What's happening
This bill creates new criminal and civil penalties for various forms of cryptocurrency fraud, including virtual token fraud, rug pulls, private key misuse, and failure to disclose token ownership in New York.
Why it matters
Introduces broad and severe criminal and civil penalties. (up to $5 million and/or 20 years imprisonment for individuals, $25 million for organizations) for a range of deceptive or manipulative behaviors in the cryptocurrency space, signaling a significant escalation in legal risks for those operating in or around digital assets in New York.
Targets "rug pulls" and undisclosed developer stakes. , which are common sources of investor losses in crypto markets; by requiring developers to publicly disclose their token holdings and restricting large-scale sell-offs, the bill aims to directly curb practices that enable sudden, developer-driven crashes in token value.
Establishes explicit rules around the handling of private keys. , making it a crime to misuse or disclose someone else’s private key without clear, affirmative consent. This could dramatically change how crypto custody services, exchanges, and even individuals manage and communicate about wallet security.
Defines key terms and categories in law. (such as "security tokens," "stablecoins," "developer," "rug pull," and more), providing legal clarity and a framework for enforcement that did not previously exist—potentially influencing how new crypto projects are designed, marketed, and operated in New York and possibly serving as a model for other jurisdictions.
Albany, before your first meeting.
Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.
Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.
Who cares
Token developers
The bill would restrict large token selloffs and require developers to publicly disclose their token holdings on their primary website’s landing page.
NFT creators
The bill’s illegal rug pull provision would exempt NFT classes with fewer than 100 tokens or a value below $20,000 when the rug pull occurs.
Crypto wallet providers
The bill would prohibit obtaining, disclosing or misusing another person’s private key without affirmative consent, with a limited exception for those who created the key.
Token buyers and holders
The bill would establish offenses covering deceptive token transactions and unauthorized private key use, with penalties including fines and up to 20 years in prison.
Headline styles
Ban Crypto Fraud
Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.
Sponsors
No co-sponsors yet.
History
- Referred to codes
- Referred to codes
Companion bill
The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.
Crack Down on Crypto Fraud
In Assembly Committee · Codes · Sponsor Clyde Vanel
Full text
4 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗
STATE OF NEW YORK
359
2023-2024 Regular Sessions
IN SENATE (Prefiled)
January 4, 2023
Introduced by Sen. THOMAS -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Codes
AN ACT to amend the penal law, in relation to establishing certain offenses relating to crypto fraud
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Title K of the penal law is amended by adding a new article 191 to read as follows:
ARTICLE 191
CRYPTO FRAUD
Section 191.00 Definitions.
191.05 Penalties.
191.10 Virtual token fraud.
191.15 Illegal rug pulls.
191.20 Private key fraud.
191.25 Fraudulent failure to disclose interest in virtual
tokens. § 191.00 Definitions.
For purposes of this article, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
1. "Virtual tokens" shall mean security tokens and stablecoins;
2. "Security tokens" shall mean any form of fungible and non-fungible computer code by which all such forms of ownership of said computer code is determined through verification of transactions or any derivative method, and that is stored on a peer-to-peer computer network or any other such computerized system or through any derivative means of storage, and which conforms to one of the following:
(a) such class of virtual tokens are advertised by the developer or an agent of the developer at the developer's direction to be bought and
EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets
[ ] is old law to be omitted.
