What's happening
Summary being written. Track this bill to get it by email.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Headline styles
Allow Mutual Insurance Conversions
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
Senator · Senate District 46
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to insurance
- Referred to insurance
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Allow Insurer Mutual Holding Companies
In Assembly Committee · Insurance · Sponsor David Weprin
Full text
14 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
3538
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE
January 31, 2023
Introduced by Sen. BRESLIN -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Insurance
AN ACT to amend the insurance law, in relation to the formation of mutual holding companies by certain domestic mutual property/casualty insurers and the reorganization in connection therewith of a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer into a domestic stock property/casualty insurer
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. The insurance law is amended by adding a new article 81 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 81
MUTUAL HOLDING COMPANY; PROPERTY/CASUALTY INSURER Section 8101. Definitions.
8102. Reorganization of mutual property/casualty insurer through
formation of a mutual holding company; contents of plan.
8103. Dividend practices.
8104. Adoption of plan; submission of plan to the superinten-
dent.
8105. Amendment or withdrawal of plan.
8106. Consultants.
8107. Approval of plan by superintendent; hearing.
8108. Approval of plan by eligible members.
8109. Filing of plan; effective date of reorganization.
8110. Effect of reorganization.
8111. Corporate existence.
8112. Directors and officers.
8113. Notice of proposed reorganization.
8114. Failure to give notice.
8115. Limitations of actions; security.
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD07348-01-3
8116. Prohibited transactions by officers, directors and employ-
ees.
8117. Requirements applicable to a mutual holding company.
8118. Other requirements applicable to an intermediate stock
holding company and a mutual holding company.
8119. Conversion of mutual holding company.
8120. Transfers of subsidiaries.
§ 8101. Definitions. As used in this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
(a) "Adoption date" means the date the board of directors of the mutual property/casualty insurer adopts the plan of reorganization.
(b) "Beneficial ownership" with respect to any security, means the sole or shared power to vote or direct the voting of, such security and/or the sole or shared power to dispose or direct the disposition of such security.
(c) "Effective date" means, in the case of the reorganization of a mutual property/casualty insurer, the date upon which the reorganization of the mutual property/casualty insurer shall be effective in accordance with section eight thousand one hundred nine of this article as a result of reorganization proceedings pursuant to this article.
(d) "Eligible member" with reference to a mutual property/casualty insurer, means a person who, by the records of the mutual property/casualty insurer, is deemed to be the "policyholder" of a policy or contract which is of a type of any one or more of the basic kinds of insurance specified in subsection (a) of section four thousand hundred one of this chapter for purposes of section four thousand one hundred sixteen of this chapter as of the adoption date. A person insured under a group policy is not an eligible member. A person whose policy becomes effective one calendar day after the board of directors adopts the plan of conversion but before the effective date of the plan of conversion is not an eligible member.
(e) "Member" means a member of such mutual holding company as provided in subsection (c) of section eight thousand one hundred seventeen of this article.
(f) "Membership interests" means, with reference to an institution that is a mutual property/casualty insurer or a mutual holding company, the rights as members arising under the charter of such institution or this chapter or otherwise by law including the rights to vote and to participate in any distribution of the surplus of such institution, whether or not incident to a liquidation thereof. The term "membership interests" does not include rights expressly conferred upon the policyholders by their policies or contracts (including the right to participate in the distribution of surplus) other than the right to vote.
(g) "Mutual holding company" means a corporation organized under section eight thousand one hundred seventeen of this article.
(h) "Mutual property/casualty insurer" for the purposes of this article means a domestic mutual property/casualty insurance company organized under article twelve of this chapter and licensed under article forty-one of this chapter, or a domestic advance premium corporation organized and licensed under article sixty-six of this chapter, or an assessment corporation organized and licensed under article sixty-six of this chapter.
(i) "Offer" includes every offer to buy or acquire, solicitation of an offer to sell, tender offer for, or request or invitation for tenders of a security or interest in a security for value.
