Skip to content
S4149Senate2023-2024 SessionSame asA2750

Ban Forensic Custody Evaluations

Official title

“Relates to prohibiting forensic evaluations in a custody or visitation proceeding; repealer”

Sponsor Anthony H. PalumboSD-1Affects Health
Status
In Senate Committee
Children And Families
Impact
8/10
Significant
Passage
0%

Bill progress

Step 2 of 7

In committee · Children And Families

What's happening

This bill prohibits New York courts from ordering or admitting forensic reports in child custody or visitation proceedings.

Why it matters

  1. Removes a key tool from custody and visitation cases. Forensic evaluations, which often provide expert insight into family dynamics, parental fitness, and child well-being, would no longer be considered by courts. This could significantly change how judges make decisions in contentious or complex cases.

  2. Shifts reliance to other types of evidence. Without forensic reports from mental health professionals, probation, or child protective services, courts would have to base their custody or visitation decisions on other forms of evidence, such as direct testimony, physical evidence, or caseworker observations.

  3. May impact protections for children and vulnerable parties. Forensic reports are sometimes used to identify risks such as abuse, neglect, or mental health concerns. Their exclusion could make it harder to surface or substantiate such issues in court, potentially affecting child safety or parental rights.

  4. Reflects broader debates on fairness and expertise. The bill addresses growing criticism of the influence, accuracy, or objectivity of forensic evaluators in family court. It may appeal to those concerned about expert bias or lack of transparency, but could also raise concerns about the loss of specialized knowledge in high-stakes decisions.

The daily · weekday mornings

Albany, before your first meeting.

Every bill that moved yesterday, summarized in a sentence and ranked by impact. The Albany Scorecard follows on Sundays.

Free. Unsubscribe in one click. Want alerts on specific bills? Create an account.

Who cares

  • Parents in custody or visitation proceedings

    The bill would bar courts from ordering or admitting forensic reports containing recommendations, opinions or conclusions about custody or visitation.

  • Judges handling custody and visitation cases

    The bill would remove forensic reports as a source of evidence for their determinations.

  • Forensic mental health professionals

    Their custody or visitation reports would be covered by the ban on court orders and admission into evidence.

  • Probation and child protective service employees

    Reports they prepare as forensic evaluators offering custody or visitation recommendations, opinions or conclusions would also fall under the ban.

Headline styles

Ban Forensic Custody Evaluations

Plain English, a few words. Used as the page title.

Sponsors

Primary sponsor
Anthony H. Palumbo

Senator · Senate District 1

No co-sponsors yet.

History

  1. Referred to children and families
  2. Referred to children and families

Companion bill

The same bill in the other chamber. A bill becomes law when one version passes both houses and the governor signs it, so either number can carry it.

A2750Assembly

Ban Forensic Custody Evaluations

In Assembly Committee · Judiciary · Sponsor Andrew Hevesi

Impact 8 · Significant0% to pass

Full text

2 pagesUnderlined is new[Struck] is removedOfficial text on nysenate.gov ↗

STATE OF NEW YORK

4149

2023-2024 Regular Sessions

IN SENATE

February 3, 2023

Introduced by Sen. PALUMBO -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Children and Families

AN ACT to amend the domestic relations law and the family court act, in relation to prohibiting forensic evaluations in a custody or visitation proceeding; and to repeal certain provisions of the domestic relations law relating thereto

The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

Section 1. Section 70 of the domestic relations law is amended by adding a new subdivision (c) to read as follows:

(c) (1) No court shall order or allow into evidence a forensic report in the context of a custody or visitation proceeding.

(2) For the purposes of this subdivision:

(i) "forensic report" shall mean any report or evaluation prepared by a forensic evaluator which includes such evaluator's recommendations, opinions or conclusions as to child custody or visitation; and

(ii) "forensic evaluator" shall mean a forensic mental health professional, a probation service employee, a child protective service employee or any other person authorized by statute or the court to perform a forensic evaluation relating to a party or a child in order to assist the court in a child custody or visitation determination.

§ 2. Paragraph (a-3) of subdivision 1 of section 240 of the domestic relations law is REPEALED and a new paragraph (a-3) is added to read as follows:

(a-3) (1) No court shall order or allow into evidence a forensic report in the context of a custody or visitation proceeding.

(2) For the purposes of this paragraph:

(i) "forensic report" shall mean any report or evaluation prepared by a forensic evaluator which includes such evaluator's recommendations, opinions or conclusions as to child custody or visitation; and

EXPLANATION--Matter in italics (underscored) is new; matter in brackets

[ ] is old law to be omitted.

LBD05025-01-3

(ii) "forensic evaluator" shall mean a forensic mental health professional, a probation service employee, a child protective service employee or any other person authorized by statute or the court to perform a forensic evaluation relating to a party or a child in order to assist the court in a child custody or visitation determination.

§ 3. Section 651 of the family court act is amended by adding a new subdivision (g) to read as follows:

(g) (1) No court shall order or allow into evidence a forensic report in the context of a custody or visitation proceeding.

(2) For the purposes of this subdivision:

(i) "forensic report" shall mean any report or evaluation prepared by a forensic evaluator which includes such evaluator's recommendations, opinions or conclusions as to child custody or visitation; and

(ii) "forensic evaluator" shall mean a forensic mental health professional, a probation service employee, a child protective service employee or any other person authorized by statute or the court to perform a forensic evaluation relating to a party or a child in order to assist the court in a child custody or visitation determination.