LBD01640-01-3
sold for the purpose of profit, whether or not such purpose is advertised as the sole purpose;
(b) such class of virtual tokens are reasonably understood by members of the public to be bought and sold for the purpose of profit;
(c) the value of such class of virtual tokens is determined by the supply and demand of the virtual token; and
(d) such class of virtual tokens: (i) are not pegged to an external source, whether or not such external source is volatile, (ii) are pegged to another virtual token, or (iii) such class of virtual tokens do not employ technology which prevents large fluctuations in its price and such technology fails to prevent the same;
3. "Stablecoin" shall mean any form of fungible and non-fungible computer code by which all such forms of ownership of said computer code is determined through verification of transactions or any derivative method, and that is stored on a peer-to-peer computer network or any other such computerized system or through any derivative means of storage, and which conforms to all of the following:
(a) such class of virtual tokens are not advertised by the developer or an agent of the developer at the developer's direction to be bought and sold for the purpose of profit, whether or not such purpose is advertised as the sole purpose;
(b) such class of virtual tokens cannot be reasonably understood by members of the public to be bought and sold for the purpose of profit; and
(c) the value of such class of virtual tokens is not determined by the supply and demand of the class of virtual token; and
(d) such class of virtual tokens are pegged to an external source other than another class of virtual tokens, whether or not such external source is volatile, or such class of virtual tokens do employ technology which prevents large fluctuations in its price and such technology succeeds in preventing the same;
4. "Class" shall mean a group of fungible or non-fungible tokens, irrespective of the amount created, that is intended by the developer to be:
(a) in the case of fungible tokens, valued and exchanged together; or
(b) in the case of non-fungible tokens, regarded as part of the same group of digital or physical items or valued together with the developers' other non-fungible tokens based on the fact that the non-fungible tokens were created by a certain developer, taking into account the developer's notoriety, sale volume, and how he or she is regarded within virtual token communities;
5. "Developer" shall mean the person or persons, whether natural or otherwise, and any agent or employee thereof who either create in whole or in part, maintain in whole or in part, or own more than ten percent of a class of virtual tokens utilizing any technical standard and who offers them for purchase in the state of New York or, where the sale of their tokens in the state of New York is prohibited, such person does not use reasonable efforts to prevent such class of virtual tokens from being made available for purchase in the state of New York;
6. "Technical standard" shall mean the rules that a class of virtual tokens shall comply with in order to use the blockchain network or any derivative means thereof;
7. "Non-fungible token" shall mean a virtual token used to denote on the blockchain ownership of any digital or physical item or any derivative means thereof;
8. "Fungible token" shall mean any virtual token stored on the blockchain other than non-fungible tokens;
9. "Own", "owning" and "ownership" shall mean the means by which possession of a digital asset is noted on the blockchain or any derivative means thereof;
10. "Token" shall mean the technical standard used to create a fungible or non-fungible piece of computer code;
11. "Wallet" shall mean a device, program, or service which stores the public and/or private keys for virtual token transactions;
12. "Burning" shall mean any method of someone making tokens inaccessible to any person including himself or herself with the intention of doing so;
13. "Rug pull" shall mean the act of a developer developing a class of virtual tokens, owning more than ten percent of the supply of such class of virtual tokens, and selling more than ten percent of the total supply of such class of virtual tokens within a five-year period from the date of the last sale of the same;
14. "Blockchain" shall mean any type of technology which stores code on a database of which said database represents the record of transactions that make up virtual tokens or any derivative technology; and
15. "Private key" shall mean the unique identifier of a wallet, or any substantially similar analogue, that is paired with a publicly available identifier and associated with an algorithm that is necessary to carry out an encryption or decryption required to execute a transaction. § 191.05 Penalties.
Any person, partnership, corporation, company, trust or association, developer, or any agent or employee thereof who violates the provisions of this article shall be subject to a civil fine of not more than five million dollars or imprisoned not more than twenty years, or both, except that where such a person is a person other than a natural person, a fine not exceeding twenty-five million dollars. § 191.10 Virtual token fraud.
A person, whether natural or otherwise, is guilty of virtual token fraud when such person engages in deceptive or fraudulent practice with the intent to deceive another in relation to the purchase, sale, exchange, transfer, offering, storage, destruction, or any relevant act related thereto of virtual tokens. § 191.15 Illegal rug pulls.
1. A developer, whether natural or otherwise, is guilty of illegal rug pulls when such developer develops a class of virtual token and sells more than ten percent of such tokens within five years from the date of the last sale of such tokens.
2. This section shall not apply to non-fungible tokens where a developer has created less than one hundred non-fungible tokens that are regarded as part of the same series or class of non-fungible tokens or where such non-fungible tokens regarded as part of the same series or class are valued at less than twenty thousand dollars at the time the rug pull occurs. § 191.20 Private key fraud.
1. A person, whether natural or otherwise, is guilty of private key fraud when such person obtains or discloses to another person or misuses another's private key without their affirmative consent, provided however that where the person created the private key, such a person shall only be prohibited from disclosing to another or misusing the private key without the owner of the private key's affirmative consent.
2. Consent is deemed affirmative only where it is obtained by a request independent from any other request or information provided to another, it is conspicuous, and it informs the person of the consequences associated with disclosing their private key to another. § 191.25 Fraudulent failure to disclose interest in virtual tokens.