(j) "Outside director" means a director:
(1) who is not an officer, employee or consultant of the mutual holding company, any stock holding company, the reorganized insurer or any other subsidiary of the mutual holding company or any stock holding company;
(2) who does not directly or indirectly own, control or hold one percent or greater of the voting securities of any stock holding company, the reorganized insurer or any other subsidiary of the mutual holding company or any stock holding company; and
(3) who is not a director, officer or employee of any person except the mutual holding company or any stock holding company that directly or indirectly owns, controls or holds such percentage of such voting security. Lesser amounts of ownership of voting securities other than those provided for in this subsection may be approved by the superintendent as a component of the mutual holding company's plan of reorganization pursuant to this article.
(k) "Person" means an individual, partnership, firm, association, corporation, joint-stock company, limited liability company, limited liability partnership, trust, government or governmental agency, state or political subdivision thereof, public or private corporation, board, association, estate, trustee or fiduciary, any similar entity or any combination of the foregoing acting in concert.
(l) "Plan of reorganization" or "plan" means a plan adopted by a mutual property/casualty insurer in compliance with this article.
(m) "Policyholder" means a person who, by the records of the mutual property/casualty insurer, is deemed to be the policyholder of a policy or contract which is of a type of any one or more of the basic kinds of insurance specified in subsection (a) of section four thousand one hundred one of this chapter for purposes of section four thousand one hundred sixteen of this chapter.
(n) "Public offering" means a stock offering required to be registered pursuant to the Securities Act of 1933, United States Code, Title 15, Section 77e.
(o) "Reorganized stock insurer" means the stock property/casualty insurer into which a mutual property/casualty insurer has been reorganized in accordance with the provisions of this article.
(p) "Reorganizing insurer" means, in the case of a plan of reorganization of a mutual property/casualty insurer under this article, the mutual property/casualty insurer that is reorganizing pursuant to such plan.
(q) "Intermediate stock holding company" means a corporation incorporated under the laws of any jurisdiction in the United States, at least fifty-one percent of the voting stock of which is owned, directly or through another intermediate stock holding company, by a mutual holding company and which holds, directly or indirectly, voting stock in at least one reorganized insurer.
(r) "Voting security" includes voting securities as defined in paragraph forty-five of subsection (a) of section one hundred seven of this chapter, any reorganization certificate or subscription (including subscription rights issued pursuant to a plan of reorganization), or any security convertible (with or without consideration) into any such security, or carrying any warrant or right to subscribe for or purchase any such security, or any such warrant or right.
(s) "Voting stock" means capital stock that constitutes voting securities as defined in paragraph forty-five of subsection (a) of section one hundred seven of this chapter. All references in this article to a specified percentage of the voting stock of any person shall mean securities having the specified percentage of the voting power in such person for the election of directors, trustees or management of such person other than securities having such power only by reason of the happening of a contingency.
§ 8102. Reorganization of mutual property/casualty insurer through formation of a mutual holding company; contents of plan. (a) A mutual property/casualty insurer may be reorganized as a domestic stock property/casualty insurer with a mutual holding company by complying with the requirements of this article.
(b) The plan of reorganization shall contain provisions for:
(1) the reorganizing insurer becoming a domestic stock property/casualty insurer;
(2) the formation of a mutual holding company;
(3) the eligible members of the reorganizing insurer becoming members of the mutual holding company with membership interests therein, and the membership interests in the reorganizing insurer being extinguished;
(4) at least fifty-one percent of the voting stock issued by the reorganized insurer being acquired and held, directly or through one or more intermediate stock holding companies, by the mutual holding company;
(5) if applicable, the general terms for the establishment of an alternative provision under the proposed dividend policy under section eight thousand one hundred three of this article; and
(6) a plan of operation for the reorganized insurer including financial projections for a three-year period and a statement indicating its intentions with regard to issuing any nonparticipating business.
