontal lobe, which is responsible for functions such as advanced cognition, controlling impulses and judging consequences, continues to develop into the early twenties. The MacArthur Foundation has conducted psychosocial and developmental research that corroborates the neurobiological findings.

New York must update its criminal procedure laws to reflect twenty-first century understanding of the adolescent brain and criminal culpability. This bill provides judges the discretion to grant the sealing and sentencing protections of youthful offender status for youth until their 26th birthday. The bill is also retroactive, in recognition of the enor- mous harm that New York State has inflicted on youth - and almost exclu- sively only youth of color - over the past forty years by saddling youth with a permanent criminal record that stays with them their entire life.

Legislative history

S5749A of 2021-22: Referred to Codes.

Fiscal implications

None.

Effective date

November first next succeeding the date on which it shall have become a law.

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.