What's happening
This bill raises population requirements for village incorporation, mandates financial impact statements, and adds State Comptroller review before elections.
Why it matters
Increases the population threshold for creating new villages. , making it harder for small communities to incorporate and potentially reducing the number of new local governments and associated costs to taxpayers.
Requires a detailed financial impact statement before incorporation. , meaning residents must be informed about projected budgets, services, and tax impacts for both the proposed village and the surrounding town(s); this adds transparency and encourages more informed decision-making.
Mandates State Comptroller review of financial projections. , introducing an expert, independent analysis to verify the reasonableness of revenue, spending, and tax impact estimates, which could prevent unsustainable or misleading proposals from moving forward.
Extends the incorporation timeline and adds procedural steps. , such as requiring the Comptroller’s review before holding an election, potentially slowing down the process but also aiming to ensure greater scrutiny and public awareness.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Village incorporation organizers
They would face minimum populations of 10,000 in suburban towns with at least 75,000 residents and 2,500 in other towns, measured by the latest decennial census, plus new financial disclosure requirements.
Property owners seeking incorporation
The bill would eliminate petitions based on property valuation and require signatures from at least 20 percent of residents qualified to vote for town officers.
Taxpayers in proposed villages and remaining town areas
Required financial statements would estimate five-year property tax impacts on both areas, with state comptroller review before an incorporation election.
State comptroller and town supervisors
The comptroller would review proposed budgets, services and tax projections, while supervisors would submit petitions for review and file and distribute the resulting letter.
Headline styles
Toughen Village Incorporation Rules
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
Senator · Senate District 42
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Recommit, enacting clause stricken
- Referred to local government
Full text
7 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
3455
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
January 31, 2023
Introduced by Sen. SKOUFIS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Local Government
AN ACT to amend the village law, in relation to the incorporation of villages; and to repeal section 2-212 of such law relating thereto
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Section 2-200 of the village law, subdivision 2 as amended by chapter 932 of the laws of 1974, is amended to read as follows:
§ 2-200 Population and area requirements. 1. A territory containing a population of at least [five] ten thousand in a suburban town pursuant to article three-A of the town law with a population of seventy-five thousand or more or twenty-five hundred persons [who are regular inhabitants thereof, as hereinafter defined,] for all other towns may be incorporated as a village under this chapter provided such territory does not include a part of a city or village and further provided the limits of such territory:
a. do not contain more than five square miles; or
b. are coterminous with the entire boundaries of a school, fire, fire protection, fire alarm, town special or town improvement district; or
c. are coterminous with parts of the boundaries of more than one school, fire, fire protection, fire alarm, town special or town improvement district, all of which are wholly contained within such limits and within one town; or
d. are coterminous with the entire boundaries of a town.
2. The [words "regular inhabitants" as used herein and for the purpose of this article shall include all persons residing in the territory proposed to be incorporated except such persons who themselves, or who are persons under the age of eighteen years residing with persons who, maintain a residence outside such territory which is used as their address for purposes of voting] population of a territory shall be determined on the basis of the most recent decennial federal census.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD04555-01-3
§ 2. Section 2-202 of the village law, subparagraph 2 of paragraph f of subdivision 1 as amended by chapter 181 of the laws of 2004, is amended to read as follows:
§ 2-202 Petition for incorporation. 1. A proceeding for the incorporation of such territory as a village shall commence with a petition. The requirements for such petition are as follows:
a. Petitioners. [Either one or both of the following two groups of persons may petition for such incorporation:
(1)] At least twenty [per cent] percent of the residents of such territory qualified to vote for town officers in a town in which all or part of such territory is located shall sign such petition.
[(2) The owners of more than fifty percent in assessed valuation of the real property in such territory assessed upon the last completed assessment roll of the town in which such territory is located. However, if such territory is located in more than one town it shall be required in computing such percentage to equalize the assessed valuations for each town; furthermore, in such case, the petition must be signed by the owners of more than fifty percent in full valuation of the real property in each part of each town in such territory and computed separately for each such part, and assessed upon the last completed assessment rolls of the towns in which any part of such territory is located. Full valuation shall be determined by applying the appropriate equalization rate to such assessed valuations. If real property in such territory is owned by tenants in common, joint tenants or tenants by the entirety, each such tenant, as a signer of such petition shall, for the purpose of ascertaining the percentage of the assessed valuation upon which the petition is based, be considered as the owner of an interest in such real property equal to the result reached by dividing the assessed valuation by the number of owners thereof and shall be credited to that extent with part of the total assessed valuation thereof. In the event such real property is part of a parcel of land partially situated within such territory, the town assessor or assessors shall, for the purposes of this section make an apportionment of the assessed value of such part as is in such territory. In such a case, only the apportioned value attributed to such part shall be considered.]
b. Contents of petition. The petition shall contain the following information:
(1) An allegation [of the basis on which the petition is signed] that at least twenty percent of the residents qualified to vote for town officers have signed such petition.