(c) The plan of reorganization shall provide that the reorganization process itself will not change premiums or reduce policy benefits or other policy obligations of the mutual property/casualty insurer, provided that the plan of reorganization may provide that the reorganized stock insurer will be able to make such changes and reductions as would be permitted under this chapter if the mutual property/casualty insurer were not a reorganizing insurer under this article.
(d) The plan may provide for the formation of one or more intermediate stock holding companies.
(e) The plan shall include the following as exhibits:
(1) the proposed charters or certificates of incorporation of the reorganized insurer, the mutual holding company and any intermediate stock holding company or companies; and
(2) the proposed by-laws of the reorganized insurer, the mutual holding company and any stock holding company or companies.
§ 8103. Dividend practices. Following the effective date of the plan, the reorganized insurer may, with respect to its individual policies and contracts:
(a) continue the dividend practices of the reorganizing insurer;
(b) continue the dividend practices of the reorganizing insurer and adopt such other dividend practices as, at the time of the effective date or at any time thereafter, may be permitted under applicable law or regulation or approved by the superintendent;
(c) adopt such other alternative with respect to dividend practices as the superintendent may approve; or
(d) discontinue the dividend practices of the reorganizing insurer.
§ 8104. Adoption of plan; submission of plan to the superintendent. (a) A mutual property/casualty insurer seeking to reorganize under this article shall, by approval of a resolution adopted by at least twothirds of its entire board of directors, adopt a plan consistent with the provisions of sections eight thousand one hundred two and eight thousand one hundred three of this article which is fair and equitable to the policyholders. The resolution voted upon by the board of directors shall specify the reasons for and the purposes of the proposed reorganization.
(b) The plan shall be submitted to the superintendent, together with the resolution of the board of directors of the reorganizing insurer, certified by the secretary thereof, adopting the plan pursuant to this article.
§ 8105. Amendment or withdrawal of plan. At any time before the plan of reorganization becomes effective as provided in section eight thousand one hundred nine of this article, the reorganizing insurer may, by resolution of a three-fourths majority of its entire board of directors, amend the plan of reorganization or withdraw the plan of reorganization. In the case of a plan amendment, all references in this article to the plan of reorganization shall be deemed to refer to the plan as amended, but no amendment shall be deemed to change the adoption date of the plan of reorganization. A further public hearing is not necessary unless the superintendent determines that amendments submitted after the original hearing required under section eight thousand one hundred seven of this article will substantially alter the plan. In the event that the superintendent determines that the amendment substantially alters the plan, the plan as amended must be submitted for reconsideration by the eligible members as provided in section eight thousand one hundred eight of this article.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the insurance law, in relation to the formation of mutu- al holding companies by certain domestic mutual property/casualty insur- ers and the reorganization in connection therewith of a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer into a domestic stock property/casualty insur- er
Purpose of bill
This bill would authorize a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer to reorganize into a domestic stock property/casualty insurer through the formation of a new mutual holding company which owns, directly or through one or more stock holding companies, at least 51% of the reor- ganized mutual property/casualty insurer.
Summary of specific provisions
Adds a new Article 81 to the Insurance Law providing for the reorganiza- tion of a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer into a domestic stock property/casualty insurer through the formation of a new mutual holding company which owns, directly or through one or more stock hold- ing companies, at least 51% of the reorganized mutual property/casualty insurer. The new Article 81 specifies in great detail: 1) The process for reorganization and required contents of the plan of reorganization; 2) obligations to policyholders; 3) application and review by the super- intendent of financial services including the holding of a public hear- ing; 4) the process for policyholder review and voting on a reorganiza- tion plan; 5) restrictions on compensation received by officers, directors and employees of the reorganized company; 6) requirements on board members of the mutual holding company and any stock holding compa- ny, including a requirement for outside directors of each, and annual filings to be made by the mutual holding company with the superintendent if required by the superintendent; 7) limitations on stock options and stock awards to officers and directors of the mutual holding company, stock holding company and the reorganized insurer; 8) l imitations on ownership of voting stock of the reorganized insurer by officers and directors of the mutual holding company, stock holding company and the reorganized insurer; and 9) many other matters related to the regu- lation, powers and duties of a reorganized mutual holding company.