§ 4. This act shall take effect on the ninetieth day after it shall have become a law.

Reflowed for reading: line numbers and page breaks removed. Cite the official text.

Sponsor's memo

Title of bill

An act to amend the domestic relations law and the family court act, in relation to prohibiting forensic evaluations in a custody or visitation proceeding; and to repeal certain provisions of the domestic relations law relating thereto

Purpose

To protect children by prohibiting forensic evaluations in child custody and visitation proceedings.

Summary of provisions

Section 1. Amends section 70 of the domestic relations law to prohibit forensic evaluations in child custody or visitation proceedings.

Read the full memo (823 words)

Section 2. Amends section 240 of the domestic relations law to prohibit forensic evaluations in child custody or visitation proceedings.

Section 3. Amends section 651 of the family court act to prohibit foren- sic evaluations in child custody or visitation proceedings.

Section 4. Effective date.

Justification

The bill prohibits forensic evaluations in child custody and visitations proceedings.

Forensic evaluators currently perform an outsized role in custody and visitations proceeding, without accountability, standards, oversight or transparency and often with tragic consequences.

The role of forensic evaluators in custody and visitation matters has been the subject of empirical study which concludes that these evalu- ations are ethically inappropriate and should be excluded from the fact finding process.(1 )

In fact, Dr. Ira Daniel Turkat, a highly regarded clinical psychologist concludes, "there is no scientific evidence whatsoever that child custo- dy evaluations result in beneficial outcomes for children. (2)

There is no scientific evidence to support the use of forensic evalu- ations. However, there are harmful sometimes, fatal consequences that warrant their prohibition.

Judges need to render their decisions after considering all factors in the case, paying particular attention to claims of domestic violence, including emotional, physical and sexual abuse and the health and safety of the child/children. Only then should judges make decisions regarding the custody and visitation schedule for the child/children. For example, during the years of custody hearings in Nassau County Family Court, Kyra Franchetti's mother warned that Kyra's father was dangerous, had severe anger management issues and was suicidal. During her case, multiple forensic evaluators were involved at different stages. While Kyra's mother repeatedly raised concerns, no one attempted to protect Kyra from her murderous father. Worse, one forensic evaluator would have made it difficult, if not impossible, for Jacqueline to secure sole custody of Kyra. In July 2016, Kyra was on a court-sanctioned visit with her father in Virginia when he shot Krya to death while she slept. He then set his house on fire and killed himself. Kyra was only two years old. (3) This is not an isolated incident. Dr. Turkat cites cases in Virginia, Mary- land and California where custody and visitation decisions made the recommendation of forensic evaluators ended tragically. (4)

In addition to those horrifying consequences, Dr. Turkat conducted the first qualitative study on the harmful effects of child custody evalu- ations. This 35 state study found other striking detrimental effects, including emotional, physical and sexual abuse. (5)

There is also the issue of the financial cost. Litigants in child custo- dy and visitation proceedings may spend tens of thousands, even hundreds of thousands, for a forensic evaluation. (6) Further, these are replete with inadmissible hearsay. Custody evaluations have been criticized as "a modus operandi crafted by a professional community impacted by an economic incentive to see its opinions accepted in the courtroom. (7). It is time for this practice to end.

Legislative history

2022 S.7742/A.3503; 2020: A.10424

Fiscal implications

Undetermined

Effective date

On the 90th day after it shall have become law; provided that, effective immediately, any rules necessary to implement the provisions for this act may be promulgated. (1) EMPIRICAL AND ETHICAL PROBLEMS WITH CUSTODY RECOMMENDATIONS; A Call for Clinical Humility and Judicial Vigilance; Timothy M. Tippins and Jeffrey P. Wittman; 43 (2) FAMILY COURT REVIEW 193 (May 3, 2005) (2) Psychological Recommendations in Custody Disputes Can Be Harmful, Even Fatal; Ira Daniel Turkat, PhD, 32 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF FAILY LAW 5 ( Spring 2019) (3) https://kyrafranchetti.org/kyras-story/ (4) Psychologist Recommendations in Custody disputes Can Be Harmful, Even Fatal; Ira Daniel Turkat, PhD, 32 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF FAMILY LAW, pp 5-8 (Spring 2018) (5) Turkat, After Children Die, New Study Questions Psychologists' Recommendations in Custody Battles, https//www.prweb.com/releases/after children die new study questions psychologists recommendations in custo- dy battles/preweb15647980. (6) Harmful Effects of Child-Custody Evaluations on Chi Idren=n, Ira Daniel Turkat, PhD, 52 COURT REVIEW: JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN JUDGE'S ASSOCIATION 152 (2016) (7) See also, The Custody Evaluator Meets Hearsay: A Star-Crossed Romance; Timothy M. Tippins and Lauren K. DeLuca, 30 JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACEDEMY OF ATRIMONIAL LAWYERS 549 (May10, 2018), also citing with approval, forensic psychologist Jeffery J. Wittman, Child Advocacy and the Scientific Model in Family Court: A Theory for Pretrial Self-As- sessment, 13 J. PSYCHIATRY & LAW, 61, 78 (1985) ("Our field is famous for supporting conclusions during testimony simply on the basis of accu- mulated clinical experience; a phrase which may mean nothing more than accumulated personal bias")

Summaries, headlines and scores are AI-generated from the official bill text. How we score bills. Source: NYS Open Legislation.