(2) The name of the proposed village.
(3) An allegation that such territory contains a population of at least [five] ten thousand in a suburban town pursuant to article three-A of the town law with a population of seventy-five thousand or more or twenty-five hundred [regular inhabitants] persons for all other towns according to the most recent decennial census.
(4) The manner in which the area requirements of section 2-200 of this article are satisfied.
(5) A designation of at least one but no more than three persons, giving full names and addresses, on whom and at which addresses all papers required to be served in connection with the proceeding for incorporation, shall be served. A majority of such designees must reside in such territory.
(6) Each page of the petition and all exhibits and certifications shall be securely fastened together.
c. Exhibits and certifications. Each copy of the petition shall have attached thereto prior to the signature pages:
(1) A description of such territory sufficient to identify the location and extent of such territory with common certainty and which shall be in one of the following forms or a combination thereof: (a) a metes and bounds description; (b) a description made with reference to existing streets and navigable waters or a combination of same; or (c) a map showing existing streets and navigable waters or a combination of same forming boundaries or metes and bounds or the entire boundaries of one or more districts of an entire town.
(2) A [list of the names and address of the regular inhabitants of such territory] copy of a financial impact statement. Such financial impact statement shall include the following: (a) a proposed operating budget for the territory to be incorporated; (b) a proposed capital budget for the territory to be incorporated; (c) a description of the services that would be provided by the proposed village and how such services would be delivered; (d) the estimated property tax impact for a five year period on the territory to be incorporated and the remaining area of the town or towns; and (e) an executive summary of such financial impact statement, including the estimated real property tax impact on the territory to be incorporated and the remaining area of the town or towns.
d. [If the petition is alleged to be signed by the owners of more than fifty per cent in assessed or full valuation, as the case may be, of the real property in such territory, there shall be attached to the petition following the signatures of the petitioners an affidavit or affidavits certifying as follows:
(1) If such territory is located entirely in one town, a certification by an assessor thereof certifying to the total assessed valuation of such territory and the correct total amount thereof owned by the signers of the petition, or
(2) If such territory is located in more than one town, separate certifications by an assessor of each town certifying to the total full valuation of that portion of such territory located in such town and the correct total amount of full valuation of real property in such territory and town owned by the signers of the petition, as specified in subparagraph two of paragraph a of subdivision one of this section.
e.] Execution of petition. (1) The signatures to a petition shall be subscribed on a separate page or pages following the exhibits.
(2) Prefatory statement. Each signature page shall be prefaced by a statement [of the basis on which the petition is signed and of the] that the petitioners are residents of the territory to be incorporated qualified to vote for town officers in such territory and that the petitioners' [familiarity] are familiar with the contents and purpose [thereof] of such petition and the boundaries of the territory sought to be incorporated.
(3) Additional information. Following each signature there shall be set forth, not necessarily by the signer, the signer's address consisting of street name and number, if any, and town[; and, if the petition is based on the ownership of more than fifty per cent in assessed or full valuation, as the case may be, of the real property located in such territory, the amount of assessed valuation of real property owned by the signer as credited to him in accordance with subparagraph two of paragraph a of subdivision one of this section].
(4) Authentication. There shall be set forth at the bottom of each page of signatures an authenticating affidavit of a witness to the signing thereof which shall be in substantially the following form:
STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF ss.:
...................................................... being duly sworn, (name of witness) says: I reside at ..................................................... in the
(street name and number) ................................ of .................................... (town, city or village) (name of municipality) .............................................. in the State of New York: I know each of the persons whose names are subscribed to the above sheet having .................................... signatures; and each of them
(number) subscribed the same in my presence.
...................................
(signature of witness)
Sworn to before me This .................. day of .................., ....................
(day) (month) (year)
...............................