Read the full memo (1,912 words)
Section two sets out the effective date.
Justification
Similar statutes allowing for insurance mutual holding companies have been enacted into law in 34 states and the District of Columbia. Numer- ous property/casualty insurance companies in the United States have converted to a mutual holding company structure in recent years. New York domestic mutual property/casualty insurers are at a competitive disadvantage because they do not have the authority to reorganize in the same mariner. In New York State, there are a number of companies, that could enhance the interests of policyholders by availing themselves of this proposed law and, as a result, being able to raise capital or merge with other mutual holding companies, thereby contributing to the growth of New York's economy. As a major part of the financial services indus- try, property/casualty insurers today face the same competitive pres- sures and capital needs that are linked to any mergers, consolidations and capital-raising activities occurring throughout the financial services arena. Within the property/casualty insurance industry itself, insurers must enhance and strengthen capital, liquidity and profitabil- ity in order to hold their own against intense competition. The insu- rance-buying public looks carefully at financial ratings an d capital base. As a consequence, more than ever before, access to capital is critical. However, one segment of the property/casualty insurance indus- try - mutual property/casualty insurers - has a decided disadvantage compared to stock property/casualty insurers in accessing capital markets. Since mutual insurers cannot issue stock, they do not have the array of methods for accessing capital markets that their stock insurer counterparts do. Additionally, mutual insurers are limited in their ability to consolidate and grow through acquisitions because other companies can only be acquired as subsidiaries of the mutual property/casualty insurer, and this structure limits the size of acqui- sitions because subsidiaries are subject to a%- risk-based-capital factor, statutory accounting requires write - off of the good will element of the purchase price, and legal investment laws may limit the amount an insurer may invest in subsidiaries. Therefore, this.law would enhance the ability of property/casualty insurers to consolidate and grow through acquisitions.
One of the few alternatives for a mutual property/casualty insurer is to convert to a stock form of ownership in a process called demutualiza- tion. Demutualization (or conversion) of New York domestic mutual property/casualty insurers is currently authorized pursuant to Insurance Law Section 7307. However, proceeding directly with demutualization is a major undertaking involving complexity and uncertainty. The feasibility of raising capital through demutualization can be hampered by stock market conditions, which can be volatile and uncertain, and by strains on the profitability of the insurance business. Conversion to the stock form opens a mutual property/casualty insurer to the possibility of hostile acquisition by a foreign management - presenting uncertainty and instability which may make property/casualty policyholders uncomforta- ble. There are therefore a number of mutual property/casualty insurers for which demutualization may not be an attractive alternative, but which still have a need to raise capital to support their business.
This bill would authorize a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer to reorganize into a domestic stock property/casualty insurer through the formation of a new mutual holding company which owns, directly or through one or more stock holding companies, at least 51% of the reor- ganized mutual property/casualty insurer. The new organization could permit capital raising by selling voting stock of the reorganized insur- er or one or more stock holding companies to persons other than the mutual holding company, and the issuer of such voting stock contributing all or a portion of the proceeds down to its stock property/casualty insurer subsidiary. Such a reorganization would not affect the obli- gations of the reorganizing insurer.
All insurance obligations of the reorganizing insurer stay intact. Policyholders/members would retain membership, voting rights and rights to participate in any distribution of surplus, but such rights in the insurer become instead rights in the mutual holding company. Policyholders/members would continue to control the reorganized insurer through their new membership interests in the mutual holding company, the directors of which are elected by the members. Policyholders then have the ability to protect and strengthen their financial position by raising new capital through a controlled subsidiary. Such a structure has been successfully employed by mutual savings banks in New York under Article VI-C of the Banking Law (enacted in 1989) and by thrifts since the late 1980s in many other states. The bill contains a number of provisions that protect the interests of policyholders of the reorganiz- ing insurer.