1. A developer of a class of virtual tokens is guilty of fraudulent failure to disclose interest in virtual tokens when such developer does not publicly and conspicuously disclose the number of tokens they own in such class of virtual tokens they developed on the landing page of such developer's primary website.
2. For the purposes of this section, the term developer shall not include a person whether natural or otherwise, and any agent or employee thereof who owns more than ten percent of a class of virtual tokens who does not create or maintain, in whole or in part, a virtual token that is offered for purchase in the state of New York.
§ 2. This act shall take effect on the thirtieth day after it shall have become a law. Effective immediately, the addition, amendment and/or repeal of any rule or regulation necessary for the implementation of this act on its effective date are authorized to be made and completed on or before such effective date.
Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.
Sponsor's memo
Title of bill
An act to amend the penal law, in relation to establishing certain offenses relating to crypto fraud
Purpose or general idea of bill
Establishes certain offenses relating to crypto fraud.
Summary of specific provisions
Section. 1 creates article 191 of the penal law of Title K of the penal law.
Read the full memo (717 words)
§ 191.00 provides important definitions.
§ 191.05 creates penalties that apply to every provision of the act.
§ 191.10 creates the crime of virtual token fraud.
§ 191.15 creates the crime of illegal rug pulls.
§ 191.20 creates the crime of private key fraud.
§ 191.25 creates the crime of fraudulent failure to disclose interest in virtual tokens.
Justification
Blockchain technology has lately risen to the forefront of the American consciousness as the foundation for the future of secure technology. Despite the fact that the interest has become critical in both our economic and political structures, we have been held back by the lack of impenetrable technology that exists to allow us to engage in activities to our democracy and our economic system. Blockchain technology is the first type of impenetrable code, which means it cannot be hacked, manip- ulated, controlled, or destroyed by malicious parties. As a result, blockchain technology has pushed us to the brink of the future, allowing us to conduct historically risky online activities such as storing and moving money, investing, producing one-of-a-kind art, and even voting in elections.
With the advancement of this new technology, it is vital to enact regu- lations that both align with the spirit of the blockchain and the neces- sity to combat fraud.
For the purposes of this act, virtual tokens are defined as security tokens and stablecoins in their current state. The definition of securi- ty tokens would include virtual tokens similar to conventional security tokens such as $ETH, leverage tokens such as $XLMUP, and non-fungible tokens and utility tokens in some scenarios. A broad virtual token fraud law is essential for avoiding the ever-evolving schemes involving virtual tokens.
Rug pulls are now wreaking havoc on the cryptocurrency industry. A rug pull is the act of an unscrupulous virtual token developer creating virtual tokens, advertising them to the masses as investments, causing them to rise steeply in price (often hundreds of thousands of percent), retaining a large supply of the tokens that they created for themselves, and then selling them all at once, causing the price to plummet instant- ly. Famous instances include Squid Game Coin ($SQUID), which began at a price of $0.016 per coin, soared to roughly $2,861.80 per coin in only one week, and then crashed to a price of $0.0007926 in less than five minutes following the rug pull. In other words, the $SQUID creators received a 23,000,000% return on their investment, and their investors were swindled out of millions. This bill will provide prosecutors with a clear legal framework in which to pursue these types of criminals.
Private key fraud is, in many ways, analogous to stealing someone else's debit card pin. When someone obtains or discloses another person's private key for their virtual token wallet, the other person gains access to all of the virtual tokens in the owner's wallet. This frequently arises when criminal mobile app developers construct virtual token wallets that use keylogging software to steal another person's private key. In 2021, a mobile application attempting to pass itself off as a legitimate company stole, what was worth at the time, $1.6 million of Bitcoin from users through the type of action that might constitute private key fraud under this act.
When individuals invest in virtual tokens, _t is critical that they have as much information as possible in order to make an informed investment decision. Unique wallet ownership in any class of virtual tokens is critical information for investors in order to predict when a rug pull or other type of virtual token manipulation will occur. Buyers have the right to know the degree of control over the virtual tokens price that the developers have and the degree of consolidation of the tokens in the developers.
Prior legislative history
2021-22: S.8839 (Thomas) / A.8820 (Vanel) - Referred to Codes.
Fiscal implications
To be determined.
Effective date
This act shall take effect on the thirtieth day aftershall have become law.
Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.