(official title of officer)
[f] e. Filing and deposit. (1) Filing. The original petition shall be filed with a supervisor of the town in which all or the greatest part of such territory is located. Duplicate originals, photocopies or other similar reproductions of the original petition shall be filed with a supervisor of each other town in which any portion of such territory is located.
(2) Deposit. At the time of filing of the petition there shall be deposited with each supervisor with whom the original or a copy of the original is filed, the sum of six thousand dollars to pay the cost of posting, publishing and serving required notices, stenographic services and services of inspectors of election in the event incorporation is not effected.
§ 3. Subdivision 1 of section 2-206 of the village law, paragraph b as amended by chapter 167 of the laws of 1985 and paragraph e as amended by chapter 561 of the laws of 1975, is amended to read as follows:
1. The supervisor, or supervisors if a joint hearing, with whom the petition or copies thereof, were filed, shall meet at the time and place specified in such notice and shall hear objections which may be presented as to the legal sufficiency of the petition for incorporation based upon any of the following grounds:
a. That a person signing such petition was not qualified therefor;
b. [If it is alleged that the petition is submitted on the basis that the persons signing such petition constitute twenty per cent of the residents in such territory qualified to vote for officers of a town in which all or part of such territory is located, that such allegation is false;
c. If it is alleged that the petition is submitted on the basis that the persons signing such petition are the owners of more than fifty percent in assessed valuation of the real property in such territory or in full valuation of the real property in each part of each town in such territory and computed separately for each such part, as the case may be, assessed upon the last completed assessment roll or rolls of the town or towns in which all or part of such territory is located, that such allegation is false] That the allegation that the petition constitutes twenty percent of the residents of the territory qualified to vote for officers of a town in which all or part of such territory is located is false;
[d] c. That such territory is part of a city or village;
[e] d. That if such territory is less than an entire town, it contains more than five square miles and the limits of such territory are not coterminous with the entire boundaries of one school, fire, fire protection, fire alarm, town special or town improvement district and the limits of such territory are not coterminous with parts of the boundaries of more than one school, fire, fire protection, fire alarm, town special or town improvement district, all of which are wholly contained within such limits and within one town;
[f] e. That such territory does not contain a population of at least [five] ten thousand in a suburban town pursuant to article three-A of the town law with a population of seventy-five thousand or more or twenty-five hundred [regular inhabitants] persons for all other towns;
[g] f. That the petition in any other specified respect does not conform to the requirements of this article.
§ 4. Subdivisions 1 and 4 of section 2-210 of the village law are amended to read as follows:
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the village law, in relation to the incorporation of villages; and to repeal section 2-212 of such law relating thereto
Purpose
To update and improve the process and requirements to incorporate as a village.
Summary of provisions
Section 1. Section 2-200 of the Village Law is amended to increase the population requirement from 500 to 2,500 to incorporate as a village; The population of the proposed village would be determined by the latest decennial federal census.
Read the full memo (1,354 words)
Section 2. Section 2-202 of the Village Law is amended to:
a) eliminate property ownership as a basis for petitioning for village incorporation.
b) contents of petition
c) exhibits and certification includes a description of such territory to be incorporating and requires a copy of a financial impact statement with a petition for incorporation that includes:
* A proposed operating budget for the territory to be incorporated *A proposed capital budget for the area to be incorporated
* A description of the services that would be provided by the proposed village and how they would be delivered
* The estimated property tax impact for a five-year period on the terri- tory to be incorporated and the remaining area of the town(s)
* An executive summary of the financial impact statement on the territo- ry to be incorporated and the remaining area of the town(s).
d) Execution of petition. Eliminates the requirement to provide a list of the names and addresses of the regular inhabitants of the territory proposed to be incorporated as a village.
Section 3. Amends subdivision 1 of Section 2-206 of the Village Law relating to objections to the legal sufficiency of the petition by conforming the objections to the new provisions relating to population and the basis for signing a petition.
Section 4. Amends subdivision 1 and subdivision 4 of Section 2-210 of the Village Law in relation to judicial review of the decisions by the Town Supervisor(s) with regard to village incorporation.
Section 5. A new Section 2-211 is added to the Village Law to provide for the review of the financial impact statement by the State Comp- troller The Town Supervisor(s), where the petition for incorporation is found to be legally sufficient, shall file a copy of the petition with the Office of the State Department of Audit and Control.