Dividend Practices. To further protect the dividend expectations of participating policyholders, the bill requires that the reorganized insurer, on or before the date on which less than 75% of the votes eligible to be cast by the mutual holding company's members are held by owners of the reorganized insurer's participating policies or contracts, provide as to its participating individual policies in a manner approved by the superintendent.
Reorganization Procedural Safeguards. The reorganization of a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer through the formation of a mutual hold- ing company would be subject to the procedural safeguards applicable to property/casualty insurer demutalization under current law, including board approval, a public hearing, the superintendent's approval and approval by eligible policyholders.
Required Outside Directors of Mutual Holding Company and Stock Holding Company and Limitations on their Ownership Interests in the Reorganized Insurer. The bill provides that (a) at least two-thirds of the directors of the mutual holding company and of any stock holding company, all of the members of the compensation committee of the board of directors of the mutual holding company and of any stock holding company, at least two-thirds of the members of any committee responsible for making deci- sions affecting the capital structure or mergers and acquisitions, and a majority of the directors on each other committee of the board of direc- tors of the mutual holding company and any stock holding company must be outside directors; and (b) the aggregate percentage of voting securities of the reorganized insurer directly or indirectly owned, controlled or held with the power to vote, either personally or by persons (other than the mutual holding company and any stock holding company) of which they are directors, officers or employees, by outside directors, may not exceed three percent or such lesser percentage as may be determined by the superintendent in his approval of the mutual holding company's plan of reorganization.
Supermajority of Directors of Mutual Holding Company and Stock Holding Company required in Certain Instances. The bill requires that the by-laws of the mutual holding company and any stock holding company provide that the affirmative vote of at least two-thirds of the board of directors of such company be required for any action by such company to (a) adopt a plan of conversion of the mutual holding company, (b) enter into a merger with the mutual holding company, or (c) conduct a public offering or authorize the issuance of any voting stock or security convertible into voting stock of the reorganized insurer or the stock holding company to any person other than the mutual holding company or the stock holding company. Limitations of Management Stock Options and Stock Awards. The bill provides that, subject to a limited exception, until six months after the completion of either an initial public offer- ing or the first issuance of voting stock or securities convertible into voting stock of the reorganized insurer or the stock holding company to any person other than the mutual holding company or the stock holding company, neither the stock holding company nor the reorganized insurer may award any stock options or stock grants to pers ons who are officers or directors of the mutual holding company, the stock holding company or the reorganized insurer.
Aggregate Limitations on Management Ownership of Voting Stock. The bill provides that, until two years after the six month period after the completion of either an initial public offering or the first issuance of voting stock or securities convertible into voting stock of the reorgan- ized insurer or the stock holding company to any person other than the mutual holding company or the stock holding company, the officers and directors of the mutual holding company, a stock holding company and of the reorganized insurer may not own beneficially, in the aggregate, more than five percent of the voting stock of the reorganized insurer.
Superintendent to Approve Valuation of Stock Offering Prior to Initial Public Offering. The bill provides that any issuance of voting stock or securities convertible into voting stock of the reorganized insurer or the stock holding company prior to an initial public offering, private equity placement, or the issuance of public or private voting stock or securities convertible into voting stock of the reorganized insurer or stock holding company or any other type of capital raised must be approved by the superintendent as to the proposed valuation of such stock or securities. Superintendent Approval Required of Mutual Holding Company Merger, Consolidation and Other Reorganization. Recognizing that the reorganization of a domestic mutual property/casualty insurer through the formation of a mutual holding company and its stock property/casualty insurer subsidiary is, in effect, the continuance of the existence of the mutual property/casualty insurer in another form. The bill would allow a mutual holding company to engage in mergers, consolidations and other reorganizations subject to the superintendent's approval.
Legislative history
2021-2022: S.9021
Fiscal implications
None.
Effective date
Immediately.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.