The State Comptroller shall review of the financial impact statement, including the proposed operating budget, the proposed capital budget, the description of services that would be provided by the proposed village and how such services would be delivered, and the estimated property tax impact for a five-year period on the territory to be incor- porated and the remaining area of the town(s). Additional information or data may be requested by the Comptroller to aid in reviewing the finan- cial impact statement.
The Comptroller shall issue a letter of the review to be filed by the Supervisor with the Town Clerk and made available for public inspection. A copy of this letter will also be mailed to the incorporators and all objectors to the petition.
Section 6. Repeals Section 2-212 of the Village Law and adds a new
Section 2212 providing for the right to an election.
Section 7. Subdivision 5 of Section 2-220 of the Village Law is renum- bered subdivision 6 and a new subdivision 5 is added to provide for absentee ballots for village incorporation elections.
Section 8. Amends subdivision d of Section 2-232 of the Village Law that requires a statement of the population of the territory as it appears in the contents of the petition for incorporation.
Section 9. Applicability. The new provisions would apply to any proceed- ing for the incorporation of a village where the right the right to an election has not already accrued pursuant to the former
Section 2-212 of the Village Law.
Section 10. Severability Clause.
Section 11. Effective Date.
Justification
The incorporation of new village can have significant tax and fiscal impacts on taxpayers in both the proposed village and throughout the town (or towns) in which a new village is to be located. It is imper- ative that the financial impacts of the new village be assessed prior the public vote on incorporation so that voters may make an informed decision.
This legislation improves the current village incorporation process by ensuring that voters possess all relevant information necessary to make an informed decision. The review of such information by the State Comp- troller will ensure that voters possess objective information reviewed by an independent professional with no interest in the outcome of a village incorporation proceeding. In the past, the lack of such accurate and objective financial information about a village incorporation has led to the creation of new villages where voters were not adequately informed about financial impacts and feasibility. The result has been
disappointment and disillusionment and ultimately dissolution, as was the case with Villages of Mastic Beach and Pine Valley.
This legislation would require that a financial impact statement be filed with a petition for incorporation that includes a proposed operat- ing and capital budget, a description of services to be offered along with their delivery method, a five-year property tax impact estimate on both the territory to be incorporated and the remaining areas of the town(s) affected, and an executive summary of the financial impact statement on the territory to be incorporated and the remaining area of the town(s).
Once the petition is filed with all the necessary requirements, the supervisor(s) shall determine the legal sufficiency of the petition. Upon a favorable determination, the petition will be submitted to the New York State Department of Audit and Control.
The State Comptroller shall review the financial impact statement and assess whether the significant revenue and expenditure projections in the proposed operating budget are reasonable in light of the services that would be provided; that the proposed capital budget clearly identi- fies future capital needs and provides reasonable estimates of each project's budgetary impact including debt service costs, impact on capi- tal reserve funds and fund balance and future operating expenditures; and the estimated property tax impact for a five-year period on the territory to be incorporated and the remaining area of the town or towns is reasonable in light of the proposed operating and capital budgets. After review, the Comptroller shall issue a letter to be filed by the Supervisor with the Town Clerk and made available for public inspection. A copy of this letter will also be mailed to the incorporators and all objectors to the petition.
An election to determine the question of incorporation shall be held no later than 40 days after the filing of the Comptroller's letter with the Town Clerk. The decisions of the Supervisor would be subject to review under Article 78 of the Civil Practice Laws and Rules. It is also noted that the village incorporation law has been virtually unchanged in 56 years and requires additional updating and modernization.
This legislation provides that a territory containing a population of at least 10,000 in a suburban town pursuant to Article 3-A of the town law with a population of 75,000, or 2500 persons for all other towns (increased from 500 persons), may be incorporated as a village. Popu- lation would be determined by the latest decennial federal census. The requirement to list the names and addresses of each regular inhabitant would be eliminated. In addition, consistent with voting reforms enacted in New York State since the enactment of the village incorporation law in 1964, property ownership would be eliminated as a basis for petition- ing for village incorporation. Absentee ballots would also be available for village incorporation elections.
These new provisions would apply to any incorporation proceeding where the right to an election has not already accrued before the effective date of this act.
Legislative history
Senate 2020 - S7375 - A, Referred to Local Government
2021 -2022 - S1657B, Referred to Local Government
Assembly
2020 - A9939, Referred to Local Governments
2021-2022- A2553B, Reported to ways and means
Fiscal implications
None.
Effective date
This act shall take effect immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.